What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

Welcome to Our Forums. Once you've registered and logged in, you're primed to talk football, among other topics, with the sharpest and most experienced fantasy players on the internet.

In this thread I rank my favorite Beatles songs: 204-1. (10 Viewers)

Notes about the Top 5..

1) #5 has 65 more points than #6.   The Top 5 is very much set apart from the rest.

2) 22 of the 35 #1's FGB's listed wound up in the Top 5.

3) The #4 and #5 songs fell there because they were on 6-7 less lists than the Top 3.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Composite Ranking #5 - Abbey Road Medley
Highest Ranked by: #1 by @shuke  #1 by @DocHolliday  #1 by @Bonzai  #2 by @Big Blue Wrecking Crew  #2 by @heckmanm  #2 by @Spock
#Of Lists: 20
Total Points: 397
Top10: 17
#1: 3
#2: 3
#3: 2
#4: 5 (13 IN THE TOP 4)
Krista Rank -3

Paul McCartney Abbey Road Medley Golden Slumbers Carry That Weight The End Live In Tokyo 2013

Top 10 Contest - Abbey Road Medley
Falguy - 3 Ringo #3!!!!!!!!
Simey - 2
Wikkid - 1
Heckmann - 1
Man of CS - 1
Uruk-hai - 1
Shaft41 - 1
Dr. O - 1
Binky - 1

Standings after song #5
 

Falguy-9

Binky The Doormat-6

Man Of CS-6

Simey-6

Tom Hagen-5

Shaft41-5

Uruk-Hai-3

Dr Octupus-3

Wikkidpissah-3

Heckmann-3

 
Getzlaf15 said:
Composite Ranking #5 - Abbey Road Medley
Highest Ranked by: #1 by @shuke  #1 by @DocHolliday  #1 by @Bonzai  #2 by @Big Blue Wrecking Crew  #2 by @heckmanm  #2 by @Spock
#Of Lists: 20
Total Points: 397
Top10: 17
#1: 3
#2: 3
#3: 2
#4: 5 (13 IN THE TOP 4)
Krista Rank -3

Paul McCartney Abbey Road Medley Golden Slumbers Carry That Weight The End Live In Tokyo 2013

Top 10 Contest - Abbey Road Medley
Falguy - 3 Ringo #3!!!!!!!!
Simey - 2
Wikkid - 1
Heckmann - 1
Man of CS - 1
Uruk-hai - 1
Shaft41 - 1
Dr. O - 1
Binky - 1

Standings after song #5
 

Falguy-9

Binky The Doormat-6

Man Of CS-6

Simey-6

Tom Hagen-5

Shaft41-5

Uruk-Hai-3

Dr Octupus-3

Wikkidpissah-3

Heckmann-3
Click to expand...
Falguy lookin good... 

Dang! 

 
Composite Ranking #4 - In My Life
Highest Ranked by: # 1 by @krista4  #1 by @Ted Lange as your Bartender  #1 by @Alex P Keaton  #1 by @wikkidpissah  #1 @ManOfSteelhead  #1 by @Binky The Doormat  #1 by @Shaft41
Of Lists: 22
Total Points: 407
Top10: 15
#1: 7
#2: 2
#3: 1
#4:1
#5: 2
Krista Rank -1

 - The Top 3 songs were listed 28-29 times.   
 - Ranked #1 by 20% of all lists.   
 - Ranked #1 the most times. 
 - 10 less Top 10 ranks than the #1 song.

lots of pics over time

The one my daughter played for us at her wedding

Top 10 Contest - In My Life
Simey - 2
Man Of CS - 2
Uruk-hai - 2
Falguy - 1
Wikkid - 1
Tom Hagen - 1
Shaft41 - 1
Dr O - 1
Binky - 1

