krista4
Footballguy
On a serious note, what are the rules here?
Would “Top 31 songs from musicians who previously had become famous as part of a band or duo” be alright?
No rules, and yes.
On a serious note, what are the rules here?
Would “Top 31 songs from musicians who previously had become famous as part of a band or duo” be alright?

Rule #1: There are no rules!!!On a serious note, what are the rules here?
I may have talked about this song in the original thread, but The Platters covered themselves on a rerecording and it then became a smash. I get why people don't like it, but I'm a sucker for 1950s group harmony. Can't help it and I love The Platters' 2nd version. The original was kind of a mess and murky.17. Only You (and You Alone) from Goodnight Vienna (1974)
Previously ranked #18 - prior write-up below
Ringo recorded this cover of the Buck Ram song (first recorded in 1954 by The Platters) at the suggestion of John, who played acoustic guitar and provided a guide vocal here, with Harry Nilsson on backing vocals. John’s version was also released in the Anthology series. This version was released as a single and hit #6 on the US charts. I don’t have it higher because I never much cared for the original version. My favorite part of this song is the hilariously sincere spoken-word part in the middle. An equally hilarious music video with Harry Nilsson was shot for this song.
I had to have seen the guitarist play live at least once - but I've seem some on the list over 35 times.“Top 31 guitarists never to be in my kitchen “ not available?
Yes #17 - Cinema / Leave It
Album - 90125 (1983)
My first set of paired up songs. Like Anytime by Journey, it would be a crime to split these two songs up. The instrumental Cinema is a perfect lead in to the vocally incredible Leave it and it’s always weird to me to hear one without the other. Yoda voice: “there is another” song pairing further up my list.
Cinema was originally part of a 20-minute song by the group Cinema (everyone on this iteration of Yes before Jon Anderson rejoined the group). It actually won the Grammy for best rock instrumental - their only Grammy win.
Leave It was the only song on 90125 written by the Cinema gang that wasn’t rearranged when Anderson jumped back in and the only song on the album he wasn’t on the writing credits for.
They had an interesting video for Leave It linked below. It was an early adopter of computer generated technology and there was actually an MTV special on the making of this video since it took so long to create (there were 18 different versions of the video made).
- YouTube
Enjoy the videos and music you love, upload original content, and share it all with friends, family, and the world on YouTube.youtu.be

#17, Rudie Can't Fail, is the 4th off of London Calling. I love it because it is such an energetic, upbeat song. Perhaps that's because of what the song is about.
The Clash kupcho1 Rudie Can't Fail
![]()
Rudie Can't Fail - Remastered
The Clash · London Calling (Remastered) · Song · 1979open.spotify.com
A "Rudie" is a "Rude Boy," which is a term for the first English generation born to Jamaican parents who had immigrated to England - the so called JamEnglish generation. These "Rude Boys" were often looked down upon as irresponsible, which is the theme of this song, but others would celebrate their ways as a rebellious expression of freedom.
Fantastic song; maybe one of the best of 1989. I had no idea Johnny Marr was involved.
Johnny Marr Eephus The The--The Beat(en) Generation
![]()
Mrs. Yambag’s favorite song as it spoke to her dreams as a young girl growing up in a toxic household, hoping and dreaming for a better future and feeling like she finally found it.
and cracks me up every time. A big difference between shows like this and the Houston '81 show just a couple years later that was linked before. Speaking of The Midnight Special, there was also a version of this song on there too. Neal bringing the goods more way than one with the solo at the end.
Eddie Vedder Tau837 Insignificance
- YouTube
Enjoy the videos and music you love, upload original content, and share it all with friends, family, and the world on YouTube.www.youtube.com
‘80s Soul Asylum is VERY different from ‘90s Soul Asylum.Counting Crows would be a good one for me too - I've only heard 2 albums and played Recovering the Satellites a lot in that same era. Toad the Wet Sprocket was another random one that I had written down along with Soul Asylum. Both of those I was surprised to see albums before the 90s.Totally agree. Even Vedder is in this category to me. He lasted longer but not by much, his star was among the brightest, then many of us looked away. I’ve enjoyed more than I thought I would.I love seeing bands like Candlebox and Our Lady Peace on the playlists. Bands I remember really digging an album or two at the most, but hearing 0% of anything else from them. I've been trying to find something that triggers a deeper dive from me, but I haven't hit that with examples I had thought of. These were great ones I hadn't thought of. The closest I came was Better Than Ezra.
.
Better than Ezra would be an interesting list.
If I were to choose a list based on this criteria, it would probably be the Offspring. Counting crows almost qualifies.
