What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Greatest Video Game Draft 2011 (2 Viewers)

Sorry about not getting to those PMs, I just woke up. Rikishiboy, games like Oregon Trail don't really fall into the RTS/Strategy category as much as they fall into the RPG or Adventure. I mean, you do have to use strategy when you play but I don't believe that is what the judge will be looking for when he is making his list of game ranks.
It's classified as a strategy sim. I don't see why it wouldn't fall into that category.http://www.giantbomb.com/the-oregon-trail/61-17852/
Really, wow, never would have known that just from playing it. Nvm then.
 
Sorry about not getting to those PMs, I just woke up. Rikishiboy, games like Oregon Trail don't really fall into the RTS/Strategy category as much as they fall into the RPG or Adventure. I mean, you do have to use strategy when you play but I don't believe that is what the judge will be looking for when he is making his list of game ranks.
It's classified as a strategy sim. I don't see why it wouldn't fall into that category.http://www.giantbomb.com/the-oregon-trail/61-17852/
Really, wow, never would have known that just from playing it. Nvm then.
Oregon trail is one of the first strategy simulations. You have to manage your supplies and keep track of your party's health while deciding which path to take to get to the destination. Definitely strategy/sim.
 
Also, aside from the unpicked guy, I was stunned that Simon Belmont fell so far. This may be skirting the rules a bit by posting about the category that I'm judging, but that's a great pick. Obviously the judges will be a bit biased towards the games that they played and enjoyed, but when I think of Castlevania, I think of Simon Belmont. I know there's been other characters since, and perhaps that's why he fell into the 19th round, but I love that pick. I'm surprised he didn't go earlier.

 
Also, aside from the unpicked guy, I was stunned that Simon Belmont fell so far. This may be skirting the rules a bit by posting about the category that I'm judging, but that's a great pick. Obviously the judges will be a bit biased towards the games that they played and enjoyed, but when I think of Castlevania, I think of Simon Belmont. I know there's been other characters since, and perhaps that's why he fell into the 19th round, but I love that pick. I'm surprised he didn't go earlier.
No real rule against discussing your category. Just personal preference.
 
Also, I would've loved a Gears invite last night....but that's the problem with only knowing like 3 people who still play...
I actually haven't played Gears in 1-2 weeks or so. Whenever I have been on I have played a few arcade games I own or the co-op game Barley and I have been playing through again.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Also, I would've loved a Gears invite last night....but that's the problem with only knowing like 3 people who still play...
They're releasing a Gears triple pack next month that includes both Gears games and all the maps and DLC. I may pick it up to finally own. Or I may just wait for Gears 3. We'll see.
 
biggamer3

BlueDredSo

ROUND 21

3. Andy Dufresne

4. madshot31

5. AcerFC

6. Yo Mama

7. wazoo11

8. bmarks6161

9. Slax

10. larry_boy_44

11. rikishiboy - i have

12. Mario Kart

13. BlueDredSo

 
Last edited by a moderator:
21.3 - Gyruss - Arcade 2

Mix Tempest with Galaga, add a bit of Bach's Tocatta en Fugue in D Minor, and you get get a great game in Gyruss.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
21.04 Area 51 - Arcade

If you were born post 1980, this is your Donkey Kong/Pac-Man. Must kill all the aliens that look like humans but have alien photos over the top of their bodies.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
21.5 Guitar Hero 3-PS 3- 7th GenerationLearn how to play real guitar on a fun game. For realz:preordered:
Every time, Some one mentions GH, I just have to listen to my brother.." Metallica's "One" is so hard! How do you defeat it on expert?" I'm like wait until you get to Raining Blood. :confused:
 
Last edited by a moderator:
21.5 Guitar Hero 3-PS 3- 7th GenerationLearn how to play real guitar on a fun game. For realz:preordered:
Every time, Some one mentions GH, I just have to listen to my brother.." Metallica's one is so hard! How do you defeat it on expert?" I'm like wait until you get to Raining Blood. :confused:
I call that song "Raining Skittles". It's a good song, but GH has made me almost hate it.
 
