In A Pick Your Coach Draft, Where Does Nick Sirianni Rank Among Active NFL Head Coaches? (1 Viewer)

[Joe Bryant]

Well, I'm looking at your site using my Android phone, not a computer. Initially I didn't realize I could click on a particular voting option total to then see who voted that option. Another poster responded (not sure who) to my post that I could actually do that. Had I known to do that, I wouldn't have asked that particular question. I didn't speculate how you voted. Still, I was interested in the discussion/disagreement with your buddy. You've already answered my questions upthread. I appreciated your responses. And, I believe I thanked you each time with a "like" handshake.

Thanks for the great product you and your staff provide. I hope you had a very nice Thanksgiving with family and friends!!!

Thanks. You "liked" the post "My guess is that he has him at #32". I don't know any reasonable person who'd rank Sirianni as #32 so I was interested why you'd given that the thumbs up. No worries though as I know the forum can be difficult to use on mobile. Thanks for the good discussion and thanks for being part of the forums. And I hope you have a great Thanksgiving weekend.

 

[Uruk-Hai]

I finally settled on the 9-12 option. I think he might be better than that and, as I said earlier in this thread, if he keeps winning at this clip he'd definitely be in the next tier. He's a little wacky, but people are allowed to mature and learn.

 

[unckeyherb]

Well, I'm looking at your site using my Android phone, not a computer. Initially I didn't realize I could click on a particular voting option total to then see who voted that option. Another poster responded (not sure who) to my post that I could actually do that. Had I known to do that, I wouldn't have asked that particular question. I didn't speculate how you voted. Still, I was interested in the discussion/disagreement with your buddy. You've already answered my questions upthread. I appreciated your responses. And, I believe I thanked you each time with a "like" handshake.

Thanks for the great product you and your staff provide. I hope you had a very nice Thanksgiving with family and friends!!!

I don't know any reasonable person who'd rank Sirianni as #32….

And yet more than 10% of voters in this poll ranked him among that cohort. 40% have him in the bottom third. The idea that there are nominally 20 or so better HC options out there is…wild.

 

[Ghost Rider]

13-16 seems right.

I suspect most of the dislike of Sirriani comes from him being such a dislikable tool (he just looks like a guy who needs a couple of hard shots to the face), but it is kind of hard to argue with his record, which is very good overall. Yes, he also has to wear last season's collapse and the team basically quitting on him in a playoff game, but this year's bounce back, which I did not see coming, has been impressive.

 

[Joe Bryant]

Well, I'm looking at your site using my Android phone, not a computer. Initially I didn't realize I could click on a particular voting option total to then see who voted that option. Another poster responded (not sure who) to my post that I could actually do that. Had I known to do that, I wouldn't have asked that particular question. I didn't speculate how you voted. Still, I was interested in the discussion/disagreement with your buddy. You've already answered my questions upthread. I appreciated your responses. And, I believe I thanked you each time with a "like" handshake.

Thanks for the great product you and your staff provide. I hope you had a very nice Thanksgiving with family and friends!!!

I don't know any reasonable person who'd rank Sirianni as #32….

And yet more than 10% of voters in this poll ranked him among that cohort. 40% have him in the bottom third. The idea that there are nominally 20 or so better HC options out there is…wild.

Yes. But I doubt anyone had him #32 even back then. And certainly not today as the poster suggested I would. Just seemed like an odd flex. But all good.

 

[unckeyherb]

13-16 seems right.

I suspect most of the dislike of Sirriani comes from him being such a dislikable tool (he just looks like a guy who needs a couple of hard shots to the face), but it is kind of hard to argue with his record, which is very good overall. Yes, he also has to wear last season's collapse and the team basically quitting on him in a playoff game, but this year's bounce back, which I did not see coming, has been impressive.

Can you name the 12-15 current head coaches you’d put over him?

 

[Snotbubbles]

13-16 seems right.

I suspect most of the dislike of Sirriani comes from him being such a dislikable tool (he just looks like a guy who needs a couple of hard shots to the face), but it is kind of hard to argue with his record, which is very good overall. Yes, he also has to wear last season's collapse and the team basically quitting on him in a playoff game, but this year's bounce back, which I did not see coming, has been impressive.

Can you name the 12-15 current head coaches you’d put over him?

I think people underestimate the fact that in 2023 he lost both coordinators. It certainly had an effect on the Eagles. Then they did it again this season and the team just keeps winning. That's why when people want to say Dan Campbell is a better coach, wait until he loses Ben Johnson and Aaron Glenn. If he can replicate winning after replacing his coordinators, then we can talk.

EDIT: It's why I'm glad they got Fangio this season, because I think he'll be around for multiple seasons so the defense will just keep getting better and better. Kellen Moore is probably a goner at some point, hopefully, he stays one more season because Hurts in year 2 of Steichen was MVP worthy.