krista4
Footballguy
and of course more Petty
If we still had thread subtitles, I would use this for this one.
and of course more Petty
Had to break my heart by crossing off Lord Huron?? :(List of 22 submitted. Partially for a couple of backups if needed because I missed something. There is only 2 I couldn't verify all the members scrounging on wikipedia and other places.
Partially hoping that since I was fast with the list, followed her preference for the links, and provided links that I'd be in her good graces and all 22 would make it in.![]()
And sadly, I'm one song in and already found an ineligible. :(
Had to break my heart by crossing off Lord Huron?? :(List of 22 submitted. Partially for a couple of backups if needed because I missed something. There is only 2 I couldn't verify all the members scrounging on wikipedia and other places.
Partially hoping that since I was fast with the list, followed her preference for the links, and provided links that I'd be in her good graces and all 22 would make it in.![]()
And sadly, I'm one song in and already found an ineligible. :(

I think I missed something in the research. Hmm.Had to break my heart by crossing off Lord Huron?? :(List of 22 submitted. Partially for a couple of backups if needed because I missed something. There is only 2 I couldn't verify all the members scrounging on wikipedia and other places.
Partially hoping that since I was fast with the list, followed her preference for the links, and provided links that I'd be in her good graces and all 22 would make it in.![]()
And sadly, I'm one song in and already found an ineligible. :(
It wouldn't have been all of Lord Huron, but just the record(s?) with Jessica Maros.![]()
“Joe wants this to be a board his pastor could read” reasons.Political reasons?Board rules don't permit me to discuss one of the reasons why I like this song
Personal anecdote:
Driving the other night down a parkway and I hear this lull in the music. Out of nowhere comes Whitney Houston's beginning of "I Will Always Love You." Normally, my reflex would be to change the channel, but in the spirit of this thread, I decide to give it a real chance. Anyway, it begins and then gets going and it's pretty good and as it picks up you can catch me reminding myself not to interfere with her vocal stylings. Made it all the way home with that song. Was that Yankee23Fan?
Good call. What a belter that is. I used to think it was oversung, but it fits the song. It was good. Pleasant surprise.
I am unable to hear that song without thinking of this. It might make me like the song more.
I have never seen that.I like the Petty update on the read lol
Here's my also-rans that I had. These I didn't look up, so there might be some on here that are also ineligible. Just giving a preview of where my mind was at last night:
Teenage Riot - Sonic Youth
Born on the Bayou - CCR
Everything's Ruined - Faith No More
Clean My Wounds - Corrosion of Conformity
Express Yourself - Madonna
Hitch a Ride - Boston
Alex Chilton - The Replacements
River of Deceit - Mad Season
Love Like Ghosts - Lord Huron
Yes. My joke just fell flat it seems. I figured it was “that” scene.“Joe wants this to be a board his pastor could read” reasons.Political reasons?Board rules don't permit me to discuss one of the reasons why I like this song
There’s a certain movie scene it’s strongly associated with.
@AAABatteries - Touch of Grey - Grateful Dead. Some of my deadhead friends somewhat scoffed at this one because it became a hit, but heck, every band needs a hit. This is a great song.
Agree - love the heck out of that song, especially as it hits closer and closer to home.
I never did get to see them back then, as I'm a bit young, but caught 'em twice in the last 6 years (sadly, post Maurice), and still, they were great.I never got to see Chic live, but I saw Sister Sledge on a bill with the Jacksons in the late 70s. Sister Sledge was basically Chic with different singers, but I don't think Rodgers, Edwards, and Thompson were playing behind them that night.I saw them open a few years ago for Earth, Wind & Fire, and they just absolutely rocked it.
I also saw EWF live during that time. They slayed it.
Yep. And for me, it was this one or the one I chose, Get Up Offa That Thing, which I went with just a notch higher on the list. I could have picked 10 by JB, but just had to spread the wealth. Either way, so much of today's music is traced straight to James Brown.
