Desert Island Album Draft - 15th Anniversary Edition - 50 Rounds in the books, sign up now for KP's listening program (2 Viewers)

[Eephus]

Roll #1 was a 9 which was the first Arctic Monkeys album.  Love it but was looking for something new.

Roll #2 was a 32 Amadou and Mariam / Dimanche a Bamako.  I know they're African but not the region and I think Dimanche is a day of the week in French.  We have a winner

 

[Binky The Doormat]

I took Post-Nothing somewhere in the middle of the draft.  Someone else got Celebration Rock earlier on.

you likely know, but you have rds 49 and 50 left if you wish to make them.

 

[Northern Voice]

Out cruising around this afternoon. I'll listen to whatever album someone posts first (that was drafted).

Børns - Dopamine

So, I was familiar with the big song from this one before listening. Overall, it's a very good album of electro/psych pop-rock, not unlike a lot of other bands I listen to - the poppier ones leaning towards MGMT and the more rocking ones maybe towards a Dear Rouge or something. 

My favourite songs were 10,000 Emerald Pools, Dopamine, Holy Ghost and Electric Love. 

The one negative for me and what keeps me liking it and not loving it is his voice. I imagine this could be a selling point for other people but an album full of falsetto wore me out. A feel like a woman's voice or a deeper/more direct man's voice over the same songs I would really love. 

 

[Eephus]

Out cruising around this afternoon. I'll listen to whatever album someone posts first (that was drafted).

Børns - Dopamine

So, I was familiar with the big song from this one before listening. Overall, it's a very good album of electro/psych pop-rock, not unlike a lot of other bands I listen to - the poppier ones leaning towards MGMT and the more rocking ones maybe towards a Dear Rouge or something. 

My favourite songs were 10,000 Emerald Pools, Dopamine, Holy Ghost and Electric Love. 

The one negative for me and what keeps me liking it and not loving it is his voice. I imagine this could be a selling point for other people but an album full of falsetto wore me out. A feel like a woman's voice or a deeper/more direct man's voice over the same songs I would really love. 

I have a pair of their clogs

 

[otb_lifer]

I almost took this for my Rd 49 pick, but felt I needed the soothing peace of the violin and piano duo I took. I can visit the other Doors islands. Waiting for the Sun was probably their most experimental album. My favorite tune on the album is Love Street. I also considered Absolutely Live if only to hear Jim's wild scream on Backdoor Man. That could have been the first thing anyone heard as they step foot on the island, and they could decide from there if they wanted to stay.

...yeah, that live album is as hallmark as any selected, Jim's the biggest personality of any of 'em on the stage. 

"Love Street" and "Spanish Caravan" were tough leave offs, as was "Unknown Soldier"

 

[wikkidpissah]

ok - free til dinner. gimme sumn to review

 

[Northern Voice]

ok - free til dinner. gimme sumn to review

Elbow - The Seldom Seen Kid

 

[Uruk-Hai]

Secret skeptic? count me in -

Hell with it..... I'll do it if there's room. I stopped at 45 albums, though - don't know if that matters

 

[Northern Voice]

ETA: probably lead the league in 70s (18) and female artists (9) and least 21st C albums (tres). and classical...

I had 12 female artists, not counting The New Pornographers who are 50/50 or bands like Arcade Fire/Rural Alberta Advantage who have one female singer. Probably others had more than me. 

 

[Northern Voice]

ok - free til dinner. gimme sumn to review

Elbow - The Seldom Seen Kid

I looked at both of our islands and we are so far opposites, this is the closest I could see possibly hitting a meeting of the minds other than like an obvious U2 or Bowie or such. 

 

[Northern Voice]

Final Island Haul:

• Neil Young    -    Harvest    1971
  
• Queen    -      Sheer Heart Attack   1974
  
• Bruce Springsteen    -    Born to Run    1975
  
• The Ramones    -    The Ramones    1976
  
• David Bowie    -    Low    1977
  
• Iggy Pop    -    Lust For Life    1977
  
•  
  
• Talking Heads    -    Remain in Light    1980
  
• INXS    -    Shabooh Shoobah    1982
  
• Janet Jackson    -    Rhythm Nation 1814    1986
  
• Pet Shop Boys    -     actually.   1987
  
• The Traveling Wilburys   Vol 1    1988
  
• Nine Inch Nails    -    Pretty Hate Machine    1989
  
•  
  
• The La's     -      The La's   1990
  
• U2    -    Achtung Baby    1991
  
• Pearl Jam    -    Ten    1991
  
• Pulp     -      His 'n' Hers    1994
  
• Suede   -    Dog Man Star  1994
  
• The Smashing Pumpkins    -     Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness   1995
  
