Black&Gold
Footballguy
I don't really care what you think of the deal. Isn't posting rosters the same as explaining why a team does a trade? Seems pretty simple to me. Just trying to help. I won't again.
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums
This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
2010 Offseason Dynasty Trades (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter jeter23
- Start date
r0llin_game
Footballguy
I just remember earlier in this thread that someone posted a roster along with their trade and someone got on them about pretty much cluttering the topic up. I don't mind rosters as much, since it does give decent insight on the trade, think I mostly put that out there for the "what do you think of my deal" type question. Biggest point of this thread was to see where value was placed in players that were being traded.
Riffraff
Footballguy
Not a big fan of having to scroll down to bypass the roster being listed. The person listing a trade can just say why they did the trade instead of all of us scanning the roster to figure it out. especially if it's just a single RB for WR or such trade. I don't really need to know who they have at QB, TE, CB, Punter, PK, and defense.
A one line blurb saying their ____ position sucks is why they pulled the trigger is enough for me. I'll believe them, really I will.
A one line blurb saying their ____ position sucks is why they pulled the trigger is enough for me. I'll believe them, really I will.
FreeBaGeL
Footballguy
On the flipside, it's completely unhelpful in determining a player's value when someone posts a trade that's ridiculous in a vacuum, but doesn't explain that it came about because of scoring requirements or a very unbalanced roster.What if I just came in here and posted that I traded Adrian Peterson for David Akers, but neglected to mention that we get 10 points per FG and the only kicker on my roster was John Carney?
r0llin_game
Footballguy
Well that's obviously not posting the scoring or league requirements which is fine by all means. In the trades I've posted, it's said what the requirements were. Obviously what I was trying to get at by my point was if you post a line or two of why you made the trade, perfectly fine. If you post 50 lines of every person on the roster, it clutters the thread if I'm looking on my phone.
FreeBaGeL
Footballguy
Got ya
broncofan13000
Footballguy
* Usual Suspects gave up Bush, Reggie NOS RB;Grant, Ryan GBP RB;Royal, Eddie DEN WR;Wayne, Reggie IND WR
* GOODFELLA'S gave up Stewart, Jonathan CAR RB; Year 2010 Draft Pick 1.11;Year 2010 Draft Pick 3.02; Year 2011 Round 2 Draft Pick from GOODFELLA'S
any thoughts on this one?
* GOODFELLA'S gave up Stewart, Jonathan CAR RB; Year 2010 Draft Pick 1.11;Year 2010 Draft Pick 3.02; Year 2011 Round 2 Draft Pick from GOODFELLA'S
any thoughts on this one?
Like it for godfellas, especially if he's in a win now mode
r0llin_game
Footballguy
lol sigh
Mighty Mice
Footballguy
14 Team PPR scoring league.
I give: Meachem, Maroney, 2.02, 2.12 (16th and 26th overall picks in this draft)
I get: R. Moss, D. Bess
I offered a small price for Bess to shore up the back end of my WR corps, and was willing to give up 2.02 for him if needed. I am pretty sure I would have been overpaying, but I wanted Bess and valued him as a mid-second rounder in a rookie draft. When the other owner counter-offered Moss for Meachem/Maroney and the later pick, I had to take it. Maroney was RB depth, and Meachem was my #3WR. Moss certainly upgrades my #3 spot, costing only RB depth and a pair of "lotto tickets."
I know Moss is 33, but I see no reason he will not have 2-3 good years left. IMO, this is a small price to pay for a likely top 5 WR in 2010, and maybe a top-10 in 2011. Is this trade reflective of Moss's low 2010 dynasty value, or do I over-value Randy?
I give: Meachem, Maroney, 2.02, 2.12 (16th and 26th overall picks in this draft)
I get: R. Moss, D. Bess
I offered a small price for Bess to shore up the back end of my WR corps, and was willing to give up 2.02 for him if needed. I am pretty sure I would have been overpaying, but I wanted Bess and valued him as a mid-second rounder in a rookie draft. When the other owner counter-offered Moss for Meachem/Maroney and the later pick, I had to take it. Maroney was RB depth, and Meachem was my #3WR. Moss certainly upgrades my #3 spot, costing only RB depth and a pair of "lotto tickets."
I know Moss is 33, but I see no reason he will not have 2-3 good years left. IMO, this is a small price to pay for a likely top 5 WR in 2010, and maybe a top-10 in 2011. Is this trade reflective of Moss's low 2010 dynasty value, or do I over-value Randy?
FUBAR
Footballguy
As always, break it down by key players, then add in the rest.KEYS:* Usual Suspects gave up Grant, Ryan GBP RB; Wayne, Reggie IND WR * GOODFELLA'S gave up Stewart, Jonathan CAR RBIf I'm building I like Stew a lot and can easily give up Grant/Wayne but if I'm in win-now, I love the other side of this. DECENT * Usual Suspects gave up Bush, Reggie NOS RB;Royal, Eddie DEN WR * GOODFELLA'S gave up Year 2010 Draft Pick 1.11;IMO either one of these is worth the 1.11 but not much more. FILLER* Usual Suspects gave up * GOODFELLA'S gave up Year 2010 Draft Pick 3.02; Year 2011 Round 2 Draft Pick from GOODFELLA'SI like to give filler and not get filler. Overall, it's a fair trade assuming US is building a G is win-now. I think Goodfellas got the slightly better end of it, but it's hard to give up a guy like Stew.