Lolz. My wife knew exactly the point in the song that I failed Reign in Blood because I played it so much (and failed so much). Those stupid triplets killed me. But I finally did it

 
I thought it was wazoo's turn anyway?
:) I've been waiting on one person to paste this pick for 30 minutes and my wife has been waiting on me to go. And it was actually 2 people ahead of me. :( Don't tell my wife.I'll just post it when I get back. Or leave it with one of you.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Master Chief (Halo) - Main character
Damn. Didn't notice he was still there. Thats a big duh. He's top 5, IMO even though I can't touch the games anymore because of the multiplayer.
Master Cheif is overrated and I like the campaigns.
I'll leave the bulk of my comments until I actually judge things, but Master Chief is THE quintessential video game character of our generation, bar none. I know you and I are pretty much the same age. You can make the argument that the character development isn't there or whatever, but Master Chief is the face of what is probably the most important/influential console* video game series of the past decade. When you say Xbox/Xbox 360, the image that immediately comes to mind for me is Master Chief in full-gear. Halo is the defining video game series for Xbox, and Master Chief is the face of it all. Hell, the series essentially spawned an entire professional gaming league based around it.And this is coming from someone who's never owned anything in the Halo series and has only played the multiplayer sparingly with friends.* console being an operative word here....Warcraft, Starcraft, etc. aside.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Master Chief (Halo) - Main character
Damn. Didn't notice he was still there. Thats a big duh. He's top 5, IMO even though I can't touch the games anymore because of the multiplayer.
Master Cheif is overrated and I like the campaigns.
I'll leave the bulk of my comments until I actually judge things, but Master Chief is THE quintessential video game character of our generation, bar none. I know you and I are pretty much the same age. You can make the argument that the character development isn't there or whatever, but Master Chief is the face of what is probably the most important/influential console* video game series of the past decade. When you say Xbox/Xbox 360, the image that immediately comes to mind for me is Master Chief in full-gear. Halo is the defining video game series for Xbox, and Master Chief is the face of it all. Hell, the series essentially spawned an entire professional gaming league based around it.And this is coming from someone who's never owned anything in the Halo series and has only played the multiplayer sparingly with friends.* console being an operative word here....Warcraft, Starcraft, etc. aside.
Nathan Drake > Master Chief
 
Master Chief (Halo) - Main character
Damn. Didn't notice he was still there. Thats a big duh. He's top 5, IMO even though I can't touch the games anymore because of the multiplayer.
Master Cheif is overrated and I like the campaigns.
I'll leave the bulk of my comments until I actually judge things, but Master Chief is THE quintessential video game character of our generation, bar none. I know you and I are pretty much the same age. You can make the argument that the character development isn't there or whatever, but Master Chief is the face of what is probably the most important/influential console* video game series of the past decade. When you say Xbox/Xbox 360, the image that immediately comes to mind for me is Master Chief in full-gear. Halo is the defining video game series for Xbox, and Master Chief is the face of it all. Hell, the series essentially spawned an entire professional gaming league based around it.And this is coming from someone who's never owned anything in the Halo series and has only played the multiplayer sparingly with friends.* console being an operative word here....Warcraft, Starcraft, etc. aside.
I already deleted my Master Chief writeup, but basically, this is the gist of it. I was looking for a character in the Main Character genre that people identified with video games. Pac-Man does that. Master Chief does that. People outside of video games don't know who Nathan Drake is. I'm not a Halo fan and most people can tell you that, but he is about the only character left that is synonymous with gaming.
 
Master Chief (Halo) - Main character
Damn. Didn't notice he was still there. Thats a big duh. He's top 5, IMO even though I can't touch the games anymore because of the multiplayer.
Master Cheif is overrated and I like the campaigns.
I'll leave the bulk of my comments until I actually judge things, but Master Chief is THE quintessential video game character of our generation, bar none. I know you and I are pretty much the same age. You can make the argument that the character development isn't there or whatever, but Master Chief is the face of what is probably the most important/influential console* video game series of the past decade. When you say Xbox/Xbox 360, the image that immediately comes to mind for me is Master Chief in full-gear. Halo is the defining video game series for Xbox, and Master Chief is the face of it all. Hell, the series essentially spawned an entire professional gaming league based around it.And this is coming from someone who's never owned anything in the Halo series and has only played the multiplayer sparingly with friends.* console being an operative word here....Warcraft, Starcraft, etc. aside.
I already deleted my Master Chief writeup, but basically, this is the gist of it. I was looking for a character in the Main Character genre that people identified with video games. Pac-Man does that. Master Chief does that. People outside of video games don't know who Nathan Drake is. I'm not a Halo fan and most people can tell you that, but he is about the only character left that is synonymous with gaming.
I understand what you guys are saying. Its just I look beyond the publicity for quality character development in my characters and Master Chief doesn't have ####.
 
