Chaka
Footballguy
I am not criticizing his rushing ability I am trying to point out that based upon how he was used in 2013 any notion that he had buttoned up his pass protection problems are likely incorrect. I think it is pretty clear that the Giants had very little faith in his pass protection so he is still a big question mark in that area going into this season. I also think there is no way Wilson sees time as anything other than a COP/return guy if Coughlin doesn't trust him to block.Agreed. I also don't have any numbers to back it up, but it also seemed like the majority of the time they gave him the ball he was being hit in the backfield or it was a run between the tackles on an offensive line that couldn't open a hole.
People that say Wilson is a failure are wrong because he hasn't had a decent chance yet. Maybe he'll still end up failing, I don't know. I saw enough in the end of 2012 to have some faith in him. It seems to me like 2013 was the perfect storm of unfortunate circumstances.
You can't judge a guy on limitied carries and on such a small sample size. If I remember correct, Eddie Lacy had negative rushing yards in one of the preseason games last year...
Coughlin also hasn't shown much faith in young running backs. In his career as a coach, he has started two rookie RBs in his James Stewart in 1995 (his first year coaching in the NFL) and Fred Taylor started 12 games in 1998 after James Stewart got hurt.
If Coughlin wouldn't allow an obviously dynamic rookie Fred Taylor to start in front of a ham'n'egger like James Stewart (3.8, 3.8 & 4.1 ypc in the two years prior to Fred joining the team) then I wouldn't hold out much hope for Williams getting a start without several injuries happening first.