What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Middle Aged Dummies!! Artists #1's have been posted!! (6 Viewers)

Nice timing, I was just going to shout out @Mt. Man I listened to Rainier Fog twice today. Safe to say I thought it was good. Thanks for taking me back with Alice in Chains, and introducing that later album. Alice in Chains was my 2nd favorite of the Seattle bands after Soundgarden. They just had that darker, metal edge to them that being a metal fan gave me something more to click with. I just never gave them a listen after Layne died. I am very impressed with how seemless the sound is on Rainier Fog with their 90s material, and how seemless the new lead singer sounds. You got the highlights from the album for sure, but I also did really like the title track, So Far Under, and Never Fade. Great job with the playlist! It's been way too long since I heard Got Met Wrong, there was plenty of Jar of Flies goodness, and we even got entries from Last Action Hero!!! :bow:

I will share a cover with you in Part 2 from that band. As I was researching, I saw a cover of one of your songs you took that I thought sounded decent. Another AIC cover I like that I drafted for a GP category is Opeth's version of Would? HERE is link if you are interested in that.
 
Now it’s time for Last Songs Out. One each per Album and EP. That includes the Music Bank compilation, but no other greatest hits or anything. Also nothing from Unplugged, as the only song that was eligible (by my own rules) was selected. In order from earliest to latest release:

Bleed The Freak (off Facelift) Not that far above “We Die Young” and “Sunshine”, but there’s only one more here.

Brother – see below

Dirt (off, well, Dirt) Dirt was #32, and probably could’ve made it, but got squeezed out.

Whale & Wasp (off Jar of Flies) Well, there’s only two songs that aren’t already on the lists. Let’s go with the instrumental for a different flavor.

Shame In You (off Alice In Chains/Tripod) Close call between this and “Sludge Factory”, which were both tough cuts. I’ll go for the more obscure song though.

Whatcha Gonna Do (Demo version off Music Bank) Cowbell! Not a typical style, but can’t fault them for the energy shown!

A Looking In View (off Black Gives Way to Blue) Yes, over “Check My Brain”, which might be controversial.

Hollow (off The Devil Put Dinosaurs Here) It seemed like either Choke or Hollow was going to make this list. Obviously I could’ve put both in, but when ranking it always fell that one was in and the other out.

So Far Under (off Rainier Fog) - This album probably deserves a couple dozen more listens to (begin to) catch up with the rest, but this one definitely vied for a spot.

Bonus ‘full’ write-up:
—------
Brother (off Sap, 1992)

You were always so far away
I know that pain
So don't you run away
Like you used to do


(Spotify) Alice in Chains - Brother
(Youtube Version) Brother
(Unplugged Version) Alice In Chains - Brother

I struggled with where to put this song. In hindsight, it would’ve made a decent intro at 31 like some others did. Instead it’s here. Maybe call it #31B? Especially since I wouldn’t be surprised if I end up throwing it onto the playlist eventually.

The thing is… I really prefer the Unplugged version. The album version has Cantrell doing lead vocals while Ann Wilson (who you MIGHT know from Heart >.>) provides back up. While Ann does an excellent job, Cantrell hits me as somewhat toned-down. It's easy to point to the addition of Layne and harmonizing that the live version provides as the difference. Plus perhaps bias. Hard to say.
 
I listened to Rainier Fog twice today. Safe to say I thought it was good. Thanks for taking me back with Alice in Chains, and introducing that later album. Alice in Chains was my 2nd favorite of the Seattle bands after Soundgarden. They just had that darker, metal edge to them that being a metal fan gave me something more to click with. I just never gave them a listen after Layne died. I am very impressed with how seemless the sound is on Rainier Fog with their 90s material, and how seemless the new lead singer sounds. You got the highlights from the album for sure, but I also did really like the title track, So Far Under, and Never Fade. Great job with the playlist! It's been way too long since I heard Got Met Wrong, there was plenty of Jar of Flies goodness, and we even got entries from Last Action Hero!!! :bow:

I will share a cover with you in Part 2 from that band. As I was researching, I saw a cover of one of your songs you took that I thought sounded decent. Another AIC cover I like that I drafted for a GP category is Opeth's version of Would? HERE is link if you are interested in that.
Glad you enjoyed! Part of this exercise was to 'force' me to listen to that album some more, as most songs were completely unfamiliar to me. Perhaps really to give the Duvall era more of a fair shake in general. I rather like "Deaf Ears Blind Eyes" too, though that's more Top 50 range. BGWTB has a lot of good songs I didn't mention as well. TDPDH has a couple too, though I think it has some of the weakest offerings of the three, so yeah. The point is that if I've inspired folks to listen, then I've done my job. As it were.
 
