MAD - Artist - Round 4 - #5's have been posted (14 Viewers)

[Zegras11]

To his credit zegras isnt precious

I might have to switch to the Pretenders after this one.


If we get enough interest to do a Theme Draft, we can do that in the future.

The Theme idea had crossed my mind before JML sent me a PM. And I was open to having him do it now as a one off. When we do it, people are going to have to be VERY specific about their theme. I don't want to get into endless debates/arguments. For example, I will be choosing Top 31 New Wave songs by 31 different artists.

Another idea that I had a week ago and ran it past KP and Pip was to do a MAD 31 list with everyone choosing a different year. They both liked it as much as I did, and then we realized there would be argument after argument about what year a song should be in. So that quickly ended that idea. Dibs on 72 or 73 if this ever happens LOL.

 

[Mrs. Rannous]

Another idea that I had a week ago and ran it past KP and Pip was to do a MAD 31 list with everyone choosing a different year. They both liked it as much as I did, and then we realized there would be argument after argument about what year a song should be in. So that quickly ended that idea. Dibs on 72 or 73 if this ever happens LOL.

You really think we would argue about this? This isn't a Timdraft, you know.

 

[Scoresman]

Can't you just pick a way to rule on year? Like "year the song was first published"?

 

[Mister CIA]

Maybe we should have BYO 31-song playlist thread later, kind of like that week when the NFL lets players wear customized cleats. As examples, I'd like to pull together a 31-song Muscle Shoals playlist, or maybe a surf-genre playlist, or sad songs, or breakup songs, or songs about sex ... or drugs ... or even songs about Rock and Roll itself.

 

[John Maddens Lunchbox]

Can't you just pick a way to rule on year? Like "year the song was first published"?

Another idea that I had a week ago and ran it past KP and Pip was to do a MAD 31 list with everyone choosing a different year. They both liked it as much as I did, and then we realized there would be argument after argument about what year a song should be in. So that quickly ended that idea. Dibs on 72 or 73 if this ever happens LOL.

You really think we would argue about this? This isn't a Timdraft, you know.

Thee are the bane of any year list of music or draft.
I used to be a chief cheerleader of the officious crew, but now…**** it.
I mean a song released in December 1975 of a year…..as an album track first.
It isnt really a 1975 song.
Defining this is difficult and leeway should be allowed within reason.
There is absolutely no fun in having someone constantly pointing out that this track was released first in Upper Volta in 1967 and therefore shouldnt be a 1968 song.
No one wants to run a draft like this without wanting to tell people to **** off every two minutes.
If someone has the fortitude to run it, great.
Thoughts and prayers

 

[John Maddens Lunchbox]

Maybe we should have BYO 31-song playlist thread later, kind of like that week when the NFL lets players wear customized cleats. As examples, I'd like to pull together a 31-song Muscle Shoals playlist, or maybe a surf-genre playlist, or sad songs, or breakup songs, or songs about sex ... or drugs ... or even songs about Rock and Roll itself.

I tried to run a trilogy draft a few years ago. The site owner thought that Rock N Roll was the devils music and objected.
Joking.
He objected to the other two.
He has lost family members through drugs and songs about blowjobs and snorting cocaine isnt his idea of PG.

 

[Mister CIA]

Maybe we should have BYO 31-song playlist thread later, kind of like that week when the NFL lets players wear customized cleats. As examples, I'd like to pull together a 31-song Muscle Shoals playlist, or maybe a surf-genre playlist, or sad songs, or breakup songs, or songs about sex ... or drugs ... or even songs about Rock and Roll itself.

I tried to run a trilogy draft a few years ago. The site owner thought that Rock N Roll was the devils music and objected.
Joking.
He objected to the other two.
He has lost family members through drugs and songs about blowjobs and snorting cocaine isnt his idea of PG.

I'd forgotten about that. It's not like a 31-song playlist about drugs would serve to promote drugs (on the contrary, it might serve as a cautionary tale), but yeah we don't want to offend the delicate sensibilities of the people at the other end of the bar who aren't listening to us.

