Still no word on if I'm totaled or not, but from everything I've read and posted on other Tesla message boards...shes a goner. I'm gonna stick with the approach of having to find something new for the time being.
For your sake, the X and the S are virtually the same when it comes to battery and hardware. This is a helpful website -
Timelines for Vehicles and Variants
This weekend I was dead set on a 2016 or 17 X. Either the 75D or 90D. I'd like the room for my kids. Unfortunately this morning I woke up thinking that was dumb. Why spend an extra $15-20k for something with 40k miles and a 4 year old battery and outdated hardware. I know any hardware will become outdated as time goes by, but its taking a big step back, when I could take a step forward. Charging speeds at a SC are big hiccup right now. From what I've read to get back on the road during a trip the 2016 X 75D would take an hour...where a 3 would take about 15 minutes to add the same amount of mileage.
My wife wants the used X. She gets frustrated putting all three kids in the 3 to run around town. They fit just fine, but they argue. They would argue in a limo...they're 9,7 and 4.
I worry 2 years from now when her 2012 Honda Van dies what will we do? She thinks I can get a 3 then and she'll take the X. I think battery degradation and old hardware will make the resale value plummet for the X. I'm not sure being an all electric family in Mississippi is a good option.
I don't know...I need more coffee! I love driving that 3. If I can get a brand new one with virtually nothing out of pocket thats probably the way I'd go.