Master Cheif is overrated and I like the campaigns.
I'll leave the bulk of my comments until I actually judge things, but Master Chief is THE quintessential video game character of our generation, bar none. I know you and I are pretty much the same age. You can make the argument that the character development isn't there or whatever, but Master Chief is the face of what is probably the most important/influential console* video game series of the past decade. When you say Xbox/Xbox 360, the image that immediately comes to mind for me is Master Chief in full-gear. Halo is the defining video game series for Xbox, and Master Chief is the face of it all. Hell, the series essentially spawned an entire professional gaming league based around it.And this is coming from someone who's never owned anything in the Halo series and has only played the multiplayer sparingly with friends.* console being an operative word here....Warcraft, Starcraft, etc. aside.
I already deleted my Master Chief writeup, but basically, this is the gist of it. I was looking for a character in the Main Character genre that people identified with video games. Pac-Man does that. Master Chief does that. People outside of video games don't know who Nathan Drake is. I'm not a Halo fan and most people can tell you that, but he is about the only character left that is synonymous with gaming.
I understand what you guys are saying. Its just I look beyond the publicity for quality character development in my characters and Master Chief doesn't have ####.
I agree with your original sentiment. Master Chief is overrated. I'd pick Gordon Freeman a million times over Master Chief and it wouldn't be close. And and I could even show you how in internet tournaments, Gordon Freeman has won even over the likes of Link, Mario, Kratos and Master Chief. But unfortunately, no one outside of gaming has probably heard of Gordon Freeman (yes, I would've taken Gordon before Pac Man. Don't think I wouldn't have). :goodposting:But that doesn't take away the fact that he IS a video game icon. Regardless of what you and I think about him.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I'll leave the bulk of my comments until I actually judge things, but Master Chief is THE quintessential video game character of our generation, bar none. I know you and I are pretty much the same age. You can make the argument that the character development isn't there or whatever, but Master Chief is the face of what is probably the most important/influential console* video game series of the past decade. When you say Xbox/Xbox 360, the image that immediately comes to mind for me is Master Chief in full-gear. Halo is the defining video game series for Xbox, and Master Chief is the face of it all. Hell, the series essentially spawned an entire professional gaming league based around it.And this is coming from someone who's never owned anything in the Halo series and has only played the multiplayer sparingly with friends.* console being an operative word here....Warcraft, Starcraft, etc. aside.
I already deleted my Master Chief writeup, but basically, this is the gist of it. I was looking for a character in the Main Character genre that people identified with video games. Pac-Man does that. Master Chief does that. People outside of video games don't know who Nathan Drake is. I'm not a Halo fan and most people can tell you that, but he is about the only character left that is synonymous with gaming.
I understand what you guys are saying. Its just I look beyond the publicity for quality character development in my characters and Master Chief doesn't have ####.
I think that looking strongly at character development as the defining factor in figuring out the "best main character" in video game history is a little simplistic, though. I understand what you're getting at, but I think that for this category, it's important to recognize that a handful of video game characters throughout history have literally transcended the video game world and become pop culture icons. That's what separate characters like Mario from the rest. There is very little character development for the Mario character, but Mario is literally a pop culture icon. Master Chief isn't at Mario's level, but there's little doubt in my mind that he's a pop culture icon in the same way that Mario is.
 
Slax is still here but I do have his pick.

madshot, please move Battlefield 2 to Flex. Thanks.

