Peyton is my RB5 in a start 3 league, behind DJ, Devonta, Conner, and Collins. I want to drop him, but just can't bring myself to do it. Yes, he is not a stud. Yes, the TB run blocking sux. Yes, TB is gonna be a pass-happy team. Yes, RoJo rushed more times than he did in week 4. Yes, dropping him now, before his bye, may make other league owners stay away. But then I look at the games TB has played:
vs NO - Barber gets 19 carries, Rodgers gets 2, Wilson gets 1, and Fitz runs 12 times (not scripted). Barber only gets 69 yds (3.6 ypc), but Rodgers and Wilson don't fare any better, going just 7 yds on 3 carries. Fitz passes only 28 times, and does not get sacked. The only RB to see a target was Rodgers (a catch for 2 yds). Barber gets 48 snaps, Rodgers gets 15, and Wilson gets 2. TB wins. The Saints run D proves stout thus far - Hyde goes 16 for 43 (2.7) in week 2, Coleman goes 15 for 33 (2.2) in week 3, and Saquon goes 10 for 44 (4.4) in week 4. - When you compare Barber's #'s to this bunch, he looks good.
vs PHI - Barber gets 16 carries, Rodgers gets 5, Wilson gets 1, and Fitz runs 1 time. Barber only gets 22 yds (1.4 ypc), but Rodgers doesn't fare much better, going 13 yds on 5 carries (2.6). Wilson does get 9 yds on his 1 carry. Fitz passes 33 times, and gets sacked twice. Fitz targets Rodgers 3 times, and Barber twice. Barber gets 36 snaps, Rodgers gets 18, and Wilson gets 3. TB wins. The Eagles run D proves stout thus far - Freeman/Coleman go 15 for 55 (3.7) in week 1, Wilkins/Hines go 11 for 37 (3.4) in week 3, and Henry/Lewis go 12 for 24 (2.0) in week 4. - When you compare Barber's #'s to this bunch, he looks hideous.
vs PIT - Barber gets 8 carries, Rodgers gets 2, Wilson gets 0, and Fitz runs 5 times. Barber gets 33 yds (4.1 ypc), and Rodgers gets negative 1 yd. Fitz passes 50 times, and gets sacked 3 times. Fitz targets Rodgers 3 times, and Barber/Wilson twice each. Barber gets 44 snaps, Rodgers gets 25, and Wilson gets 3. TB loses. The Steelers run D proves very good thus far - Hyde goes 22 for 62 (2.8) in week 1, Hunt goes 18 for 75 (4.2) in week 2, and Collins/Allen go 21 for 72 (3.4) in week 4. - When you compare Barber's #'s to this bunch, he looks good.
vs CHI - Barber gets 7 carries, Jones gets 10, and Winston runs 1 time. Barber gets 24 yds (3.4 ypc), and Jones gets 29 yds (2.9). Winston/Fitz pass 38 times, and get sacked 2 times each. Barber and Jones each get 2 targets. Barber gets 31 snaps, Jones gets 20, and Rodgers gets 11. TB loses. The Bears run D proves stout thus far - Williams/Montgomery go 17 for 54 (3.2) in week 1, Carson/Penny/Davis go 19 for 57 (3.0) in week 2, and David Johnson goes 12 for 31 (2.6) in week 3. - When you compare Barber's #'s to this bunch, he looks very good.
- After having probably the toughest first 4 games for any RB this season, and playing behind a poor run-blocking line, his numbers show he only had 1 terrible game, and actually did relatively well in the other 3.
- Jacquizz Rodgers has proven himself to be a small part in TB's plan, with only 9 carries and 7 targets in the first 3 games. He had no carries and no targets in game 4. He is obviously just a 3rd down back.
- Shaun Wilson was never a factor, getting only 2 carries and 2 targets in the first 3 games, then not even seeing the field in game 4.
- Barber's only real competition is Jones. Against CHI, Barber got 6 carries in the first half, and only 1 at the start of the 3rd quarter. Jones only got 1 carry in the first half, and 9 more when the game was out of reach, yet Barber still had a better YPC.
- Barber got 35 carries in TB's 2 wins, and only 15 carries in TB's 2 losses. Coincidence?
- Perhaps TB comes back after the bye with Winston and gives Jones a chance to be the main RB, with Barber playing second fiddle. Jones obviously has a better chance at explosive plays, but TB is going to be a pass first team, and Barber fits the bill better.
For all the stats and reasons above, I am choosing to hold him and see what week 6 versus ATL brings.