Standings after song #4
 

Falguy-10

Man Of CS-8

Simey-8

Binky The Doormat-7

Tom Hagen-6

Shaft41-6

Uruk-Hai-5

Dr Octupus-4

Wikkidpissah-4

Heckmann-3

 
Getzlaf15 said:
Composite Ranking #4 - In My Life
Highest Ranked by: # 1 by @krista4  #1 by @Ted Lange as your Bartender  #1 by @Alex P Keaton  #1 by @wikkidpissah  #1 @ManOfSteelhead  #1 by @Binky The Doormat  #1 by @Shaft41
Of Lists: 22
Total Points: 407
Top10: 15
#1: 7
#2: 2
#3: 1
#4:1
#5: 2
Krista Rank -1

 - The Top 3 songs were listed 28-29 times.   
 - Ranked #1 by 20% of all lists.   
 - Ranked #1 the most times. 
 - 10 less Top 10 ranks than the #1 song.

lots of pics over time

The one my daughter played for us at her wedding

Top 10 Contest - In My Life
Simey - 2
Man Of CS - 2
Uruk-hai - 2
Falguy - 1
Wikkid - 1
Tom Hagen - 1
Shaft41 - 1
Dr O - 1
Binky - 1

Standings after song #4
 

Falguy-10

Man Of CS-8

Simey-8

Binky The Doormat-7

Tom Hagen-6

Shaft41-6

Uruk-Hai-5

Dr Octupus-4

Wikkidpissah-4

Heckmann-3
Click to expand...
that being my #1, that could have closed me out - though I am fairly confident I have the other three.  😥

 
Composite Ranking #3 - While My Guitar Gently Weeps
Highest Ranked by: #1 by @heckmanm  #1 by @Ilov80s  #1 by @Dinsy Ejotuz  #3 by @Getzlaf15
#Of Lists: 28 
Total Points: 428
Top10: 18
#1: 3
#2: 0
#3: 1
#4: 0
#5: 2
#6: 2
#7: 3
#8: 3
#9: 2
#10: 2
Krista Rank -20

My favorite cover

Top 10 Contest - While My Guitar Gently Weeps
Heckmann - 3  Ringo!!!
Man of CS - 3 . Ringo!!!
Simey - 2
Shaft41 - 2
Uruk-hai - 2
Wikkid - 1
Binky -1
Tom Hagen  - 1

Standings after Song #3
 

Man Of CS-11

Falguy-10

Simey-10

Binky The Doormat-8

Shaft41-8

Tom Hagen-7

Uruk-Hai-7

Heckmann-6

Wikkidpissah-5

Dr Octupus-4

 
Getzlaf15 said:
Composite Ranking #3 - While My Guitar Gently Weeps
Highest Ranked by: #1 by @heckmanm  #1 by @Ilov80s  #1 by @Dinsy Ejotuz  #3 by @Getzlaf15
#Of Lists: 28 
Total Points: 428
Top10: 18
#1: 3
#2: 0
#3: 1
#4: 0
#5: 2
#6: 2
#7: 3
#8: 3
#9: 2
#10: 2
Krista Rank -20

My favorite cover

Top 10 Contest - While My Guitar Gently Weeps
Heckmann - 3  Ringo!!!
Man of CS - 3 . Ringo!!!
Simey - 2
Shaft41 - 2
Uruk-hai - 2
Wikkid - 1
Binky -1
Tom Hagen  - 1

Standings after Song #3
 

Man Of CS-11

Falguy-10

Simey-10

Binky The Doormat-8

Shaft41-8

Tom Hagen-7

Uruk-Hai-7

Heckmann-6

Wikkidpissah-5

Dr Octupus-4
Click to expand...
👀

🤞

 
Composite Ranking #2 - Here Comes The Sun
Highest Ranked by: #1 by @Tom Hagen  #1 by @fatguyinalittlecoat  #1 by @Dr. Octopus  #1 by @The Future Champs
#Of Lists: 29 (only 6 did not list it)
Total Points: 463 
Top10: 16
#1: 4
#2: 0
#3: 1
#4: 4
#5: 4
#8 :1
#9: 2
#19: 4
 Krista Rank -17

I had this at #14

 - On more lists than any song

lots of old pics

Top 10 Contest - Here Comes the Sun
Everyone was way off on this song.
Tom Hagen - 1 (missed by 2 spots)
Uruk-Hai -1
Heckmann - 1
Falguy - 1
Simey - 1
Binky -1

Four did not list this song.