• Alanis Morissette     -    Jagged Little Pill   1995
  
• Sloan     -      One Chord to Another   1996
  
• The Tragically Hip    -    Live Between Us    1997
  
• Dixie Chicks    -    Fly    1999
  
• Matthew Good Band    -     Beautiful Midnight  1999
  
•  
  
• The Strokes    -    Is This It?    2001
  
• Spoon    -    Kill The Moonlight     2002
  
• The New Pornographers    -    Electric Version  2003
  
• The Killers    -    Hot Fuss    2004
  
• Arcade Fire    -    Funeral    2004
  
• Franz Ferdinand    -    Franz Ferdinand    2004
  
• Modest Mouse    -    Good News for People Who Love Bad News    2004
  
• The Streets   -    A Grand Don't Come For Free   2004
  
• LCD Soundsystem    -    LCD Soundsystem    2005
  
• The National     -     Alligator  2005
  
• The Hold Steady    -    Boys and Girls in America    2006
  
• My Chemical Romance    -   The Black Parade   2006
  
• Rihanna   -    Good Girl Gone Bad  2007
  
• Frightened Rabbit    -    The Midnight Organ Fight    2008
  
• Arkells    -    Jackson Square    2008
  
• Elbow    -    The Seldom Seen Kid    2008
  
• Metric    -    Fantasies   2009
  
•  
  
• Robyn    -    Body Talk  2010
  
• Tokyo Police Club     -    Champ    2010
  
• Arctic Monkeys    -    AM    2013
  
• Lorde    -    Pure Herione    2013
  
• The Rural Alberta Advantage      -       Mended With Gold   2014
  
• Taylor Swift    -    1989     2014
  
• Courtney Barnett    -    Sometimes I Sit And Think, And Sometimes I Just Sit    2015
  
• PUP    -    The Dream is Over    2016
  
• Charly Bliss     -     Young Enough  2019
  
• Lana Del Rey    -     Norman ####### Rockwell! 2019
  

-----

1970s - 6

1980s - 6

1990s - 11

2000s - 17

2010s - 10

----

USA 21.5

UK 12.5

CAN 12

AUS 1

NZ 1

BAR 1

SWE 1

wikkid haul: 

classical (10): Beethoven's 9th, Bach's Art of Fugue & Cello Suites (my only double up), Debussy/Ravel String Quartets, Schubert String Quintet, Mozart's Sinfonia Concertante, keyboard suites by Chopin, DScarlatti, ESatie & GHandel

jazz (3): MDavis, Kind of Blue. The Essential Django Reinhardt, Bill Evans - Alone

1960s (4): JHendrix, Are You Experienced; Dr. John - GRIS-gris; It's a Beautiful Day; Rolling Stones - Aftermath

1970s (18): SWonder - Fulfillingness' First Finale; Little Feat - Dixie Chicken; JMitchell - Shadows & Light; Mahavishnu Orchestra - Inner Mounting Flame; The Yes Album;  TWaits - Nighthawks; Jethro Tull - Thick as a Brick; Santana - Abraxas; Earth, Wind & Fire - Gratitude; The Allman Brothers Band; Laura Nyro & LaBelle - Gonna Take a Miracle; BRaitt - Give It Up; EL&P - Brain Salad Surgery; Rickie Lee Jones; Genesis Live; EMcIlwaine - Honky Tonk Angel; Aretha - Hey Now Hey; The Pointer Sisters

1980s (9): Prince - 1999; Peter Gabriel Plays Live; XTC - Skylarking; U2 - Under a Blood Red Sky; ECostello - Punch the Clock; Steely Dan - Gaucho; The Police - Zenyatta Mondatta; BBrown - Don't Be Cruel; Was Not Was - What Up Dog?

