Moonlight
Footballguy
You want to make more good moves than bad ones. They have certainly done that.Most of the moves they have made have been great but I'm still so bitter about the Gibbs pick. I could accept taking an RB like Bijan, but a player like Gibbs at pick 12, that is outrageous. They knew a player like Gibbs is not their identity and RB has no current value in todays NFL, WTF were they thinking. Keeping Swift and drafting Carter would have put them in serious super bowl consideration this year, now I think this pushes them back one year.They’ve got Gibbs for five years. They want him peaking in late December & January. In September he’s a luxury item.
It’s still early on Gibbs and there are 13 more games to go. And if they keep running Montgomery 32 times a game they’ll need Gibbs.
Regarding Carter to me this needs to be a long term evaluation. His character and fit were the questions and that is going to take time to determine if they were right to pass on him. Besides their draft looks a lot different if Carter was the pick at 6.
The Swift trade also needs to be evaluated longer term. Questions about his ability to be available and fit were there.
How Swift and Carter go longer term will serve as a good comparison of the Eagles and Lions organizations. Right now in the short term the advantage goes to the Eagles.
Last edited: