prob true but then shouldn't be a big deal if no longer allowed
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums
This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
Tush Push - Do the rules apply for this play or not? Doesn't seem like it (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter trader jake
- Start date
The play has been legal in the NFL since 2005 when the league removed the language in the rule book that prohibited pushing offensive players.
(copied from an article)
Alex P Keaton
Footballguy
Yup. Which has been covered repeatedly in this thread.
Biabreakable
Footballguy
Yeah I regret ever coming into the thread.
I just wondered why it kept being bumped is all.
Excuuuse me for not being up to speed on this terrible conversation.
unckeyherb
Footballguy
Not a big deal either way IMO. But seeing as how this is on page 14 I guess it’s a big deal for some.
pinkstapler
Footballguy
Maybe people subconsciously don't like it cause the phrase tush push isn't masculine enough. Maybe if it was called something like the a$$ blast they'd get on board. "Eagles punch it through the end zone with another a$$ blast for the win!"
Amused to Death
Footballguy
I don't care what they call it, as long as the ref signals first down or TD when bodies are getting up off the turf.
And the fact they're now attaching a name to it with a Phillly connotation tells you its viewed as an Eagles play - one they're very successful at, so sure let's ban it.
And the fact they're now attaching a name to it with a Phillly connotation tells you its viewed as an Eagles play - one they're very successful at, so sure let's ban it.
Terpman22
Footballguy
Funny this play has been legal since 2005 but just these past 2 years are the complaints about it. I wonder what happened in the last 2 years.
This thread was started on the day of a certain team's NFC Title Game this past year.....
Amused to Death
Footballguy
Yup, players have been pushing the ball carrier for 19 seasons now - over the line to gain, over the goal line....but something about the last 2 years are just unacceptable.
If you can't stop it, ban it. And trust me, if they could stop the Eagles, they wouldn't be worried about banning it.
Insein
Footballguy
brettdj
Footballguy
More than likely this is much more injury prone than just pushing someone.
Football Jones
Footballguy
I think you’re talking to the wrong guy. The Fanny Pack has been successful for the Eagles, but it’s not like a difference-maker (not anywhere close).
There was a reason it was illegal for so long. You can make cases both ways, but all the attention it’s getting is now subtracting from the game. It’s time to put it on the shelf so it’s not a thing. Tomorrow won’t be soon enough. It’s the worst “hot” NFL topic I can ever remember, lol.
It’ll get the ax next season & we can go back to actual NFL news. Rules get changed all the time…just have to adapt & overcome. I didn’t like it as a Cowboys fan when the NFL started FA in the early 90s. We were the deepest team in the league by far, but it was best for the league.
My advice is to enjoy the Fanny Pack this year as long as it keeps working, then try to come up with something else. The NFL is an ever-changing organism.
Amused to Death
Footballguy
I agree with everything here. The reason they now allow pushing the ball carrier is because the refs couldn't call it consistently. In a scrum, it was too difficult to determine if players were pushing the runner, so they allowed pushing. But the move now seems to be to ban the pushing of the QB but allow it elsewhere on the field, and that's where I have a big problem.
Go back to 2004, but don't complain when your* team is flagged for pushing the WR over the goal line.
*not you specifically
Amused to Death
Footballguy
@trader jake can you please post the full quote of the Eagles player who "admits what they're doing is illegal"? TIA
Alex P Keaton
Footballguy
“I was yanking him for sure,” Goedert said. “They say you can’t pull, but I was behind him.”
That’s all I’ve seen
Amused to Death
Footballguy
Me too, which is the equivalent of a O lineman admitting he may have been holding on a play or two that wasn't flagged. But I'm going to give @trader jake the benefit of the doubt that he's not using a misleading thread title.
unckeyherb
Footballguy
Right. That’s not him saying the play is illegal. That’s him admitting to doing something that IS illegal and getting away with it.
I think all the rule needs is some clarification.
Can you "push" the ball carrier in the back?
Or can you "push" the ball carrier in the "tush"?
Or are both legal?
Or is neither legal in the truist sense of how the rule reads?
Is there a lawyer here on the board who could look into this to see what the rule implies?
Or is implication a mute point?
Or is implication even a word?
I hope this brings some clarity to this thread.
I'm just glad Travis Kelce and his new girlfriend knocked this item from the news cycle for even a little bit.
Or did it?
Has this thread "jumped the shark" yet?
Anyway I am rambling,like this thread.
Peace
Out
Can you "push" the ball carrier in the back?
Or can you "push" the ball carrier in the "tush"?
