***OFFICIAL 'The Walking Dead' TV Series Thread*** (7 Viewers)

[Nick Vermeil]

hmmm... I thought the Governator was the worst of this series- completely ridiculous.

Let me refine, the governor was pretty absurd. But the core team america they kept fairly "real" as it were through the experiences.

It's not all that out of the question that people would group up and then turn on eachother as resources became more scarce. It's sort of how we were not that long ago.

His character was written a little over the top, yeah. But you gotta give it a slight pass just as a plot vehicle. I guess I saw it a bit different as I plowed through the govenor stuff in about 2 weeks time. It took you guys what? 2 years?

I marathoned it too until last season.

IMO, the plot vehicles are what makes the show lack transcendence. I really like the soul-searching and glimpses into what makes us human vs animal/zombies that the show gets into... at it's best. usually in the quieter moments, IIRC. I'm also a sucker for the post-apocolyptic "how would I survive and live if those conditions happened to me" kind of thing- so

Do you really think you would survive in these conditions? Your wife would put up a fuss when you had to eat rat instead of 30 minutes or less door to door sashimi and then some fool would stab you for your scarf.

 

[El Floppo]

hmmm... I thought the Governator was the worst of this series- completely ridiculous.

Let me refine, the governor was pretty absurd. But the core team america they kept fairly "real" as it were through the experiences.

It's not all that out of the question that people would group up and then turn on eachother as resources became more scarce. It's sort of how we were not that long ago.

His character was written a little over the top, yeah. But you gotta give it a slight pass just as a plot vehicle. I guess I saw it a bit different as I plowed through the govenor stuff in about 2 weeks time. It took you guys what? 2 years?

I marathoned it too until last season.

IMO, the plot vehicles are what makes the show lack transcendence. I really like the soul-searching and glimpses into what makes us human vs animal/zombies that the show gets into... at it's best. usually in the quieter moments, IIRC. I'm also a sucker for the post-apocolyptic "how would I survive and live if those conditions happened to me" kind of thing- so

Do you really think you would survive in these conditions? Your wife would put up a fuss when you had to eat rat instead of 30 minutes or less door to door sashimi and then some fool would stab you for your scarf.

you know what I used to make... it was rat pretty much 3 or 4 nights a week. only difference here is a chance to decapitate folk just for S&Gs

eta: and fwiw- I've designed more zombie-proof habitations in my head than you can imagine. when I start actually putting them to paper, look out

 

[NewlyRetired]

If everyone is infected and if they die they turn into a zombie means the lifespan of the earth is merely as long as the longest living human can manage to stay alive, no more. Is there anything at all to suggest this is not the case?

People can still get pregnant and give birth.

I was under the impression the virus spread first like a flu. Then the ones that were symptomatic died and turned and started eating everyone or they survived.

So the survivors now are yes/no??? still contagious to someone without exposure??

I would assume those that are carriers is like aids. the baby probably has it or else also got it and was non symptomatic.

What plotline would tell you this baby is the cure?

I did not say the baby was the cure. I was pointing out that your statement (see bolded above) might not be true if people keep having kids.

We know next to nothing about the initial outbreak. Neither the tv series, the webisodes or the comics touch on it in any great depth

We have an "early days" webisode and one line from Jenner to base everything on.

I think we need to wait for the spin off to get more information.

 

[El Floppo]

If everyone is infected and if they die they turn into a zombie means the lifespan of the earth is merely as long as the longest living human can manage to stay alive, no more. Is there anything at all to suggest this is not the case?

People can still get pregnant and give birth.

I was under the impression the virus spread first like a flu. Then the ones that were symptomatic died and turned and started eating everyone or they survived.

So the survivors now are yes/no??? still contagious to someone without exposure??

I would assume those that are carriers is like aids. the baby probably has it or else also got it and was non symptomatic.

What plotline would tell you this baby is the cure?

I did not say the baby was the cure. I was pointing out that your statement (see bolded above) might not be true if people keep having kids.

We know next to nothing about the initial outbreak. Neither the tv series, the webisodes or the comics touch on it in any great depth

We have an "early days" webisode and one line from Jenner to base everything on.

