Top 50 Sandwiches - Ranked by Scoresman (2 Viewers)

[Zow]

#1 - Crabcake sandwich from Faidley's Crabcakes in Baltimore

"Mrs. McNulty didn't raise no fools. Four Faidley’s crab cakes in the bag, 24 Dutch beers in the box."

 

[northern exposure]

Maybe I need to start up an artisanal lettuce company

You also think all lettuces taste the same??

Basically , or at least all of the green ones

Dude, you have no taste buds.

Of course he doesn't. Didn't you see his cheese rankings?

 

[UncleZen]

Taking into account the environment, nothing better than a grilled cheese on Shakedown Street. Ask @shuke and I think he can confirm.

 

[the moops]

Taking into account the environment, nothing better than a grilled cheese on Shakedown Street. Ask @shuke and I think he can confirm.

A bean burrito may be better though.

 

[Dan Lambskin]

I chastised a coworker for putting ketchup on a hotdog at a baseball game today

 

[Eephus]

I chastised a coworker for putting ketchup on a hotdog at a baseball game today

If your coworker needs a clever retort, I'm sure some folks on here can oblige.

 

[Mrs. Rannous]

I chastised a coworker for putting ketchup on a hotdog at a baseball game today

Ketchup and sweet relish belong on hot dogs.

 

[shuke]

Is this now the ***OFFICIAL*** sandwich thread? Would love to see what people are making at home.

If you like sandwiches, follow me on twitter.
My favorite to do at home.
Only made these once, were so damn good, need to again.
Was just playing around and did these. Suck it, @New Binky the Doormat
It's a sandwich, and perfect after midnight. Someone's favorite cheese @Dan Lambskin !

 

[ChiefD]

I chastised a coworker for putting ketchup on a hotdog at a baseball game today

I put ketchup, mustard, onions…..whatever on a hot dog.

You elitists with your stinking stupid hot dogs. It’s a tube of the dregs of whatever meat they scoop up off the factory floor.

 

[DA RAIDERS]

I chastised a coworker for putting ketchup on a hotdog at a baseball game today

I put ketchup, mustard, onions…..whatever on a hot dog.

You elitists with your stinking stupid hot dogs. It’s a tube of the dregs of whatever meat they scoop up off the factory floor.

Mmmm…dregs

I will order anything that comes with “pork debris”

 

[Tau837]

Is this now the ***OFFICIAL*** sandwich thread? Would love to see what people are making at home.

If you like sandwiches, follow me on twitter.
My favorite to do at home.
Only made these once, were so damn good, need to again.
Was just playing around and did these. Suck it, @New Binky the Doormat
It's a sandwich, and perfect after midnight. Someone's favorite cheese @Dan Lambskin !

LOL at "follow me for gourmet recipes"

Well done.

 

[Eephus]

Speaking of dregs, anybody else like head cheese sandwiches

 

[Mrs. Rannous]

Is this now the ***OFFICIAL*** sandwich thread? Would love to see what people are making at home.

If you like sandwiches, follow me on twitter.
My favorite to do at home.
Only made these once, were so damn good, need to again.
Was just playing around and did these. Suck it, @New Binky the Doormat
It's a sandwich, and perfect after midnight. Someone's favorite cheese @Dan Lambskin !

Are those pickled jalapenos on that first sandwich? I love those things.

 

[Osaurus]

Love the glizzy chat

 

[The Z Machine]

Venezuelan arepa >>>>>> Colombian arepa

 

[Leroy Hoard]

I chastised a coworker for putting ketchup on a hotdog at a baseball game today

I put ketchup, mustard, onions…..whatever on a hot dog.

You elitists with your stinking stupid hot dogs. It’s a tube of the dregs of whatever meat they scoop up off the factory floor.

My basic rule of thumb with meat is the higher the quality, the less it needs to be cooked/things added to it. So count me in for a well done dreg dog with the works.

 

[Beef Ravioli Part 2]

I chastised a coworker for putting ketchup on a hotdog at a baseball game today

One of the few things I think you and I would agree on.

#Miracle Whip
#Go Buckeyes
#No ketchup on Hot Dogs

 

[shuke]

Is this now the ***OFFICIAL*** sandwich thread? Would love to see what people are making at home.

If you like sandwiches, follow me on twitter.
My favorite to do at home.
Only made these once, were so damn good, need to again.
Was just playing around and did these. Suck it, @New Binky the Doormat
It's a sandwich, and perfect after midnight. Someone's favorite cheese @Dan Lambskin !

Are those pickled jalapenos on that first sandwich? I love those things.

No just pickled hot peppers (not jalapeños).

 

[heckmanm]

Finally getting ripe tomatoes, so my dinner last night was

• Duke's mayo and fresh tomato
• Duke's mayo, homemade pesto and fresh tomato

Both open-faced with salt and cracked pepper on toasted whole grain bread (Daves Killer Bread FTW)

 

[Mister CIA]

Venezuelan arepa >>>>>> Colombian arepa

Hmmm. Is a cachapa considered a sandwich? If it is, we'll need a redo of this thread.