Standings after song #2
 

Man Of CS-11

Falguy-11

Simey-11

Binky The Doormat-9

Shaft41-8

Tom Hagen-8

Uruk-Hai-8

Heckmann-7

Wikkidpissah-5

Dr Octupus-4

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Getzlaf15 said:
Composite Ranking #2 - Here Comes The Sun
Highest Ranked by: #1 by @Tom Hagen  #1 by @fatguyinalittlecoat  #1 by @Dr. Octopus  #1 by @The Future Champs
#Of Lists: 29 (only 6 did not list it)
Total Points: 463 
Top10: 16
#1: 4
#2: 0
#3: 1
#4: 4
#5: 4
#8 :1
#9: 2
#19: 4
 Krista Rank -17

I had this at #14

 - On more lists than any song

lots of old pics

Top 10 Contest - Here Comes the Sun
Everyone was way off on this song.
Tom Hagen - 1 (missed by 2 spots)
Uruk-Hai -1
Heckmann - 1
Falguy - 1
Simey - 1
Binky -1

Four did not list this song.

Standings after song #2
 

Man Of CS-11

Falguy-11

Simey-11

Binky The Doormat-9

Shaft41-8

Tom Hagen-8

Uruk-Hai-8

Heckmann-7

Wikkidpissah-5

Dr Octupus-4
Click to expand...
Whiffff for me...totally. 

Wow. What a climax. 

 
Getz, you a mad man. 👍

Thanks so much for all the math'in and such....especially for staying up all night for us nerds - with the grandkids tomorrow. 

Have fun. You deserve it. 

Ok, I needed to say that b4 the finale...as I may freak out over either result. :shrug:

 
Composite Ranking #1 - A Day in the Life
Highest Ranked by: #1 by @BobbyLayne  #1 by @ScottNorwood  #1 by @Spock  #1 by @Yankee23Fan  #1 by @worrierking
#2 by @Ted Lange as your Bartender  #2 by @Alex P Keaton  #2 by @wikkidpissah  #2 by @Bonzai  #2 by @shuke
#Of Lists: 28
Total Points: 566
Top10: 25
#1: 5
#2: 5
#3: 1
#4: 2
#5: 4
#6: 3
#7: 3
#8: 0
#9: 1
#10: 1
Krista Rank -6

- 25 Top 10 lists out of 28 lists total.  (89.2%  :eek: )

- 103 more Total Points than the #2 song  :eek:

Live by Paul 2017

Top 10 Contest - A Day In the Life
Shaft41 - 3
Uruk-hai - 3
Tom Hagen - 3
WIkkid - 3
Falguy - 3
Simey - 3
Man of CS  - 2
Heckmann - 2
Dr O - 1
Binky - 1

Top 10 Contest - FINAL RESULTS
Falguy-14 (wins tiebreaker - hit 4 songs on the nose  :thumbup:  .  ) PM me your charity of choice for the $100  @falguy

Simey-14 (hit the most songs with 8, but only one perfect. Four 2-pointers)

Man Of CS-13 (also had four 2-pointers and one perfect)

Shaft41-11

Tom Hagen-11

Uruk-Hai-11 (scored on his Top 7)

Binky The Doormat-10 (scored 1 point on each of his top 6) (had 10 points and hit 8 songs  :lmao: )

Heckmann-9

Wikkidpissah-8

Dr Octupus-5















THE END















Thank you @krista4  :heart:

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Man of Constant Sorrow said:
Oddly enough - especially when you consider my handle here - I am not much of a bluegrass fan either.

The "Grammy's" for bluegrass were once held in Louisville (which you may already know). I am not sure if they are any more, but...

One year I volunteered to be a driver (Baby you can drive my car...) for the talent. So, I picked up this guy from the hotel and we had about a 10 to 20 minute drive - pending on traffic. 