The couple songs I skimmed sounded more like The Replacements.‘80s Soul Asylum is VERY different from ‘90s Soul Asylum.Counting Crows would be a good one for me too - I've only heard 2 albums and played Recovering the Satellites a lot in that same era. Toad the Wet Sprocket was another random one that I had written down along with Soul Asylum. Both of those I was surprised to see albums before the 90s.Totally agree. Even Vedder is in this category to me. He lasted longer but not by much, his star was among the brightest, then many of us looked away. I’ve enjoyed more than I thought I would.I love seeing bands like Candlebox and Our Lady Peace on the playlists. Bands I remember really digging an album or two at the most, but hearing 0% of anything else from them. I've been trying to find something that triggers a deeper dive from me, but I haven't hit that with examples I had thought of. These were great ones I hadn't thought of. The closest I came was Better Than Ezra.
.
Better than Ezra would be an interesting list.
If I were to choose a list based on this criteria, it would probably be the Offspring. Counting crows almost qualifies.
Yep. I saw them in 1993 on a bill with the Spin Doctors and Screaming Trees -- holy '90s, Batman! -- and much of their non-Grave Dancers Union material sounded like the 'Mats to me.The couple songs I skimmed sounded more like The Replacements.‘80s Soul Asylum is VERY different from ‘90s Soul Asylum.Counting Crows would be a good one for me too - I've only heard 2 albums and played Recovering the Satellites a lot in that same era. Toad the Wet Sprocket was another random one that I had written down along with Soul Asylum. Both of those I was surprised to see albums before the 90s.Totally agree. Even Vedder is in this category to me. He lasted longer but not by much, his star was among the brightest, then many of us looked away. I’ve enjoyed more than I thought I would.I love seeing bands like Candlebox and Our Lady Peace on the playlists. Bands I remember really digging an album or two at the most, but hearing 0% of anything else from them. I've been trying to find something that triggers a deeper dive from me, but I haven't hit that with examples I had thought of. These were great ones I hadn't thought of. The closest I came was Better Than Ezra.
.
Better than Ezra would be an interesting list.
If I were to choose a list based on this criteria, it would probably be the Offspring. Counting crows almost qualifies.
Is it Neil? I don't think people would "at" me if it wasn't Neil.#17: LORD HURON - MINE FOREVER
- YouTube
Enjoy the videos and music you love, upload original content, and share it all with friends, family, and the world on YouTube.www.youtube.com
Another track, another slower tune with themes of love and love lost. Watching the link today also reminded me that I haven't talked about the videos Lord Huron puts out and how fun and cinematic they tend to be.
If you're ever gonna leave this place
Don't wait, it's time to go
If you really wanna stay, I'll go alone
If you tell me where to meet
Then I'll wait 'til I turn to bones
Oh, we really should've left here long ago
Next up: A cover!!! @Pip's Invitation can tell me if it is a quality one....
They ran out of holes/positions?The groups was running out of ideas, though, for a bunch of reasons.
As in you aren't overly familiar with this group of artists and have been surprised by the quality?Maybe it's just my familiarity with the artists, but Yes, Journey, Eurythmics, Whitney Houston, R.E.M., Radiohead and the Bee Gees have had some solid winners and we're only up to (down to?) 17.
Nope, very familiar but hadn't dug deep on them in a while. The depth is tremendousAs in you aren't overly familiar with this group of artists and have been surprised by the quality?Maybe it's just my familiarity with the artists, but Yes, Journey, Eurythmics, Whitney Houston, R.E.M., Radiohead and the Bee Gees have had some solid winners and we're only up to (down to?) 17.
One of their longer '70s tunes and off their Main Course album, "Edge of the Universe" has a bit of a country-like element to it, maybe with a tinge of Beach Boys as well. Some vibrant keyboard work by Blue Weaver, with a captivating melody and bridge. And Dennis Bryon's drum work over the last minute or so is pretty impressive. The original studio version never charted in the U.S., although a few years later (1977) the band released a live album in which the live version hit #26 in the States.
The Bee Gees zamboni Edge of the Universe
![]()
Shifting back to their debut album, "To Love Somebody" was their second international/U.S. hit (reaching #17 in the States). Really nice orchestral arrangement with emotional vocal performance by Barry and harmonized chorus with the brothers. Has a nice soulful element that probably fit in rather well with the great Motown efforts that were permeating the airwaves at the time. In fact, some (unsubstantiated) accounts say that the song was written for Otis Redding and that he died before having a chance to record it. Per Wiki: "Redding came to see Barry at the Plaza in New York City one night. Robin claimed that "Otis Redding said he loved our material and would Barry write him a song"". That said, Barry later indicated that he wrote it for his manager Robert Stigwood as admiration for getting them to where they were.
