Chaka
Footballguy
Okay I get that everyone views me as the Negative Nellie in here but what did I fabricate?Yeah, not sure why the need to completely fabricate arguments to make Carr look worse than he was. Some kind of agenda, but what?Actually Carr didn't have Streater last season and Streater was by far the Raiders best WR in 2013 when McGloin played.Chaka said:Okay but it was the same guys at WR and Olson was the OC. The difference between 2013 and 2014 is the QB(s) not the OC or WRs.Toomuchnv said:Raiders ranked 31st in YAC avg in 2014 with 4.5 YAC per reception on 365 receptions. In 2013 they ranked 6th at 6.1 YAC per reception on 298 receptions. I gotta think that has something to do with it no?Chaka said:I'm not going to cross reference Olson coached offenses as it relates to YAC. I've done enough on that front but they had pretty much the same WRs in Oakland in 2013 and the QBs overall YPA was over a yard better.
Also, the running game for Oakland last season was epically bad. That hurt as well.
Don't get me wrong. Carr has a ways to go and a lot to learn yet. I'm not trying to make excuses here but I will wait to see how he does in the regular season before I make any declarations one way or the other on Carr.
2013: Streater - 100 targets, Moore - 86 targets, Jennings - 48 targets out of the backfield
2014: Jones - 112 targets, Holmes - 99 targets, Rivera - 99 targets, McFadden - 56 targets out of the backfield
Think what you will about the names, but they're certainly not the same, or used in the same way.
These guys were terrible getting YAC. Not surprising, when you read the names. They had hope for Jones, but it was unfounded. The 2013 guys were nothing to write odes to, but were measurably better. And why compare Olson offenses across the years against teams that were running Torry Holt, Isaac Bruce, and a young SJax out there? Of course they were 1.5 or 2 yards better each time. Look at the names, man!
It's crazy to be pessimistic about Carr coming off that season with those "weapons." Give the kid a sophomore year with guys orders of magnitude better everywhere but maybe TE, and see if he and they show even more signs of life. If not, THEN look for reasons why. All of the things that have changed about the offense are reasons it should improve. None of the things that have changed are reasons it should be stagnant, or regress. They are better everywhere, have more experience at the young-and-talented positions, and face an infinitely easier slate of games.
Negativity to this extent with this quantum shift forward in terms of talent and situation isn't devil's advocate; it's irrational pessimism.
It seems more like a fabrication to suggest that Rod Streater is so magical and talented that he would have bumped Carr's YPA from terrible to...what? Mediocre?
I have repeatedly stated that I think Carr can be the guy but I simply don't understand why people are anointing him before he has actually accomplished anything.
Rod Streater guys? Rod freaking Streater? Are you kidding me? Look at the pre-Carr and post Carr numbers for all of the Raider's WRs in 2013 & 2014.
Moore 15.1 to 9.6
Rivera 10.7 to 9.2
Holmes 17.2 to 14.7
Streater 14.8 to 9.3 (only 13 targets so I am sure he would have turned that around for the whole team in a huge way, right?)
Butler 11.4 to 13.3 (WINNING!!!)
Come on guys I don't mind if you argue against my lone point (and that is really my only point) but I sincerely take exception to the suggestion that I have an agenda or am making #### up.
Rod ####### Streater? Yeesh,
Last edited by a moderator:
People are going way overboard on Carr. I can't remember who it was, but I heard an NFL commentator describe his rookie year as brilliant. He showed enough last year to give us some optimism, which we badly needed, but that's as far as I'm willing to go.
and let's see what we got, Kay?
Nobody's saying Rod Streater is Jerry Rice. We're saying that there's evidence he and Moore were better than Jones and Holmes. Just that there's evidence, and it's worth evaluating each season very differently given all the differences -- QB, WR's, guys out of the backfield, AND OC.