In A Pick Your Coach Draft, Where Does Nick Sirianni Rank Among Active NFL Head Coaches? (1 Viewer)

[joey]

Nick Sirianni’s record vs:

• Mike Tomlin
• Andy Reid
• Sean McDermott
• Sean Payton
• Kyle Shanahan
• Matt LeFleur
• Kevin O’Connell
• Dan Campbell

15-3.

Great stat. Impressive indeed.

 

[crushedspirit]

I put more stock into coaches that can win playoff games.

Just for context,
Reid
McVay

Shanny
McDermott

Nick has beaten all these guys. McVay in the NFC Divisional round, Shanny in the NFCC, Reid in the Super Bowl.

Nick Sirianni’s record vs:

• Mike Tomlin
• Andy Reid
• Sean McDermott
• Sean Payton
• Kyle Shanahan
• Matt LeFleur
• Kevin O’Connell
• Dan Campbell

15-3.

In season and playoffs combined he's 1-2 vs Shanny and 2-2 vs Reid. He's also 1-2 vs Bowles.

He has accumulated an excellent record against most others though for sure.

 

[Deamon]

This thread is aging well!

Agreed. Things changing is part of sports and one of the things that makes it interesting.

What exact number would you put him at now?

"Exact number"?

I was going to say top 10, but in that case, I think I'd say exactly 9.15.

And as always, reserving the right to move these at will.

ah, unfortunate you didnt want to answer the question without sarcasm

Why do you say 9.15?

Sorry if you think that's unfortunate. No sarcasm. Just trying to be exact.

And could see him in the top 5. Some of my Eagles friends have him #1. Clearly the team did a great job this year.

9 would be an exact number if you had him ranked as 9th best coach.

If you were being serious, can you explain how you have him as the 9.15th best coach?

Thanks.

 

[Deamon]

I don't remember the exact numbers, but early on in this poll, the votes were very heavily weighted toward the bottom half. I feel like my vote (5-8) was the only vote in the top 12 after a pretty decent sampling of votes had come in. Interesting to see the distribution now. I wonder how much of that was just due to the early sample being a poor representation of the remaining votes that were yet to come in (maybe they counted the votes in Dallas, TX, first ), and how much of that is votes that were actually changed.

I don't think you can change your vote. If so, I think he would be much higher right now.

It's tough to really rank a coach as so much has to do with the players on the field. You can watch Brady throw and see talent, skill, mechanics and judge him based on that.

Sure you can judge a coach on if you think his decision to go for it on 4th was a good one, but that result is still usually determined by how good of a throw that QB made on 4th down (as an example)

 

[eighsse2]

I don't remember the exact numbers, but early on in this poll, the votes were very heavily weighted toward the bottom half. I feel like my vote (5-8) was the only vote in the top 12 after a pretty decent sampling of votes had come in. Interesting to see the distribution now. I wonder how much of that was just due to the early sample being a poor representation of the remaining votes that were yet to come in (maybe they counted the votes in Dallas, TX, first ), and how much of that is votes that were actually changed.

I don't think you can change your vote. If so, I think he would be much higher right now.

It's tough to really rank a coach as so much has to do with the players on the field. You can watch Brady throw and see talent, skill, mechanics and judge him based on that.

Sure you can judge a coach on if you think his decision to go for it on 4th was a good one, but that result is still usually determined by how good of a throw that QB made on 4th down (as an example)

You can change your vote on this poll. There's a button at the bottom of the poll results. I think whenever someone creates a poll, that person chooses whether votes can be changed or not.

 

[Deamon]

I don't remember the exact numbers, but early on in this poll, the votes were very heavily weighted toward the bottom half. I feel like my vote (5-8) was the only vote in the top 12 after a pretty decent sampling of votes had come in. Interesting to see the distribution now. I wonder how much of that was just due to the early sample being a poor representation of the remaining votes that were yet to come in (maybe they counted the votes in Dallas, TX, first ), and how much of that is votes that were actually changed.

I don't think you can change your vote. If so, I think he would be much higher right now.

It's tough to really rank a coach as so much has to do with the players on the field. You can watch Brady throw and see talent, skill, mechanics and judge him based on that.

Sure you can judge a coach on if you think his decision to go for it on 4th was a good one, but that result is still usually determined by how good of a throw that QB made on 4th down (as an example)

You can change your vote on this poll. There's a button at the bottom of the poll results. I think whenever someone creates a poll, that person chooses whether votes can be changed or not.

Ah! I wasn't aware, thanks.

 

[massraider]

It's tough to really rank a coach as so much has to do with the players on the field.

It's actually really easy to rank coaches, you just go by a 10 game sample size, over two seasons, with both WRs injured. What else do you need??

I always enjoy whenever people who seem to get almost no slack win like this. In this case, we had a two-fer, with a HC and a QB both making a bunch of posts/takes/tweets from a few months/years ago laughable. Jalen Hurts was even more satisfying. The 'Is Nick Siranni the Problem??' nonsense was more short-lived---but equally silly. I don't believe for a second that anyone with any input on the Eagles (Lurie/Roseman, etc) has had any doubts about their QB or coach since they have both arrived.

Although in fairness, I must say, this a is a little bit of a self-inflicted wound. This is a fan base that can disagree internally over almost anything. (Personally, I love this about Philly fans)
So, if one were to go knee jerk after a losing streak, and looking for homer fans to pile on, Philly is the town to do it.

 

[eighsse2]

I don't remember the exact numbers, but early on in this poll, the votes were very heavily weighted toward the bottom half. I feel like my vote (5-8) was the only vote in the top 12 after a pretty decent sampling of votes had come in. Interesting to see the distribution now. I wonder how much of that was just due to the early sample being a poor representation of the remaining votes that were yet to come in (maybe they counted the votes in Dallas, TX, first ), and how much of that is votes that were actually changed.

I don't think you can change your vote. If so, I think he would be much higher right now.

It's tough to really rank a coach as so much has to do with the players on the field. You can watch Brady throw and see talent, skill, mechanics and judge him based on that.

Sure you can judge a coach on if you think his decision to go for it on 4th was a good one, but that result is still usually determined by how good of a throw that QB made on 4th down (as an example)

You can change your vote on this poll. There's a button at the bottom of the poll results. I think whenever someone creates a poll, that person chooses whether votes can be changed or not.

Ah! I wasn't aware, thanks.

Also just fyi if you didn't know, on certain polls (like this one) you can click on any of the options and it will list all the users who voted for that option. Can be interesting sometimes.

 

[Joe Bryant]

I don't remember the exact numbers, but early on in this poll, the votes were very heavily weighted toward the bottom half. I feel like my vote (5-8) was the only vote in the top 12 after a pretty decent sampling of votes had come in. Interesting to see the distribution now. I wonder how much of that was just due to the early sample being a poor representation of the remaining votes that were yet to come in (maybe they counted the votes in Dallas, TX, first ), and how much of that is votes that were actually changed.

I don't think you can change your vote. If so, I think he would be much higher right now.

It's tough to really rank a coach as so much has to do with the players on the field. You can watch Brady throw and see talent, skill, mechanics and judge him based on that.

Sure you can judge a coach on if you think his decision to go for it on 4th was a good one, but that result is still usually determined by how good of a throw that QB made on 4th down (as an example)

You can change your vote on this poll. There's a button at the bottom of the poll results. I think whenever someone creates a poll, that person chooses whether votes can be changed or not.

Thanks.