Getcha passports ready - the middle-aged dummies are going to the British Isles! Top 31 song countdown. (2 Viewers)

[Ilov80s]

Interesting contrast in it. On one hand it’s obviously going to get heat for the second line but then it’s going to get a lot of love from the same group for its openly anti-rich, anti-capitalist POV. It’s economically left, socially right. That’s probably a very small sliver of the population.

as Uruk stated, I don't think TYA is making political statements here but rather just throwing out the "talking points" that were being bandied about by opposing political/social groups.

Never looked at it like that before but I think you are right.

 

[Dr. Octopus]

I had expected to see A LOT more of them in this exercise.

There's still a lot of "rounds" left with 40+ songs in each round.

 

[AAABatteries]

My Idiots #15

Scooter
Yellow - Coldplay

Doug
Peace Train – Cat Stevens

Jeb
Watcher of the Skies - Genesis

Chap
Sympathy for the Devil – The Rolling Stones

Solid list from the Original Dummies ®

 

[Westerberg]

A couple dinosaurs with the last two on my list in Time and Baba. Both still have something left for me and are known to get cranked up when they come on. Not sure why some get worn out and others still bring it but these two still resonate with me.

 

[Westerberg]

Also checking in to say that I really appreciate all that goes into this thing and am having a blast following along. Can't wait to see how it plays out.

 

[Uruk-Hai]

Yeah, in retrospect shouldn't the countdown be a count up? Then the person who had the song ranked highest could be first to discuss it?

No.

 

[simey]

A few favorites from round 15 excluding repeats and the Foursome.

All I Want is You - Great song. I love the vocals and music in it. Dig that outro.
Won't Get Fooled Again - My favorite part is the ending starting with the drums that lead up to the final scream of YEAH. I also like Sally Simpson a lot.
When The Levee Breaks - I love this song. It is so bluesy, and the intro is one of my all time favorites.
Beware of Darkness
I'm the Man
Both Ends Burning
Mercy Street
Get Started, Start a Fire
I'd Love to Change the World
All three of the ELO songs
For Your Love
Death or Glory

New to me favorites

Pink Flag
The A Team

 

[Uruk-Hai]

Yep, not a fan of this concept with this many songs. For one, it's just too many songs to get through in a 24 hour period. I've sort of given up trying. And then if someone lists one of your songs a pick or two above yours it's lost. (Until the top 5 or so). I understand the drawback of a draft, but I also miss talking about a song that has the spotlight and doesn't have to share it with 40 other songs.

The older I get, the more I realize how many things I'm wrong about. If I had posted the above anytime in the last 30 years, I'd have said "yep - there's another one".

Context and intent matters. This isn't an exercise that someone can "win". It's supposed to be fun.

JFC, y'all can screw up a soup sandwich.

 

[Andy Dufresne]

JFC, y'all can screw up a soup sandwich.

Wouldn't the bread get soggy?

 

[New Binky the Doormat]

The Who with the unprecedented quintuple-up! And a surprise (to me) triple-up for ELO.

I didn't time my picks to be with the cool kids...

see pip ...ranking something lower actually means it's "higher" on your scale of "likey-ness"

so, I truly hope this helps you for future music song drafts

it really has for me

 

[AAABatteries]

.

I was so mad/excited when I saw someone take I Can See For Miles a couple days ago. I thought maybe it was going to somehow not get disused until my selection. It’s always fun to be first on a song even if being later actually means you ranked it better.

Yeah, in retrospect shouldn't the countdown be a count up? Then the person who had the song ranked highest could be first to discuss it?

Yep, not a fan of this concept with this many songs. For one, it's just too many songs to get through in a 24 hour period. I've sort of given up trying. And then if someone lists one of your songs a pick or two above yours it's lost. (Until the top 5 or so). I understand the drawback of a draft, but I also miss talking about a song that has the spotlight and doesn't have to share it with 40 other songs. And I sort of miss sniping.

Oh, and I want my Avatar back...

Settle down - I'll get off your lawn in a minute.

 

[Don Quixote]

I like the format. I’ve never done a music draft and don’t think I’d have much interest in that format. I just enjoy the music talk and the playlists to listen to while working.

