Dynasty Value Discussion Thread (20 Viewers)

[Hot Sauce Guy]

Really stumped as what to do with Jameson Williams. Would you trade out of him to get Shakir and Jaylin Noel?

I’d hold until he pops off with a big game then try to move him.

It’s what I’m planning to do with him in one league. I have Charbs and the KW guy has made inquiries. He has London & Rice, so I might try to package Charbs+Jamo+[TBD pick] for one of them.

But not until Jamo pops off. Which I think is inevitable.

The Lions haven’t really had a lot of contests where they had to chuck the ball around all Willy nilly. The one time they did Jamo had a good game.

It’s frustrating, but it feels a little flukey.

 

[houston]

Yeah, that all makes sense about Jamo. I wasn’t crazy about either Shakir or Noel in the offer I got. But at same time there was some appeal to have 2 young WRs rather than 1.

 

[mjb03003]

10 team Superflex league. My QBs are Josh Allen, Lamar Jackson, Drake Maye, Sam Darnold.

Who should I try to trade away?

 

[TampaMike19]

10 team Superflex league. My QBs are Josh Allen, Lamar Jackson, Drake Maye, Sam Darnold.

Who should I try to trade away?

Allen gets you the best haul but probably Lamar given the age and rushing ability probable decline

 

[JoeJoe88]

10 team Superflex league. My QBs are Josh Allen, Lamar Jackson, Drake Maye, Sam Darnold.

Who should I try to trade away?

Allen gets you the best haul but probably Lamar given the age and rushing ability probable decline

Probably a tough time to try and sell Lamar. I’ve wait for him to come back and drop 28 first.

 

[BoltNlava]

Price check on Daniel Jones. TE+ league with contracts he currently has 2.

 

[TartanLion]

Price check on Davante Adams ? Guy that has him probs won’t make playoffs and considering buying to beef up WR corps for a run

 

[InDitkaWeTrust]

Price check on Daniel Jones. TE+ league with contracts he currently has 2.

Depends on league settings. In SF, he's worth a mid 1st or better. In 1QB, probably closer to a high 2nd. But man, that guy is a league winner right now. Who knows if he can keep it up for the remainder of the season and onwards, but he's killing it right now. I dunno if I trade him away in Dynasty (SF or 1QB) without coming away with a young player with potential or a 27 draft pick. I just don't see the 2026 dart throws as worth giving him up.

I'm pulling for the guy given the crap he had to deal with in New York.

 

[InDitkaWeTrust]

Price check on Davante Adams ? Guy that has him probs won’t make playoffs and considering buying to beef up WR corps for a run

26 mid to early 2nd? He's the perfect guy to add to a contender to potentially put you over the top.

 

[Buckna]

Price check on Davante Adams ? Guy that has him probs won’t make playoffs and considering buying to beef up WR corps for a run

After that 3 TD game folks were saying a 1st but looks like Puka is back sooner than expected so I agree with early to mid 2nd.

 

[BearsFan4Life]

Vele or AMitchell ... better pickup after trade deadline?

 

[InDitkaWeTrust]

Vele or AMitchell ... better pickup after trade deadline?

Mitchell is in the better situation. I'd suppose I'd lean toward him, but this is really a hold your nose and pick one scenario.

 

[BearsFan4Life]

Vele or AMitchell ... better pickup after trade deadline?

Mitchell is in the better situation. I'd suppose I'd lean toward him, but this is really a hold your nose and pick one scenario.

That is what I had queued up, but Mitchell was taken ahead of me on waiver so wound up with Vele. One roster spot to play around with.

 

[BespokeJort]

In dynasty? Mitchell and it’s not close IMO

 

[BearsFan4Life]

I am a serious contender and a non- contender offered to give up Hurts for my Daniels... I am very hesitant as I have Dak, but cant afford terrible games like Monday night..thoughts?

 

[InDitkaWeTrust]

I am a serious contender and a non- contender offered to give up Hurts for my Daniels... I am very hesitant as I have Dak, but cant afford terrible games like Monday night..thoughts?

No brainer. Hurts is only 27 and should give you 5+ more years of high level dynasty production. Is Daniels the guy we saw last year or the guy we saw this year? Who knows and I'm not sure we'll ever know given his proclivity to injury.

 

[joey]

I am a serious contender and a non- contender offered to give up Hurts for my Daniels... I am very hesitant as I have Dak, but cant afford terrible games like Monday night..thoughts?

I love Win Now deals, personally. That said, Hurts is only scoring 2 ppg more than Dak according to one of my leagues pretty generic scoring rules. What I’m really replying for is that I just said this weekend that Jayden Daniels is giving me RGIII vibes. Amazing athlete, throw and running, but getting banged up bad and I’m not sure how long he lasts at a high level. He makes me nervous is what I’m saying.

So I wouldn’t object to giving up Daniels for Hurts. Heck, maybe he’ll throw in something a little extra for his chance to roster the young phenom.

ETA: making the trade this week makes you also not have a bye week for Hurts for the rest of the way. Tiny factor but worth mentioning.

 

[BearsFan4Life]

I am a serious contender and a non- contender offered to give up Hurts for my Daniels... I am very hesitant as I have Dak, but cant afford terrible games like Monday night..thoughts?

I love Win Now deals, personally. That said, Hurts is only scoring 2 ppg more than Dak according to one of my leagues pretty generic scoring rules. What I’m really replying for is that I just said this weekend that Jayden Daniels is giving me RGIII vibes. Amazing athlete, throw and running, but getting banged up bad and I’m not sure how long he lasts at a high level. He makes me nervous is what I’m saying.

So I wouldn’t object to giving up Daniels for Hurts. Heck, maybe he’ll throw in something a little extra for his chance to roster the young phenom.

ETA: making the trade this week makes you also not have a bye week for Hurts for the rest of the way. Tiny factor but worth mentioning.

That's funny, because after offering it up, he pulled the deal saying Daniels gave him the RGIII feeling. Oh well. Brissett this week and Dak the rest of the year. All other non-contenders don't have good QBs with the exception of the Allen team, but his whole team is terrible other than Josh and won't deal him.

 

[jp81976]

price check on Travis Kelce? i have a fairly strong team but not quite as strong as the top two teams. but get in the playoffs and anything can happen. my current TE is Hunter Henry and i do have Gunnar Helm on my rookie squad but I don't think he's ready for prime time. thinking either a 3rd or a 4th for Kelce. Keep in mind...I have basically no picks next year, already traded my 1st and 2nd in other deals.

 

[kutta]

price check on Travis Kelce? i have a fairly strong team but not quite as strong as the top two teams. but get in the playoffs and anything can happen. my current TE is Hunter Henry and i do have Gunnar Helm on my rookie squad but I don't think he's ready for prime time. thinking either a 3rd or a 4th for Kelce. Keep in mind...I have basically no picks next year, already traded my 1st and 2nd in other deals.

I don’t think you’ll get him for a fourth or a late third. He still holds some value. Maybe a 2027 second?
Is his owner a contender?

 

[BearsFan4Life]

price check on Travis Kelce? i have a fairly strong team but not quite as strong as the top two teams. but get in the playoffs and anything can happen. my current TE is Hunter Henry and i do have Gunnar Helm on my rookie squad but I don't think he's ready for prime time. thinking either a 3rd or a 4th for Kelce. Keep in mind...I have basically no picks next year, already traded my 1st and 2nd in other deals.

I don’t think you’ll get him for a fourth or a late third. He still holds some value. Maybe a 2027 second?
Is his owner a contender?

I own as my 2nd/3rd TE so would trade him for a 2nd and no less

 

[jp81976]

price check on Travis Kelce? i have a fairly strong team but not quite as strong as the top two teams. but get in the playoffs and anything can happen. my current TE is Hunter Henry and i do have Gunnar Helm on my rookie squad but I don't think he's ready for prime time. thinking either a 3rd or a 4th for Kelce. Keep in mind...I have basically no picks next year, already traded my 1st and 2nd in other deals.

I don’t think you’ll get him for a fourth or a late third. He still holds some value. Maybe a 2027 second?
Is his owner a contender?

his owner went all in last year and traded basically all of their picks through 2027 and this year they are having **** luck and decided to sell.