1990s (3): Bjork - Homogenic; Foo Fighters - There Is Nothing Left To Lose; Stone Temple Pilots - No 4;

2000s (uno): Plant & Krauss - Raising Sand;

2010s (dos): AWinehouse - Back to Black; Radiohead - Moon-shaped Pool

ETA: probably lead the league in 70s (18) and female artists (9) and least 21st C albums (tres). and classical...

Like seriously, our islands are in different hemispheres I think. 

 

[wikkidpissah]

I looked at both of our islands and we are so far opposites, this is the closest I could see possibly hitting a meeting of the minds other than like an obvious U2 or Bowie or such. 

no - i want your best. and i'd prefer a studio album for concept. i'll still check Elbow and do it, but gimme the hardest time your island has right off

 

[Ilov80s]

I'll roll a d50 and take one of your albums for a noontime walk to Alamo Square

ETA:  I'll do one of pik's picks after that

Nice, I’ll queue up yours for an afternoon walk.

 

[Northern Voice]

I looked at both of our islands and we are so far opposites, this is the closest I could see possibly hitting a meeting of the minds other than like an obvious U2 or Bowie or such. 

no - i want your best. and i'd prefer a studio album for concept. i'll still check Elbow and do it, but gimme the hardest time your island has right off

Have you listened to the first albums by Franz Ferdinand (2004, self titled) or The Strokes (2001, Is This It? ). That's what I'd throw at someone trying to get the early 00s rock that I love and doesn't make your island. 

 

[Binky The Doormat]

1.21Binky the Doormat-The Beatles-Revolver1966

2.20Binky the Doormat-Led Zeppelin-II1969

3.21Binky the Doormat-Jethro Tull-Aqualung1971

4.20Binky the Doormat-Yes-Yessongs1973

5.21Binky the Doormat-Neil Young-After the Goldrush1970

6.20Binky the Doormat-Elton John-Tumbleweed Connection1970

7.21Binky the Doormat-Traffic-The Low Spark of High Heeled Boys1971

8.20Binky the Doormat-Cream-Disraeli Gears1967

9.21Binky the Doormat-Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young-Deja Vu1970

