Parenting dilemma...this might be long.On Saturday, I received a text message from my wife saying we had a problem. Our youngest son Cooper got mad at his older brother Kellen and decided to retaliate against him by essentially ratting him out for something he did this summer. Kellen is 9. Across the street lives a boy named Zack, who is now a freshman in high school. I like Zack, but he's kind of an awkward kid. He's not every big for his size and if you didn't know better, you'd assume he was much younger than he truly is. I also like Zack's mom Angie, whom I have known since we moved into this house back in 2001. Zack comes to our house to play with the boys and he invites them to his house too. While I like him, my ex-wife does not and hates the idea of a freshman in high school playing with boys much younger. While it is a bit odd, I don't think it's nearly as strange as she does and I allow them to play. Again, I know his mom well and I've known Zack since he was 2 years old. They ride bikes, throw the football, smash rocks...they do what boys do and so I don't restrict their involvement. In fact, there are other boys in the neighborhood who play with Zack and my boys too. Now, here's what happened. This summer, Zach talked Kellen into riding his scooter with him up to a Plaid Pantry (like a 7-11). It's not THAT far away, but it is on a busy road and I would probably have told Kellen 'no' had he asked me if he could ride his scooter there. However, we didn't get that opportunity because Zach told Kellen NOT to tell his parents. And we probably would have never known about it except that Kellen pissed his brother off and his brother ratted him out. Cooper knew about it because Zach asked him to go to Plaid Pantry too and Cooper said 'no'. So I have one kid who caved to the peer pressure and one kid who did not. Batting .500 here, which given my pedigree with peer pressure is a huge win.

So, obviously the big problem is that Zack told Kellen to lie to his parents about going to Plaid Pantry. After talking to my wife about it, we decided to punish Kellen for a week with no video games on the computer, which is what he loves to do for fun. However, after talking to my ex-wife about it today, she wants to basically keep our sons from ever playing with Zack again. She thinks it is a HUGE red flag that a kid in HS plays with kids who are in 3rd and 4th grade and she does not want them every playing with him again. My wife and I both think that is a little extreme and we are of the mind that boys will be boys and we can't keep them from making mistakes in life. What we can do is address mistakes when they happen and try to work through them. To that end, I have agreed to talk to Zack and his mother about what happened. I'm not so upset that they walk or ride up to Plaid Pantry. As long as I know about it, I'm actually okay with it. But asking a 4th grader to lie to his parents about it is wrong and it needs to be addressed. I just don't think prohibiting them from ever playing together again is wrong. But it is what their mother (my ex wife) wants and so now, we're kind of battling it out a little over email. Any tips or advise?