I think we need to wait for the spin off to get more information.

I mentioned some folk positing that Judith was the cure.

 

[NewlyRetired]

If everyone is infected and if they die they turn into a zombie means the lifespan of the earth is merely as long as the longest living human can manage to stay alive, no more. Is there anything at all to suggest this is not the case?

People can still get pregnant and give birth.

I was under the impression the virus spread first like a flu. Then the ones that were symptomatic died and turned and started eating everyone or they survived.

So the survivors now are yes/no??? still contagious to someone without exposure??

I would assume those that are carriers is like aids. the baby probably has it or else also got it and was non symptomatic.

What plotline would tell you this baby is the cure?

I did not say the baby was the cure. I was pointing out that your statement (see bolded above) might not be true if people keep having kids.

We know next to nothing about the initial outbreak. Neither the tv series, the webisodes or the comics touch on it in any great depth

We have an "early days" webisode and one line from Jenner to base everything on.

I think we need to wait for the spin off to get more information.

I mentioned some folk positing that Judith was the cure.

I realize that. I thought he was asking me the question. I must have misunderstood his post.

 

[roadkill1292]

A hypothetical floated at another board: if Rick dies in the next episode, who would and who should take up the role of group leader?

 

[Parrothead]

A hypothetical floated at another board: if Rick dies in the next episode, who would and who should take up the role of group leader?

Abraham

Carol

 

[El Floppo]

A hypothetical floated at another board: if Rick dies in the next episode, who would and who should take up the role of group leader?

Abraham

Carol

Kaaaaaaaaaaaarl

more likely Darryl or Meeeshawn

 

[Jules Winnfield]

If everyone is infected and if they die they turn into a zombie means the lifespan of the earth is merely as long as the longest living human can manage to stay alive, no more. Is there anything at all to suggest this is not the case?

People can still get pregnant and give birth.

you forgot about the stinky hoo-hah syndrome limiting such things.

Have they had any running water since the farm? (I am assuming the farm had some because of the wells but they never showed a shower being used I don't think).

They have to be beyond ripe right now and that is not even taking into account where are they all taking their dumps.

Zombies eating the poop?

 

[flapgreen]

It's a rare show that imo got better with age.

Watched chunks of a few of the old episodes this past weekend on some marathon thing they were running.

The mid season finale where they shoot up all the walkers in the barn is still one of the single best 5 minutes of any program I have ever watched, movie or TV show. It was like a really long wick on a giant bomb, and BOOM. Then super duper sadness like 5 seconds later. God Shane's character was so fabulous.

The other two I saw were the episode where Rick reunites with his wife/son and Shane, and the episode where they are at the CDC. Both awesome. So different than the episodes now.

Rememer when one walker took em like 10 seconds to kill and it was always super dangerous??

The dialogue and writing is vastly improved since the first 2 seasons. Some of the dialogue was so forced it got to the point where I just pushed through to some of the action sequences that seemed to matter and focused most on the characters that I knew were going to live to Season 5. I may have missed some of the decent shane stuff as I felt it somewhat pointless to watch him as I knew going into it just from hearing people around IRL discuss the show before that he didn't make it long. I knew that the farm season sort of sucked so I maybe only really watched 50% of the non action stuff there.

I mean the upgrade from the writing was most evident in old guy #1 with the winnebago compared to Herschel. Old Guy 1 was just a cardboard cutout of an old dude. By about the point where the Governor turned up it was 10x better. Some of that was death of the more boring characters and actors. But most was writing.

Second half of Season 2 was the best stretch of the series. I'd hate to fast forward through stuff and miss something important.

 

[BustedKnuckles]

The First 2 Minutes of the Mid-Season Premiere: The Walking Dead: Season 5

 

[Loan Sharks]

If everyone is infected and if they die they turn into a zombie means the lifespan of the earth is merely as long as the longest living human can manage to stay alive, no more. Is there anything at all to suggest this is not the case?

People can still get pregnant and give birth.

I was under the impression the virus spread first like a flu. Then the ones that were symptomatic died and turned and started eating everyone or they survived.

So the survivors now are yes/no??? still contagious to someone without exposure??