10.20Binky the Doormat-The Who-Live at Leeds1970

1121Binky the Doormat-Genesis-Trick Of The Tail1976

12.20Binky the Doormat-Todd Rundgren-A Wizard A True Star1973

13.21Binky the Doormat-Rush-21121976

14.20Binky the Doormat-U2-All That You Can't Leave Behind2000

1521Binky the Doormat-The Allman Brothers Band-Eat A Peach1972

16.20Binky the Doormat-Brian Eno-Here Come The Warm Jets1974

17.21Binky the Doormat-Small Faces-There Are But Four Small Faces1968

18.20Binky the Doormat-Fiona Apple-Tidal1996

19.21Binky the Doormat-The Stranglers-No More Heroes1977

20.20Binky the Doormat-Black Sabbath-Sabbath Bloody Sabbath1973

21.21Binky the Doormat-Roxy Music-Avalon1982

22.20Binky the Doormat-The Moody Blues-Days Of Future Past1967

23.21Binky the Doormat-Squeeze-Argybargy1980

24.20Binky the Doormat-Queens Of The Stone Age-Songs For The Deaf2002

25.21Binky the Doormat-Talking HeadsLittle Creatures1985

26.20Binky the Doormat-Steve Miller Band-Brave New World1969

27.21Binky the Doormat-Mott the Hoople-Mott1974

28.20Binky the Doormat-The Tubes-Remote Control1979

29.22Binky the Doormat-The Doobie Brothers-The Captain And Me1973

30.20Binky the Doormat-Utopia-Oblivion1984

31.21Binky the Doormat-Grand Funk Railroad-Caught In The Act1975

32.20Binky the Doormat-Tom Petty And The Heartbreakers-You're Gonna Get It!1978

33.21Binky the Doormat-Chris Isaak-Heart Shaped World1989

34.20Binky the Doormat-Robert Plant-Now And Zen1988

35.21Binky the Doormat-Peter Gabriel-Growing Up Live2003

36.20Binky the Doormat-Procol Harum-Procol Harum1967

37.21Binky the Doormat-Electric Light Orchestra-Face The Music1975

38.20Binky the Doormat-Fleetwood Mac-Fleetwood Mac1975

39.21Binky the Doormat-Ted Nugent-Ted Nugent Double Live Gonzo!1978

40.20Binky the Doormat-David Bowie-Live In Santa Monica 19721972

41.21Binky the Doormat-Bonnie Raitt-Luck Of The Draw1991

42.20Binky the Doormat-Sting-Ten Summoner's Tales1993

43.21Binky the Doormat-The Guess Who-American Woman1970

44.20Binky the Doormat-Supertramp-Crime Of The Century1974

45.21Binky the Doormat-Bryan Ferry-Boys And Girls1985

46.20Binky the Doormat-Ambrosia-Ambrosia1975

47.21Binky the Doormat-The Rolling Stones-Get Yer Ya-Ya's Out1970

48.20Binky the Doormat-Jellyfish-Bellybutton1990

49.21Binky the Doormat-Elvis Costello & The Imposters-Look Now2018

50.20Binky the Doormat-Frank Zappa-Over-Nite Sensation1973

 

[wikkidpissah]

Have you listened to the first albums by Franz Ferdinand (2004, self titled) or Strokes (2001, Is This It? ). That's what I'd throw at someone trying to get the early 00s rock that I love and doesn't make your island. 

i've listened to FF all the way thru, but it's been a while. close to my favorite of the 21st C bands. i've tried Strokes a dozen times and quit. which to you want me to do?

 

[Northern Voice]

i've listened to FF all the way thru, but it's been a while. close to my favorite of the 21st C bands. i've tried Strokes a dozen times and quit. which to you want me to do?

If you know those grab a new one. Courtney Barnett? The New Pornographers? I'll do one of yours shortly too. No classical or Jazz plz

 

[wikkidpissah]

If you know those grab a new one. Courtney Barnett? The New Pornographers? I'll do one of yours shortly too. No classical or Jazz plz

heard a good bit of both (tho Barnett only w Kurt Vile). i'm not deeply familiar with any of em, i'm old and flush all memory as soon as i determine i dont need it, so it'll be a pretty fresh listen on all of em. pick one and tell me if you want top-o-my-head impression or double-listen analysis. i love #### like this - i only never do it cuz nobody gives me a reason anymore

 

[zamboni]

My ice-land. Serving margaritas with prune juice chasers.

