ok...
@shuke... a few stories- but these kind of things feel like they happen a lot, at maybe smaller scales.
Exhibit A:
Our first time back into a broadway theater since the pandemic for Dear Evan Hansen... like in March. I'm with 10yo floppinha in good seats next to three young/mid-age women there together. all three spend the entire first act looking at their phones every few minutes- including in the middle of the big songs (the songs floppinha and I have been excited to see and hear).
At intermission, I very politely ask the women to please avoid looking at their phones until after the show is over. 2 of them very sheepishly apologize, but the one sitting next to me starts into me- not my business, her daughter is sick... how would I like it if my daughter was sick (while looking at floppinha). at that point, I say- this shouldn't be a big thing to ask- we're at show and the phone is taking away from the experience. she won't let it go, again, bringing up floppinha. At this point, I'm pissed- it's almost like she's threatening my daughter- so I tell her if she can't do this simple thing, I'll bring an usher over to help her find a new seat or leave... and I hope your daughter feels better.
Part Deux:
My mom's in town, I'm waiting at the bus-stop with her the other night and an equally old (80s) woman walks over so I get up from the bench to let her and her giant cart sit down and have room. but she stands over us instead- I get the impression just looking to talk to another older person. my mom and I are in deep conversation, so that doesn't happen.
the bus comes and my more sprightly mom hops up into the bus. I ask the other woman if I can help her onto the bus with her giant cart.
"I'm 80 years old- do you know that?!"
"No- I never would have guessed, you look a lot younger. (asking again) Can I help with your cart?"
"I CAN DO THIS MYSELF!!!- LEAVE ME ALONE!!!"
my mom tells me the next day about this old woman who spent the entire busride screaming/cursing at a guy in a wheel chair who had the audacity to ask if she and her cart would move to his side to open up room for other customers (instead of his chair and her cart blocking the aisle). every time the guy would try explain himself, the woman would scream more and louder- cursing at him and needing to get the last word. same woman.
Title C.2:
On the subway out to Floppinha's tennis class in far away Queens a couple weeks ago, a tiny young trans woman gets on board screaming at two Karen looking women who had apparently said something hurtful to her. I'm sitting there with Floppinha, internally debating- do I interject in what seems to be a bullying situation, as I always advise her to do? or is this woman crazy and maybe the Karen's are in the right or just innocent bystanders here? Is it better to just keep quiet and ignore her?
I've lived in NYC a long time and have gone through many, many permutations of how to engage or not engage people (mostly the homeless) and situations in public. with the kids with me, it's often about life-safety trumping "the right thing" to do. but I figure even if this woman is nutso, I can take her, so I decide to wait until the young woman has calmed down and offer... "are you ok? do you need any help?". She starts screaming and cursing at me "F You, all you people"..something..soemthing about her being trans and small. I'm sitting next to a young girl- my daughter- but still let her scream and curse at me, and when she takes a breath, I offer "I'm just trying to see if you're ok- nothing more- I've got your back if you need help". She again starts yelling "Do you even know any trans people, wtf do you know"... "I do know a number of trans people, including some kids just starting out- it seems like it can be a hard road, which is why I wanted to see if you were ok and to let you know you're not alone here and that we're (looking at my daughter- primarily so the woman sees there's a young girl here too) her for you if you need us". She seems placated for a hot second, but then keeps screaming and cursing at me... so I go into ignore/ready to react physically if needed mode.
my daughter was really upset by this particular encounter. had a bad dream about me talking to somebody who followed us into a store and shot/killed me (recent US news also playing into this fear)... and asked my wife to talk to me about not talking to strangers any more. again- I play these scenarios out carefully in regards to life-safety before saying or doing anything... but I wanted Floppinha to know that I had her back 100% on this, so of course told her I would stop.