Enraged Nerfball
Footballguy
This is the data I have been trying to get you to comment on. Fostergames carries yds ypc tdActual 8 216 1109 5.1 12Extrap. 11 297 1523 5.1 16Brown 11 303 1841 6.0 19It has been on several threads, including this one and most of the ones you have responded to. It has carries, yards, TD's and the now infamous YPC. In your response you only responded to YPC and I wanted to know why?I have stated this over and over, but you can't compare YPCs from different systems...especially in college where schedule variance and system variance is so drastic.A) It is widely accepted that Foster was going to win the Heisman before the SUV scandal that knocked him out of it...Chris Brown did not have a season that matched that year. B) I have seen both players run. In my opinion Foster is a superior runningback to Chris Brown...so superior, that in our hypothetical Foster would be worth much more than is Brown. So basically the huge disparity you are asking for is in talent...because obviously the hypothetical situation has all other variables the same. Although I doubt A. Smith would have been brought in as rapidly if they had a healthy Foster....thus lessening the likelihood of a RBBC...or as Fisher stated "split" in carries.Does that answer your question?On what basis is your projection of Foster as a top 10 back different from projecting Brown lower than A. Smith and James Stewart. Neither Foster or Brown have played entire seasons as starting RB's, both have had injury issues, and Foster did not have superior college stats to Brown. So, I ask again, on what basis do you arrive at your projection, and why such a huge disparity.I have taken the "Heisman" year for Foster and taken Brown's last yr. as a player (as a Jr.) and crunched some numbers. I extrapolated for Foster based on his numbers for 8 games. As you said he missed three games that year Foster games carries yds ypc tdActual 8 216 1109 5.1 12Extrap. 11 297 1523 5.1 16Brown 11 303 1841 6.0 19Comments?A) It is widely accepted that Foster was going to win the Heisman before the SUV scandal that knocked him out of it...Chris Brown did not have a season that matched that year.
OK, but you introduced the comparison of college production with this responseb) I don't care what he did in college
I simply responded to that statement with the data that clearly refutes it. Again, the data includes more than YPC if you just look at it.A) It is widely accepted that Foster was going to win the Heisman before the SUV scandal that knocked him out of it...Chris Brown did not have a season that matched that year.

I can't help myself. I am like a bug to a bug light
SOMEBODY STOP ME!! 


Colin
it just makes you look ridiculous.
Sure sounds to me like he didn't want to leave . . .
:rotflmao:
Love bumping this thread for LHucks though... he dished out alot on me for taking Brown as my #1 RB... in the third round