QB Brock Purdy, SF (1 Viewer)

[N Zone]

Brock Purdy is #3 in QB Rating for the last 2 years (2023 - 2024)

NFL Passer Rating Leader 2023 To 2024 | StatMuse

Since 2023, Lamar Jackson had the best passer rating, with a 111.3 rating.

www.statmuse.com

I don't give a F if you think he doesn't have enough zip on the ball He gets the job done at an extremely high level.
Brock Purdy is FIRST over the last 2 years (2023 -2024) in yards per attempt, the most decisive measure of a QB's ability, in my opinion.

NFL Passer Rating Leader 2023 To 2024 | StatMuse

Since 2023, Lamar Jackson had the best passer rating, with a 111.3 rating.

www.statmuse.com

Results don't lie.
Pay that man his money.

 

[drummer]

BTW, this is the thing that a few who cover the NFL said about Purdy in his last few games but didn't point out this:

The difference of the 49ers having a winning season - never mind Purdy blowing a potential playoff slot against the Rams when the 49ers could only score 6 points, and was a winnable game until the game was in Purdy's hands - was that against the Dolphins the next week, 2 minutes to go and on offense, the lack of clutch sealed a losing season with a Purdy soul crushing INT guarntteed a sub .500 season, Kyle Shanahan's 4th out of 8 seasons. Purdy not only had thrown season ending and game ending INT's, but now had split Shanahan's W/L record overall with some of the worst clutch QB play down the stretch in game that were within 3, 5, and 7 points. And then he couldn't even finish the season. Why? He got hurt again. Purdy alone cost them the final four games all due to him. He alone is the difference between the 49ers being a 6 win team to a 10 win team. Because how he finished the season with winnable games.

A better QB would had won more games with this team despite all the injuries. Just because he would had won those last four games down the stretch.

 

[drummer]

Brock Purdy is #3 in QB Rating for the last 2 years (2023 - 2024)

NFL Passer Rating Leader 2023 To 2024 | StatMuse

Since 2023, Lamar Jackson had the best passer rating, with a 111.3 rating.

www.statmuse.com

I don't give a F if you think he doesn't have enough zip on the ball He gets the job done at an extremely high level.
Brock Purdy is FIRST over the last 2 years (2023 -2024) in yards per attempt, the most decisive measure of a QB's ability, in my opinion.

NFL Passer Rating Leader 2023 To 2024 | StatMuse

Since 2023, Lamar Jackson had the best passer rating, with a 111.3 rating.

www.statmuse.com

Results don't lie.
Pay that man his money.

If you're going to pay anyone due to passer rating, than that's why you'll never be anyone who holds the purse strings.

BTW, Kyle Shanahan would pay Lamar Jackson more money than tiny Brock Purdy, simply because Brock Purdy can't beat Lamar Jackson or Patrick Mahomes, Josh Allen, or Joe Burrow.

 

[travdogg]

49ers motivated to get Brock Purdy's extension done quickly

After reading those love filled quotes from the HC and GM to Purdy Im pretty confident that he's getting locked up. Id buy low for next year if there is a dip

What is the floor on his annual salary. 50?

Id be guessing but I cant see less than $50M

Yeah. Looks like the franchise tag is gonna be like $41M, so makes sense.

I'd say $53M is the floor.

AAVs of guys who signed in 2024
Dak Prescott - $60M
Trevor Lawrence - $55M
Jordan Love - $55M
Tua Tagovailoa - $53.1M
Jared Goff - $53M

Then you got guys like: Kirk Cousins ($45M) and Baker Mayfield ($33.3M)

There's a good argument for Brock Purdy>every QB on that list. Goff has a chance to maybe change that these next 3 weeks, but right now, I think Purdy (youth helps too) has the edge

 

[Snotbubbles]

49ers motivated to get Brock Purdy's extension done quickly

After reading those love filled quotes from the HC and GM to Purdy Im pretty confident that he's getting locked up. Id buy low for next year if there is a dip

What is the floor on his annual salary. 50?

Id be guessing but I cant see less than $50M

Yeah. Looks like the franchise tag is gonna be like $41M, so makes sense.

I'd say $53M is the floor.

AAVs of guys who signed in 2024
Dak Prescott - $60M
Trevor Lawrence - $55M
Jordan Love - $55M
Tua Tagovailoa - $53.1M
Jared Goff - $53M

Then you got guys like: Kirk Cousins ($45M) and Baker Mayfield ($33.3M)

There's a good argument for Brock Purdy>every QB on that list. Goff has a chance to maybe change that these next 3 weeks, but right now, I think Purdy (youth helps too) has the edge

Honestly, it doesn't even matter if he's better or not, that's the QB market right now. If not SF, then someone will pay him in that range. They can play the tag game all they want, and it will either lead to the floor going from $53M to $60M or him leaving and them starting over at the position. The 49ers have enough data on Purdy to know if they want to keep him long-term, waiting to sign him is not wise.

 

[Kiddnets]

You can definitely debate how good Purdy is - but you cant debate he's better in this system than any other available QB. There is no alternative that makes sense to me - they are going to pay him

 

[joey]

It’s like screaming in the wind.
Can’t change the laws of physics and you can’t change the QB market in the NFL.

 

[drummer]

49ers motivated to get Brock Purdy's extension done quickly

After reading those love filled quotes from the HC and GM to Purdy Im pretty confident that he's getting locked up. Id buy low for next year if there is a dip

What is the floor on his annual salary. 50?

Id be guessing but I cant see less than $50M

Yeah. Looks like the franchise tag is gonna be like $41M, so makes sense.

I'd say $53M is the floor.

AAVs of guys who signed in 2024
Dak Prescott - $60M
Trevor Lawrence - $55M
Jordan Love - $55M
Tua Tagovailoa - $53.1M
Jared Goff - $53M

Then you got guys like: Kirk Cousins ($45M) and Baker Mayfield ($33.3M)

There's a good argument for Brock Purdy>every QB on that list. Goff has a chance to maybe change that these next 3 weeks, but right now, I think Purdy (youth helps too) has the edge

Honestly, it doesn't even matter if he's better or not, that's the QB market right now. If not SF, then someone will pay him in that range. They can play the tag game all they want, and it will either lead to the floor going from $53M to $60M or him leaving and them starting over at the position. The 49ers have enough data on Purdy to know if they want to keep him long-term, waiting to sign him is not wise.

They can wait, he's still under contract. It's really about guaranteed money. The 49ers really would want back the deal they made with Aiyuk, they would be in the same situation with Purdy, who is tiny and for sure will wind up in IR like Garoppolo once they give him a max contract filled with guaranteed money since he is again a tiny QB with a suspect arm. He owes his value to CMC, and that highest payed player at his position could only start four games this past regular season and could be cooked for the next. If CMC were healthy and 100% CMC, the 49ers would be in the playoffs. But he wasn't, and they wound up 6-10. With Purdy not affecting their books, who have a ton of money spent on players who could be sunsetting.

 

[Tau837]

49ers motivated to get Brock Purdy's extension done quickly

After reading those love filled quotes from the HC and GM to Purdy Im pretty confident that he's getting locked up. Id buy low for next year if there is a dip

What is the floor on his annual salary. 50?

Id be guessing but I cant see less than $50M

Yeah. Looks like the franchise tag is gonna be like $41M, so makes sense.

I'd say $53M is the floor.