I would assume those that are carriers is like aids. the baby probably has it or else also got it and was non symptomatic.

What plotline would tell you this baby is the cure?

I did not say the baby was the cure. I was pointing out that your statement (see bolded above) might not be true if people keep having kids.

We know next to nothing about the initial outbreak. Neither the tv series, the webisodes or the comics touch on it in any great depth

We have an "early days" webisode and one line from Jenner to base everything on.

I think we need to wait for the spin off to get more information.

I mentioned some folk positing that Judith was the cure.

Fact is two infected people did the nasty and had a baby that did not die so it is at least possible to repopulate to some extent.

 

[culdeus]

The First 2 Minutes of the Mid-Season Premiere: The Walking Dead: Season 5

That looks more like a preview than the first two minutes. Just fyi for spoiler alerts

 

[skol asylum]

I'm so glad Dale is dead

Wait, what? I thought he was running the lawnmowing service with Laurie?

 

[NewlyRetired]

Imo, Dale and Andrea were the two worst character changes they made from the comics to the tv show. They were both relatively beloved characters in the comics, but in the tv show they were both detestable.

 

[flapgreen]

Agreed. Horrible characters

 

[SacramentoBob]

Watching some old episodes and damn was Carl young.

 

[bigmarc27]

If everyone is infected and if they die they turn into a zombie means the lifespan of the earth is merely as long as the longest living human can manage to stay alive, no more. Is there anything at all to suggest this is not the case?

People can still get pregnant and give birth.

I was under the impression the virus spread first like a flu. Then the ones that were symptomatic died and turned and started eating everyone or they survived.

So the survivors now are yes/no??? still contagious to someone without exposure??

I would assume those that are carriers is like aids. the baby probably has it or else also got it and was non symptomatic.

What plotline would tell you this baby is the cure?

I wouldn't overthink it.

This show is better if you suspend logic and just take it for what it is. If you start questioning the pandemic and the motives and such, it falls apart pretty quickly.

 

[RaiderBones]

waaaaaa, no WAlking Dead tonight, waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa

Sooo...this Z Nation show...any good?

I have seen a few episodes. I actually think its pretty good.

Doc cracks me up. He has the best lines in the show.

 

[BustedKnuckles]

waaaaaa, no WAlking Dead tonight, waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa

Sooo...this Z Nation show...any good?

I have seen a few episodes. I actually think its pretty good.

Doc cracks me up. He has the best lines in the show.

it moves along at a much faster pace than TWD

 

[tommyboy]

How/when did we determine everyone has the virus and will turn when they die?

 

[FreeBaGeL]

It's a rare show that imo got better with age.

Watched chunks of a few of the old episodes this past weekend on some marathon thing they were running.

The mid season finale where they shoot up all the walkers in the barn is still one of the single best 5 minutes of any program I have ever watched, movie or TV show. It was like a really long wick on a giant bomb, and BOOM. Then super duper sadness like 5 seconds later. God Shane's character was so fabulous.

The other two I saw were the episode where Rick reunites with his wife/son and Shane, and the episode where they are at the CDC. Both awesome. So different than the episodes now.

Rememer when one walker took em like 10 seconds to kill and it was always super dangerous??

The dialogue and writing is vastly improved since the first 2 seasons. Some of the dialogue was so forced it got to the point where I just pushed through to some of the action sequences that seemed to matter and focused most on the characters that I knew were going to live to Season 5. I may have missed some of the decent shane stuff as I felt it somewhat pointless to watch him as I knew going into it just from hearing people around IRL discuss the show before that he didn't make it long. I knew that the farm season sort of sucked so I maybe only really watched 50% of the non action stuff there.

I mean the upgrade from the writing was most evident in old guy #1 with the winnebago compared to Herschel. Old Guy 1 was just a cardboard cutout of an old dude. By about the point where the Governor turned up it was 10x better. Some of that was death of the more boring characters and actors. But most was writing.

If you asked me "of all the things in the universe, what is the thing that you can most count on getting worse every year?" I would have answered "the writing on TWD since the end of season 2".

