Shutout said:
Arodin said:
Ketamine Dreams said:
Thoughts on Moncrief and Dorsett going forward?
Competing for the #2 slot once AJ retires. Both could have good fantasy value in this offense.
I see Moncrief as the more interesting player that brings something different and Dorsett as more the guy without a true role (unless of course Hilton is injured and then it becomes obvious his value can rise quicker than anyone else's).
I still don't understand the Colts taking Dorsett. They had other needs and this was a bit of a luxury. It can definitely benefit them if they need to call in the hedged bet but, as it stands with a healthy team, Moncrief if the less-inspiring but more steady guy in this mix while Dorsett is the more boom-or-bust guy with much higher possible return.
It was a bit of luxury pick but they had a lot of questions when they drafted him:
- Will Hilton re-sign at a reasonable price?
- Does AJ have anything left?
- Will Moncrief keep developing?
- Should they re-sign Fleener and Allen?
Worst case for the Colts is Hilton, Fleener, and Allen all leave, AJ looks washed up, and Moncrief plateaus. Without Dorsett they are suddenly looking weak at receiver.
I don't really see it that way, but just my opinion.
Hilton could have been tagged and I really never saw anything from the COlts that indicated they aren't willing to work in good faith with their players.
Aj is far from washed up. People who really think that just haven't paid attention to the hell he has lived through in terms of QB and offensive philosophy the past few years.
I never saw anything from Moncrief last year that made me think he was anywhere close to peaked. He always looked promising to me. Again, just my opinion.
I guess when you figure out Luck, Hilton, etc, where Carter fits in if he does, then you have the decisions to make with the TEs. I don't know the answer to that one but it is a nice problem for the COlts to have so, overall,
I don't think by any means they made that pick because they were worried about scarcity of available play-makers. I think they just got caught up in the rut of a particular way of thinking at the time. Something told them to go that way over LB, Lineman, other areas they really NEEDED. But if it works, it works. Although now, it looks like more of a luxury than ever.