AAVs of guys who signed in 2024
Dak Prescott - $60M
Trevor Lawrence - $55M
Jordan Love - $55M
Tua Tagovailoa - $53.1M
Jared Goff - $53M

Then you got guys like: Kirk Cousins ($45M) and Baker Mayfield ($33.3M)

There's a good argument for Brock Purdy>every QB on that list. Goff has a chance to maybe change that these next 3 weeks, but right now, I think Purdy (youth helps too) has the edge

Honestly, it doesn't even matter if he's better or not, that's the QB market right now. If not SF, then someone will pay him in that range. They can play the tag game all they want, and it will either lead to the floor going from $53M to $60M or him leaving and them starting over at the position. The 49ers have enough data on Purdy to know if they want to keep him long-term, waiting to sign him is not wise.

They can wait, he's still under contract. It's really about guaranteed money. The 49ers really would want back the deal they made with Aiyuk, they would be in the same situation with Purdy, who is tiny and for sure will wind up in IR like Garoppolo once they give him a max contract filled with guaranteed money since he is again a tiny QB with a suspect arm. He owes his value to CMC, and that highest payed player at his position could only start four games this past regular season and could be cooked for the next. If CMC were healthy and 100% CMC, the 49ers would be in the playoffs. But he wasn't, and they wound up 6-10. With Purdy not affecting their books, who have a ton of money spent on players who could be sunsetting.

This insistence you have on repeatedly calling Purdy tiny hurts your credibility.

• 2024 starters shorter than Purdy (6'1"): Wilson, Murray, Young
• 2024 starters with same height as Purdy (6'1"): Hurts, Mayfield, Tua, Caleb, Minshew
• 2024 starters who weigh less than Purdy (220 lbs): Jackson, Burrow, Goff, Love, Daniels, Stroud, Stafford, Mayfield, Nix, Caleb, Wilson, Murray, Young, Carr
• 2024 starters with same weight as Purdy (220 lbs): Lawrence, Penix

He is as tall as a quarter of the starting QBs in the league and weighs as much as half of the starters in the league. Most of the others outweigh him by 5 pounds or less. This entire premise seems off base and unnecessary to the conversation.

As for "they can wait", he will be a UFA after next season. They will pay more to keep him after next season than they will this offseason, unless he suffers a major injury (not predictable) or falls off a performance cliff (very unlikely).

 

[thecatch]

For a guy who hasn't been playing, Purdy's been having a great postseason.

 

[Faust]

Brock Purdy's extension: When could it happen and how much?

 

[(HULK)]

49ers motivated to get Brock Purdy's extension done quickly

After reading those love filled quotes from the HC and GM to Purdy Im pretty confident that he's getting locked up. Id buy low for next year if there is a dip

What is the floor on his annual salary. 50?

Id be guessing but I cant see less than $50M

Yeah. Looks like the franchise tag is gonna be like $41M, so makes sense.

I'd say $53M is the floor.

AAVs of guys who signed in 2024
Dak Prescott - $60M
Trevor Lawrence - $55M
Jordan Love - $55M
Tua Tagovailoa - $53.1M
Jared Goff - $53M

Then you got guys like: Kirk Cousins ($45M) and Baker Mayfield ($33.3M)

There's a good argument for Brock Purdy>every QB on that list. Goff has a chance to maybe change that these next 3 weeks, but right now, I think Purdy (youth helps too) has the edge

Honestly, it doesn't even matter if he's better or not, that's the QB market right now. If not SF, then someone will pay him in that range. They can play the tag game all they want, and it will either lead to the floor going from $53M to $60M or him leaving and them starting over at the position. The 49ers have enough data on Purdy to know if they want to keep him long-term, waiting to sign him is not wise.

They can wait, he's still under contract. It's really about guaranteed money. The 49ers really would want back the deal they made with Aiyuk, they would be in the same situation with Purdy, who is tiny and for sure will wind up in IR like Garoppolo once they give him a max contract filled with guaranteed money since he is again a tiny QB with a suspect arm. He owes his value to CMC, and that highest payed player at his position could only start four games this past regular season and could be cooked for the next. If CMC were healthy and 100% CMC, the 49ers would be in the playoffs. But he wasn't, and they wound up 6-10. With Purdy not affecting their books, who have a ton of money spent on players who could be sunsetting.

You sure seem confident and certain about a lot of uncertain things. FWIW, this makes you feel much less credible to me.

 

[Wingnut]

Yall new to these forums? It's always the same with that guy. Not even worth reading.

 

[LawFitz]

FTR, once the Raiders get their HC, I'd luv it if they traded #6 this year and their 2026 1st for Purdy, and then paid him $55 MM per for 4-5 years.

Not happening, but a Purdy fan can dream. I think he is still disrespected for being Mr. I.

 

[JoeJoe88]

FTR, once the Raiders get their HC, I'd luv it if they traded #6 this year and their 2026 1st for Purdy, and then paid him $55 MM per for 4-5 years.

Not happening, but a Purdy fan can dream. I think he is still disrespected for being Mr. I.

I’ve said this multiple times but if he were a 1st round pick as opposed to a 7th he wouldn’t get nearly the criticism he does. People just can’t separate the draft capital from what he’s actually done on the field in his short NFL career.

 

[Faust]

Owner Jed York: 49ers will 'do everything' to extend Brock Purdy

 

[travdogg]

FTR, once the Raiders get their HC, I'd luv it if they traded #6 this year and their 2026 1st for Purdy, and then paid him $55 MM per for 4-5 years.

Not happening, but a Purdy fan can dream. I think he is still disrespected for being Mr. I.

I’ve said this multiple times but if he were a 1st round pick as opposed to a 7th he wouldn’t get nearly the criticism he does. People just can’t separate the draft capital from what he’s actually done on the field in his short NFL career.

100% agree. There aren't 10 better QBs in the NFL.

 

[TheDirtyWord]

FTR, once the
Raiders
get their HC, I'd luv it if they traded #6 this year and their 2026 1st for
Purdy
, and then paid him $55 MM per for 4-5 years.

Not happening, but a
Purdy
fan can dream. I think he is still disrespected for being Mr. I.

I’ve said this multiple times but if he were a 1st round pick as opposed to a 7th he wouldn’t get nearly the criticism he does. People just can’t separate the draft capital from what he’s actually done on the field in his short NFL career.

100% agree. There aren't 10 better QBs in the NFL.

While I do think people have jumped off his bandwagon a little because of that 7th round stigma...I do think he benefits greatly from the Shanahan effect.

 

[JohnnyU]

FTR, once the
Raiders
get their HC, I'd luv it if they traded #6 this year and their 2026 1st for
Purdy
, and then paid him $55 MM per for 4-5 years.

Not happening, but a
Purdy
fan can dream. I think he is still disrespected for being Mr. I.

I’ve said this multiple times but if he were a 1st round pick as opposed to a 7th he wouldn’t get nearly the criticism he does. People just can’t separate the draft capital from what he’s actually done on the field in his short NFL career.

100% agree. There aren't 10 better QBs in the NFL.

While I do think people have jumped off his bandwagon a little because of that 7th round stigma...I do think he benefits greatly from the Shanahan effect.

I think the "Shanahan effect" is overstated. That asside, I thought Purdy did OK after all his weapons went down and should look more like 2023 once everyone is healthy.

 

[Kiddnets]

FTR, once the
Raiders
get their HC, I'd luv it if they traded #6 this year and their 2026 1st for
Purdy
, and then paid him $55 MM per for 4-5 years.

Not happening, but a
Purdy
fan can dream. I think he is still disrespected for being Mr. I.

I’ve said this multiple times but if he were a 1st round pick as opposed to a 7th he wouldn’t get nearly the criticism he does. People just can’t separate the draft capital from what he’s actually done on the field in his short NFL career.

100% agree. There aren't 10 better QBs in the NFL.

While I do think people have jumped off his bandwagon a little because of that 7th round stigma...I do think he benefits greatly from the Shanahan effect.

I think the "Shanahan effect" is overstated. That asside, I thought Purdy did OK after all his weapons went down and should look more like 2023 once everyone is healthy.

Definite buy low window - even if Deebo is traded he has enough weapons to be a clear top 10 QB.

 

[Ray_T]

FTR, once the
Raiders
get their HC, I'd luv it if they traded #6 this year and their 2026 1st for
Purdy
, and then paid him $55 MM per for 4-5 years.

Not happening, but a
Purdy
fan can dream. I think he is still disrespected for being Mr. I.

I’ve said this multiple times but if he were a 1st round pick as opposed to a 7th he wouldn’t get nearly the criticism he does. People just can’t separate the draft capital from what he’s actually done on the field in his short NFL career.

100% agree. There aren't 10 better QBs in the NFL.

While I do think people have jumped off his bandwagon a little because of that 7th round stigma...I do think he benefits greatly from the Shanahan effect.

I think the "Shanahan effect" is overstated. That asside, I thought Purdy did OK after all his weapons went down and should look more like 2023 once everyone is healthy.

maybe, but maybe not.

there are system QB's who really can only excel in a certain type of system. I think he may be one of those. Hes good where he is at. but I'm not sure he does better if he leaves to chase dollars.

its a good offense with playmakers and a good line. This limits what a defense can do. Take away the line or some of the playmakers and hes likely no longer the player he is now.

I'd suggest its good for both sides to sign this deal. Purdy's greatest value is where he is at, and San Fran needs him to stay. if Purdy ends up elsewhere it would be bad for both him and for the 49ers

 

[JohnnyU]

FTR, once the
Raiders
get their HC, I'd luv it if they traded #6 this year and their 2026 1st for
Purdy
, and then paid him $55 MM per for 4-5 years.

Not happening, but a
Purdy
fan can dream. I think he is still disrespected for being Mr. I.

I’ve said this multiple times but if he were a 1st round pick as opposed to a 7th he wouldn’t get nearly the criticism he does. People just can’t separate the draft capital from what he’s actually done on the field in his short NFL career.

100% agree. There aren't 10 better QBs in the NFL.

While I do think people have jumped off his bandwagon a little because of that 7th round stigma...I do think he benefits greatly from the Shanahan effect.

I think the "Shanahan effect" is overstated. That asside, I thought Purdy did OK after all his weapons went down and should look more like 2023 once everyone is healthy.

maybe, but maybe not.

there are system QB's who really can only excel in a certain type of system. I think he may be one of those. Hes good where he is at. but I'm not sure he does better if he leaves to chase dollars.

its a good offense with playmakers and a good line. This limits what a defense can do. Take away the line or some of the playmakers and hes likely no longer the player he is now.

I'd suggest its good for both sides to sign this deal. Purdy's greatest value is where he is at, and San Fran needs him to stay. if Purdy ends up elsewhere it would be bad for both him and for the 49ers

I disagree with most of this. I would argue having a good line, coaching and weapons is good for any QB regardless of system. I’ve seen lots of QBs with oodles of talent fuzzle out quickly because of a lack of these things.

 

[thecatch]

FTR, once the
Raiders
get their HC, I'd luv it if they traded #6 this year and their 2026 1st for
Purdy
, and then paid him $55 MM per for 4-5 years.

Not happening, but a
Purdy
fan can dream. I think he is still disrespected for being Mr. I.

I’ve said this multiple times but if he were a 1st round pick as opposed to a 7th he wouldn’t get nearly the criticism he does. People just can’t separate the draft capital from what he’s actually done on the field in his short NFL career.

100% agree. There aren't 10 better QBs in the NFL.

While I do think people have jumped off his bandwagon a little because of that 7th round stigma...I do think he benefits greatly from the Shanahan effect.

I think the "Shanahan effect" is overstated. That asside, I thought Purdy did OK after all his weapons went down and should look more like 2023 once everyone is healthy.

maybe, but maybe not.

there are system QB's who really can only excel in a certain type of system. I think he may be one of those. Hes good where he is at. but I'm not sure he does better if he leaves to chase dollars.

its a good offense with playmakers and a good line. This limits what a defense can do. Take away the line or some of the playmakers and hes likely no longer the player he is now.