 

[AAABatteries]

Is this now the ***OFFICIAL*** sandwich thread? Would love to see what people are making at home.

If you like sandwiches, follow me on twitter.
My favorite to do at home.
Only made these once, were so damn good, need to again.
Was just playing around and did these. Suck it, @New Binky the Doormat
It's a sandwich, and perfect after midnight. Someone's favorite cheese @Dan Lambskin !

Are those pickled jalapenos on that first sandwich? I love those things.

I go through about a jar of these a week

Sliced Tamed™ Jalapeño Peppers

Our Sliced Tamed™ Jalapeños—a hybrid of a jalapeño and a bell pepper— provide all the flavor and texture of a regular jalapeño but with less heat. Exclusive to Mezzetta, our Sliced Tamed™ Jalapeños are the perfect thing when you want the taste of jalapeño without knock-your-socks-off spiciness...

www.mezzetta.com

 

[Scoresman]

I've never been a huge fan of open faced sandwiches. It feels wrong holding a sandwich like a slice of pizza to eat it and then have half the ingredients fall off anyway, and it feels even more wrong to use a fork and knife if it's super messy/wet.

The point of a sandwich to me is to put something delicious into bread so you can fairly easily eat it with your hands.

 

[heckmanm]

I've never been a huge fan of open faced sandwiches. It feels wrong holding a sandwich like a slice of pizza to eat it and then have half the ingredients fall off anyway, and it feels even more wrong to use a fork and knife if it's super messy/wet.

The point of a sandwich to me is to put something delicious into bread so you can fairly easily eat it with your hands.

Agree generally but always have tomatoes on toast open-faced.

 

[Dickies]

Speaking of dregs, anybody else like head cheese sandwiches

I posted earlier in the thread that the classic banh mi with head cheese, ham and pate is my favorite sandwich. It’s so good.

 

[massraider]

I've never been a huge fan of open faced sandwiches. It feels wrong holding a sandwich like a slice of pizza to eat it and then have half the ingredients fall off anyway, and it feels even more wrong to use a fork and knife if it's super messy/wet.

The point of a sandwich to me is to put something delicious into bread so you can fairly easily eat it with your hands.

An open faced sandwich is a sandwich the same way a motorcycle is a two-wheeled car.

 

[Mister CIA]

Yep.

x.com

x.com

 

[General Malaise]

I chastised a coworker for putting ketchup on a hotdog at a baseball game today

I put ketchup, mustard, onions…..whatever on a hot dog.

You elitists with your stinking stupid hot dogs. It’s a tube of the dregs of whatever meat they scoop up off the factory floor.

Mmmm…dregs

I will order anything that comes with “pork debris”

"Debris Po'Boy" would have been in my top 5. Great minds.....

 

[Instinctive]

I'm gonna do another tomato sandwich today, but use avocado instead of mayo.

 

[Leroy Hoard]

I'm gonna do another tomato sandwich today, but use avocado instead of mayo.

I had an avocado/tomato/turkey sandwich that was great.

 

[CGRdrJoe]

lightly toasted baguette topped with cream cheese, smoked salmon, lemon and capers

 

[bryhamm]

hamburger not a sandwich....it hangs out with hot dogs, gyros, patty melts....

what's your definition of a sandwich then?

 

[AAABatteries]

Had a pork Banh Mi for lunch today. It was in our office food court so didn't expect much and they delivered. It was fine though.

 

[Hastur]

Had a pork Banh Mi for lunch today. It was in our office food court so didn't expect much and they delivered. It was fine though.

Don't you dare settle for fine

 

[FiredMartz]

hamburger not a sandwich....it hangs out with hot dogs, gyros, patty melts....

what's your definition of a sandwich then?

anything with sandwich in the name

 

[Dickies]

hamburger not a sandwich....it hangs out with hot dogs, gyros, patty melts....

what's your definition of a sandwich then?

anything with sandwich in the name

I enjoy a good hamburger sandwich

 

[Galileo]

#1 - Italian Sub/Grinder​

Country of origin: USA

Italian cold cuts, cheese, shredded lettuce, tomatoes, red onion, peppers, vinaigrette on a hoagie/sub

We finally come to the sandwich that is as close to a religious experience as I will ever have. Everything that is good about sandwiches is included here. That said, the ratio of the ingredients is critical. Maybe more critical than any other sandwich. If any one ingredient is too heavy handed, it will throw it off. More often than not, if one of these is off it tends to be because of too much lettuce, not enough vinaigrette, or just too much of everything making it near impossible to enjoy properly. New Yorkers have it pretty good because finding a perfect one of these anywhere else is difficult. My meats of choice are mortadella, capicola, and genoa salami. Provolone, red onion and peppers, red wine vinegar and olive oil.

If you want to kick this up another notch add a smear of tapenade onto the bread and use a crusty Italian roll or baguette as the bread of choice.

