OK, time for my annual request: PLEASE don't just list your roster. After a few dozen of those long lists, my eyes cross and I stop reading. If you want to generate discussion, instead give at least a little of your reasoning. Here's mine:
QB - Jared Goff - LAR/12 - $11
QB - Andy Dalton - CIN/9 - $6
QB - Ryan Tannehill - MIA/11 - $6
Like I said earlier, the midlevel QBs are such a bargain this year, I can't see paying more. According to the Draft Dominator projections, these 3 will be within 1 or 2 ppw of Rodgers (and actually outscore him some weeks) and collectively cost less than him. Each is nearly 100% sure of being the starter all year barring injury, and each has the potential for a 4 TD week at any time. Going cheap saves money for RB & TE.
RB - Ezekiel Elliott - DAL/8 - $35
RB - David Johnson - ARI/9 - $34
RB - Christian McCaffrey - CAR/4 - $26
RB - Peyton Barber - TB/5 - $8
RB - James Conner - PIT/7 - $4
Big $$ on RB. There's been a lot of discussion about whether the drop to .5 ppr for RBs devalues them, but a combo of Goff and Zeke still projects to more points than an equally priced combo of a higher priced QB and a midlevel RB. Originally I had Cook instead of CMC, but the week 4 bye was much better than a week 10 bye. When Freeman was named the starter in Denver, I actually switched to him and tried upgrading my #3 TE to Burton, but didn't like the way the roster looked as much as I like this one, partly because I couldn't convince myself of what Freeman's ultimate value would be. If he turns into a reincarnation of Zeke's or Kamara's rookie seasons, I'll be sorry. If not, maybe zigging instead of zagging was the right thing to do . If Barber can hold onto the starting position, he'll be cheap gold. I've had Conner in there from my earliest teams, thinking he'll be good for at least an occasional TD. With Bell playing his reporting game, he'll be worth even more early in the season and who knows what happens later. Unfortunately, that news also resulted in him being on nearly everyone's roster.
WR - Marquise Goodwin - SF/11 - $13
WR - Kenny Stills - MIA/11 - $11
WR - Keelan Cole - JAX/9 - $7
WR - Michael Gallup - DAL/8 - $6
WR - John Brown - BAL/10 - $6
WR - Dede Westbrook - JAX/9 - $5
WR - John Ross - CIN/9 - $5
WR - Taywan Taylor - TEN/8 - $4
WR - Jaron Brown - SEA/7 - $3
Quantity over quality at WR. 9 guys who are capable of a big week or two (or hopefully more). Some potential risks: Week 11 with my two "big guns" (hey, it's a relative term) on bye, but I have 7 other WRs to pick up the slack, plus all my RBs and TEs are active that week, so hopefully I won't need a flex from the WR spot. Week 9 has 3 guys on bye, but with the top 2 and 4 others available, it should be survivable. The week 9 and 11 guys just seemed to have so much value I couldn't pass them up, so I decided to run the risk...besides, with 6 teams on bye those 2 weeks, I'm guessing everyone will have some kind of bye issues, so maybe scores will be low all around. The bargains were so obvious that the same guys keep showing up on a ton of rosters, but that's OK--I'm perfectly willing to have the same WR production as everyone else and depend on my RBs to be the difference makers.
TE - Travis Kelce - KC/12 - $25
TE - Jared Cook - OAK/7 - $8
TE - Austin Hooper - ATL/8 - $8
TE - Dallas Goedert - PHI/9 - $4
One big gun, two midlevels and the cheap flyer. Went back and forth between Goedert and Vannett for the final spot. Vannett's bye week is better and he's $1 cheaper and I think both have similar floors and likely output. But, Goedert has a way higher ceiling if Ertz gets hurt, so I went that way. Kelce/Goff sharing the week 12 bye makes me a little nervous, but both are covered pretty well in their positions and all my RBs and WRs are active that week, so I can get my flex scores there.
PK - Dustin Hopkins - WAS/4 - $3
PK - Kaimi Fairbairn - HOU/10 - $2
PK - Cody Parkey - CHI/5 - $2
TD - Tampa Bay Buccaneers - TB/5 - $3
TD - Cincinnati Bengals - CIN/9 - $3
TD - Cleveland Browns - CLE/11 - $2
Meh, 3 cheap kickers and 3 cheap defenses with bye weeks spread around (other than the early week 5, I'll have at least 5 of the 6 active every week). I almost went with a Bears/Cards combo at D, but I tried 2 defenses one year and it didn't work out well, so I stuck with 3. I tried to squeeze in Bears/Cards/Browns, but it would have meant cutting a WR, which I didn't want to do with the bye week issues.
Nice QBs!