 

[jp81976]

so i was able to get him for a 4th round pick and Jonnu Smith. not bad. better if he plays beyond this year.

 

[kutta]

so i was able to get him for a 4th round pick and Jonnu Smith. not bad. better if he plays beyond this year.

Great deal - congrats!

 

[menobrown]

price check on Travis Kelce? i have a fairly strong team but not quite as strong as the top two teams. but get in the playoffs and anything can happen. my current TE is Hunter Henry and i do have Gunnar Helm on my rookie squad but I don't think he's ready for prime time. thinking either a 3rd or a 4th for Kelce. Keep in mind...I have basically no picks next year, already traded my 1st and 2nd in other deals.

I traded him a few weeks ago in FFPC 1.5 TEP for a guaranteed late second, probably 2.12.

I have Mahomes and have enjoyed that connection for years and maybe the return was a little light, maybe could have held out for a better second, especaily after some of his games he had after I traded him.

But I lost some key players to injuries, got 6 players on IR with only 3 IR spots, deep at TE, so decided to pull the plug and thought a side benefit of trading him is it would help my team lose and not make the playoffs naturally without tanking, which I'm extremely against. I'll be damned if my sorry team just keeps winning is the only thing that has given me second thoughts on the trade.

Not to get off track but I don't even understand my team. I've got some strong looking teams that are doing meh. This team makes no sense, Kamara and Walker are my top two RB's, Tre Tucker is my WR2, and I'm almost locked into a playoff spot right now and not even far off from seed 2 and for weeks I've just wanted to lose naturally.

 

[heckmanm]

Thoughts on Jalen Milroe? I've got a SF team with Geno and Tua as my #2 and #3 , and just lost Daniels, so I'm going to sell some guys and look to '26 and beyond.

I had an eye on Milroe during our draft but didn't get him

 

[Ray Barboni]

Thoughts on Jalen Milroe? I've got a SF team with Geno and Tua as my #2 and #3 , and just lost Daniels, so I'm going to sell some guys and look to '26 and beyond.

I had an eye on Milroe during our draft but didn't get him

I believe Darnold has proven himself plenty, he’s not going anywhere.

I really wanted Milroe in the rookie draft as well, but I don’t see a path for him in Seattle.

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

Thoughts on Jalen Milroe? I've got a SF team with Geno and Tua as my #2 and #3 , and just lost Daniels, so I'm going to sell some guys and look to '26 and beyond.

I had an eye on Milroe during our draft but didn't get him

My understanding is Milroe is seen by SEA as a “project”. I’m not sure what his path to playing time in Seattle is, but it likely isn’t at QB. Darnold looks plenty good & IMO Seattle will extend him before his contract is up.

 

[BearsFan4Life]

TE Question:

Gadsden vs Fannin

Keep 1 .. Trade 1 and why?

I own McBride and fortunate enough to grab both of the other two as free agents. So IF you were to sell one, which one and why? I suppose keep both and see where their value goes is another option.

 

[heckmanm]

Thanks, guys. I have a guy looking at Loveland and said he won't pay a first, but said to see what I'd want on top of a 26 2nd (probably mid-late). I took Loveland at 1.08 ish and I know there's no guarantee of getting the same pick back, but late-ish 2nd is too low especially after that last game.

(he even said he wishes he'd sent the trade before last weekend )

 

[kutta]

Thanks, guys. I have a guy looking at Loveland and said he won't pay a first, but said to see what I'd want on top of a 26 2nd (probably mid-late). I took Loveland at 1.08 ish and I know there's no guarantee of getting the same pick back, but late-ish 2nd is too low especially after that last game.

(he even said he wishes he'd sent the trade before last weekend )

No way I let Loveland go for that. It’s his rookie year. Give him time.

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

Thanks, guys. I have a guy looking at Loveland and said he won't pay a first, but said to see what I'd want on top of a 26 2nd (probably mid-late). I took Loveland at 1.08 ish and I know there's no guarantee of getting the same pick back, but late-ish 2nd is too low especially after that last game.