21.09 Counter-Strike: Source, PC, First-Person Shooter

Counter-Strike was originally developed as a Half-Life mod by Minh "Gooseman" Le and Jess Cliffe. The game quickly gained a following in the mod community and those at Valve took notice and purchased the game, making it a full-fledged retail game. Counter-Strike quickly became the most popular and top played first-person shooter game in the world.

After release of Half-Life 2 and the Source engine, Counter-Strike was retooled and remade to use the new engine. The original gameplay mechanics are exactly the same and no changes were made other than the game physics. Of course, some maps are different, since Source .bsp (map file) files are different than those using the Quake engine that the original Half-Life and Counter-Strike used.

For those not familiar with the game, Counter-Strike: Source pits a team of counter-terrorists against a team of terrorists in a series of rounds. Each round is won by either completing an objective (such as detonating a bomb or rescuing hostages) or by eliminating all members of the opposing team. Depending on how well you did in the round, you will earn money, which is put toward upgrading and buying weapons and ammunition for later rounds.

Gameplay Footage - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LJp92sNe_IQ

 
21.08 Jackal - NES - Third generation

This one brings back memories for me. I absolutely loved this game as a kid. I had to have it on my squad.

Gameplay
I had this game...it was ridiculously hard...

and I never got anywhere NEAR the final boss, but the web videos I've seen of the final boss make it look like it isn't even possible to beat the final boss without cheating...

 
not that anyone will be surprised... but I'm not a huge fan of the Master Chief pick...

I get why someone would pick him, I just don't think he's that important, and the fact that he has little story or character development, IMO, hurts his value here...

 
I'll leave the bulk of my comments until I actually judge things, but Master Chief is THE quintessential video game character of our generation, bar none. I know you and I are pretty much the same age. You can make the argument that the character development isn't there or whatever, but Master Chief is the face of what is probably the most important/influential console* video game series of the past decade. When you say Xbox/Xbox 360, the image that immediately comes to mind for me is Master Chief in full-gear. Halo is the defining video game series for Xbox, and Master Chief is the face of it all. Hell, the series essentially spawned an entire professional gaming league based around it.And this is coming from someone who's never owned anything in the Halo series and has only played the multiplayer sparingly with friends.* console being an operative word here....Warcraft, Starcraft, etc. aside.
I already deleted my Master Chief writeup, but basically, this is the gist of it. I was looking for a character in the Main Character genre that people identified with video games. Pac-Man does that. Master Chief does that. People outside of video games don't know who Nathan Drake is. I'm not a Halo fan and most people can tell you that, but he is about the only character left that is synonymous with gaming.
I understand what you guys are saying. Its just I look beyond the publicity for quality character development in my characters and Master Chief doesn't have ####.
I think that looking strongly at character development as the defining factor in figuring out the "best main character" in video game history is a little simplistic, though. I understand what you're getting at, but I think that for this category, it's important to recognize that a handful of video game characters throughout history have literally transcended the video game world and become pop culture icons. That's what separate characters like Mario from the rest. There is very little character development for the Mario character, but Mario is literally a pop culture icon. Master Chief isn't at Mario's level, but there's little doubt in my mind that he's a pop culture icon in the same way that Mario is.
Your the judge, so you get the final say on how much you want certain aspects of a character to determine its end value. But for me, Mario, Master Chief, and another high profile characters don't crack my top 10 best characters. I try and remember playing the game and think about what made it great. Does the game make the characters, or do the characters make the game? Everybody does it a different way, but I go by the latter when deciding on my great characters and villains.
 
not that anyone will be surprised... but I'm not a huge fan of the Master Chief pick...I get why someone would pick him, I just don't think he's that important, and the fact that he has little story or character development, IMO, hurts his value here...
He's the franchise cover boy of Microsoft. (And I'm not a fan of Halo,btw.)
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I'll leave the bulk of my comments until I actually judge things, but Master Chief is THE quintessential video game character of our generation, bar none. I know you and I are pretty much the same age. You can make the argument that the character development isn't there or whatever, but Master Chief is the face of what is probably the most important/influential console* video game series of the past decade. When you say Xbox/Xbox 360, the image that immediately comes to mind for me is Master Chief in full-gear. Halo is the defining video game series for Xbox, and Master Chief is the face of it all. Hell, the series essentially spawned an entire professional gaming league based around it.