 

[Mt. Man]

Okay, after overthinking it, I've nailed it down. I'll be taking
Candlebox

It's a band I lost connection with thanks mostly to that whole 10-year hiatus thing, then found again. There might be an emphasis on those first 3 albums (we'll see; the list isn't done), but there's some great stuff throughout their (apparently) recently-ended history.

 

[Raging weasel]

Maybe we should have BYO 31-song playlist thread later, kind of like that week when the NFL lets players wear customized cleats. As examples, I'd like to pull together a 31-song Muscle Shoals playlist, or maybe a surf-genre playlist, or sad songs, or breakup songs, or songs about sex ... or drugs ... or even songs about Rock and Roll itself.

I tried to run a trilogy draft a few years ago. The site owner thought that Rock N Roll was the devils music and objected.
Joking.
He objected to the other two.
He has lost family members through drugs and songs about blowjobs and snorting cocaine isnt his idea of PG.

I was in that draft

 

[KarmaPolice]

Maybe we should have BYO 31-song playlist thread later, kind of like that week when the NFL lets players wear customized cleats. As examples, I'd like to pull together a 31-song Muscle Shoals playlist, or maybe a surf-genre playlist, or sad songs, or breakup songs, or songs about sex ... or drugs ... or even songs about Rock and Roll itself.

I tried to run a trilogy draft a few years ago. The site owner thought that Rock N Roll was the devils music and objected.
Joking.
He objected to the other two.
He has lost family members through drugs and songs about blowjobs and snorting cocaine isnt his idea of PG.

I was in that draft

:reported:

 

[Mrs. Rannous]

Maybe we should have BYO 31-song playlist thread later, kind of like that week when the NFL lets players wear customized cleats. As examples, I'd like to pull together a 31-song Muscle Shoals playlist, or maybe a surf-genre playlist, or sad songs, or breakup songs, or songs about sex ... or drugs ... or even songs about Rock and Roll itself.

I tried to run a trilogy draft a few years ago. The site owner thought that Rock N Roll was the devils music and objected.
Joking.
He objected to the other two.
He has lost family members through drugs and songs about blowjobs and snorting cocaine isnt his idea of PG.

I was in that draft

Were you also in the draft of songs by performers who had joined the choir eternal? I'm not sure which cancellation was dumber.

(It's easy to know when that was. Tom Petty died smack dab in the middle of it.)

 

[Eephus]

Maybe we should have BYO 31-song playlist thread later, kind of like that week when the NFL lets players wear customized cleats. As examples, I'd like to pull together a 31-song Muscle Shoals playlist, or maybe a surf-genre playlist, or sad songs, or breakup songs, or songs about sex ... or drugs ... or even songs about Rock and Roll itself.

I tried to run a trilogy draft a few years ago. The site owner thought that Rock N Roll was the devils music and objected.
Joking.
He objected to the other two.
He has lost family members through drugs and songs about blowjobs and snorting cocaine isnt his idea of PG.

I was in that draft

Were you also in the draft of songs by performers who had joined the choir eternal? I'm not sure which cancellation was dumber.

(It's easy to know when that was. Tom Petty died smack dab in the middle of it.)

We covered all those forbidden themes and then some in the big Genrepalooza Radio draft but that thread was so arcane that the mods didn't care.

 

[Yo Mama]

Maybe we should have BYO 31-song playlist thread later, kind of like that week when the NFL lets players wear customized cleats. As examples, I'd like to pull together a 31-song Muscle Shoals playlist, or maybe a surf-genre playlist, or sad songs, or breakup songs, or songs about sex ... or drugs ... or even songs about Rock and Roll itself.

I tried to run a trilogy draft a few years ago. The site owner thought that Rock N Roll was the devils music and objected.
Joking.
He objected to the other two.
He has lost family members through drugs and songs about blowjobs and snorting cocaine isnt his idea of PG.

I was in that draft

Were you also in the draft of songs by performers who had joined the choir eternal? I'm not sure which cancellation was dumber.

