Another good posting Chase. One thing I have been struggling with here the whole time was what was in it for Curley? Why would he lie under oath? Why wouldn't he act on what Joe and McQueary told him?
At this point, Joe is the least culpable in my mind. I do not think McQueary gave Joe the full picture. The grand jury and DA agree that both Joe and McQueary's testimony/stories do not contradict each other.
My question revolves around the 1998 incident and who at PSU knew of this investigation.
Really? Remember what McQueary saw. He saw a grown man raping a 10 year old boy. And you think he told Paterno there was just some inappropriate behavior going on? Maybe that's true, but I find that explanation incredible. How else would McQueary describe it? I think its impossible to believe that McQueary saw the rape and didn't tell Paterno the full extent. How could he not?
Would you tell your conservative 80 year old grandfather all of those gruesome details, or would you use a little more tact? Based on the coward McQueary calling his dad asking what he should do, I think he did something similar with Paterno. He told him what he saw, but in more general terms. He asked Joe what he should do. Joe should have said to call the police. Instead, Joe said he would call the AD and the school would take it from there etc.
Again, I'm not buying it. First, Paterno was 75 not 80. Second - he wasn't McQueary's grandfather. He was his boss. At the minimum, McQueary would have said, "Sandusky was having sex with a 10 year old boy." That's not a gruesome detail but it does convey what happened better than "inappropriate conduct." And its MORE than enough to put Paterno into action. Or at least it should have been.
Even if MM was vague at the beginning of the talk, at some point when he saw how Paterno was reacting, he HAD to have made it clear what happened. It was too big. Too dramatic. There's
no way he brushed it aside.
And even if he didn't tell Paterno at the initial meeting (which, again, I think is completely unbelievable), there's simply no way MM didn't make it clear to the AD the next day. At a meeting that Paterno attended.
Paterno knew what happened.