btemp
Footballguy
"an average RB"?
Gruden / Mayock had HORRIBLE drafts. It's kind of hard to get how bad. Here's their draft history (reminder Mayock / Gruden drafted from 2018 to 2021): https://www.pro-football-reference.com/teams/rai/draft.htm
That's 7 first round picks - with ZERO hits. The best pick has been an average RB who didn't even get his 5th year option picked up.
There's also a lot of hype about last year, but the Raiders squeaked into the playoffs after playing THE easiest schedule in the NFL. The teams they played had the worst win total in 2021 and thus
the Raiders had the #1 cucpcake schedule. And still - barely got into the playoffs.
I say all this just to point out - McDaniels tenure has been bad. But he didn't take over a real playoff team, he took over a bad team with a very abd talent level. A team which had 1 winning season since 2016 while playing the easiest schedule in the entire NFL. This isn't an excuse for McDaniels and Carr, but a reflection that, to DocHolliday's point, they are part of a bad organization that appeared better than it was due to a flukey 2021.Ok.
He's had a negative DVOA in 2021 and 2020 and a barely positive DVOA in 2019. For those unfamiliar, DVOA is an efficiency metric which is a far superior analysis to looking at simple yards or TDs. In 2022. It factors in situation - getting 1 yard on 3rd and 1 is a success but getting 1 yard on 2nd and 8 is a failure.
In DVOA the last two years, Jacobs has ranked 38th and 39th. And as a receiver, one of the most important skills for today's RBs, he's also been a detriment. He was mildly positive in rushing (not receiving) his first year and this year is finally ranked in the top 10 at 5.
Jacobs has not been very good until a few games this year. I don't know what you would point to otherwise. Maybe now he becomes a good back but up until this point he's been average in his performance, at best. And the Raiders not picking up his 5th year option tell you exactly what they think.
Ok.