This is one of the best and most influential funk songs and has shown up on several "Rolling Stone garbage lists," as krista calls them. It never fails to make me move (mentally if not always physically).
Ain't that the truth. Jar of Flies is so meditative, and solemn, from start to finish.@krista4
Dont follow is on the Jar of Flies EP that was realeased early in '94. They went into the studio with basically no material written, and came out with Jar Flies in like a week, which, imo, is incredible. The EP is amazing!
Don't Follow is hauntingly beautiful. The first half is Jerry Cantrell trying to save his friend, Layne Staley, who sings the second part.....it's a conversation of what was really going on with them at the time. Staley was back on heroin during the making of J of F.
Staley never performed Don't Follow on stage. He left the band, and largely became a recluse, with his heroin habit in '96.....he died alone in '02 from an OD. It was sad. He was Uber talented, but could never get past his demons.
@AAABatteries - Touch of Grey - Grateful Dead. Some of my deadhead friends somewhat scoffed at this one because it became a hit, but heck, every band needs a hit. This is a great song.
Agree - love the heck out of that song, especially as it hits closer and closer to home.
I thought I may get some grief for this pick but didn’t care - I wanted to include a Dead song and that one is my favorite, makes me smile.
1983 US Festival@Zegras11 's post about seeing Missing Persons live made me wonder: Did Terry Bozzio feature drum solos in the Missing Persons live sets, or did they kind of avoid that kind of noodling?I was always fascinated by Missing Persons. One of the most technically accomplished drummers in the world forms a band to play a genre that doesn't have anything to do with technical accomplishment in the slightest, fronted by his wife who has some sort of futuristic aerobic instructor shtick.
To explain this one.
To me, a perfect pop song has to be endlessly listenable, an earworm that just gets in there and stays with you. But - crucially - it also has to have something a bit off-kilter about it. And with this song, it's that opening lyric, "To the left, to the left..." It presents a mystery immediately. What does it mean? Is it a dance instruction, a movement? No, it refers to the remainder of the guy's stuff that she's gathered together for him to pick up now that she's done with his dumbass. It's a great open. Beyonce has plenty that could go in this list, but this one was the one I had to go with.
The Wall -- Johnny Cash (Rockaction) -- That's a hell of a story for just over 2 minutes. And it's Johnny.
Early '70s Funkadelic is very different from late '70s Funkadelic. The latter's music was pretty much interchangeable with Parliament's. The former was a whole other thing, with rocking out, mainly courtesy of Eddie Hazel, a major part of the mix.The Wall -- Johnny Cash (Rockaction) -- That's a hell of a story for just over 2 minutes. And it's Johnny.
I just listened to Super Stupid. I liked it a bunch. Not what I expected from Funkadelic. At all.
To explain this one.
To me, a perfect pop song has to be endlessly listenable, an earworm that just gets in there and stays with you. But - crucially - it also has to have something a bit off-kilter about it. And with this song, it's that opening lyric, "To the left, to the left..." It presents a mystery immediately. What does it mean? Is it a dance instruction, a movement? No, it refers to the remainder of the guy's stuff that she's gathered together for him to pick up now that she's done with his dumbass. It's a great open. Beyonce has plenty that could go in this list, but this one was the one I had to go with.
That was another one where I didn't know the song title but knew the song. As soon as she started with "To the left, to the left..." I was like, oh, it's THAT one.
To explain this one.
To me, a perfect pop song has to be endlessly listenable, an earworm that just gets in there and stays with you. But - crucially - it also has to have something a bit off-kilter about it. And with this song, it's that opening lyric, "To the left, to the left..." It presents a mystery immediately. What does it mean? Is it a dance instruction, a movement? No, it refers to the remainder of the guy's stuff that she's gathered together for him to pick up now that she's done with his dumbass. It's a great open. Beyonce has plenty that could go in this list, but this one was the one I had to go with.
I haven't had a chance for a listening party of the "new-to-me" songs yet today, but this description makes me really look forward to hearing this one.