I'd suggest its good for both sides to sign this deal. Purdy's greatest value is where he is at, and San Fran needs him to stay. if Purdy ends up elsewhere it would be bad for both him and for the 49ers

Well he had no line and no playmakers last year.

 

[Snotbubbles]

FTR, once the
Raiders
get their HC, I'd luv it if they traded #6 this year and their 2026 1st for
Purdy
, and then paid him $55 MM per for 4-5 years.

Not happening, but a
Purdy
fan can dream. I think he is still disrespected for being Mr. I.

I’ve said this multiple times but if he were a 1st round pick as opposed to a 7th he wouldn’t get nearly the criticism he does. People just can’t separate the draft capital from what he’s actually done on the field in his short NFL career.

100% agree. There aren't 10 better QBs in the NFL.

While I do think people have jumped off his bandwagon a little because of that 7th round stigma...I do think he benefits greatly from the Shanahan effect.

I think the "Shanahan effect" is overstated. That asside, I thought Purdy did OK after all his weapons went down and should look more like 2023 once everyone is healthy.

maybe, but maybe not.

there are system QB's who really can only excel in a certain type of system. I think he may be one of those. Hes good where he is at. but I'm not sure he does better if he leaves to chase dollars.

its a good offense with playmakers and a good line. This limits what a defense can do. Take away the line or some of the playmakers and hes likely no longer the player he is now.

I'd suggest its good for both sides to sign this deal. Purdy's greatest value is where he is at, and San Fran needs him to stay. if Purdy ends up elsewhere it would be bad for both him and for the 49ers

I disagree with most of this. I would argue having a good line, coaching and weapons is good for any QB regardless of system. I’ve seen lots of QBs with oodles of talent fuzzle out quickly because of a lack of these things.

49ers don't have a good offensive line and the one guy who is good is will be 37, anything you get from him past this point is gravy. They're getting ready to trade Deebo Samuel. Their other WR is coming of ACL surgery. They have a RB who has achilles tendonitis and may never be the same player again. Their TE is going to 32. The 49ers are getting ready to take a couple steps back on offense.

 

[JohnnyU]

FTR, once the
Raiders
get their HC, I'd luv it if they traded #6 this year and their 2026 1st for
Purdy
, and then paid him $55 MM per for 4-5 years.

Not happening, but a
Purdy
fan can dream. I think he is still disrespected for being Mr. I.

I’ve said this multiple times but if he were a 1st round pick as opposed to a 7th he wouldn’t get nearly the criticism he does. People just can’t separate the draft capital from what he’s actually done on the field in his short NFL career.

100% agree. There aren't 10 better QBs in the NFL.

While I do think people have jumped off his bandwagon a little because of that 7th round stigma...I do think he benefits greatly from the Shanahan effect.

I think the "Shanahan effect" is overstated. That asside, I thought Purdy did OK after all his weapons went down and should look more like 2023 once everyone is healthy.

maybe, but maybe not.

there are system QB's who really can only excel in a certain type of system. I think he may be one of those. Hes good where he is at. but I'm not sure he does better if he leaves to chase dollars.

its a good offense with playmakers and a good line. This limits what a defense can do. Take away the line or some of the playmakers and hes likely no longer the player he is now.

I'd suggest its good for both sides to sign this deal. Purdy's greatest value is where he is at, and San Fran needs him to stay. if Purdy ends up elsewhere it would be bad for both him and for the 49ers

I disagree with most of this. I would argue having a good line, coaching and weapons is good for any QB regardless of system. I’ve seen lots of QBs with oodles of talent fuzzle out quickly because of a lack of these things.