(he even said he wishes he'd sent the trade before last weekend )

I don’t understand some people. You paid a 1st and this yambag doesn’t want to even offer you what you paid?

I’d end the conversation right there. That’s just insulting.

 

[heckmanm]

I put a bunch of veterans on the block when Daniels went down (superflex and my other QBs are Tua and Geno). Of course the first 2 offers I get are for Jamarr Chase and Loveland. Granted I put Loveland on the block but I'm not selling for that.

 

[kutta]

I put a bunch of veterans on the block when Daniels went down (superflex and my other QBs are Tua and Geno). Of course the first 2 offers I get are for Jamarr Chase and Loveland. Granted I put Loveland on the block but I'm not selling for that.

Admittedly I’ve had a few whiskeys. But I don’t understand what offer you actually got.

 

[heckmanm]

I put a bunch of veterans on the block when Daniels went down (superflex and my other QBs are Tua and Geno). Of course the first 2 offers I get are for Jamarr Chase and Loveland. Granted I put Loveland on the block but I'm not selling for that.

Admittedly I’ve had a few whiskeys. But I don’t understand what offer you actually got.

I didn't actually post it explicitly - it was a 2026 2nd for Loveland. And he's currently 6-3 and in the top 4 in points, so it would likely be something like 2.08.

 

[heckmanm]

I put a bunch of veterans on the block when Daniels went down (superflex and my other QBs are Tua and Geno). Of course the first 2 offers I get are for Jamarr Chase and Loveland. Granted I put Loveland on the block but I'm not selling for that.

Oh and another guy offered Tet McMillan and Matthew Golden for Jamarr Chase. I don't even need to ask around about that one.

 

[kutta]

Yeah, those are pretty crummy offers.

 

[BearsFan4Life]

Value of Gasden.. I was offered a late 2026 1st (somewhere between 1.10-1.14) for him, but feel that's too light. Am I wrong?

0.5 ppr

 

[Coos Coostofferson]

Value of A. jones and Mason? In first and need rb depth. Was offered them for Brashard Smith and a 26 3rd and 5th. Problem is I need to drop Tahj Brooks. So thinking of countering with Brashard and Tahj for Mason/Jones.

Is Min and their backfield shot? Or a buy low?

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

Value of Gasden.. I was offered a late 2026 1st (somewhere between 1.10-1.14) for him, but feel that's too light. Am I wrong?

0.5 ppr

In .5 PPR (non TEP?) that seems like a decent opening salvo. I’d probably counter for a 3rd on top since it’s expected to be a late 1st, but that definitely seems like ballpark.

TEP would change the value by a sizable amount.

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

Value of A. jones and Mason? In first and need rb depth. Was offered them for Brashard Smith and a 26 3rd and 5th. Problem is I need to drop Tahj Brooks. So thinking of countering with Brashard and Tahj for Mason/Jones.

Is Min and their backfield shot? Or a buy low?

meh & meh. I’d probably hang onto Smith.

 

[oldmanhawkins]

Price check on Hurts in SF? Assuming the push goes away - where does his value settle?

Got an offer of Trevor Lawrence+Judkins+Early 26 1st. Might counter with my late 1st but still feels expensive.

 

[BearsFan4Life]

Value of Gasden.. I was offered a late 2026 1st (somewhere between 1.10-1.14) for him, but feel that's too light. Am I wrong?

0.5 ppr

In .5 PPR (non TEP?) that seems like a decent opening salvo. I’d probably counter for a 3rd on top since it’s expected to be a late 1st, but that definitely seems like ballpark.

TEP would change the value by a sizable amount.

Thanks.. Other owner wants me to add a late 2026 2nd to Gadsden for the 1st.. Thats too much.

 

[BearsFan4Life]

What's the value of Hurts in a start 1 QB league ... 1 1st Round Pick or would you have to go to 2 1sts to get him?

QB situation suck and Hurts owner willing to deal, but wants 2 1sts.

 

[InDitkaWeTrust]

What's the value of Hurts in a start 1 QB league ... 1 1st Round Pick or would you have to go to 2 1sts to get him?

QB situation suck and Hurts owner willing to deal, but wants 2 1sts.