I'm Not Crying, Karl -- The Karl Hendricks Rock Band (OH) -- Neil minus Neil! This is currently my top-ranked new-to-me song.
@AAABatteries - Touch of Grey - Grateful Dead. Some of my deadhead friends somewhat scoffed at this one because it became a hit, but heck, every band needs a hit. This is a great song.
Agree - love the heck out of that song, especially as it hits closer and closer to home.
I thought I may get some grief for this pick but didn’t care - I wanted to include a Dead song and that one is my favorite, makes me smile.
I went back and forth with it, I had it listed, I replaced it, I put it back in, replaced it. Krista4 said two of my songs were ineligible so I replaced two, I had 5 "standby" songs locked and loaded, Touch of Grey was #3 out of 5. I re-discovered it about 5 or 6 years ago. I was in the grocery store and it was playing in the background and it immediately took me back to freshman year of college, 1987, living in Cincinnati, Grateful Dead were touring and in town, maybe it was 88? I dunno, that song always takes me back to that moment of being downtown Cincinnati, at the farmer's market on a crisp Saturday morning surrounded by dead heads. That farmer's market was usually kinda dead if you got there super early like I used to but that day it was crawling with dead head fans.
For me, it is oversung. I much prefer Dolly. Whitney always sounds like a foghorn to me.Personal anecdote:
Driving the other night down a parkway and I hear this lull in the music. Out of nowhere comes Whitney Houston's beginning of "I Will Always Love You." Normally, my reflex would be to change the channel, but in the spirit of this thread, I decide to give it a real chance. Anyway, it begins and then gets going and it's pretty good and as it picks up you can catch me reminding myself not to interfere with her vocal stylings. Made it all the way home with that song. Was that Yankee23Fan?
Good call. What a belter that is. I used to think it was oversung, but it fits the song. It was good. Pleasant surprise.
It's really good. I had Bootlicious under consideration.
To explain this one.
To me, a perfect pop song has to be endlessly listenable, an earworm that just gets in there and stays with you. But - crucially - it also has to have something a bit off-kilter about it. And with this song, it's that opening lyric, "To the left, to the left..." It presents a mystery immediately. What does it mean? Is it a dance instruction, a movement? No, it refers to the remainder of the guy's stuff that she's gathered together for him to pick up now that she's done with his dumbass. It's a great open. Beyonce has plenty that could go in this list, but this one was the one I had to go with.
I haven't had a chance for a listening party of the "new-to-me" songs yet today, but this description makes me really look forward to hearing this one.
Floater is a trio from Eugene, Oregon. Pretty much PNW regional success. Their first four albums are brilliant, imo. Their first two (Sink, and Glyph) were a huge part of my teens, and early adulthood.....lots of shows, in various states of non-sobriety.....their live shows are legit.....they are doing a show in December, at the Crystal ballroom, in Portland where they are playing Pink Floyds Animals front to back.....I believe it sold out pretty quickly......I think theyre doing the same in Eugene on New Years Eve....I’d say something about Tom Petty here. But if(when?) I include my own list, you just might find him on there >.>. So moving on….
#27
Recognized by title alone: 17
Sounded familiar: 2
Didn't know: 15
Selected Favorites:
Killing Me Softly with His Song - Nothing wrong with the more famous cover, but it’s been a while since this more classic version.
Bad Seamstress Blues/Falling Apart at the Seams. Me, admit that I rather like this? It’ll be a long, cold winter. *looks outside to snow* Dammit.
Hey Ya -![]()
![]()
(if you know, you know)
Songs I didn't know that I ended up liking:
Exiled - This sounds like something I should’ve discovered in the late 90s to early 2000s, but nope, that’s now. Leaving myself a note to check Floater out more later.
Makes No Sense At All/I Apologize - These two bounced between “sounds familiar” and “don’t know”. Or maybe I just don’t remember? >.>
I debated whether to throw A Good Idea in here, too. That would be three from the same singer though, so maybe cheating?