(It's easy to know when that was. Tom Petty died smack dab in the middle of it.)

We covered all those forbidden themes and then some in the big Genrepalooza Radio draft but that thread was so arcane that the mods didn't care.

Moderation disappears after page 1000

 

[MAC_32]

One of my favorite new songs from all the MAD lists has been "Sometime Around MIdnight," by THE AIRBORNE TOXIC EVENT. Just love everything about this song from start to finish.

As you stand under the bar lights
And the band plays some song about forgetting yourself for a while

 

[Zegras11]

No one wants to run a draft like this without wanting to tell people to **** off every two minutes.

 

[Zegras11]

1	Zegras11	The Airborne Toxic Event
2	Don Quixote	Tim Maia
3	Pip's Invitation	Triumph
4	Uruk-Hai	PFunk
5	Raging weasel	The Pretty Reckless
6	New binky the doormat	Doobie Brothers
7	kupcho1	The Clash
8	The Dreaded Marco	Built To Spill
9	Scoresman	The Walkman
10	-OZ-	Lindsey Stirling
11	Mrs. Rannous	Annie Lennox
12	Charlie Steiner	Whitney Houston
13	Yo Mama	Yes
14	John Maddens Lunchbox	Robyn
15	MAC_32	Our Lady Peace
16	zamboni	Bee Gees
17	Yambag	Ryan Star
18	landrys hat	My Morning Jacket
19	Karma Police	Journey
20	Mister CIA	Frederick John Elgersma
21	jwb	Motley Crew
22	eephus	Johnny Marr
23	tuffnut	R.E.M.
24	Mt. Man	Candlebox

 

[MAC_32]

Okay, after overthinking it, I've nailed it down. I'll be taking
Candlebox

It's a band I lost connection with thanks mostly to that whole 10-year hiatus thing, then found again. There might be an emphasis on those first 3 albums (we'll see; the list isn't done), but there's some great stuff throughout their (apparently) recently-ended history.

Oh, it's clear you're...far behind

 

[MAC_32]

Was going to set this round out but what the hell.... Give me R.E.M.

Birdie in the hand...

 

[Mrs. Rannous]

The Yeah Yeah Yeahs performed the end music for this week's episode of Agatha All Along.

 

[Raging weasel]

Maybe we should have BYO 31-song playlist thread later, kind of like that week when the NFL lets players wear customized cleats. As examples, I'd like to pull together a 31-song Muscle Shoals playlist, or maybe a surf-genre playlist, or sad songs, or breakup songs, or songs about sex ... or drugs ... or even songs about Rock and Roll itself.

I tried to run a trilogy draft a few years ago. The site owner thought that Rock N Roll was the devils music and objected.
Joking.
He objected to the other two.
He has lost family members through drugs and songs about blowjobs and snorting cocaine isnt his idea of PG.

I was in that draft

Were you also in the draft of songs by performers who had joined the choir eternal? I'm not sure which cancellation was dumber.

(It's easy to know when that was. Tom Petty died smack dab in the middle of it.)

Was not in that one.

 

[Dr. Octopus]

1	Zegras11	The Airborne Toxic Event
2	Don Quixote	Tim Maia
3	Pip's Invitation	Triumph
4	Uruk-Hai	PFunk
5	Raging weasel	The Pretty Reckless
6	New binky the doormat	Doobie Brothers
7	kupcho1	The Clash
8	The Dreaded Marco	Built To Spill
9	Scoresman	The Walkman
10	-OZ-	Lindsey Stirling
11	Mrs. Rannous	Annie Lennox
12	Charlie Steiner	Whitney Houston
13	Yo Mama	Yes
14	John Maddens Lunchbox	Robyn
15	MAC_32	Our Lady Peace
16	zamboni	Bee Gees
17	Yambag	Ryan Star
18	landrys hat	My Morning Jacket
19	Karma Police	Journey
20	Mister CIA	Frederick John Elgersma
21	jwb	Motley Crew
22	eephus	Johnny Marr
23	tuffnut	R.E.M.
24	Mt. Man	Candlebox

You left me out (Jeff Tweedy).