Seriously, they don't even bother trying to make up a believable way for people to get into trouble with walkers anymore. They commonly just have walkers sneak up on people in the middle of the woods. A freaking ninja couldn't sneak up on someone in the middle of the woods but mindless walkers dragging their feet through every twig and rustly leaf imaginable just come out of nowhere.

 

[FreeBaGeL]

How/when did we determine everyone has the virus and will turn when they die?

Season 2 finale.

"We're all infected. At the CDC, Jenner told me. Whatever it is, we all carry it."

 

[BustedKnuckles]

How/when did we determine everyone has the virus and will turn when they die?

a scientist at the CDC whispered it in Ricks ear before he died

 

[FreeBaGeL]

Imo, Dale and Andrea were the two worst character changes they made from the comics to the tv show. They were both relatively beloved characters in the comics, but in the tv show they were both detestable.

Andrea was OK until the Governor plotline where she went into full-on ##### mode.

 

[tommyboy]

Andrea was always a follower and weak

 

[BustedKnuckles]

Andrea was always a follower and weak

but she was pretty hot

 

[flapgreen]

It's a rare show that imo got better with age.

Watched chunks of a few of the old episodes this past weekend on some marathon thing they were running.

The mid season finale where they shoot up all the walkers in the barn is still one of the single best 5 minutes of any program I have ever watched, movie or TV show. It was like a really long wick on a giant bomb, and BOOM. Then super duper sadness like 5 seconds later. God Shane's character was so fabulous.

The other two I saw were the episode where Rick reunites with his wife/son and Shane, and the episode where they are at the CDC. Both awesome. So different than the episodes now.

Rememer when one walker took em like 10 seconds to kill and it was always super dangerous??

The dialogue and writing is vastly improved since the first 2 seasons. Some of the dialogue was so forced it got to the point where I just pushed through to some of the action sequences that seemed to matter and focused most on the characters that I knew were going to live to Season 5. I may have missed some of the decent shane stuff as I felt it somewhat pointless to watch him as I knew going into it just from hearing people around IRL discuss the show before that he didn't make it long. I knew that the farm season sort of sucked so I maybe only really watched 50% of the non action stuff there.

I mean the upgrade from the writing was most evident in old guy #1 with the winnebago compared to Herschel. Old Guy 1 was just a cardboard cutout of an old dude. By about the point where the Governor turned up it was 10x better. Some of that was death of the more boring characters and actors. But most was writing.

If you asked me "of all the things in the universe, what is the thing that you can most count on getting worse every year?" I would have answered "the writing on TWD since the end of season 2".

Seriously, they don't even bother trying to make up a believable way for people to get into trouble with walkers anymore. They commonly just have walkers sneak up on people in the middle of the woods. A freaking ninja couldn't sneak up on someone in the middle of the woods but mindless walkers dragging their feet through every twig and rustly leaf imaginable just come out of nowhere.

I'm not a fan of seeing walkers sneak upon people in the middle of the woods. Ridiculous part of the show

 

[tdoss]

Imo, Dale and Andrea were the two worst character changes they made from the comics to the tv show. They were both relatively beloved characters in the comics, but in the tv show they were both detestable.

And Cryrese? I haven't read the comics but is this dude this damned whiny in the comics?

 

[tommyboy]

Watching it now, its actually season one finale. Everyone younger looking, cdc explosion is unreal, the zombie killings werent as "ripe". Lori was hot, id give her the best 8 seconds of her life. However, no scene where doctor says that everyone has it. There is a scene where doctor whispers in ricks ear but you cant hear what he said

Stumped

 

[Homer J Simpson]

Watching it now, its actually season one finale. Everyone younger looking, cdc explosion is unreal, the zombie killings werent as "ripe". Lori was hot, id give her the best 8 seconds of her life. However, no scene where doctor says that everyone has it. There is a scene where doctor whispers in ricks ear but you cant hear what he said

Stumped

Rick tells them later.

 

[skol asylum]

Its first confirmed that everyone has it when Shane is killed and turns if i remember correctly.

 

[NewlyRetired]

Imo, Dale and Andrea were the two worst character changes they made from the comics to the tv show. They were both relatively beloved characters in the comics, but in the tv show they were both detestable.