ETA...here is my go to place for this type of sandwich https://alescis.com/menu/ There are a few here that would be right up your alley, but the Mufaletta and The Vito are my jam (notice the tapenade!)

 

[Eephus]

I enjoy a good hamburger sandwich

It's a grind away from the steak sandwich that finished #3

 

[bryhamm]

hamburger not a sandwich....it hangs out with hot dogs, gyros, patty melts....

what's your definition of a sandwich then?

anything with sandwich in the name

cool, so a cheesesteak is not a sandwich. got it.

 

[Scoresman]

hamburger not a sandwich....it hangs out with hot dogs, gyros, patty melts....

what's your definition of a sandwich then?

anything with sandwich in the name

cool, so a cheesesteak is not a sandwich. got it.

Neither is a Reuben, Panini, or a Jambon Beurre I guess.

You cant define a sandwich in simple terms. There's always going to be exceptions and inclusions that need to be noted, etc.

 

[DA RAIDERS]

I enjoy a good hamburger sandwich

It's a grind away from the steak sandwich that finished #3

And whatever that chopped cheese thing is..

 

[Dan Lambskin]

I enjoy a good hamburger sandwich

It's a grind away from the steak sandwich that finished #3

And whatever that chopped cheese thing is..

It’s a cheeseburger, but then chopped it up and put it in a sub bun

 

[the moops]

I must say that I don't really ever miss eating meat but the few times over the years when I have craved something, it was an Italian sub with everything (add hot peppers) from a place called Anthony's in the town I grew up in. Damn that thing was good.

 

[northern exposure]

Had a pork Banh Mi for lunch today. It was in our office food court so didn't expect much and they delivered. It was fine though.

I had a bbqed pork Banh Mi on Tuesday. It is from a new place I discovered. I ordered two of them, one for me and another for my youngest son. As I sat waiting for my takeout order, I noticed I was the only Caucasian person in the crowded restaurant. This is usually a very good indication of the quality of the food. The sandwiches didn't disappoint.

 

[the moops]

Had a pork Banh Mi for lunch today. It was in our office food court so didn't expect much and they delivered. It was fine though.

I had a bbqed pork Banh Mi on Tuesday. It is from a new place I discovered. I ordered two of them, one for me and another for my youngest son. As I sat waiting for my takeout order, I noticed I was the only Caucasian person in the crowded restaurant. This is usually a very good indication of the quality of the food. The sandwiches didn't disappoint.

Definitely want the place to be filled with people of the race/nationality/culture/whatever

 

[gianmarco]

I chastised a coworker for putting ketchup on a hotdog at a baseball game today

I put ketchup, mustard, onions…..whatever on a hot dog.

You elitists with your stinking stupid hot dogs. It’s a tube of the dregs of whatever meat they scoop up off the factory floor.

Mmmm…dregs

I will order anything that comes with “pork debris”

My link

 

[DA RAIDERS]

I enjoy a good hamburger sandwich

It's a grind away from the steak sandwich that finished #3

And whatever that chopped cheese thing is..

It’s a cheeseburger, but then chopped it up and put it in a sub bun

So a cheeseburger hoagie/grinder/sub/sandwich. it’s probably American cheese, right?

We really need to petition to have this changed the :Americancheese: emoji @FBG Moderator

 

[DA RAIDERS]

I chastised a coworker for putting ketchup on a hotdog at a baseball game today

I put ketchup, mustard, onions…..whatever on a hot dog.

You elitists with your stinking stupid hot dogs. It’s a tube of the dregs of whatever meat they scoop up off the factory floor.

Mmmm…dregs

I will order anything that comes with “pork debris”

My link

Peppa pig was/is awesome.

 

[Mrs. Rannous]

I chastised a coworker for putting ketchup on a hotdog at a baseball game today

I put ketchup, mustard, onions…..whatever on a hot dog.

You elitists with your stinking stupid hot dogs. It’s a tube of the dregs of whatever meat they scoop up off the factory floor.

Mmmm…dregs

I will order anything that comes with “pork debris”

My link

Peppa pig was/is awesome.

Or gross.

 

[DA RAIDERS]

I chastised a coworker for putting ketchup on a hotdog at a baseball game today

I put ketchup, mustard, onions…..whatever on a hot dog.

You elitists with your stinking stupid hot dogs. It’s a tube of the dregs of whatever meat they scoop up off the factory floor.

Mmmm…dregs

I will order anything that comes with “pork debris”

My link

Peppa pig was/is awesome.

Or gross.

She’s a kids cartoon. My daughter loved her

 

[Mrs. Rannous]

I chastised a coworker for putting ketchup on a hotdog at a baseball game today

I put ketchup, mustard, onions…..whatever on a hot dog.

You elitists with your stinking stupid hot dogs. It’s a tube of the dregs of whatever meat they scoop up off the factory floor.

Mmmm…dregs

I will order anything that comes with “pork debris”

My link

Peppa pig was/is awesome.

Or gross.

She’s a kids cartoon. My daughter loved her

I know who Peppa Pig is. I don't live in a cave.