zamboni-Television-Marquee Moon 1977

zamboni-Love-Forever Changes 1967

zamboni-The Band-Music From Big Pink 1968

zamboni-Queen-A Night at the Opera 1975

zamboni-Iron Maiden-The Number of the Beast 1982

zamboni-Miles Davis-#####es Brew 1970

zamboni-Chicago Transit Authority-Chicago Transit Authority 1969

zamboni-Cat Stevens-Tea For The Tillerman 1970

zamboni-King Crimson-In The Court Of The Crimson King 1969

zamboni-Moby Grape-Moby Grape 1967

zamboni-Thin Lizzy-Live & Dangerous 1978

zamboni-Def Leppard-Pyromania 1983

zamboni-Tears for Fears-The Hurting 1984

zamboni-Varied Artists-Valley Girl Soundtrack 1983

zamboni-Deep Purple-Machine Head 1972

zamboni-John Coltrane-A Love Supreme 1965

zamboni-Buffalo Springfield-Buffalo Springfield Again 1967

zamboni-Lynyrd Skynyrd-(Pronounced 'Lĕh-'nérd 'Skin-'nérd) 1973

zamboni-The Church-Starfish 1988

zamboni-Scorpions-Blackout 1982

zamboni-Simon and Garfunkel-Bookends 1968

zamboni-Rush-Hemispheres 1978

zamboni-David Gilmour-Live In Gdansk 2008

zamboni-Robin Trower-Bridge of Sighs 1974

zamboni-Hall & Oates-Abandoned Luncheonette 1973

zamboni-ABC-The Lexicon of Love 1982

zamboni-Earth, Wind & Fire-That's the Way of the World 1975

zamboni-Jefferson Airplane-Surrealistic Pillow 1967

zamboni-Booker T. And The MGs-Green Onions 1962

zamboni-Humble Pie-Performance Rockin' The Fillmore 1971

zamboni-Jimmy Cliff-Wonderful World, Beautiful People 1970

zamboni-Wishbone Ash-Argus 1972

zamboni-Midnight Oil-Diesel And Dust 1987

zamboni-Van Halen-Fair Warning 1981

zamboni-Living Colour-Vivid 1988

zamboni-Spirit-Twelve Dreams of Dr. Sardonicus 1970

zamboni-Billy Squier-Don't Say No 1981

zamboni-Robert Cray-Strong Persuader 1986

zamboni-Mike Bloomfield, Al Kooper, and Stephen Stills-Super Session 1968

zamboni-Ozzy Osbourne-Blizzard of Ozz 1980

zamboni-UFO-Strangers In The Night 1979

zamboni-Simply Red-Stars 1991

zamboni-Quicksilver Messenger Service-Happy Trails 1969

zamboni-Weather Report-Weather Report 1977

zamboni-Oingo Boingo-Only A Lad 1985

zamboni-The Clientele-Strange Geometry 2005

zamboni-Manassas-Manassas 1972

zamboni-The Hooters-Nervous Night 1985

zamboni-Ennio Morricone-Once Upon A Time In America (Soundtrack) 1983

zamboni-Mike Massé-Covers (Mostly Live) 2012

 

[Binky The Doormat]

sorry ...I should have waited to post until after I organized it first ...

note:  I turned 12 in 1970 and carried a metal Beatles lunchbox with matching thermos at age 6

1960s

The Beatles - Revolver

Cream - Disraeli Gears

The Moody Blues - Days Of Future Past

Procol Harum - Procol Harum

Small Faces - There Are But Four Small Faces

Led Zeppelin - Led Zeppelin II

Steve Miller Band - Brave New World

1970s

Neil Young - After the Goldrush

Elton John - Tumbleweed Connection

Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young - Deja Vu

The Who - Live at Leeds

The Guess Who - American Woman

The Rolling Stones - Get Yer Ya-Ya's Out

Jethro Tull - Aqualung

Traffic - The Low Spark of High Heeled Boys

The Allman Brothers Band - Eat A Peach

David Bowie - Live In Santa Monica 1972

Yes - Yessongs

Todd Rundgren - A Wizard A True Star

Black Sabbath - Sabbath Bloody Sabbath

The Doobie Brothers - The Captain And Me

Frank Zappa - Over-Nite Sensation

Brian Eno - Here Come The Warm Jets

Mott the Hoople - Mott

Supertramp - Crime Of The Century

Grand Funk Railroad - Caught In The Act

Electric Light Orchestra - Face The Music

Fleetwood Mac - Fleetwood Mac

Ambrosia - Ambrosia

Genesis - Trick Of The Tail

Rush - 2112

The Stranglers - No More Heroes

Tom Petty And The Heartbreakers - You're Gonna Get It!

Ted Nugent - Ted Nugent Double Live Gonzo!

The Tubes - Remote Control

1980s

Squeeze - Argybargy

Roxy Music - Avalon

Utopia - Oblivion

Talking Heads - Little Creatures

Bryan Ferry - Boys And Girls

Robert Plant - Now And Zen

Chris Isaak - Heart Shaped World

1990s

Jellyfish - Bellybutton

Bonnie Raitt - Luck Of The Draw

Sting - Ten Summoner's Tales

Fiona Apple - Tidal

2000s

U2 - All That You Can't Leave Behind

Queens Of The Stone Age - Songs For The Deaf

Peter Gabriel - Growing Up Live

2010s

Elvis Costello & The Imposters - Look Now

 

[Northern Voice]

heard a good bit of both (tho Barnett only w Kurt Vile). i'm not deeply familiar with any of em, i'm old and flush all memory as soon as i determine i dont need it, so it'll be a pretty fresh listen on all of em. pick one and tell me if you want top-o-my-head impression or double-listen analysis. i love #### like this - i only never do it cuz nobody gives me a reason anymore

Do Courtney Barnett Sometimes I Sit and Think...

its different enough than her stuff with Vile and for New Pornos, I'd actually recommend the album Tasker took over the one I have anyway. 

 

[wikkidpissah]

okeydokey - first impression or two-dayer?

 

[Northern Voice]

okeydokey - first impression or two-dayer?

Sure double down. 

 

[wikkidpissah]

Sure double down. 