He got to talkin, way more than the other talent. We never talked about music...just life...really cool guy.

When we got to the Palace, I finally asked what instrument he played? He laughed....guitar.

 

I related this to my buddy that  got me gig.

Him: WTF? You asked him what instrument he played?!

Me: :shrug:

Him: He's the F'n Jimi Hendrix of Bluegrass - moron!

:shrug:
Click to expand...
So who was it? Not a bluegrass man, so guessing a McCoury?

 
Consensus album rankings (total points / number of songs on album; songs outside the consensus 143 get 0 points)

1. Abbey Road (1426 points, 129.64 average) *

2. Let it Be (739, 105.57)

3. Help! (1136 , 87.31)

4. Rubber Soul (1186 , 84.71)

. Revolver (1164 , 83.14)

* Since some people ranked individual songs in the medley, while others ranked the medley as a whole, I took the total points for the album and divided by 11, not by 18.

 
Albums with the fewest songs outside the consensus countdown:

Sgt Peppers (1 - Good Morning) - but only a 75.00 average per song (6th overall)

Abbey Road (1 - Her Majesty) - again, if counting the medley as a single piece; 3 medley songs didn't get an individual vote

Rubber Soul & MMT with 2 each

 
heckmanm said:
Consensus album rankings (total points / number of songs on album; songs outside the consensus 143 get 0 points)

1. Abbey Road (1426 points, 129.64 average) *

2. Let it Be (739, 105.57)

3. Help! (1136 , 87.31)

4. Rubber Soul (1186 , 84.71)

. Revolver (1164 , 83.14)

* Since some people ranked individual songs in the medley, while others ranked the medley as a whole, I took the total points for the album and divided by 11, not by 18.
Click to expand...
Looks like I need to listen to Let It Be more.  

 
Uruk-Hai said:
Getzlaf15 said:
Binky The Doormat-10 (scored 1 point on each of his top 6) (had 10 points and hit 8 songs  :lmao: )
Click to expand...
:lol:
Click to expand...
First of all congrats @falguy !

Many thanks to @Getzlaf15 for tracking all of this - great combination of stats and Beatles love.  

Many thanks to @krista4 for taking on this monumental task and doing it so incredibly well.  

MOCS - at least one of us came close!  

 
Getzlaf15 said:
Composite Ranking #1 - A Day in the Life
Highest Ranked by: #1 by @BobbyLayne  #1 by @ScottNorwood  #1 by @Spock  #1 by @Yankee23Fan  #1 by @worrierking
#2 by @Ted Lange as your Bartender  #2 by @Alex P Keaton  #2 by @wikkidpissah  #2 by @Bonzai  #2 by @shuke
#Of Lists: 28
Total Points: 566
Top10: 25
#1: 5
#2: 5
#3: 1
#4: 2
#5: 4
#6: 3
#7: 3
#8: 0
#9: 1
#10: 1
Krista Rank -6

- 25 Top 10 lists out of 28 lists total.  (89.2%  :eek: )

- 103 more Total Points than the #2 song  :eek:

Live by Paul 2017

Top 10 Contest - A Day In the Life
Shaft41 - 3
Uruk-hai - 3
Tom Hagen - 3
WIkkid - 3
Falguy - 3
Simey - 3
Man of CS  - 2
Heckmann - 2
Dr O - 1
Binky - 1

Top 10 Contest - FINAL RESULTS
Falguy-14 (wins tiebreaker - hit 4 songs on the nose  :thumbup:  .  ) PM me your charity of choice for the $100  @falguy

Simey-14 (hit the most songs with 8, but only one perfect. Four 2-pointers)

Man Of CS-13 (also had four 2-pointers and one perfect)

Shaft41-11

Tom Hagen-11

Uruk-Hai-11 (scored on his Top 7)

Binky The Doormat-10 (scored 1 point on each of his top 6) (had 10 points and hit 8 songs  :lmao: )

Heckmann-9

Wikkidpissah-8

Dr Octupus-5















THE END















Thank you @krista4  :heart:
Click to expand...
Gtfo! 

