82. What’s That You’re Doing (
Tug Of War, 1982)
Spotify YouTube
(Paul #37)
I’m going to let you all in on a little secret: this isn’t that great a song. Maybe I didn’t need to tell you that. But since this is
my “favorites” list, and Stevie Wonder is second only to the Beatles as my favorite artist,* it gets an otherwise unjustified position on my list. The good part of this song is Stevie. The bad part is Paul. I don’t know what happened here and why Paul used the vocal style that he did, but it. does. not. work.
The song came about when Stevie simply began grooving during a session. Because Paul perceived that the keyboard part Stevie was improvising was its own bass line, Paul jumped in on drums instead of bass, to avoid stepping all over what Stevie was doing. Even that proved too much for Stevie, who directed Paul to cut back, and later Paul replaced his drum line in the overdubs, along with adding guitar and a terrific bass part as well as Andy MacKay on lyricon. As I said, Stevie pulls this song out for me, from his spoken word intro to his vocal performance throughout, but it doesn’t hit that deep funk groove I would have loved. And Paul’s vocal…why?
OH described the issues better than I do...well, maybe: “One thing you notice about fake white guy electronic funk of the era is the riff is too short and it’s in 4/4 time with the drums. [
makes sounds] Say a Parliament riff or a DC gogo band riff is in 7/8 or 6/7 time, the guitar/bass/horns riff in 7/8 and the drums in 4/4 or 8/8 time, and the riffs are way longer. [
makes sounds] A riff where the 8 and the 1 are the same. Where the drummer is playing the 1 there is a silent 8 from the riff. [
makes sounds] Like a circular thing. That’s how you get a really deep groove. Which that song doesn’t have despite the length. That’s why Funkadelic or Parliament songs weren’t as long, but the groove was deep. That song took a bunch of funk signifiers without making funk. Stevie Wonder killed it on the vocals, though.”
This is another song where I find the
“Twin Freaks” version worth a listen as well.
*And also because it is not “Ebony and Ivory.”
UP NEXT: the green, green grass of home...