What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

"Is that all the taller it is?" (1 Viewer)

TheMagus

Footballguy
My wife said that sentence this morning. She was trying to express the fact that she thought something would be bigger than it is. I'm trying to tell her that this sentence is not grammatically correct and/or English. She plugged the sentence into several grammar check sites and it comes back with no errors. I don't think I'm crazy. Looking for the sage wisdom of footballguys to settle this matter. 

 
If she means that something is taller than another thing or taller than it used to be, and she expected a greater difference between the two heights, I believe the sentence is grammatically correct.

Though there are many better ways to express it.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I'm surprised you found a woman to marry you.  Treat her right, and stop looking for ways to put her down.

 
I have heard that sentence structure used often in Western MD (Garrett County).

Is that all the [adjective] it is?  although it would be tall, not taller.  Tall,short,fast,slow,big,little, heavy,light etc

 
I'm surprised you found a woman to marry you.  Treat her right, and stop looking for ways to put her down.
Ah yes. I had a momentary lapse of judgment and forgot how very very serious life is. Point taken. I'll also tell her to stop calling me a dumb ### because life is very serious.

I was going to show her this thread but now I'm not sure. Not sure how she would take the ESL and dumber comments.  :lmao:

 
It can't be grammatically correct. You use an article before a noun. Taller is not a noun. I have no idea why the all is in there. Her parents are from the mid-west even though she grew up on the east coast and every once in a while she busts out some phrase and I have no idea what language she is speaking.

 
It can't be grammatically correct. You use an article before a noun. Taller is not a noun. I have no idea why the all is in there. Her parents are from the mid-west even though she grew up on the east coast and every once in a while she busts out some phrase and I have no idea what language she is speaking.
I'm all the wiser after that explanation.

 
It can't be grammatically correct. You use an article before a noun. Taller is not a noun. I have no idea why the all is in there. Her parents are from the mid-west even though she grew up on the east coast and every once in a while she busts out some phrase and I have no idea what language she is speaking.
I think we are all the wiser for having read this post.

 
i, too, look for petty reasons to fight with my wife. it breaks up the spontaneity of fighting with her over other meaningless #### that i didn't see coming from 1000 miles away.

 
It can't be grammatically correct. You use an article before a noun. Taller is not a noun. I have no idea why the all is in there. Her parents are from the mid-west even though she grew up on the east coast and every once in a while she busts out some phrase and I have no idea what language she is speaking.
The words are English, but that's not English.  Methinks the lady doth yoda too much.

 
My wife said that sentence this morning. She was trying to express the fact that she thought something would be bigger than it is. I'm trying to tell her that this sentence is not grammatically correct and/or English. She plugged the sentence into several grammar check sites and it comes back with no errors. I don't think I'm crazy. Looking for the sage wisdom of footballguys to settle this matter. 
You're not from 'round here are ya boy? You best be keeping yaself quiet if ya know what's good fer ya.

 
Also, never end a sentence with a preposition.  That is the sort of grammar up with which we should not put.
We always taunted the English teachers & editors etc in the family with "A preposition is a terrible thing to end a sentence with."

 
Funny story aside, is ending a sentence with a preposition no longer a big deal?  That would be good.
I believe that in formal writing it is still frowned upon.  There are better words to end sentences with.  If you end a sentence with a preposition around a true grammar snob, you'll hear about it after.

 
Which is funny to me.  The rules.
Well, Latin is where it came from.  Because English is a relatively new language, rather than intrinsically building grammar from within, much of it comes from without.  Because "preposition" translates literally to "before place" the object noun in the sentence is expected to come after.  We have just kept it ever since.

 
Good stuff Henry Ford . . . that's why I asked.  Thanks.  But holding on to broken parts just for the sake of holding on is a little silly, no?

 
Good stuff Henry Ford . . . that's why I asked.  Thanks.  But holding on to broken parts just for the sake of holding on is a little silly, no?
It's also a good way to help avoid passive writing.  If you read everything I typed above on this page, it feels unfinished and lacks real punch.  Like a Philip Glass composition, it's just dissonant in the reading.  That's solely because the sentence structure was put together to place the preposition at the end of every sentence.

 
the beauty of English. it's literally a living, breathing organism. it grows and changes with time. soon it will evolve and devour us all but until then it doesn't hurt to poke, prod and taunt it. 

damn the rules, full speed ahead.

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top