The Bee Gees zamboni To Love Somebody
![]()
Ten of the remaining Annie Lennox songs should be ones that everyone knows. It was fun filling out the dance card.Nope, very familiar but hadn't dug deep on them in a while. The depth is tremendousAs in you aren't overly familiar with this group of artists and have been surprised by the quality?Maybe it's just my familiarity with the artists, but Yes, Journey, Eurythmics, Whitney Houston, R.E.M., Radiohead and the Bee Gees have had some solid winners and we're only up to (down to?) 17.
Translation - I will probably know 2-3.Ten of the remaining Annie Lennox songs should be ones that everyone knows. It was fun filling out the dance card.Nope, very familiar but hadn't dug deep on them in a while. The depth is tremendousAs in you aren't overly familiar with this group of artists and have been surprised by the quality?Maybe it's just my familiarity with the artists, but Yes, Journey, Eurythmics, Whitney Houston, R.E.M., Radiohead and the Bee Gees have had some solid winners and we're only up to (down to?) 17.
Translation - I will probably know 2-3.Ten of the remaining Annie Lennox songs should be ones that everyone knows. It was fun filling out the dance card.Nope, very familiar but hadn't dug deep on them in a while. The depth is tremendousAs in you aren't overly familiar with this group of artists and have been surprised by the quality?Maybe it's just my familiarity with the artists, but Yes, Journey, Eurythmics, Whitney Houston, R.E.M., Radiohead and the Bee Gees have had some solid winners and we're only up to (down to?) 17.
I will give you an honest count how many i know.Translation - I will probably know 2-3.Ten of the remaining Annie Lennox songs should be ones that everyone knows. It was fun filling out the dance card.Nope, very familiar but hadn't dug deep on them in a while. The depth is tremendousAs in you aren't overly familiar with this group of artists and have been surprised by the quality?Maybe it's just my familiarity with the artists, but Yes, Journey, Eurythmics, Whitney Houston, R.E.M., Radiohead and the Bee Gees have had some solid winners and we're only up to (down to?) 17.
Not unless you were living under a rock in Outer Slabovia.
You may only know nine of them. Quite a few have been selected in previous drafts. One will likely turn up in the theme draft, although not on my list.I will give you an honest count how many i know.Translation - I will probably know 2-3.Ten of the remaining Annie Lennox songs should be ones that everyone knows. It was fun filling out the dance card.Nope, very familiar but hadn't dug deep on them in a while. The depth is tremendousAs in you aren't overly familiar with this group of artists and have been surprised by the quality?Maybe it's just my familiarity with the artists, but Yes, Journey, Eurythmics, Whitney Houston, R.E.M., Radiohead and the Bee Gees have had some solid winners and we're only up to (down to?) 17.
Not unless you were living under a rock in Outer Slabovia.
No peeking! That's my shtick.You may only know nine of them. Quite a few have been selected in previous drafts. One will likely turn up in the theme draft, although not on my list.I will give you an honest count how many i know.Translation - I will probably know 2-3.Ten of the remaining Annie Lennox songs should be ones that everyone knows. It was fun filling out the dance card.Nope, very familiar but hadn't dug deep on them in a while. The depth is tremendousAs in you aren't overly familiar with this group of artists and have been surprised by the quality?Maybe it's just my familiarity with the artists, but Yes, Journey, Eurythmics, Whitney Houston, R.E.M., Radiohead and the Bee Gees have had some solid winners and we're only up to (down to?) 17.
Not unless you were living under a rock in Outer Slabovia.


I'm sure that's doable. You could definitely take some... inspiration from the various M-AD countdowns, and then there are some decently well-known bands yet to be covered. I suppose the main "danger" is if he spotlights some of your picks during the countdown.I will have to look to see if I even have enough ideas to make it work. I was thinking my shtick for the Krista draft will be 31 songs from artists NOT on Shuke's 1000+ artist countdown.![]()
I will have to look to see if I even have enough ideas to make it work. I was thinking my shtick for the Krista draft will be 31 songs from artists NOT on Shuke's 1000+ artist countdown.![]()

Sounds like a Bee Gees concept album.Currently listening to a documentary about the great storm of 1703 in England.
I remember when MTV played all of those versions consecutively in one sitting. Pretty sure I watched them all.They had an interesting video for Leave It linked below. It was an early adopter of computer generated technology and there was actually an MTV special on the making of this video since it took so long to create (there were 18 different versions of the video made).
Have you seen my wife, Mr. Zamboni?Sounds like a Bee Gees concept album.Currently listening to a documentary about the great storm of 1703 in England.