I can't see a situation where I'd give 2 1sts for ANY QB in a 1QB league. MAYBE for Josh Allen if the 1sts are late?

 

[BearsFan4Life]

What's the value of Hurts in a start 1 QB league ... 1 1st Round Pick or would you have to go to 2 1sts to get him?

QB situation suck and Hurts owner willing to deal, but wants 2 1sts.

I can't see a situation where I'd give 2 1sts for ANY QB in a 1QB league. MAYBE for Josh Allen if the 1sts are late?

Both 1sts are late .. Only considering as I am a strong contender and have Dak to win it for me with Daniels out.

 

[wlwiles]

price check on Travis Kelce? i have a fairly strong team but not quite as strong as the top two teams. but get in the playoffs and anything can happen. my current TE is Hunter Henry and i do have Gunnar Helm on my rookie squad but I don't think he's ready for prime time. thinking either a 3rd or a 4th for Kelce. Keep in mind...I have basically no picks next year, already traded my 1st and 2nd in other deals.

I traded him a few weeks ago in FFPC 1.5 TEP for a guaranteed late second, probably 2.12.

I have Mahomes and have enjoyed that connection for years and maybe the return was a little light, maybe could have held out for a better second, especaily after some of his games he had after I traded him.

But I lost some key players to injuries, got 6 players on IR with only 3 IR spots, deep at TE, so decided to pull the plug and thought a side benefit of trading him is it would help my team lose and not make the playoffs naturally without tanking, which I'm extremely against. I'll be damned if my sorry team just keeps winning is the only thing that has given me second thoughts on the trade.

Not to get off track but I don't even understand my team. I've got some strong looking teams that are doing meh. This team makes no sense, Kamara and Walker are my top two RB's, Tre Tucker is my WR2, and I'm almost locked into a playoff spot right now and not even far off from seed 2 and for weeks I've just wanted to lose naturally.

I have a team just like this. Entered the year planning on continuing a rebuild, but every week I manage to squeak out a win, even despite losing Daniels and Kraft. My top two RB are Charbonnet and Marks, my QB1 is now Gabriel, I end up starting Juwan Johnson in the SF slot every week. But I'm tied for 3rd place, and I may only need 1 more win to secure a playoff spot.

It's maddening because I realistically should have no shot in the playoffs, so I feel like I'm on a collision course to the 1.07 or 1.08. I've already won too much to firesale, if I did that I'd only get 1.05 at best, so I just make small trades (gave Dowdle for Marks, gave Ferguson for a projected mid-late 2) and we'll see what happens when playoffs hit.

 

[InDitkaWeTrust]

What's the value of Hurts in a start 1 QB league ... 1 1st Round Pick or would you have to go to 2 1sts to get him?

QB situation suck and Hurts owner willing to deal, but wants 2 1sts.

I can't see a situation where I'd give 2 1sts for ANY QB in a 1QB league. MAYBE for Josh Allen if the 1sts are late?

Both 1sts are late .. Only considering as I am a strong contender and have Dak to win it for me with Daniels out.

I hear ya. Hurts is not 2 late 1sts better than Dak, for this year, anyway. I'd consider a cheap rental of someone like DJones or Stafford. Both could likely be had for a lot less than 2 1sts.

 

[JoeJoe88]

What's the value of Hurts in a start 1 QB league ... 1 1st Round Pick or would you have to go to 2 1sts to get him?

QB situation suck and Hurts owner willing to deal, but wants 2 1sts.

I don’t play in 1QB leagues but two 1sts for him seems absurd.

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

What's the value of Hurts in a start 1 QB league ... 1 1st Round Pick or would you have to go to 2 1sts to get him?

QB situation suck and Hurts owner willing to deal, but wants 2 1sts.

I can't see a situation where I'd give 2 1sts for ANY QB in a 1QB league. MAYBE for Josh Allen if the 1sts are late?

Both 1sts are late .. Only considering as I am a strong contender and have Dak to win it for me with Daniels out.

I’d stick with Dak. He should be plenty. I agree with @InDitkaWeTrust - no QB is worth 2 1sts in a 1 QB format. And you have plenty in Dak to win it all.