FUBAR
Footballguy
hmmm, I have Moss and Bess and I think I'd have to trade them for Meachem and the 2nds. I just happen to like Meachem.
massraider
Footballguy
No you won't. He's gonna beat out Ocho, Bryant, and Gresham for targets? Dixon in the 5th is great value.
noleinfrance
Footballguy
16 team ppr/idp dynasty
Team A gives Shonn Greene RB, NYJ and Will Smith, DE, NO Saints
Team B gives Javid Best, RB, Detroit and Kroy Bierman, DE ATL
Team A gives Shonn Greene RB, NYJ and Will Smith, DE, NO Saints
Team B gives Javid Best, RB, Detroit and Kroy Bierman, DE ATL
Multiple Scores
Footballguy
Opposite here. I play IDP and smith/bierman aren't that valuable. I would take Greene over Best and it's not even close.
Multiple Scores
Footballguy
Team A might be getting arrested soon for robbery.Deuceman said:
JohnnyU
Footballguy
Really? I'd rather have any one of Mathews, Bryant, or Best over Moreno and as so many like the phrase, "and it isn't even close". I think Moreno will bust big time.
FreeBaGeL
Footballguy
Ditto, I'd take 1.03 over Moreno any day, as would about half the shark pool. Moreno is the definition of a sell high. He just doesn't have it. The next A-train, Cadillac, Marshawn, etc.
GreatLakesMike
Footballguy
I'd like to see scoring and starting requirements for this league. I haven't seen a draft where Dixon falls past the early 3rd.
Last edited by a moderator:
Matt's Eagles
Footballguy
PPR league 16 team
Team A traded Leon Washington and Justin Forsett
for
Johnny Knox, Stafon Johnson and 2011 2nd round pick (10-16 range)
Team A traded Leon Washington and Justin Forsett
for
Johnny Knox, Stafon Johnson and 2011 2nd round pick (10-16 range)
Donsmith753
Footballguy
...to a Seahawks fan?
Matt's Eagles
Footballguy
Nope to a guy in need of a rb. He has slaton, mendenhall and kevin smith.Donsmith753 said:
shamrock84
Footballguy
Team A gives: Roddy White
Team B gives: Knowshon Moreno, Kenny Britt
Team B gives: Knowshon Moreno, Kenny Britt
ChuckLiddell
Footballguy
Love Team B's side on this one. I would not even think about taking Knowshon/Britt for Roddy, unless a top 5 1st rounder for 2010 or 2011 was also dangled. Even then, I am not sure I would do it. Roddy IMO is a shoe-in top 10 dynasty WR, and those are tough to come by.
FunkyPlutos
Footballguy
Team A gives: Chad Ochocinco
Team B gives: Toby Gerhart
Team B gives: Toby Gerhart
thriftyrocker
Footballguy
Kind of like the Seattle side of the trade. Knox won't be very valuable if Aromashadu is legit assuming Hester plays the other side. Whereas the Seattle RB pair gives you a RB3 in PPR leagues, with some potential for more if White gets hurt or one of them establishes himself as "the guy".
thriftyrocker
Footballguy
Good indication of 85's value, but still highway robbery.
Matt's Eagles
Footballguy
16 team ppr league
Team trades
Shon Greene
for
Dez Bryant and Clinton Portis
Team trades
Shon Greene
for
Dez Bryant and Clinton Portis
Billy Ball Thorton
Footballguy
??PPR Best>>>>>Green
Avery
Footballguy
PPR? I'd do that for Dez in a second.
Matt's Eagles
Footballguy
Yep PPR. I got Dez and Portis
No Way Jose
Footballguy
Team A: 1.02 and Ricky Williams
Team B: Desean Jackson and 3.03
ppr
Team B: Desean Jackson and 3.03
ppr
GSWarriors
Footballguy
Team 1 gets Knox, 2011 2nd, 9ers defense
Team 2 gets Edelman, 2011 1st, Brandon Lafell
Team 1 gets Laurent Robinson, Mike Thomas, 2011 2nd
Team 2 gets Edelman, 2011 4th
Team 1 gets Mike Williams WR TBB
Team 2 gets Sam Bradford.
Team 2 gets Edelman, 2011 1st, Brandon Lafell
Team 1 gets Laurent Robinson, Mike Thomas, 2011 2nd
Team 2 gets Edelman, 2011 4th
Team 1 gets Mike Williams WR TBB
Team 2 gets Sam Bradford.
King of the Jungle
Footballguy
weird
King of the Jungle
Footballguy
PPR
knowshon moreno
eddie royal
big ben
for
1.01
knowshon moreno
eddie royal
big ben
for
1.01
Wow, that's a lot for 1.01. I'm not the biggest Moreno or Ben fan but I'd rather have that end.
Guess I should be shopping Maroney harder...
FreeBaGeL
Footballguy
I'd rather 1.01 by a mile.
Each to his own, I'd rather have the package.
Avery
Footballguy
I'm down on Bowe, but he's gotta be worth more than that.
Steel Dillo
Footballguy
Team A gives up Jackson, Vincent SDC WR; Year 2011 Round 4 Draft Pick
Team B gives up Maclin, Jeremy PHI WR; Year 2011 Round 2 Draft Pick
Zealots League
12 team
Standard Scoring
IDPs
53 MAn rosters
Team B gives up Maclin, Jeremy PHI WR; Year 2011 Round 2 Draft Pick
Zealots League
12 team
Standard Scoring
IDPs
53 MAn rosters
As a Roddy White owner that would be turned down quickly.
Similar threads
