The defending of Irving here is bizarre. Even as a basketball player, he is highly overrated. ....
Defending what exactly?
What I'm seeing here is many people ( not all but many) are conflating their negative feelings/emotions regarding Kyrie Irving (mostly from his off court behaviors/actions/statements/choices) and are mixing that into his actual production value/projectible value/established skill set on the court.
Davis Bertans, Mavericks Actual salary: $16.0 million
Tobias Harris, 76ers Actual salary: $37.6 million
Russell Westbrook, Lakers $47.1 million
Your "value" in the NBA is dependent on what you can currently produce to help your team win basketball games against your contract length and it's AAV (Annual Average Value)
Bertans is a bad contract. He's a one dimensional long range gunner who has been grossly overpaid. However if he was on a 2 year, 8 million dollar contract, with the 2nd year as a team option, then he suddenly becomes a possible bargain. A matchup dependent reliable three point specialist you can use in specific spots during game flow. For 16 million, that's obscene. For the vets minimum or something like 4 million, on a short term deal, that's not so bad at all.
Tobias Harris can do enough to help a team win basketball games. He is also grossly overpaid to league market values. He's more than one dimensional, but if he was paid 16 million a year and expiring instead of close to 38 million a year, the perspective on him totally changes.
If RWB was at the point of his career where he was a journeyman free agent, looking to ring chase, for the grand sum of 1.7 million in cash from any contender that could use 10 good minutes a night of limited offense from someone with lots of playoff experience and game experience, he starts to appear entirely different.
Does Irving still have the talent level to help some team, particularly some contender? Yes. He can easily be a 20 minutes a guy who consistently creates a threat to score 20 points from the bench. Literally by himself. The four other guys could just play defense and become spot up shooters. Not some flash in the pan, but an established consistent All Star in terms of pure offensive pedigree and proven production. Will that value be mitigated by possible contract length and AAV? Of course.
But for some here to assess that Irving's career is plainly over without any choice of his own, given how rare his skill set actually becomes in the modern NBA, is not reality. You can call him "overrated", but like Bertans, RWB and Tobias Harris, there is a price point/contract length where the situation turns from toxic/troublesome/burdensome to pure bargain.
I'm separating Irving the person and his actions off the court AWAY from Irving the basketball player.
What's "bizarre" is that I'm basically the only person right now currently in this thread saying Irving, strictly assessing his worth as an actual functional basketball player, should be judged on what Irving has shown as an actual functional basketball player ON THE COURT.
Michael Vick played 6 seasons before he was banished, suspended, imprisoned and out of football for two whole years before he played another 7 seasons in the NFL. Three of those as a full time starter. And for three different franchises. I said it before and I'll say it again, Vick had a longer career AFTER his big scandal than before it. And much of that was because QB1 is a coveted and hard to fill position in the NFL. Just like finding an established All Star level offensive engine is a coveted and hard to fill position in the modern NBA.
I don't see a single person here talking about the specific decline in Irving's skill set or the sudden influx of pure shot creators across the league that makes Irving so expendable, as some here are pushing.
From a pure player standpoint, for practical functional basketball, what specifically is wrong with Irving that he can't contribute to a modern NBA team winning on the court? That's not a rhetorical, I'm asking you and but also everyone else here who keeps talking about Irving's off the court problems as a means to shade down on his actual NBA skill set.