And Cryrese? I haven't read the comics but is this dude this damned whiny in the comics?

Are you talking about Tyrese? In the comics he was a very conflicted character but tougher than the TV version. In the comics he dies the death that Herschel got on tv.

 

[NewlyRetired]

Imo, Dale and Andrea were the two worst character changes they made from the comics to the tv show. They were both relatively beloved characters in the comics, but in the tv show they were both detestable.

Andrea was OK until the Governor plotline where she went into full-on ##### mode.

She was a pretty hefty ##### before that as well going all the way back to the original camp and particularly at the farm when she was so ignorant that she almost killed Daryl.

She was a dead eye shooter in the comics, but much more demure and likable.

 

[tommyboy]

Watched the shane death episode again, i had forgotten he turned and carl blasted him in the eyeball. Great scene

Thx homer

 

[(HULK)]

Its first confirmed that everyone has it when Shane is killed and turns if i remember correctly.

Prior to that, Shane finds some security guards who turned but had no bite marks.

 

[ClownCausedChaos2]

Its first confirmed that everyone has it when Shane is killed and turns if i remember correctly.

Prior to that, Shane finds some security guards who turned but had no bite marks.

I thought it started with that kid they took hostage. Shane broke his neck and he turned.

 

[NewlyRetired]

Its first confirmed that everyone has it when Shane is killed and turns if i remember correctly.

Prior to that, Shane finds some security guards who turned but had no bite marks.

I thought it started with that kid they took hostage. Shane broke his neck and he turned.

That was after they find the security guards with no bites. There were a handful of clues given before Rick finally told everyone what Jenner said.

 

[packersfan]

Based on their conversation last night I wonder if Steven Yeun and Conan read this thread. They had a lot of fun tearing apart all the over-anxiety that often comes with stuff like the lawns being mowed and gasoline's expiration dates. It was pretty funny.

 

[stbugs]

Its first confirmed that everyone has it when Shane is killed and turns if i remember correctly.

Prior to that, Shane finds some security guards who turned but had no bite marks.

I thought it started with that kid they took hostage. Shane broke his neck and he turned.

That was after they find the security guards with no bites. There were a handful of clues given before Rick finally told everyone what Jenner said.

Yep, they said the security guards didn't look like they had bites. That was a clue to us that something else was going on and Rick spilled the beans when they were on the run from the farm on that road. Everyone was starting to get mad at Rick, including his ##### wife who somehow was mad at him for killing Shane when Shane was going to kill Rick. He said Jenner told him, but he didn't believe it until he saw Shane turn after getting shot and not bit.

ETA: You are correct on the timing. The kid was with them when they saw the security guards, before Shane let him go to kill him.

 

[packersfan]

Lori goading Rick into killing Shane and then getting pissed at Rick when he did was a pretty bat-chit crazy ### turn even by nutty AMC wife standards.

 

[NewlyRetired]

Lori goading Rick into killing Shane and then getting pissed at Rick when he did was a pretty bat-chit crazy ### turn even by nutty AMC wife standards.

I enjoyed her ####### Shane, then getting pissed at Shane when Rick comes back like she did nothing wrong, then telling Shane not to ever talk to Carl, and then getting pissed at Shane for not talking to Carl.

 

[packersfan]

Lori goading Rick into killing Shane and then getting pissed at Rick when he did was a pretty bat-chit crazy ### turn even by nutty AMC wife standards.

I enjoyed her ####### Shane, then getting pissed at Shane when Rick comes back like she did nothing wrong, then telling Shane not to ever talk to Carl, and then getting pissed at Shane for not talking to Carl.

I liked it too. Just saying Lori was pretty off-the-hook at that point. AMC has a strong history of the wives of their show's lead characters becoming completely unlikable at times. Lori did it here but to her credit she did it with gusto.

 

[NewlyRetired]

Lori goading Rick into killing Shane and then getting pissed at Rick when he did was a pretty bat-chit crazy ### turn even by nutty AMC wife standards.

I enjoyed her ####### Shane, then getting pissed at Shane when Rick comes back like she did nothing wrong, then telling Shane not to ever talk to Carl, and then getting pissed at Shane for not talking to Carl.