For V2.0 of this I am pretty sure I know who I will highlight and am 100% sure nobody else will select them. However, I would prefer a bit of a break so I can check out some of the playlists before spending time on my artist. Of course, I'm just one person so whatever y'all decide.
You realise we can pick our artists and still take a break, right?
 
For V2.0 of this I am pretty sure I know who I will highlight and am 100% sure nobody else will select them. However, I would prefer a bit of a break so I can check out some of the playlists before spending time on my artist. Of course, I'm just one person so whatever y'all decide.
You realise we can pick our artists and still take a break, right?
Yes
 
For V2.0 of this I am pretty sure I know who I will highlight and am 100% sure nobody else will select them. However, I would prefer a bit of a break so I can check out some of the playlists before spending time on my artist. Of course, I'm just one person so whatever y'all decide.
Seems consensus opinion - except for @KarmaPolice who wants Round 31 to be released tonight.
LOL. I understand I get carried away sometimes. ;)

Like you I am cool with whatever, and also have 3 lists that are completed. :bag:
Maybe you need to have a secret identity too.
I am now up to 17 artists i am considering lists for.

My secret ID is definitely getting trotted out next time
Secret ID can do the weird stuff, my ID more normal....if you can consider the Stranglers normal.

17 artist list in alphabetical order
1) Swedish band everyone knows
2) Norwegian band everyone knows
3) US band with a female lead
4) Uk band partially covered first round
5) Scottish band from this century with a female lead
6) UK cartoon band partially covered first round
7) US Indie band
8) Australian band that were a global smash
9) US Band that owes a heavy debt to 80s music
10) German band highly revered
11) Artist who had an early top 40 hit in his band. Since primarily invisible with a dedicated fanbase
12) My favorite Liverpool band
13) UK duo still going with 40 years of music under their belt
14) Australian band who had a massive hit with a rock cover of a disco song
15) Less known norwegian duo from this century
16) English duo. Highly intense. Had multiple US #1 singles. More than 3 albums despite what people think
17) Scottish singer/songwriter who was a main player in about 4 bands plus solo. Needs more than a Band Aid to describe
 
Last edited:
17 artist list in alphabetical order
1) Swedish band everyone knows
2) Norwegian band everyone knows
3) US band with a female lead
4) Uk band partially covered first round
5) Scottish band from this century with a female lead
6) UK cartoon band partially covered first round
7) US Indie band
8) Australian band that were a global smash
9) US Band that owes a heavy debt to 80s music
10) German band highly revered
11) Artist who had an early top 40 hit in his band. Since primarily invisible with a dedicated fanbase
12) My favorite Liverpool band
13) UK duo still going with 40 years of music under their belt
14) Australian band who had a massive hit with a rock cover of a disco song
15) Less known norwegian duo from this century
16) English duo. Highly intense. Had multiple US #1 singles. More than 3 albums despite what people think
17) Scottish singer/songwriter who was a main player in about 4 bands plus solo. Needs more than a Band Aid to describe
I've only got one artist in mind, and based on your descriptions above, I'm in no danger of you selecting them. (One possible exception is your #7, but I don't think that descriptor applies to mine.)
 
39. JAR (unranked) - for those unfamiliar and love the Dookie sound I strongly endorse this track

Now he's gone and all I can say is you gotta live while life goes on
Would have been a top thirty-one for me.

Daft Punk - had no idea what this was or where it was going at first but once this got going it blew me away.

Heh. I felt the same way the first time I got through it. The record scratching sent it wayyyy over the top for me. #1? Maybe if not for a few others. . .
 
17 artist list in alphabetical order
1) Swedish band everyone knows
2) Norwegian band everyone knows
3) US band with a female lead
4) Uk band partially covered first round
5) Scottish band from this century with a female lead
6) UK cartoon band partially covered first round
7) US Indie band
8) Australian band that were a global smash
9) US Band that owes a heavy debt to 80s music
10) German band highly revered
11) Artist who had an early top 40 hit in his band. Since primarily invisible with a dedicated fanbase
12) My favorite Liverpool band
13) UK duo still going with 40 years of music under their belt
14) Australian band who had a massive hit with a rock cover of a disco song
15) Less known norwegian duo from this century
16) English duo. Highly intense. Had multiple US #1 singles. More than 3 albums despite what people think
17) Scottish singer/songwriter who was a main player in about 4 bands plus solo. Needs more than a Band Aid to describe
I've only got one artist in mind, and based on your descriptions above, I'm in no danger of you selecting them. (One possible exception is your #7, but I don't think that descriptor applies to mine.)
It doesn’t take an International Police Organization based in france to figure out who #7 is
 
For V2.0 of this I am pretty sure I know who I will highlight and am 100% sure nobody else will select them. However, I would prefer a bit of a break so I can check out some of the playlists before spending time on my artist. Of course, I'm just one person so whatever y'all decide.
Seems consensus opinion - except for @KarmaPolice who wants Round 31 to be released tonight.
LOL. I understand I get carried away sometimes. ;)

Like you I am cool with whatever, and also have 3 lists that are completed. :bag:
Maybe you need to have a secret identity too.
I am now up to 17 artists i am considering lists for.

My secret ID is definitely getting trotted out next time
Secret ID can do the weird stuff, my ID more normal....if you can consider the Stranglers normal.

17 artist list in alphabetical order
1) Swedish band everyone knows
2) Norwegian band everyone knows
3) US band with a female lead
4) Uk band partially covered first round
5) Scottish band from this century with a female lead
6) UK cartoon band partially covered first round
7) US Indie band
8) Australian band that were a global smash
9) US Band that owes a heavy debt to 80s music
10) German band highly revered
11) Artist who had an early top 40 hit in his band. Since primarily invisible with a dedicated fanbase
12) My favorite Liverpool band
13) UK duo still going with 40 years of music under their belt
14) Australian band who had a massive hit with a rock cover of a disco song
15) Less known norwegian duo from this century
16) English duo. Highly intense. Had multiple US #1 singles. More than 3 albums despite what people think
17) Scottish singer/songwriter who was a main player in about 4 bands plus solo. Needs more than a Band Aid to describe
#5, please.
 
I don’t see any singers from Hong Kong who gained fame singing Ricky Martin on American Idol. ;)
Imagine what the songs that dont make the top 31 would sound like :shudder:

If we do this for a few years, maybe iteration #57 I might do the lovely chinese superstar Faye Wong.
Depends how many mandarin speakers we have on board by then
I am all for Faye Wong even not knowing Mandarin — fan of the Wong Kar Wai movies that she was in. (But I just did 31 songs in Portuguese, so language clearly no music barrier for me.)
 
So I know who I plan to choose next but have a big dilemma. This artist is way more diverse in their output than most any artist. He has religious music, folk, classical, electronic, full Xmas albums, indie, pop. It's all over the map. I am torn between just taking the 31 best songs that people are most likely to dig and I dig the most or trying to take at least 1 track from each album which will leave me only room for like 16-18 of his most popular "hit" songs but also will make for some surprises for the listeners...but of course those surprises might just turn into quick skips.
 
So I know who I plan to choose next but have a big dilemma. This artist is way more diverse in their output than most any artist. He has religious music, folk, classical, electronic, full Xmas albums, indie, pop. It's all over the map. I am torn between just taking the 31 best songs that people are most likely to dig and I dig the most or trying to take at least 1 track from each album which will leave me only room for like 16-18 of his most popular "hit" songs but also will make for some surprises for the listeners...but of course those surprises might just turn into quick skips.
I'd rather get some stuff I don't know. I don't need a top 31 songs from Casey Kasem.
 
So I know who I plan to choose next but have a big dilemma. This artist is way more diverse in their output than most any artist. He has religious music, folk, classical, electronic, full Xmas albums, indie, pop. It's all over the map. I am torn between just taking the 31 best songs that people are most likely to dig and I dig the most or trying to take at least 1 track from each album which will leave me only room for like 16-18 of his most popular "hit" songs but also will make for some surprises for the listeners...but of course those surprises might just turn into quick skips.
IMO only do that if you actually love those songs. Also, everyone is free to skip right over Christmas music in any list. ;)

I had a similar debates with what to include and what my reasoning was.
 
So I know who I plan to choose next but have a big dilemma. This artist is way more diverse in their output than most any artist. He has religious music, folk, classical, electronic, full Xmas albums, indie, pop. It's all over the map. I am torn between just taking the 31 best songs that people are most likely to dig and I dig the most or trying to take at least 1 track from each album which will leave me only room for like 16-18 of his most popular "hit" songs but also will make for some surprises for the listeners...but of course those surprises might just turn into quick skips.
I'd rather get some stuff I don't know. I don't need a top 31 songs from Casey Kasem.
Me too, but even that threshold is all over the place for this group. I think all of us are pretty conscious of bring some depth even to artists that are more known. AC/DC is a perfect example for me, or Rush.
 