My song today, Paper Planes, was discussed a couple of weeks ago when it first showed up in the countdown. I think I made a post about liking it then (or maybe just mentioned liking the cocktail)— don’t really care about who “owns” it or whatever.

 

[Uruk-Hai]

JFC, y'all can screw up a soup sandwich.

Wouldn't the bread get soggy?

Are you being obtuse?

 

[Doug B]

JFC, y'all can screw up a soup sandwich.

Wouldn't the bread get soggy?

Are you being obtuse?

(see thread title)

 

[AAABatteries]

I would never have brought this up and nobody is asking me but since it's out there, my 2 cents:

• I love the format - these 2 threads have been some of my favorite ever on the boards
• Krista has done a ridiculous amount of work - I never would have done it. I don't like you people enough
• The lists, the reveal, the playlist, the discussion is all fantastic
• If I had to complain I'd say it would be nice to maybe do a reveal every 2-3 days versus every day but that's totally unfair to Krista as she's investing so much time and isn't signing up for a 3 month commitment. For that reason it's cool. I'm not able to keep up or contribute as much but that's ok - and sometimes the Hippling posts are my favorite ones.
• Definitely 31 down to 1. If you did 1 up to 31 I'd probably stop paying attention after the top 20.

 

[Andy Dufresne]

JFC, y'all can screw up a soup sandwich.

Wouldn't the bread get soggy?

Are you being obtuse?

Always.

Although, I've never heard of a soup sandwich. Is that similar to a kitchen oven?

 

[New Binky the Doormat]

Yeah, in retrospect shouldn't the countdown be a count up? Then the person who had the song ranked highest could be first to discuss it?

I think counting down is always the right way to go. Just my general editorial opinion.

Poor Binky is going to be so confused.

that confusion isn't just limited to countdowns pal.

 

[KarmaPolice]

Now Won't Get Fooled Again will be forever tied to one of the best movies of the year from 2022 for me.

 

[KarmaPolice]

I wonder what album will have the most different songs selected?

One of the odd frontrunners might be Paranoid.

 

[AAABatteries]

worrierking:

Waterloo Sunset - The Kinks
(duplicate – second vote)

Val Rannous:

When The Levee Breaks - Led Zeppelin
(new song)

Andy Dufresne:

Gimme Shelter - The Rolling Stones
(duplicate – second song)

New Binky the Doormat:

London Calling - The Clash
(duplicate – third vote)

Doug B:

One Night In Bangkok - Murray Head
(new artist)

Favorites from today that I haven't already given a shout out to.

 

[New Binky the Doormat]

.

I was so mad/excited when I saw someone take I Can See For Miles a couple days ago. I thought maybe it was going to somehow not get disused until my selection. It’s always fun to be first on a song even if being later actually means you ranked it better.

Yeah, in retrospect shouldn't the countdown be a count up? Then the person who had the song ranked highest could be first to discuss it?

wut?

why would we care more about lesser rated songs - and stick around for it?

come on Andy!!! you're better than that!!

 

[KarmaPolice]

I wonder what album will have the most different songs selected?

Legendary double albums are the most obvious guesses. London Calling, Exile on Main Street, Tommy, Quadrophenia, Goodbye Yellow Brick Road, Physical Graffiti, The White Album, The Wall, etc.

Doh! I read that as album with highest % of songs drafted.
Of course double ablums with MOST songs drafted.

 

[Andy Dufresne]

I think this anecdote surrounding Gimme Shelter interesting:

Jagger stated that the band thought, "it'd be great to have a woman come do the… chorus." They called Clayton "randomly" in the middle of the night in Los Angeles, and she showed up to the studio "in curlers" and contributed her parts in a few takes, which Jagger remarked was "pretty amazing." Clayton performed her parts while pregnant.

 

[Yankee23Fan]

Regarding my Iron Maiden pick today: It's been one of my favorites since the first time I heard it on the much anticipated Powerslave album. It's a long song that tells the story from the Samuel Taylor Coleridge poem of the same name. The version linked (here again) has the lyrics which tell Maiden's version of the tale. If you have 13 minutes and don't mind some (fairly light) metal, it's a good listen/story. I particularly like the drums in this song.

One of my favorite albums when I was a kid

 

[Andy Dufresne]

.