I liked it too. Just saying Lori was pretty off-the-hook at that point. AMC has a strong history of the wives of their show's lead characters becoming completely unlikable at times. Lori did it here but to her credit she did it with gusto.

The ##### off between her and Andrea at the farm was great. They kept trying to top each other for Queen #####.

 

[kentric]

If everyone is infected and if they die they turn into a zombie means the lifespan of the earth is merely as long as the longest living human can manage to stay alive, no more. Is there anything at all to suggest this is not the case?

People can still get pregnant and give birth.

you forgot about the stinky hoo-hah syndrome limiting such things.

Have they had any running water since the farm? (I am assuming the farm had some because of the wells but they never showed a shower being used I don't think).

They have to be beyond ripe right now and that is not even taking into account where are they all taking their dumps.

I would think after a while you senses get immune to the smell. Plus, its got to be better than zombies who have been slowly falling apart for a few years.

 

[packersfan]

Lori goading Rick into killing Shane and then getting pissed at Rick when he did was a pretty bat-chit crazy ### turn even by nutty AMC wife standards.

I enjoyed her ####### Shane, then getting pissed at Shane when Rick comes back like she did nothing wrong, then telling Shane not to ever talk to Carl, and then getting pissed at Shane for not talking to Carl.

I liked it too. Just saying Lori was pretty off-the-hook at that point. AMC has a strong history of the wives of their show's lead characters becoming completely unlikable at times. Lori did it here but to her credit she did it with gusto.

The ##### off between her and Andrea at the farm was great. They kept trying to top each other for Queen #####.

Season 2 was so great on so many levels. I still think it's the best season of the series to date although the current one is making a strong run at the top.

 

[kentric]

Lori goading Rick into killing Shane and then getting pissed at Rick when he did was a pretty bat-chit crazy ### turn even by nutty AMC wife standards.

I enjoyed her ####### Shane, then getting pissed at Shane when Rick comes back like she did nothing wrong, then telling Shane not to ever talk to Carl, and then getting pissed at Shane for not talking to Carl.

I liked it too. Just saying Lori was pretty off-the-hook at that point. AMC has a strong history of the wives of their show's lead characters becoming completely unlikable at times. Lori did it here but to her credit she did it with gusto.

My favorite Lori moment was her crashing her car when there anything near her to cause a crash.

 

[stbugs]

Imo, Dale and Andrea were the two worst character changes they made from the comics to the tv show. They were both relatively beloved characters in the comics, but in the tv show they were both detestable.

Andrea was OK until the Governor plotline where she went into full-on ##### mode.

She was a pretty hefty ##### before that as well going all the way back to the original camp and particularly at the farm when she was so ignorant that she almost killed Daryl.

She was a dead eye shooter in the comics, but much more demure and likable.

I've said this a few times in here, but they had a great chance to redeem her after what I thought was her best scene in the show. When the Governor was after her in that factory and she tricked him with the open door for zombies and stand behind it, they should have ended the Governor then. It was a great scene and they missed a golden opportunity to just rip him to shreds right there. They could have worked the prison tank attack with Rodriguez, etc., and killed Andrea during that attack. If she had killed him there, bam, clean slate and she is a good character.

 

[packersfan]

Lori goading Rick into killing Shane and then getting pissed at Rick when he did was a pretty bat-chit crazy ### turn even by nutty AMC wife standards.

I enjoyed her ####### Shane, then getting pissed at Shane when Rick comes back like she did nothing wrong, then telling Shane not to ever talk to Carl, and then getting pissed at Shane for not talking to Carl.

I liked it too. Just saying Lori was pretty off-the-hook at that point. AMC has a strong history of the wives of their show's lead characters becoming completely unlikable at times. Lori did it here but to her credit she did it with gusto.

My favorite Lori moment was her crashing her car when there anything near her to cause a crash.

Wasn't she swerving to avoid a walker in the road?

The crash made plenty of sense. What didn't was Lori leaving the farm to go and leaving Carl alone after being upset with Rick that he was leaving them alone.

 

[(HULK)]

Lori has redeemed herself with all of the lawn mowing she's done. She's paid for her crimes.