 

[tuffnutt]

Okay, after overthinking it, I've nailed it down. I'll be taking
Candlebox

It's a band I lost connection with thanks mostly to that whole 10-year hiatus thing, then found again. There might be an emphasis on those first 3 albums (we'll see; the list isn't done), but there's some great stuff throughout their (apparently) recently-ended history.

Looking forward to this one. Loved Candlebox in the 90s. Saw them in concert a few years ago and Kevin Martin's voice still sounded great

 

[Yo Mama]

Woohoo! I think I’m done with my YES list, aside from some final tinkering and fine-tuning.

To keep from including the entire track listing from just 5 albums, I’m trying to include at least one song from every album in the time range I’m using. There were a few albums I hadn’t listened to for 20-30 years, and those were fun to revisit. Not sure why their first two albums in particular fell off my radar over the years, but I really liked those and am including a number of songs from each on my list.

And with a little discipline around the super long songs, I kept the running time well below my Genesis playlist. Its still long but not 4 hours.

 

[Eephus]

Batman joins other musical legends in getting a star on Hollywood Boulevard.

BATMAN TO BE HONORED AS FIRST SUPER HERO ON THE HOLLYWOOD WALK OF FAME - Hollywood Walk of Fame

Batman, one of the most iconic fictional characters in the world, will be honored with the 2,790th star on the Hollywood Walk of Fame on Thursday, September 26, at 11:00 am PT at 6764 Hollywood Boulevard in front of The Hollywood Guinness World Records Museum. Batman will receive his star in the...

walkoffame.com

 

[John Maddens Lunchbox]

Batman joins other musical legends in getting a star on Hollywood Boulevard.

BATMAN TO BE HONORED AS FIRST SUPER HERO ON THE HOLLYWOOD WALK OF FAME - Hollywood Walk of Fame

Batman, one of the most iconic fictional characters in the world, will be honored with the 2,790th star on the Hollywood Walk of Fame on Thursday, September 26, at 11:00 am PT at 6764 Hollywood Boulevard in front of The Hollywood Guinness World Records Museum. Batman will receive his star in the...

walkoffame.com

Doing the Batusi/Watusi to celebrate

 

[-OZ-]

I see candle box and am like “didn’t we do that in round 2?” Just to realize I’m confusing candle box and collective soul.

 

[KarmaPolice]

I see candle box and am like “didn’t we do that in round 2?” Just to realize I’m confusing candle box and collective soul.

LOL. I swore somebody did The Clash too, but was confusing them with The Jam and/or The Kinks.

 

[titusbramble]

Will push the idea I DMed about to either a theme countdown, if it happens, or an independent list in the future

For the purposes of an artist being involved in a record, does remixing something count?

 

[Mrs. Rannous]

Will push the idea I DMed about to either a theme countdown, if it happens, or an independent list in the future

For the purposes of an artist being involved in a record, does remixing something count?

If it's Fatboy Slim, sure. I reckon it's on a case-by-case basis.

 

[titusbramble]

Well Norman Cook was one of those I was considering, but yeah I'm thinking from mainly an electronic standpoint, like if I did pick him do I get the radio version of Brimful of Asha as eligible, that sort of thing. Artist I'm thinking of has a decent enough list of things he has produced himself but a very extensive remixing catalogue

 

[John Maddens Lunchbox]

Well Norman Cook was one of those I was considering, but yeah I'm thinking from mainly an electronic standpoint, like if I did pick him do I get the radio version of Brimful of Asha as eligible, that sort of thing. Artist I'm thinking of has a decent enough list of things he has produced himself but a very extensive remixing catalogue

In the Royksopp countdown I included their remix of Cry Baby by Spiller.
I am sure we have had a few artists picked that do a variety of stuff.
As long as zegras has said ok, im all good.
Long as its not Batman related

 

[kupcho1]

Well Norman Cook was one of those I was considering, but yeah I'm thinking from mainly an electronic standpoint, like if I did pick him do I get the radio version of Brimful of Asha as eligible, that sort of thing. Artist I'm thinking of has a decent enough list of things he has produced himself but a very extensive remixing catalogue

He's one i considered. You get the Housemartins and some other things as well.