I was so mad/excited when I saw someone take I Can See For Miles a couple days ago. I thought maybe it was going to somehow not get disused until my selection. It’s always fun to be first on a song even if being later actually means you ranked it better.

Yeah, in retrospect shouldn't the countdown be a count up? Then the person who had the song ranked highest could be first to discuss it?

wut?

why would we care more about lesser rated songs - and stick around for it?

come on Andy!!! you're better than that!!

I most certainly am not!

 

[KarmaPolice]

Regarding my Iron Maiden pick today: It's been one of my favorites since the first time I heard it on the much anticipated Powerslave album. It's a long song that tells the story from the Samuel Taylor Coleridge poem of the same name. The version linked (here again) has the lyrics which tell Maiden's version of the tale. If you have 13 minutes and don't mind some (fairly light) metal, it's a good listen/story. I particularly like the drums in this song.

I saw Krista's question, and I honestly didn't think that Rime would be taken, but glad to see it get some love.
I was going to say to @Pip's Invitation that it must we one of their longer songs, so in that sense it's got a bit going for him.

 

[simey]

I ranked this #7 in JML's U2 countdown. It's an amazing ballad WITHOUT the string arrangement -- with it, it's one of the most gorgeous songs ever produced in the "rock" genre.

U2 is so over-rated, generally imo, but this song is so beautiful and could have made my list.

I think they are a great band, and they are a big soundtrack to my mid to late teens, twenties, and some of my thirties. It was such a great time to be listening to new and different music, and I feel lucky that they were making their way on the music scene during that time.

 

[simey]

I think this anecdote surrounding Gimme Shelter interesting:

Jagger stated that the band thought, "it'd be great to have a woman come do the… chorus." They called Clayton "randomly" in the middle of the night in Los Angeles, and she showed up to the studio "in curlers" and contributed her parts in a few takes, which Jagger remarked was "pretty amazing." Clayton performed her parts while pregnant.

She had a miscarriage that night too. For years she wouldn't listen to Gimme Shelter.

 

[KarmaPolice]

Or to use the wise words of Bruce:

"This is what not to do if a bird ****s on you."

 

[MAC_32]

I fell woefully far behind again and have now accepted that I'll never be caught up as long as we're doing this countdown. But on that note I just got to something called Echo & The Bunnymen (I think this is from yesterday), which prompted me to google to see if it was the same singer as Frightened Rabbit. There's a sliiiiight gap in years between these two acts.

 

[Andy Dufresne]

I think this anecdote surrounding Gimme Shelter interesting:

Jagger stated that the band thought, "it'd be great to have a woman come do the… chorus." They called Clayton "randomly" in the middle of the night in Los Angeles, and she showed up to the studio "in curlers" and contributed her parts in a few takes, which Jagger remarked was "pretty amazing." Clayton performed her parts while pregnant.

She had a miscarriage that night too. For years she wouldn't listen to Gimme Shelter.

I think there are questions around whether or not it was that night. It lends some heft to the legend of the song, but I'm not convinced that correlation equates to causation there.

 

[Doug B]

Doug B:

One Night In Bangkok - Murray Head
(new artist)

Favorites from today that I haven't already given a shout out to.

I wonder if this is the only show tune in this exercise? Probably not, though if there's been another one, it's escaped my notice.

 

[New Binky the Doormat]

I ranked this #7 in JML's U2 countdown. It's an amazing ballad WITHOUT the string arrangement -- with it, it's one of the most gorgeous songs ever produced in the "rock" genre.

U2 is so over-rated, generally imo, but this song is so beautiful and could have made my list.

I think they are a great band, and they are a big soundtrack to my mid to late teens, twenties, and some of my thirties. It was such a great time to be listening to new and different music, and I feel lucky that they were making their way on the music scene during that time.

agreed.

and I completely flaked and forgot on my list ...

 

[Don Quixote]

Doug B:

One Night In Bangkok - Murray Head
(new artist)

Favorites from today that I haven't already given a shout out to.

I wonder if this is the only show tune in this exercise? Probably not, though if there's been another one, it's escaped my notice.

I Dreamed a Dream showed up earlier.

 

[KarmaPolice]

Oof. Wasn't expecting a 20min wait out the door at the dispensary at 8am on a Weds. Lol.