49ers don't have a good offensive line and the one guy who is good is will be 37, anything you get from him past this point is gravy. They're getting ready to trade Deebo Samuel. Their other WR is coming of ACL surgery. They have a RB who has achilles tendonitis and may never be the same player again. Their TE is going to 32. The 49ers are getting ready to take a couple steps back on offense.

Losing Deebo isn't bad IMO. I think he's almost done anyway. You make good points about the others, but I think CMC will be ready to roll in 2025 and Aiyuk had an ACL and MCL tear, so while I think that is more important to RBs the next yea, and, Aiyuk may be slow to start 2025, but I think could be OK for most of 2025. I can see Pearsall taking another step in 2025, as he started to flash late in the season. Let's see how their OL shapes out going forward. I didn't look up their cap situation, but they may be involved in free agency for OL help if a good one is out there. Hopefully they draft some of both OL and WR.

 

[Ray_T]

FTR, once the
Raiders
get their HC, I'd luv it if they traded #6 this year and their 2026 1st for
Purdy
, and then paid him $55 MM per for 4-5 years.

Not happening, but a
Purdy
fan can dream. I think he is still disrespected for being Mr. I.

I’ve said this multiple times but if he were a 1st round pick as opposed to a 7th he wouldn’t get nearly the criticism he does. People just can’t separate the draft capital from what he’s actually done on the field in his short NFL career.

100% agree. There aren't 10 better QBs in the NFL.

While I do think people have jumped off his bandwagon a little because of that 7th round stigma...I do think he benefits greatly from the Shanahan effect.

I think the "Shanahan effect" is overstated. That asside, I thought Purdy did OK after all his weapons went down and should look more like 2023 once everyone is healthy.

maybe, but maybe not.

there are system QB's who really can only excel in a certain type of system. I think he may be one of those. Hes good where he is at. but I'm not sure he does better if he leaves to chase dollars.

its a good offense with playmakers and a good line. This limits what a defense can do. Take away the line or some of the playmakers and hes likely no longer the player he is now.

I'd suggest its good for both sides to sign this deal. Purdy's greatest value is where he is at, and San Fran needs him to stay. if Purdy ends up elsewhere it would be bad for both him and for the 49ers

I disagree with most of this. I would argue having a good line, coaching and weapons is good for any QB regardless of system. I’ve seen lots of QBs with oodles of talent fuzzle out quickly because of a lack of these things.

49ers don't have a good offensive line and the one guy who is good is will be 37, anything you get from him past this point is gravy. They're getting ready to trade Deebo Samuel. Their other WR is coming of ACL surgery. They have a RB who has achilles tendonitis and may never be the same player again. Their TE is going to 32. The 49ers are getting ready to take a couple steps back on offense.

Losing Deebo isn't bad IMO. I think he's almost done anyway. You make good points about the others, but I think CMC will be ready to roll in 2025 and Aiyuk had an ACL and MCL tear, so while I think that is more important to RBs the next yea, and, Aiyuk may be slow to start 2025, but I think could be OK for most of 2025. I can see Pearsall taking another step in 2025, as he started to flash late in the season. Let's see how their OL shapes out going forward. I didn't look up their cap situation, but they may be involved in free agency for OL help if a good one is out there. Hopefully they draft some of both OL and WR.

honestly, Deebo has had 2 good seasons. thats it.

he had the one 1400 yard season (I think) and then he had a season where he got around 900 yards but likely would have been over 1000 yards if he played the whole year.

other than that hes been nothing special. I suspect its a case where they'd have to overpay to keep him. so it may actually be smart for them to part ways with him now that he has come out and said he wants out.

 

[LawFitz]

he had the one 1400 yard season (I think) and then he had a season where he got around 900 yards but likely would have been over 1000 yards if he played the whole year.

other than that hes been nothing special.

Very much disagree. He may not be the same player now that he once was, but he was indeed special in his prime. Injuries were what prevented him from accumulating stats. On a per-play basis, he was a beast until he wasn't.