 

[Eephus]

Well Norman Cook was one of those I was considering, but yeah I'm thinking from mainly an electronic standpoint, like if I did pick him do I get the radio version of Brimful of Asha as eligible, that sort of thing. Artist I'm thinking of has a decent enough list of things he has produced himself but a very extensive remixing catalogue

He's one i considered. You get the Housemartins and some other things as well.

Beats International FTW

 

[The Dreaded Marco]

Going with Boise’s own Built To Spill

The Boise, Idaho-based indie rock band Built to Spill meet in the middle ground between postmodern, Pavement-style pop and the loose, spacious jamming of Neil Young. The group is a vehicle for singer/songwriter/guitarist Doug Martsch, who -- heavily inspired by Dinosaur Jr.'s J Mascis -- helped keep the concept of the indie guitar hero alive. On record, Martsch the arranger crafted intricate, artfully knotted tangles of guitar; in concert, his rough-edged soloing heroics earned Built to Spill a reputation as an exciting and unpredictable live act. The band formed in Boise, Idaho, in 1993, shortly after Martsch had departed the Boise-rooted, Seattle-based Treepeople. Martsch had grown up in Twin Falls, Idaho, where he formed his first band, Farm Days, with bassist Brett Nelson and drummer Andy Capps while in high school during the mid-'80s. After moving to Boise, Martsch hooked up with former members of the local hardcore punk band State of Confusion to form Treepeople, which relocated to Seattle in 1988. There they signed with the local indie C/Z and issued several albums and EPs that offered a distinctive take on early Northwestern grunge. Eventually tiring of the band's far-ranging touring commitments, Martsch departed after 1993's Just Kidding album, and despite the continuing boom of the Seattle scene, he returned to Boise to refresh himself. Their early records betrayed some punk scrappiness around the edges, but as Martsch's songwriting matured, he was able to crank out complicated, emotionally wracked songs that melted hearts as easily as they did speakers. The artistic success of 1994's There's Nothing Wrong with Love led to the band signing a deal with Warner Bros., where they released a string of albums highlighted by alt-rock classics Perfect from Now On and Keep It Like a Secret. As the '90s receded in the rearview mirror, the band kept going strong. Through numerous lineup changes and a shifting musical landscape, Martsch stayed true to his roots, and records like 2015's Untethered Moon and 2022's When the Wind Forgets Your Name sound remarkably similar to early works, only with an added element of maturity.

 

[Eephus]

My Johnny Marr list is a wrap. I did things a little differently this time with three separate mini-lists of his solo material, his work with the Smiths and songs representing his many other musical collaborations. They'll be presented in rotation with solo Johnny getting the first and last words at #31 and #1.

I found ranking them in separate sub-group simplified the process a lot; in fact trimming the less homogeneous side projects down to ten was by far the toughest of the three sets. I also wanted to be respectful of my featured artist by considering his recent solo career on its own merits rather than comparing his newer songs directly with those he wrote 40 years ago as a member of one of the most beloved bands of their age.

 

[John Maddens Lunchbox]

@Zegras11 if the artist deadline is the 13th, what will be the approximate deadline for list submissions?
At this stage we have well under 35 so i want to see if theres enough time to do a second list.

 

[rockaction]

I'm still deliberating about which artist to do. Somebody mentioned one upthread that I have a list for, but I made it a while ago and I've forgotten some of the reasons for the executive decisions. There are other bands and artists I'm considering, but given that it's due the 13th of October I think that I can come up with something and narrow it down to one artist (there's nothing urgently pressing me to do more than one—just having trouble deciding).