These aren’t the stoners of yesteryear who didn’t roll out of bed until noon and were too stoned to remember where they left their Dozer CD. The live resin is the worm and these are your early birds. They probably even have jobs that don’t involve making pizza or selling guitars.

Honestly most were my parents' age it seemed.

 

[New Binky the Doormat]

I wonder if this is the only show tune in this exercise?

reaction.

 

[Doug B]

I wonder if this is the only show tune in this exercise?

reaction.

I checked this out with the sound off. That no work

 

[shuke]

Pip’s Invitation:

Empty Pages - Traffic
(new song)

My #1 Traffic rotates a bunch. The band has always been very special to me, so I wanted them represented on my list. John Barleycorn Must Die was one of the first cassettes I bought, and it's a tour de force of jazzy rock, which is not the same as jazz-rock fusion. You can't go wrong with any of its six tracks, but Empty Pages has always been a favorite for its compelling melody, Steve Winwood's keening vocal and the fantastic piano solo.

Love this pick!!!

 

[KarmaPolice]

.

I was so mad/excited when I saw someone take I Can See For Miles a couple days ago. I thought maybe it was going to somehow not get disused until my selection. It’s always fun to be first on a song even if being later actually means you ranked it better.

Yeah, in retrospect shouldn't the countdown be a count up? Then the person who had the song ranked highest could be first to discuss it?

Yep, not a fan of this concept with this many songs. For one, it's just too many songs to get through in a 24 hour period. I've sort of given up trying. And then if someone lists one of your songs a pick or two above yours it's lost. (Until the top 5 or so). I understand the drawback of a draft, but I also miss talking about a song that has the spotlight and doesn't have to share it with 40 other songs. And I sort of miss sniping.

Oh, and I want my Avatar back...

I have found it easier and easier to keep up, actually. I am not listening to all the playlists start to finish anymore. No need to listen to the repeats unless it's something I really love.

It's also why many of us are doing the after-listen posts, to highlight stuff we love or make posts about our picks. It's a different format for sure, but IMO there is a lot more actual listening to the music and playlists than there is in the typical drafts.

 

[shuke]

I see we've reached the whining stage. Somehow we avoided this in the US one.

Nothing keeps you from discussing a song you have later on your list. I've done it with songs that I had higher, without saying it's going to be on my list. My pick tomorrow is a prime example. Say that you love a song and why, without doing the silly "wink, wink, we'll be seeing this again" stuff. The latter means that you've (1) revealed the song is on your list without (2) saying anything meaningful about it, which is the exact opposite of what should happen.

Oops. I'll edit my post, but what's wrong with saying you picked it later? I'm not sure anything is actually getting spoiled here.

 

[krista4]

Doh! I read that as album with highest % of songs drafted.
Of course double ablums with MOST songs drafted.

I read it (incorrectly) the same way you did. And I have no idea what the answer is, to either question.

 

[Dr. Octopus]

Doug B:

One Night In Bangkok - Murray Head
(new artist)

Favorites from today that I haven't already given a shout out to.

I wonder if this is the only show tune in this exercise? Probably not, though if there's been another one, it's escaped my notice.

I Dreamed a Dream showed up earlier.

Also a song from Mary Poppins.

 

[KarmaPolice]

I see we've reached the whining stage. Somehow we avoided this in the US one.

Nothing keeps you from discussing a song you have later on your list. I've done it with songs that I had higher, without saying it's going to be on my list. My pick tomorrow is a prime example. Say that you love a song and why, without doing the silly "wink, wink, we'll be seeing this again" stuff. The latter means that you've (1) revealed the song is on your list without (2) saying anything meaningful about it, which is the exact opposite of what should happen.

Oops. I'll edit my post, but what's wrong with saying you picked it later? I'm not sure anything is actually getting spoiled here.

At least part of it is the charity contest guesses. If all of us say that we have Stairway to Heaven in the top 10, we would probably have some big clues to how some of those questions turned out. Also, I just generally like to be in the dark as to what is coming up in the countdowns.