Was expecting last place.

 
Getzlaf15 said:
@krista4. I'm baby sitting and now there is a cat on my lap. Help.  
Click to expand...
Quick Binky, have Charlie crank the car up and load a lunch basket! 

I'm bringing a tranquilizer gun, a ball of yarn, a laser pointer & catnip. 

Getz, don't move! 

Once we get there, I'm gonna snort the catnip & Binky's gonna shoot me with the tranq gun. 

Charlie will use the lunch basket to lure the cat away. 

Then, we can all play with the yarn & laser pointer. 🥳

Can't wait... 👍

 
Big Blue Wrecking Crew said:
So who was it? Not a bluegrass man, so guessing a McCoury?
Click to expand...
Thanks so much for the question. 

Unfortunately, I can't answer. 🤔

This happened around 2000, and I never really knew his name to begin with. 😕

He was older, white, male, cool & funny. 

I liked him. 👍

 
Hey, I just got done with 10 hours of hiking and figure I’ll settle in and wait for the top 10 to start.  This is going to be great!  You sure have posted a lot today...probably just speculating about the top 10 and Binky whining about Piggies not making it or something.  I’m sure you weren’t going through the actual top 10 without me around!  Go, Getz, go!

 
Getzlaf15 said:
Composite Ranking #10 - Help!
Highest Ranked by: #3 by @Bonzai  #4 by @Getzlaf15  #8 by @Yankee23Fan  #9 by @DocHolliday
#Of Lists: 21
Total Points: 272
Top10: 4
#1: 0
#2: 0
Krista Rank -15

13 FGB ranked this from #11-#17.

Blackpool Night Out, ABC Theatre, Blackpool, United Kingdom


Cheesy live version with Ringo holding an umbrealla.  WTF?

Top 10 Contest - Help
Shaft - 2
Tom Hagen  - 1
Simey . - 1


Top 10 Standings after #10
 

Shaft41-2

Binky The Doormat-2

Tom Hagen-1

Simey-1

Wikkidpissah-0

Uruk-Hai-0

Man Of CS-0

Heckmann-0

Falguy-0

Dr Octupus-0
Click to expand...
Oh.  Nevermind.   :mellow:

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Getzlaf15 said:
Composite Ranking #7 - Elanor Rigby
Highest Ranked by: #1 by @Getzlaf15   :hifive:   #2 by @Binky The Doormat  #3 by @heckmanm  #4 by @Shaft41  #4 by Boise St Bronco @Ilov80s
#Of Lists: 22
Total Points: 319
Top10: 11
#1: 1
#2: 1
Krista Rank -36

As this is winding down for me, actually had an hour of free time with wife today. W/O knowing my #1, she chose Elanor Rigby as her #1.  :clap: Pic of us at Realtor Gala last night on FB.

Mitteleuropa Orchestra

(live London 2007) with orchestra

Top 10 Contest - Elanor Rigby
Heckmann - 1
Wikkid - 1
Simey - 1
Dr. O - 1
Binky - 1

Standings after song #7
 

Tom Hagen-5

Binky The Doormat-5

Shaft41-4

Man Of CS-4

Simey-4

Falguy-3

Uruk-Hai-2

Dr Octupus-2

Wikkidpissah-1

Heckmann-1
Click to expand...
Since it’s your favorite one...it’s “Eleanor.”

 
Last edited by a moderator:
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Hot Sauce Guy
Popular Songs With Terrible Lyrics
2 3
Replies
102
Views
2K
Hot Sauce Guy
Hot Sauce Guy
JB Breakfast Club
FBG Music League
2 3
Replies
103
Views
2K
Ilov80s
Ilov80s
Eephus
2023 Year-end Song Draft - Ends Thursday Jan 25
5 6 7
Replies
325
Views
6K
squistion
squistion

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 11 (members: 0, guests: 11)
Top