 

[Zegras11]

@Zegras11 if the artist deadline is the 13th, what will be the approximate deadline for list submissions?
At this stage we have well under 35 so i want to see if theres enough time to do a second list.

the same day, 13th

 

[John Maddens Lunchbox]

@Zegras11 if the artist deadline is the 13th, what will be the approximate deadline for list submissions?
At this stage we have well under 35 so i want to see if theres enough time to do a second list.

the same day, 13th

Ouch. Everything due on the same day. Dont we have to get a spreadsheet first to enter our picks?
Spreadsheet deadline?

 

[Mrs. Rannous]

@Zegras11 if the artist deadline is the 13th, what will be the approximate deadline for list submissions?
At this stage we have well under 35 so i want to see if theres enough time to do a second list.

the same day, 13th

Ouch. Everything due on the same day. Dont we have to get a spreadsheet first to enter our picks?
Spreadsheet deadline?

Uh-oh. I've been dawdling. Must go faster.

 

[Uruk-Hai]

@Zegras11 if the artist deadline is the 13th, what will be the approximate deadline for list submissions?
At this stage we have well under 35 so i want to see if theres enough time to do a second list.

the same day, 13th

Oh, crap. I was thinking the song submissions would be a few weeks later. Time to get to work.

 

[Pip's Invitation]

I'm on studio album #8 of 10. Though most of the list is determined because the vast majority of songs will come from albums 3 through 7.

 

[zamboni]

@Zegras11 if the artist deadline is the 13th, what will be the approximate deadline for list submissions?
At this stage we have well under 35 so i want to see if theres enough time to do a second list.

the same day, 13th

Oh, crap. I was thinking the song submissions would be a few weeks later. Time to get to work.

Yeah the 13th is going to be tough for me but I’ll make it work if need be. May be a bit chalkier than I’d like.

 

[-OZ-]

Y’all might be into this book I just started reading

This Is What It Sounds Like: What the Music You Love Sa…

This Is What It Sounds Like is a journey into the scien…

www.goodreads.com

This Is What It Sounds Like is a journey into the science and soul of music that reveals the secrets of why your favorite songs move you. But it’s also a story of a musical trailblazer who began as a humble audio tech in Los Angeles to became Prince’s chief engineer for Purple Rain, and then create other No. 1 hits (including Barenaked Ladies' "One Week") as one of the most successful female record producers of all time.


Now an award-winning professor of cognitive neuroscience, Susan Rogers leads readers to musical self-awareness. She explains that we each possess a unique “listener profile” based on our brain’s natural response to seven key dimensions of any song. Are you someone who prefers lyrics or melody? Do you like music “above the neck” (intellectually stimulating), or “below the neck” (instinctual and rhythmic)? Whether your taste is esoteric or mainstream, Rogers guides readers to recognize their musical personality, and offers language to describe one's own unique taste. Like most of us, Rogers is not a musician, but she shows that all of us can be musical—simply by being an active, passionate listener.

 

[Zegras11]

@Zegras11 if the artist deadline is the 13th, what will be the approximate deadline for list submissions?
At this stage we have well under 35 so i want to see if theres enough time to do a second list.

the same day, 13th

Ouch. Everything due on the same day. Dont we have to get a spreadsheet first to enter our picks?
Spreadsheet deadline?

I'll send the Google form info in the next day or two.

We have like 25 now. And like 3 to 4 weeks until Oct 13 from starting this thread.

 

[MAC_32]

What's the planned roll out schedule? I just found an Our Lady Peace Christmas song. Need to plot out its ranking accordingly

 

[KarmaPolice]

What's the planned roll out schedule? I just found an Our Lady Peace Christmas song. Need to plot out its ranking accordingly

Pretty sure commish said no Christmas songs.

 

[Mrs. Rannous]

What's the planned roll out schedule? I just found an Our Lady Peace Christmas song. Need to plot out its ranking accordingly

Pretty sure commish said no Christmas songs.

That's why I'm going to have a five song mini playlist just for Christmas.

 

[Mrs. Rannous]

And like 3 to 4 weeks until Oct 13 from starting this thread.

You may want to consult a calendar.

 

[Zegras11]

And like 3 to 4 weeks until Oct 13 from starting this thread.

You may want to consult a calendar.

Oct 13 is 20 days since last Monday