Welcome to Our Forums. Once you've registered and logged in, you're primed to talk football, among other topics, with the sharpest and most experienced fantasy players on the internet.
This is why you don't do startups before the NFL Draft
Which makes it interesting that so many people want to take Gibbs at 1.02 over the WR's in rookie drafts
Lockett's gonna be 31 in September, not exactly a death sentence for JSN
IMO their concern is more than justified. Like going from having a FF RB1 to a potential FF RB2-3, depending on format/role.
It’s gonna delay things though. I agree JSN will be fine, but short term, it’s not ideal.
Two high to mid 2nd round picks is definitely not 'no cost' dude.
I’ll take the over.
It could be and maybe not. The instinctive feeling here is to be worried. I like Charbs and not taking anything away from him but I look at it like this. Who would I rather have head-to-head? That would be Walker for me. That said. I see an opportunity to get Charbs at a lower cost. This is the life of FF running backs now. RBBC is the way a lot of teams are going. I'm shocked The Bengals have not grabbed another back myself. I thought for sure they would invest in one by now. I can see the Bengals getting one in the fourth or maybe trading for one.
Over here tooI’ll take the over.
I coulda sworn I posted this last night but posts seem to be missing.
Dude averaged 7 YPC. And yeah - he’s a really good receiver.
It’s a blow to both of their values, but I guess we have to get used to RBBC.
Charbs is more of a handcuff for Walker owners than he is for anyone else. Since I don't have Walker I won't have Charbs.
Elevates the value of guys like Bijan, JT, Hall even more. There are so few bellcow backs.
If you're going to quote me, please do it in a way that doesn't look like I posted something I didn't.
“FYP” (fixed your post) is intended as humor, not deception.If you're going to quote me, please do it in a way that doesn't look like I posted something I didn't.
Sorry, I had no idea what FYP meant.“FYP” (fixed your post) is intended as humor, not deception.If you're going to quote me, please do it in a way that doesn't look like I posted something I didn't.
Sorry - I thought this was a well-understood meme around here. I’ll delete.
I don’t 100% agree in the day of RBBC and where RBs get hurt often, but get your point. I do think Walker is better but this will be not better than 60/40 split for Walker. On a Carroll team both RBs could have RB2 value. I don’t have Walker anywhere and would consider Charbs as high as 1.05 maybe.
Without having Walker I believe 1.05 is too high for Charbs.
I agree. I see him more as a back of the first round/early second round kind of pick.
This is kind of my point and honestly, we forget the health factor. Backs have been getting hurt quite a bit. If one of these backs goes down then it's all in again. I think you should still consider Charbs just cheaper. The Seahawks might be ahead of the game here. Go ask the Breece Hall manager how it feels to lose your stud RB. The Javonte Williams manager might have something to say as well. Pete knows the feeling as well with his prior backs. It's the way of the world now in the NFL. Go cheaper on-backs in Dynasty and handcuff in the right situation. Or invest cheaply in another team's handcuff. I think this situation could work out for the manager that takes Charbs later.
While I agree with most of what you said, it's been that way since the beginning of time. I'm just saying no way I take Charbs at 1.5 if I'm not the Walker owner.
I can get on board with this. Where would you take him if you are not a Walker owner compared to being a Walker owner?
I'm pretty sure I wouldn't get him if I'm not the Walker owner. However, in a start 1QB league I would be comfortable taking him in the 2nd round if there is no one else I like.
That’s putting too much on situation which can change quick. Beside the top 2 which rookie RB landed in a much better situation?
I don't necessarily think 2 RBs landed in a good situation. I'm just saying I don't think Charbs is worth a 1st round pick unless I'm the Walker owner. I'd much rather throw a dart at someone like Richardson, Stroud, or Young in a start 1QB league. I might also consider Kincaid over him in a TE premium league. Not being a Walker owner, the players I would take over him in my leagues would be: Bigan, JSN, Gibbs, Addison, Young, Richardson, Stroud, Kincaid, Mayer, Flowers, Mims, Johnston, Miller and perhaps another RB or two depending on landing spot today.