So I know who I plan to choose next but have a big dilemma. This artist is way more diverse in their output than most any artist. He has religious music, folk, classical, electronic, full Xmas albums, indie, pop. It's all over the map. I am torn between just taking the 31 best songs that people are most likely to dig and I dig the most or trying to take at least 1 track from each album which will leave me only room for like 16-18 of his most popular "hit" songs but also will make for some surprises for the listeners...but of course those surprises might just turn into quick skips.
I'd rather get some stuff I don't know. I don't need a top 31 songs from Casey Kasem.
Me too, but even that threshold is all over the place for this group. I think all of us are pretty conscious of bring some depth even to artists that are more known. AC/DC is a perfect example for me, or Rush.
And some artists require multiple visits. Dolly Parton's catalogue is just scary.
 
For V2.0 of this I am pretty sure I know who I will highlight and am 100% sure nobody else will select them. However, I would prefer a bit of a break so I can check out some of the playlists before spending time on my artist. Of course, I'm just one person so whatever y'all decide.
Seems consensus opinion - except for @KarmaPolice who wants Round 31 to be released tonight.
LOL. I understand I get carried away sometimes. ;)

Like you I am cool with whatever, and also have 3 lists that are completed. :bag:
Maybe you need to have a secret identity too.
I am now up to 17 artists i am considering lists for.

My secret ID is definitely getting trotted out next time
Secret ID can do the weird stuff, my ID more normal....if you can consider the Stranglers normal.

17 artist list in alphabetical order
1) Swedish band everyone knows
2) Norwegian band everyone knows
3) US band with a female lead
4) Uk band partially covered first round
5) Scottish band from this century with a female lead
6) UK cartoon band partially covered first round
7) US Indie band
8) Australian band that were a global smash
9) US Band that owes a heavy debt to 80s music
10) German band highly revered
11) Artist who had an early top 40 hit in his band. Since primarily invisible with a dedicated fanbase
12) My favorite Liverpool band
13) UK duo still going with 40 years of music under their belt
14) Australian band who had a massive hit with a rock cover of a disco song
15) Less known norwegian duo from this century
16) English duo. Highly intense. Had multiple US #1 singles. More than 3 albums despite what people think
17) Scottish singer/songwriter who was a main player in about 4 bands plus solo. Needs more than a Band Aid to describe
#5, please.
Only 4 albums, so small but high quality pool. They are a frontrunner though
I don’t see any singers from Hong Kong who gained fame singing Ricky Martin on American Idol. ;)
Imagine what the songs that dont make the top 31 would sound like :shudder:

If we do this for a few years, maybe iteration #57 I might do the lovely chinese superstar Faye Wong.
Depends how many mandarin speakers we have on board by then
I am all for Faye Wong even not knowing Mandarin — fan of the Wong Kar Wai movies that she was in. (But I just did 31 songs in Portuguese, so language clearly no music barrier for me.)
A lot of Fayes stuff is in English.
Pretty sure at least two of her albums
Several collaborations or covers of Cocteau Twins songs.
But she sounds even sweeter in Mandarin.
Australian band that were a global smash
I really don't need to hear "The Safety Dance" again.

Do please leave some bands for the rest of us.
We can dance if we want to.
Its not a band with the Scottish born Singer. One of many Australian bands with such a situation lol
All of the members of this band were born in Australia. An incredible feat given the makeup of Australian society
Half the 6 members were brothers

Plenty left. I can only pick one (or two if My Secret Identity resurrects)
My status is officially questionable for the next one. I've whined at length before about my aversion to lists and I just don't spend as much time on the board as I used to.

I'll probably throw an artist into the hat but I don't know if I have another deep dive in me right now.
These things are always better with you in them. Paul Weller seems like a natural for you.
Hope you can find enough time to do a list, if not brief descriptions.
 
For V2.0 of this I am pretty sure I know who I will highlight and am 100% sure nobody else will select them. However, I would prefer a bit of a break so I can check out some of the playlists before spending time on my artist. Of course, I'm just one person so whatever y'all decide.
Seems consensus opinion - except for @KarmaPolice who wants Round 31 to be released tonight.
LOL. I understand I get carried away sometimes. ;)

Like you I am cool with whatever, and also have 3 lists that are completed. :bag:
Maybe you need to have a secret identity too.
I am now up to 17 artists i am considering lists for.

