I'm going to go with Eric Moulds and Reggie Brown.
Stranger things have happened, but I still don't get why people keep throwing Moulds name out there. The Eagles broke the mold by bringing in TO, sure. But remember, TO was a) one of the best receivers in the league [Moulds is not], and more importantly b) TO was a WCO-schooled receiver. Moulds isn't a WCO guy, I don't see how Reid would value his presence on the team.
I guess I just have a really hard time envisioning the Eagles standing pat with what they've got given their propensity to pass the ball. I don't see where Gaffney is a significant contributor. I think Brown can develop into a solid WR but I don't think it'll happen just yet. I think a guy like Moulds would be a solid pickup for Philly, although they don't have a habit of bringing guys his age in.
Eagles Leading WR
2000 -- Eagles (11-5) -- Charles Johnson -- 56 recs/642 yards/7 TDs
2001 -- Eagles (11-5) -- James Thrash -- 63 recs/833 yards/8 TDs
2002 -- Eagles (12-4) -- Todd Pinkston -- 60 recs/798 yards/7 TDs
2003 -- Eagles (12-4) -- Todd Pinkston -- 36 recs/575 yards/2 TDs
And wasn't the outrage reaction in Philly concerning the inability to advance to the Super Bowl blamed on a lack of playmakers for McNabb to throw to?
There was an outrage by the FANS, not the team management. There was also an outrage when we a) drafted McNabb over Ricky Williams, b) let Jeremiah Trotter sign with the Skins, c) let Shawn Barber sign with the Chiefs, d) let Troy Vincent sign with the Bills, e) let Bobby Taylor sign with Seattle, f) let Hugh Douglas leave for Jacksonville, g) drafted three DBs on the first day [sheppard, Brown, Lewis] when we already had three Pro Bowl defensive backs, h) hired an unproven coach named Andy Reid who was never even a coordinator...etc...etc...The general consensus view of Philly fans has proven to be almost perfectly negatively correlated to what the team ultimately SHOULD do.
And, in 2004 when the Eagles advanced to the Super Bowl, they did so WITHOUT TO [who was injured for the entirety of the playoffs].
Personally, I would love a more proven WR1, but I'm also not going to panic if we go to war with this corps of receivers. Again, few teams if any would pass up five consecutive seasons of 11, 11, 12, 12 and 13 wins without any WR "playmakers" but that's the system Reid has in place.