And this is coming from someone who's never owned anything in the Halo series and has only played the multiplayer sparingly with friends.

* console being an operative word here....Warcraft, Starcraft, etc. aside.
I already deleted my Master Chief writeup, but basically, this is the gist of it. I was looking for a character in the Main Character genre that people identified with video games. Pac-Man does that. Master Chief does that. People outside of video games don't know who Nathan Drake is. I'm not a Halo fan and most people can tell you that, but he is about the only character left that is synonymous with gaming.
I understand what you guys are saying. Its just I look beyond the publicity for quality character development in my characters and Master Chief doesn't have ####.
I think that looking strongly at character development as the defining factor in figuring out the "best main character" in video game history is a little simplistic, though. I understand what you're getting at, but I think that for this category, it's important to recognize that a handful of video game characters throughout history have literally transcended the video game world and become pop culture icons. That's what separate characters like Mario from the rest. There is very little character development for the Mario character, but Mario is literally a pop culture icon. Master Chief isn't at Mario's level, but there's little doubt in my mind that he's a pop culture icon in the same way that Mario is.
Ignoring the fact that looking strongly at "iconess" as the defining factor in figuring out the "best main character" in video game history is more simplistic than looking strongly at character development imo, but I don't think Master Chief's anywhere near the pop culture icon that Mario is. I'd say close to 100% of the general population knows who Mario is. I'd be surprised if 25% of the general population knows who Master Chief is. I know going by personal experience alone is a very small sample size, but of my buddies who don't play video games, I know if I asked them who Master Chief was they wouldn't have the slightest idea. Master Chief is a video game icon, not a pop culture icon imo, and I think that's a huge difference.
 
I'll leave the bulk of my comments until I actually judge things, but Master Chief is THE quintessential video game character of our generation, bar none. I know you and I are pretty much the same age. You can make the argument that the character development isn't there or whatever, but Master Chief is the face of what is probably the most important/influential console* video game series of the past decade. When you say Xbox/Xbox 360, the image that immediately comes to mind for me is Master Chief in full-gear. Halo is the defining video game series for Xbox, and Master Chief is the face of it all. Hell, the series essentially spawned an entire professional gaming league based around it.

And this is coming from someone who's never owned anything in the Halo series and has only played the multiplayer sparingly with friends.

* console being an operative word here....Warcraft, Starcraft, etc. aside.
I already deleted my Master Chief writeup, but basically, this is the gist of it. I was looking for a character in the Main Character genre that people identified with video games. Pac-Man does that. Master Chief does that. People outside of video games don't know who Nathan Drake is. I'm not a Halo fan and most people can tell you that, but he is about the only character left that is synonymous with gaming.
I understand what you guys are saying. Its just I look beyond the publicity for quality character development in my characters and Master Chief doesn't have ####.
I think that looking strongly at character development as the defining factor in figuring out the "best main character" in video game history is a little simplistic, though. I understand what you're getting at, but I think that for this category, it's important to recognize that a handful of video game characters throughout history have literally transcended the video game world and become pop culture icons. That's what separate characters like Mario from the rest. There is very little character development for the Mario character, but Mario is literally a pop culture icon. Master Chief isn't at Mario's level, but there's little doubt in my mind that he's a pop culture icon in the same way that Mario is.
Ignoring the fact that looking strongly at "iconess" as the defining factor in figuring out the "best main character" in video game history is more simplistic than looking strongly at character development imo, but I don't think Master Chief's anywhere near the pop culture icon that Mario is. I'd say close to 100% of the general population knows who Mario is. I'd be surprised if 25% of the general population knows who Master Chief is. I know going by personal experience alone is a very small sample size, but of my buddies who don't play video games, I know if I asked them who Master Chief was they wouldn't have the slightest idea. Master Chief is a video game icon, not a pop culture icon imo, and I think that's a huge difference.
Master Chief is nowhere near Mario in the grand scheme of things, no question. And "iconness" isn't the only factor in judging the best character ever, obviously. I just think that it's important to recognize that there are a select handful of video game characters that are more legendary, if you will, than the rest. Master Chief is one of those characters.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top