My secret ID is definitely getting trotted out next time
Secret ID can do the weird stuff, my ID more normal....if you can consider the Stranglers normal.

17 artist list in alphabetical order
1) Swedish band everyone knows
2) Norwegian band everyone knows
3) US band with a female lead
4) Uk band partially covered first round
5) Scottish band from this century with a female lead
6) UK cartoon band partially covered first round
7) US Indie band
8) Australian band that were a global smash
9) US Band that owes a heavy debt to 80s music
10) German band highly revered
11) Artist who had an early top 40 hit in his band. Since primarily invisible with a dedicated fanbase
12) My favorite Liverpool band
13) UK duo still going with 40 years of music under their belt
14) Australian band who had a massive hit with a rock cover of a disco song
15) Less known norwegian duo from this century
16) English duo. Highly intense. Had multiple US #1 singles. More than 3 albums despite what people think
17) Scottish singer/songwriter who was a main player in about 4 bands plus solo. Needs more than a Band Aid to describe
I vote for #2.
 
So I know who I plan to choose next but have a big dilemma. This artist is way more diverse in their output than most any artist. He has religious music, folk, classical, electronic, full Xmas albums, indie, pop. It's all over the map. I am torn between just taking the 31 best songs that people are most likely to dig and I dig the most or trying to take at least 1 track from each album which will leave me only room for like 16-18 of his most popular "hit" songs but also will make for some surprises for the listeners...but of course those surprises might just turn into quick skips.
I'd rather get some stuff I don't know. I don't need a top 31 songs from Casey Kasem.
Yeah I tried to use hits loosely. My guess is most people aren’t that familiar with the artist in general. He’s definitely never had a song on mainstream radio or anything. Just some songs are very typical and some are piano pieces or meditative electronic.
 
So I know who I plan to choose next but have a big dilemma. This artist is way more diverse in their output than most any artist. He has religious music, folk, classical, electronic, full Xmas albums, indie, pop. It's all over the map. I am torn between just taking the 31 best songs that people are most likely to dig and I dig the most or trying to take at least 1 track from each album which will leave me only room for like 16-18 of his most popular "hit" songs but also will make for some surprises for the listeners...but of course those surprises might just turn into quick skips.
IMO only do that if you actually love those songs. Also, everyone is free to skip right over Christmas music in any list. ;)

I had a similar debates with what to include and what my reasoning was.
I considered The Kinks' Father Christmas, but then left it out. It may have been worthy of a spot. I then completely forgot about it when I built my list out to 100 for the extended playlist. I should probably add it in there. It is definitely deserving of top 100 recognition.
 
So I know who I plan to choose next but have a big dilemma. This artist is way more diverse in their output than most any artist. He has religious music, folk, classical, electronic, full Xmas albums, indie, pop. It's all over the map. I am torn between just taking the 31 best songs that people are most likely to dig and I dig the most or trying to take at least 1 track from each album which will leave me only room for like 16-18 of his most popular "hit" songs but also will make for some surprises for the listeners...but of course those surprises might just turn into quick skips.
IMO only do that if you actually love those songs. Also, everyone is free to skip right over Christmas music in any list. ;)

I had a similar debates with what to include and what my reasoning was.
Yeah maybe I’ll keep some of the odd songs but not make a point to capture something from every non tradition release. The Christmas song probably stays though.
 
My status is officially questionable for the next one. I've whined at length before about my aversion to lists and I just don't spend as much time on the board as I used to.

I'll probably throw an artist into the hat but I don't know if I have another deep dive in me right now.
The lists are just a means to an end of getting the music out there.
I became a fan of your Albarn pick, so hope you jump back in for Part 2.
 
For V2.0 of this I am pretty sure I know who I will highlight and am 100% sure nobody else will select them. However, I would prefer a bit of a break so I can check out some of the playlists before spending time on my artist. Of course, I'm just one person so whatever y'all decide.
Seems consensus opinion - except for @KarmaPolice who wants Round 31 to be released tonight.
LOL. I understand I get carried away sometimes. ;)

Like you I am cool with whatever, and also have 3 lists that are completed. :bag:
Maybe you need to have a secret identity too.
I am now up to 17 artists i am considering lists for.

My secret ID is definitely getting trotted out next time
Secret ID can do the weird stuff, my ID more normal....if you can consider the Stranglers normal.

17 artist list in alphabetical order
1) Swedish band everyone knows
2) Norwegian band everyone knows
I vote for #2.
reaction
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top