 

[krista4]

Regarding my Iron Maiden pick today: It's been one of my favorites since the first time I heard it on the much anticipated Powerslave album. It's a long song that tells the story from the Samuel Taylor Coleridge poem of the same name. The version linked (here again) has the lyrics which tell Maiden's version of the tale. If you have 13 minutes and don't mind some (fairly light) metal, it's a good listen/story. I particularly like the drums in this song.

I saw Krista's question, and I honestly didn't think that Rime would be taken, but glad to see it get some love.
I was going to say to @Pip's Invitation that it must we one of their longer songs, so in that sense it's got a bit going for him.

When I put the questions together, Rime actually was winning that one. We'll see if it remained on top.

 

[shuke]

I get some of the whining but realize in the end it's all silly. I think people just really like to share things with others and like the feeling of give others some magic, in any form, and this form for me can be very magical. I think 7 of my top 10 have been taken already, and am actually flabbergasted about 2 of them. I'm happy they have been, but the possibility that I'm going to open someone's eyes to something new is now gone.

 

[New Binky the Doormat]

I see we've reached the whining stage. Somehow we avoided this in the US one.

Nothing keeps you from discussing a song you have later on your list. I've done it with songs that I had higher, without saying it's going to be on my list. My pick tomorrow is a prime example. Say that you love a song and why, without doing the silly "wink, wink, we'll be seeing this again" stuff. The latter means that you've (1) revealed the song is on your list without (2) saying anything meaningful about it, which is the exact opposite of what should happen.

Oops. I'll edit my post, but what's wrong with saying you picked it later? I'm not sure anything is actually getting spoiled here.

At least part of it is the charity contest guesses. If all of us say that we have Stairway to Heaven in the top 10, we would probably have some big clues to how some of those questions turned out. Also, I just generally like to be in the dark as to what is coming up in the countdowns.

same, but it's random enough - I'm not picking up any real clues anywhere near to the point where it's telling me the top songs

caveat: remember, I'm the the high-low and generally all-around confused guy

 

[krista4]

I ranked this #7 in JML's U2 countdown. It's an amazing ballad WITHOUT the string arrangement -- with it, it's one of the most gorgeous songs ever produced in the "rock" genre.

U2 is so over-rated, generally imo, but this song is so beautiful and could have made my list.

I think they are a great band, and they are a big soundtrack to my mid to late teens, twenties, and some of my thirties. It was such a great time to be listening to new and different music, and I feel lucky that they were making their way on the music scene during that time.

I'm so glad that JML did that U2 thread so that I can re-acquaint myself with some old favorites plus listen to the albums of the last 20 years or so. Today's selection, "All I Want Is You," was one of the seven songs tied for my #1 U2.

 

[KarmaPolice]

I get some of the whining but realize in the end it's all silly. I think people just really like to share things with others and like the feeling of give others some magic, in any form, and this form for me can be very magical. I think 7 of my top 10 have been taken already, and am actually flabbergasted about 2 of them. I'm happy they have been, but the possibility that I'm going to open someone's eyes to something new is now gone.

I would guess most or all of us feel that way. It's that balance of wanting to the be the one with the story of the song and the spotlight on the song mixed with being happy that other people already know and love the same thing you do.

I would be lying if I said that didn't have a small part to play with some of my song selections and placements. If I have a band I honestly can't choose a top song from 5-10 favorites, I probably leaned more taking one I thought had less of a chance at being taken by another person. It also just increases the odds that somebody not versed on that artist might be introduced to a song that they like.

 

[krista4]

I think today's playlist was my favorite so far. Nary a song on there that I didn't at least somewhat like, including OH's "deeply disturbing" selection.

Most of the new-to-me songs didn't turn out to be new to me after all, so I'll highlight that I particularly enjoyed the two ELO songs I hadn't remembered ("Sweet Is The Night" and "Shine A Little Light") and Traffic's "Empty Pages."

 

[KarmaPolice]

I think today's playlist was my favorite so far. Nary a song on there that I didn't at least somewhat like, including OH's "deeply disturbing" selection.

Most of the new-to-me songs didn't turn out to be new to me after all, so I'll highlight that I particularly enjoyed the two ELO songs I hadn't remembered ("Sweet Is The Night" and "Shine A Little Light") and Traffic's "Empty Pages."

I saw the other post about his comment. My thought was on the lines of me probably liking the pick because finding it desturbing would require attention to lyrics.