“[P]olice did not follow the obvious leads that would have quickly identified the suspect as well as witnesses, one of whom videotaped part of the sexual encounter.” Angullo and the TPD did not contact the bar where the alleged victim, Winston, and other football players who witnessed the attack had been earlier in the night to obtain surveillance video of their time there. Angullo also made no effort to find the “football player named Chris” that the accuser had identified as one of the men she left the bar with. After failing on early attempts, Angullo stopped trying to track down the taxi driver who had taken the woman and the football players home from the bar.
— Angullo, the lead investigator, waited two months to file his first police report of the incident, and he “prematurely suspended his inquiry without informing the accuser.” This prohibited Angullo and the TPD from obtaining valuable evidence in the case, including a video that existed on the phone of one of the players who allegedly witnessed the sexual encounter.
— After the woman identified Winston as her attacker on January 10, 2013, the TPD waited more than two weeks to contact Winston, and then only did so by phone. Winston declined to talk. Angullo also decided against subjecting Winston to a DNA test. He then suspended the investigation. Winston would not submit to a DNA test until the State Attorney’s Office took up the case nearly a year later.
— Police did not subpoena phone records from Winston or either two witnesses “even though they investigated all electronic communications to and from the accuser around the time of the sexual encounter.”
The Times investigation also found that the university made mistakes — possibly in violation of federal law — in how it handled the case:
— Though the FSU athletic department “had known early on that Mr. Winston had been accused of a serious crime,” the school did not seem to launch its own inquiry into the case until after the football season was completed. Federal law requires athletic department officials who have knowledge of sexual crimes to notify university administrators. Florida State did not comment to the Times about whether it had launched its own investigation into the case before the allegations became public.