This is gonna be FUN! First listen and i got tons to say

 

[Northern Voice]

This is gonna be FUN! First listen and i got tons to say

 

[Ilov80s]

I asked Siri for my random number to listen to an @Eephus album. I got 48 (I noticed while scrolling that you don't have a pick in for round 47) which was an album by some guy named Terrence Trent D'Arby. Honestly, zero clue what this is. I see it's from 92 so I am expecting some 90s style R&B. The name is throwing me though. I feel like most people would change their name to something more catchy like Terrence Trent or just Terrence or Trent D'Arby. The 3 name thing is tough to pull off in music.  

4 tracks in:

- the beginning of the album where it sounds like chanting "welcome to a Monastery" and the album is called Symphony or Damn had me wondering if it was actually going to be some kind of experimental classical -electronic avant-garde thing. Its not, it's much more like Prince. I think my 90s R&B hunch was right. 

7 tracks in: 

- doing Google now and it blew my mind that Terrence Trent D'Arby isn't even his given name- like not even close. This is the stage name he chose? Why not just stick with your real name, Sananda? That's a cool name- reminds me of Sade. As does some of the music. I like this duet called Delicate. So far I think the first real song called She Kissed Me was my least favorite. It was too Lenny Kravitz straight forward rock. 

11 tracks in: 

- also cool to see that he's a multi-instrumentalist, that is always really impressive. It's good music, my biggest complaint is that it's all too clean for me. This is so polished and I tend to like stuff a little less so. Despite so many songs, he does a good job keeping things fresh. 

final 6 tracks: 

- he's really good at changing his voice, sometimes he sounds like Otis and other times like Jeff Buckley and then Smokey or Marvin Gaye. Sometimes even on the same song. 

- the guy is really talented and it's a heck of a collection here with over an hour of solid music. He even pulls out a piano ballad to close it. Not many highs but not too many lows either, very consistent album. I doubt I will go further into his catalog, but I enjoyed hearing it. 

 

[Abrantes]

This is gonna be FUN! First listen and i got tons to say

 

[Eephus]

Amadou and Mariam  - Dimanche a Bamako    (2005) - drafted by @Ilov80s in round 32

Amadou and Mariam are a blind husband/wife couple from Mali who sing in French.  I'm more familiar with their Taureg countrymen Tinariwen and Bombino.  A&M's music is similar but probably a bit less guitar heavy and immediately accessible to Rock audiences than the other two artists I mentioned. 

Amadou plays guitar but shared the spotlight with a variety of percussionists.  One song featured harmonica and another a trumpet.  Mariam and Amadou mostly swapped lead vocals; they rarely sang together and when they did, it was almost always in octaves rather than more complex harmony.  My tourist French wasn't adequate to decipher the lyrics but there were a couple of times where English words jumped out.  I don't think many of the songs followed Western verse/chorus structures.  More often there were repeated refrains separated by instrumental breaks.

  It was good walking music with its bubbling polyrhythms.  I liked Camions Sauvages with its chunky rhythm guitar and overlapping vocal lines.

 

[Eephus]

I asked Siri for my random number to listen to an @Eephus album. I got 48 (I noticed while scrolling that you don't have a pick in for round 47) 

 

[KarmaPolice]

Everybody starting this without me??!!

 So, it looks like the only other poster to say they are in today was @wikkidpissah?

That will bring us to 21.  

I will put out the bat signal to @Nigel Tufnel since he was waffling a little and reiterate that there is no minimum albums required and no elaborate writeups required.  Just listening to a few from an island for something to do...

 

[KarmaPolice]

4 or 5 should be good - I like what you did with my island. Randomly assign me an island, based on my interests have that island suggest a handful or so and I pick 2 or 3 of them. Then I pick 2 others on my own.

Yeah I'm thinking I will choose 1 or more, have the islander give me at least one "blind" suggestion just based on what the islander is feeling and maybe a suggestion based on my feedback and then see if kp will give a random 50-sided die roll for a totally rando album. Kind of want some immersion on the island I'm assigned to.

I think this is about what I was going to try, but I will be honest - some islands I could go 20+, and some maybe a handful, so I really want to keep it loose and open to other people's schedules and music tastes.  

If somebody wants to do 10 with elaborate write-ups, knock yourselves out.  

 

[wikkidpissah]

Everybody starting this without me??!!

 So, it looks like the only other poster to say they are in today was @wikkidpissah?