I had that combo at one point.
I see you took the opposite approach I did with JAX WRs. 9 is a lot of WRs so you definitely didn't need to spend big on anyone. The bottom 4 scare me a bit. I only have a single $5 WR, but felt like there were some better gambles down in that range I'd have grabbed if I could have a larger roster. Chad Williams ($3) is a guy I would've liked to have had.
I'd have broken Kelce up into 2-3 TEs. Partially bc I don't trust Mahommes yet and partially bc I prefer quantity over quality in best ball.
Always been a fan of the 3/3 approach.
---------------------------------------------------------------------
QB - Jared Goff - LAR/12 - $11
QB - Eli Manning - NYG/9 - $7
QB - Ryan Tannehill - MIA/11 - $6
QB - Sam Darnold - NYJ/11 - $3
I'm usually a 3QB guy, but couldn't pass up Darnold for $3. Even without Darnold, at one point I was tempted by the 4-combo of Trubisky, Eli, Dalton, and Tannehill. In the end, I put a little faith in the Gase offense to eclipse the value of Dalton and Cincy.
I hated spending the extra money on Goff with all the value at QB, but if he takes a step in his 2nd year under McVay I'd really regret not having him. I think the 2nd year jump could be huge and that Cooks >> Sammy.
I'm not an Eli fan, but Shurmur and all those weapons (OBJ, Shepard, Engram, Barkley) have to equate to a few huge weeks.
RB - Royce Freeman - DEN/10 - $16
RB - Jamaal Williams - GB/7 - $15
RB - Marshawn Lynch - OAK/7 - $15
RB - Peyton Barber - TB/5 - $8
RB - Matt Breida - SF/11 - $8
RB - Bilal Powell - NYJ/11 - $7
RB - Samaje Perine - WAS/4 - $4
I feel really good about Royce, Jamaal, and Lynch. Couldn't pass up the value in Perine, as I think he'll eventually overtake AP as he improves in his 2nd year in the league. I don't play for the early weeks in this contest anyway.
I had Crowell but switched to Powell after he got the nod with the 1st team in the preseason. Even if Crowell is the lead back, Powell is always the garbage time guy and this should lead to some big games. For $7 savings, I felt like I had to make the move.
Barber and Breida scare me. They could both lose their jobs before the important weeks of this contest, but if they don't then they'll be huge value.
WR - Marvin Jones - DET/6 - $20
WR - Josh Gordon - CLE/11 - $18
WR - Corey Davis - TEN/8 - $15
WR - Tyler Lockett - SEA/7 - $9
WR - Chris Godwin - TB/5 - $6
WR - John Brown - BAL/10 - $6
WR - Donte Moncrief - JAX/9 - $5
I spent more money at the top of WR than usual (still no top 20 guy, tho). Every one of these guys is the big play guy for their team, IMO. I don't expect consistency from any of them, but I do expect at least 2 big games a week out of these 7. I don't know why Moncrief isn't getting more love.
Keelan Cole is not a big play WR. Moncrief is starting. He may not get Cole's volume, but he should have some big weeks which is all I'm looking for at $5. I really wanted to find a way to get Woods, Moore, or Stills on this team, but just couldn't do it.
TE - David Njoku - CLE/11 - $12
TE - George Kittle - SF/11 - $12
TE - O.J. Howard - TB/5 - $11
TE - Tyler Eifert - CIN/9 - $9
TE - Austin Hooper - ATL/8 - $8
TE - Nick Vannett - SEA/7 - $3
Njoku is my big play TE. I don't like SF's WRs, so I'm hoping Kittle pulls in a lot of volume. Howard was a TD machine last year on low volume, hopefully that continues. Eifert is huge when healthy, but he's the type of gamble I feel must be taken to win this thing. Vannett was only selected to help cover my week 11 bye issue. Hooper 3rd year breakout? I dunno, but I liked him as a prospect and the opportunity is ripe.
PK - Robbie Gould - SF/11 - $4
PK - Josh Lambo - JAX/9 - $3
PK - Caleb Sturgis - LAC/8 - $3
TD - Oakland Raiders - OAK/7 - $2
TD - Indianapolis Colts - IND/9 - $2
TD - Cleveland Browns - CLE/11 - $2
3/3 with minimal investment is my usual combo. I considered CIN as my 4th D, but went with Vannett instead. After finding myself short handed at K in past years, I spent a little extra $ for job security.
Overall, week 11 is going to be my huge hurdle. Missing 2 low-end QBs, 2 low-end RBs, my 2 top TEs, Josh Gordon, 1 K, and 1 D. So 9 guys, but just as importantly $72. Hopefully the 30 man roster can handle being that short handed so late in the contest.