Or are both legal?
Or is neither legal in the truist sense of how the rule reads?
Is there a lawyer here on the board who could look into this to see what the rule implies?
Or is implication a mute point?
Or is implication even a word?
I hope this brings some clarity to this thread.
I'm just glad Travis Kelce and his new girlfriend knocked this item from the news cycle for even a little bit.
Or did it?
Has this thread "jumped the shark" yet?
Anyway I am rambling,like this thread.
Peace
Out
for all I care the defense could be allowed to form a human pyramid to block a FG.Amused to Death
Footballguy
Recently, five-time All-Pro and former Houston Texans standout J.J. Watt defended the play, surmising that even without the extra push, the Eagles would be "just as successful" due to their dominant offensive line. Meanwhile, Kansas City Chiefs quarterback Patrick Mahomes echoed Watt, praising how the unit has "mastered" the play.
"It's an advantage for them but you see other teams try to do it and they can't do it as well as they do," Mahomes said, via the Chiefs. "It speaks to their offensive line, it speaks to their quarterback."
"It's an advantage for them but you see other teams try to do it and they can't do it as well as they do," Mahomes said, via the Chiefs. "It speaks to their offensive line, it speaks to their quarterback."
Pffft. What do those guys know?
trader jake
Footballguy
4th and a long 1 in overtime.
No problem, run the play.
No problem, run the play.
Chaka
Footballguy
Yup. No problem. Not sure why it's an issue with you.4th and a long 1 in overtime.
No problem, run the play.
Didn't you at least appreciate the refs calling an offensive offsides penalty on the play earlier in the game? When was the last time that penalty was called?
watch it again, the pushers didn't even get their hands on Hurts until he was over the line to gain. Without the pushes Eagles would still be super successful on sneaks4th and a long 1 in overtime.
No problem, run the play.
Amused to Death
Footballguy
Are going to leave an incorrect thread title?4th and a long 1 in overtime.
No problem, run the play.
Snotbubbles
Footballguy
Patriots just tried the TP. Didn't get the yard. LOL!
was just coming here to post the same. Throw out the Eagles numbers and it hasn't been shown to be all that much better then the traditional QB sneak
Amused to Death
Footballguy
It so funny watching other teams try to run it. But its so easy, its unfair!!!!1!2!
Chaka
Footballguy
Worked for Aidan O'Connell & the Raiders.
I mean that specific play. Everything else has been a #### show.
Chaka
Footballguy
Wat???
N Zone
Footballguy
A thought that just popped into my head that I had to write down. Haha.
They do not allow a player to jump on another player in any way to try and block a field goal so i don't know why this push from multiple players forward is allowed. Just seems like an odd play and and unfair advantage for the offense.
Chaka
Footballguy
They're entirely different plays. Completely unrelated.
Chaka
Footballguy
They have tried.
Chaka
Footballguy
Yes. Most teams are trying it to varying degrees of success. Raiders scored on one today.
Alex P Keaton
Footballguy
Totally agree with this. It usually is irrelevant whether any Eagles’ OL push.watch it again, the pushers didn't even get their hands on Hurts until he was over the line to gain. Without the pushes Eagles would still be super successful on sneaks4th and a long 1 in overtime.
No problem, run the play.
probably
Amused to Death
Footballguy
Raiders just tried and failed. Just from what I've seen today, the rest of the league is 1 for 4 running this "unstoppable" play.
Chaka
Footballguy
Raiders just stuffed Herbert on it!
Amused to Death
Footballguy
And the Chargers just attempted it with Herbert - and failed miserably. "UNSTOPPABLE!!!1!"
Amused to Death
Footballguy
UNSTOPPABLE! BAN IT!!!
FreeBaGeL
Footballguy
So it's hard to find actual metrics on conversion rate this year, but if we go by the metric that Redzone generally shows every short yardage play then the rest of the league appears to be converting right around 50-60% on tush pushes this year that we've been able to see on TV, which is below the league average on traditional short yardage plays. That gives some good insight on solving the great mystery of why every team isn't using it every time when it's allegedly an automatic 1st down.
That's not even accounting for the notion that at least two of the conversions on it (Pats a couple weeks ago and Broncos today) came on plays where the QB had already picked up the 1st down before the "pusher" even got to him, so in reality it was more of a traditional QB sneak.
That's not even accounting for the notion that at least two of the conversions on it (Pats a couple weeks ago and Broncos today) came on plays where the QB had already picked up the 1st down before the "pusher" even got to him, so in reality it was more of a traditional QB sneak.