That will bring us to 21.  

I will put out the bat signal to @Nigel Tufnel since he was waffling a little and reiterate that there is no minimum albums required and no elaborate writeups required.  Just listening to a few from an island for something to do...

i dont really know what's goin on. i said "shoot", NV shot, after my review tomorrow i'll fall in line or be odd man out for Secret Skeptic if there's not an even #

 

[Eephus]

I'm going to listen to one of @PIK95's albums next.  I rolled a 33 which gives us.

Tesla    -    The Great Radio Controversy    (1989)

I'm pretty sure I own a copy of this on vinyl.  1989 was a dark year for promotional copies on vinyl as most labels had switched to CD or even cassettes by then.  I must have found this in a cheap bin of promo LPs.  I'm certain I haven't listened to it since at least 1992 when most of my vinyl went into storage.

 

[Val Rannous]

OK, back up and running, on with the list!

Desert Island Take VII

Pick 19:  B-52's, Cosmic Thing (1989).  From comments earlier today, looks like I wasn't the only one who thought this needed to be drafted.  I thought the extra musicians on this version of the band gave them a more rounded out sound without losing their punk edges.

• Love Shack
  
• Roam
  

Pick 20:  Pandora's Box, Original Sin (1989).  Yep, more Steinman.  This band idea apparently came from an idea of his that he wanted multiple lead female singers, all of whom sounded like, in his words, "horny angels".  Since this never got a lot of notice, a lot of the songs got re-used in later Steinman projects.

• Original Sin
  
• It's All Coming Back To Me Now
  

Pick 21:  Stevie Ray Vaughn and Double Trouble, In Step (1989).  Got my ZZ, now I need some Stevie Ray to finish up my Texas Boogie set.  Stevie Ray was one of those artists that was really just getting started when he was taken from us - when will the great ones learn to stay off of things that fly?

• This House is Rockin'
  
• Crossfire
  

 

[Ilov80s]

Everybody starting this without me??!!

 So, it looks like the only other poster to say they are in today was @wikkidpissah?

That will bring us to 21.  

I will put out the bat signal to @Nigel Tufnel since he was waffling a little and reiterate that there is no minimum albums required and no elaborate writeups required.  Just listening to a few from an island for something to do...

I am still in. That was just a side thing @Eephus and I did. We even got in before you posted the pairings. 

 

[Binky The Doormat]

OK, back up and running, on with the list!

Desert Island Take VI

Pick 19:  B-52's, Cosmic Thing (1989).  From comments earlier today, looks like I wasn't the only one who thought this needed to be drafted.  I thought the extra musicians on this version of the band gave them a more rounded out sound without losing their punk edges.

• Love Shack
  
• Roam
  

Pick 20:  Pandora's Box, Original Sin (1989).  Yep, more Steinman.  This band idea apparently came from an idea of his that he wanted multiple lead female singers, all of whom sounded like, in his words, "horny angels".  Since this never got a lot of notice, a lot of the songs got re-used in later Steinman projects.

• Original Sin
  
• It's All Coming Back To Me Now
  

Pick 21:  Stevie Ray Vaughn and Double Trouble, In Step (1989).  Got my ZZ, now I need some Stevie Ray to finish up my Texas Boogie set.  Stevie Ray was one of those artists that was really just getting started when he was taken from us - when will the great ones learn to stay off of things that fly?

• This House is Rockin'
  
• Crossfire
  

enjoying following along ...

 

[krista4]

i dont really know what's goin on. i said "shoot", NV shot, after my review tomorrow i'll fall in line or be odd man out for Secret Skeptic if there's not an even #

I didn’t expect we’d be paired in parallel, such as I listen to yours and you listen to mine, but that it would be round robin, for which we don’t need even numbers.  KP?

 

[KarmaPolice]

Ok, now I am confused - are we pairing up, or do I shuffle the names?  Wikkid in or out?

 

[KarmaPolice]

I didn’t expect we’d be paired in parallel, such as I listen to yours and you listen to mine, but that it would be round robin, for which we don’t need even numbers.  KP?

Correct - I am just going to shuffle numbers and assign my list of names another person.   # of participants or even/odd matters not.  

 

[KarmaPolice]

All right, I am posting in the PSF too much, so I need a project here, so I am going to post the pairing for the music listening.  

