David Yudkin
Footballguy
To make it easier, assume that each guy plays out his career on the team he is on currently. You can vote for all of them, none of them, or all points in between.
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums
This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
Which of the following QBs will win another SB? (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter David Yudkin
- Start date
Insein
Footballguy
I think realistically predicting, Manning is the only real shot at another title. Pats are coming down and unless they rebuild fast on defense, it isn't going to happen. Roethlesberger had his run. I can see the Steelers retooling but I think the team and the city are not in love with him any more. Brees had the cinderella story of the decade but the Saints just don't look like a dynasty team.
Chicago Hooligan
Footballguy
I spent the weekend in Pittsburgh. The intensity of the fandom is quite amazing. They will love him the minute he can and does take another snap.I think Brees has the best chance to win again though with his super accuracy. If Gregg Williams stays there the defense will get better. They are excellent at drafting WRs (if they need replacements) and have plenty of good young-ish players.
Godsbrother
Footballguy
Roethlisberger received a very warm reception all during training camp. He still has plenty of detractors but I think if he keeps his nose (and other body parts) clean then he could very well retire a Steeler.FallenHero32
Footballguy
Brees and Manning. Manning in the next year or 2, Brees within the next 4-5.
PinkydaPimp
Footballguy
Lots of love for Manning. Out of all of them, he is the one that i don't trust in the postseason. he is the one who plays worse in the post season then in the regular season. To be honest, he wouldn't have won the first, if his defense hadn't played great in the postseason that year. To be clear, im not saying he has played awful in every post season game. But for the most part, his play falls off in the post season while the other qbs play seems to get better.
Divisional alignments are a conspiracy against Boston sports teams...
timschochet
Footballguy
isn't there a QB missing from this poll? Hint- his name is Eli. I'm not a Giants fan, but this guy is getting better and better.
Andy Herron
Footballguy
Manning is the only one I would feel comfortable in seriously betting on.
Andy Herron
Footballguy
It took a miracle in addition to a mirage for him to win the first one.He's missing from this poll for a reason.
SYMPHONY X
Footballguy
With a healthy Bob Sanders on the other side of the ball, Manning will win his 2nd THIS YEAR.
As long as the Steelers continue to draft well, and retool the O-line at some point, Big Ben will be in contention for one each and every year.
With no Moss next year, and the defense already somewhat decimated by injuries this year, I don't like Brady's chances for another one. If anyone's run is over, it is him.
Brees..you gotta like his chances for another one too, but not this year. No one is beating the Pack to the superbowl in 2010.
Manning versus Rodgers will be your 2010 SB matchup (just throwing that in there)..should be a doozy!
As long as the Steelers continue to draft well, and retool the O-line at some point, Big Ben will be in contention for one each and every year.
With no Moss next year, and the defense already somewhat decimated by injuries this year, I don't like Brady's chances for another one. If anyone's run is over, it is him.
Brees..you gotta like his chances for another one too, but not this year. No one is beating the Pack to the superbowl in 2010.
Manning versus Rodgers will be your 2010 SB matchup (just throwing that in there)..should be a doozy!
Dr. No
Footballguy
If not for his #32 run D coming out of NOWHERE to dominate the post-season and then getting the luxury of playing Rex Grossman in the super bowl - he'd have zero.manning really feels like the 90's Braves - tons of reg. season wins, tons of titles, tons of post-seasons.. 1 title.
KentGraham10
Footballguy
Forgot Eli Manning, and he gets my vote, but if I had to vote for someone in this poll it would be Big Ben.
Even divisional alignments can't keep us down when we're the best team in the world. When we're the third best team in the world, however...
jurb26
Footballguy
I'm surprised so few like Big Ben in a poll like this. He is far and away the youngest of the group. If he stays in Pitt he should have better than average odds simply because the owner and team management is so strong. I'd have to think he has the best chance of the group over the rest of their careers, mainly because his career is likely to be much longer.
I voted Ben and Manning. Ben for the reasons jurb already laid out, and Manning because the Colts are an unstoppable winning machine at this point. 7 straight 12-win seasons? More preseason losses than regular season losses over that span? Are you freaking kidding me?
timschochet
Footballguy
MAYBE his career will be longer. Have you watched the Steeler's offensive line during the Big Ben era, especially the last two years (including the SB year)? Roethlisberger gets pounded on a regular basis. Part of that is because he hangs onto the ball for a long time (which also makes him so effective.) I'm not convinced his body can keep surviving all the brutal hits he takes every year.