J of F came out my senior year of HS, and it really blew me away. I find it, and Sap, so much more interesting than any of their other material.Ain't that the truth. Jar of Flies is so meditative, and solemn, from start to finish.@krista4
Dont follow is on the Jar of Flies EP that was realeased early in '94. They went into the studio with basically no material written, and came out with Jar Flies in like a week, which, imo, is incredible. The EP is amazing!
Don't Follow is hauntingly beautiful. The first half is Jerry Cantrell trying to save his friend, Layne Staley, who sings the second part.....it's a conversation of what was really going on with them at the time. Staley was back on heroin during the making of J of F.
Staley never performed Don't Follow on stage. He left the band, and largely became a recluse, with his heroin habit in '96.....he died alone in '02 from an OD. It was sad. He was Uber talented, but could never get past his demons.
I'm actually kicking myself for not having a Mad Season song on my top 31. I could've went with River, Wake up, or I'm Above.....such a great album!Here's my also-rans that I had. These I didn't look up, so there might be some on here that are also ineligible. Just giving a preview of where my mind was at last night:
Teenage Riot - Sonic Youth
Born on the Bayou - CCR
Everything's Ruined - Faith No More
Clean My Wounds - Corrosion of Conformity
Express Yourself - Madonna
Hitch a Ride - Boston
Alex Chilton - The Replacements
River of Deceit - Mad Season
Love Like Ghosts - Lord Huron
@AAABatteries - Touch of Grey - Grateful Dead. Some of my deadhead friends somewhat scoffed at this one because it became a hit, but heck, every band needs a hit. This is a great song.
Agree - love the heck out of that song, especially as it hits closer and closer to home.
I thought I may get some grief for this pick but didn’t care - I wanted to include a Dead song and that one is my favorite, makes me smile.
I went back and forth with it, I had it listed, I replaced it, I put it back in, replaced it. Krista4 said two of my songs were ineligible so I replaced two, I had 5 "standby" songs locked and loaded, Touch of Grey was #3 out of 5. I re-discovered it about 5 or 6 years ago. I was in the grocery store and it was playing in the background and it immediately took me back to freshman year of college, 1987, living in Cincinnati, Grateful Dead were touring and in town, maybe it was 88? I dunno, that song always takes me back to that moment of being downtown Cincinnati, at the farmer's market on a crisp Saturday morning surrounded by dead heads. That farmer's market was usually kinda dead if you got there super early like I used to but that day it was crawling with dead head fans.
OMG dude. Are you talking about 1989? That was my first show. The previous show in Cincy was in 1986 out at Riverbend. That was before Touch was released as a single in '87.
@Doug B: Check It Out - John Mellencamp - sad I didn't include any Mellencamp, but I think I burnt out on him in the 80s. But this might be my favorite of his.
krista4: Milwaukee – The Both -- This one's a real nice one. Pretty cool, really enjoyed it.
scorchy: Mayonaise – Smashing Pumpkins
Uruk-Hai: Mama Tried - Merle Haggard - I'm not a country fan, but Merle Haggard can sing and play, and this one has some real power. Rewrite it just slightly and it's a blues tune.
Manster: Sheep Go to Heaven - Cake - This one's goofy, and enjoyable.
rockaction: The Wall - Johnny Cash - I mean, what can you say about Cash? He kind of made everything work.
worrierking: Taneytown - Steve Earle -- Yeah, this is a nice, moody piece, real bleak and creepy. Me likey.
Oliver Humanzee: I'm Not Crying, Karl - The Karl Hendricks Rock Band - This was kind of cool. I may have to check out more by this band.
Her violin/fiddle and the accordion are great in this song. It's my favorite song by him.@Doug B: Check It Out - John Mellencamp - sad I didn't include any Mellencamp, but I think I burnt out on him in the 80s. But this might be my favorite of his.
Lisa Germano was Mellencamp's secret weapon in the late 80s. Her violin work makes this song to me.