Could somebody post 2 numbers between 1 and 10, please?

I am including wikkid in the shuffle since he said he would fall in line.   PIK said he would if needed, but isn't on this initial list, so if Mr.Tufnel would like to join, I will pair those two together.  

 

[Val Rannous]

7, 9

 

[wikkidpissah]

Ok, now I am confused - are we pairing up, or do I shuffle the names?  Wikkid in or out?

one may almost always successfully assume i'm in on any opportunity to improve y'all w my opinions

 

[KarmaPolice]

one may almost always successfully assume i'm in on any opportunity to improve y'all w my opinions

Lol.  Fair enough.

 

[Dr. Octopus]

Ok, now I am confused - are we pairing up, or do I shuffle the names?  Wikkid in or out?

Shuffle names. Wikkid is in.

 

[KarmaPolice]

7, 9

Alright, basically a triple shuffle.  A little overkill, but I have my list from the post above of the 21 participants.  I am going to do the number sequence randomizer and click it 9 times - at 7 I will write the names of the reviewer, and at 9 I will stop and line them up with the island they are visiting.  

 

[simey]

Ok, now I am confused - are we pairing up, or do I shuffle the names?  Wikkid in or out?

In post #8 it looks like Uruk is saying he is in.

 

[KarmaPolice]

In post #8 it looks like Uruk is saying he is in.

####

 

[Buffaloes]

island contents for whatever poor FBG shipwrecks here...


 

• LCD Soundsystem - American Dream
  
• Yo La Tengo- I Can Hear the Heart Beating as One
  
• Sublime - 40 Oz to Freedom
  
• D'Angelo - Voodoo
  
• Bill Withers - Still Bill
  
• The Offspring - Ignition
  
• The Strokes - First Impressions of Earth
  
• David gray - White Ladder
  
• Beck - Morning Phase
  
• Atoms for Peace - Amok
  
• Soundgarden - Down on the Upside
  
• N.E.R.D. - In Search of...
  
• Glass Animals - Zaba
  
• Blur - 13
  
• Steve Winwood - Back in the High Life
  
• Augustus Pablo - East of the Nile
  
• Manu Chao - Clandestino
  
• The Strokes - The New Abnormal
  
• The Prodigy - The Fat of the Land
  
• Bloc Party - Silent Alarm
  
• Arctic Monkeys - Favourite Worst Nightmare
  
• Sarah McLachlan - Fumbling Toward Ecstasy
  
• Marcy Playground - Shapeshifter
  
• Sasha & Digweed - Northern Exposure
  
• Rolling Stones - Tattoo You
  
• EOB - Earth
  
• Sigur Ros - ()
  
• Slightly Stoopid - The Longest Barrel Ride
  
• Aaliyah - One in a Million
  
• Yo-Yo Ma, Chris Thile & Edgar Meyer - Bach Trios
  

 

[Val Rannous]

Desert Island Take VIII

Pick 22:  AC/DC, The Razors Edge (1990).  Gotta have me some hard rockin' Aussies.  Thunderstruck may be my all time favorite song from them, and considering how many awesome songs they've had over the years, that's saying a lot.

• Thunderstruck
  
• Moneytalks
  

Pick 23:  Joan Jett, The Hit List (1990).  Wait, what?  Nobody drafted ANY Joan Jett??  Hunh?  She had multiple albums that should have found homes somewhere.  I'm particularly fond of this lesser known album, where she does covers of other people's hits and adds her own sharp, rockabilly style to them.

• Tush
  
• Love Me Two Times
  

Pick 24:  Queensryche, Empire (1990).  Thinking man's metal, prog metal, glam metal - don't really know what to call these guys, but I really like it.  One of the few full-on metal bands that I can think of that the musicianship quality may have been more important than just "crushin' it".

• Silent Lucidity
  
• Jet City Woman
  

 

[Buffaloes]

Pick 23:  Joan Jett, The Hit List (1990).  Wait, what?  Nobody drafted ANY Joan Jett??  Hunh?  She had multiple albums that should have found homes somewhere.  I'm particularly fond of this lesser known album, where she does covers of other people's hits and adds her own sharp, rockabilly style to them.

• Tush
  
• Love Me Two Times
  

wow, good call... surprised Jett went undrafted.