 

[Ray_T]

FTR, once the
Raiders
get their HC, I'd luv it if they traded #6 this year and their 2026 1st for
Purdy
, and then paid him $55 MM per for 4-5 years.

Not happening, but a
Purdy
fan can dream. I think he is still disrespected for being Mr. I.

I’ve said this multiple times but if he were a 1st round pick as opposed to a 7th he wouldn’t get nearly the criticism he does. People just can’t separate the draft capital from what he’s actually done on the field in his short NFL career.

100% agree. There aren't 10 better QBs in the NFL.

While I do think people have jumped off his bandwagon a little because of that 7th round stigma...I do think he benefits greatly from the Shanahan effect.

I think the "Shanahan effect" is overstated. That asside, I thought Purdy did OK after all his weapons went down and should look more like 2023 once everyone is healthy.

maybe, but maybe not.

there are system QB's who really can only excel in a certain type of system. I think he may be one of those. Hes good where he is at. but I'm not sure he does better if he leaves to chase dollars.

its a good offense with playmakers and a good line. This limits what a defense can do. Take away the line or some of the playmakers and hes likely no longer the player he is now.

I'd suggest its good for both sides to sign this deal. Purdy's greatest value is where he is at, and San Fran needs him to stay. if Purdy ends up elsewhere it would be bad for both him and for the 49ers

Well he had no line and no playmakers last year.

NFL Offensive Line Rankings 2025: Insights Into All 32 OLs

Our NFL Offensive Line rankings break down all 32 units using our OL+ metric. Where do the Chiefs and Eagles rank ahead of Super Bowl 59?

www.profootballnetwork.com

ok based on this link the 9ers are ranked #14 out of a 30 team league. kinda meh. but not bad. and San fran also has better blocking from the WR than a lot of teams get.

so its not as big a strength as I thought but its not bad. I agree they likely need to address this in the next year or so. I do think Pearsall is ready for more action this year, so it might be a good time to unload Deebo..... maybe for someone that can plug and play on the O line? or just a draft pick

I think the larger issue this year in San fran was the holdout of Aiyuk and the large number of injuries they had this year. My opinion only. but I do think this is a far better team on paper than they performed at and for me this is the main reason why.

 

[thecatch]

FTR, once the
Raiders
get their HC, I'd luv it if they traded #6 this year and their 2026 1st for
Purdy
, and then paid him $55 MM per for 4-5 years.

Not happening, but a
Purdy
fan can dream. I think he is still disrespected for being Mr. I.

I’ve said this multiple times but if he were a 1st round pick as opposed to a 7th he wouldn’t get nearly the criticism he does. People just can’t separate the draft capital from what he’s actually done on the field in his short NFL career.

100% agree. There aren't 10 better QBs in the NFL.

While I do think people have jumped off his bandwagon a little because of that 7th round stigma...I do think he benefits greatly from the Shanahan effect.

I think the "Shanahan effect" is overstated. That asside, I thought Purdy did OK after all his weapons went down and should look more like 2023 once everyone is healthy.

maybe, but maybe not.

there are system QB's who really can only excel in a certain type of system. I think he may be one of those. Hes good where he is at. but I'm not sure he does better if he leaves to chase dollars.

its a good offense with playmakers and a good line. This limits what a defense can do. Take away the line or some of the playmakers and hes likely no longer the player he is now.

I'd suggest its good for both sides to sign this deal. Purdy's greatest value is where he is at, and San Fran needs him to stay. if Purdy ends up elsewhere it would be bad for both him and for the 49ers

Well he had no line and no playmakers last year.

NFL Offensive Line Rankings 2025: Insights Into All 32 OLs

Our NFL Offensive Line rankings break down all 32 units using our OL+ metric. Where do the Chiefs and Eagles rank ahead of Super Bowl 59?

www.profootballnetwork.com

ok based on this link the 9ers are ranked #14 out of a 30 team league. kinda meh. but not bad. and San fran also has better blocking from the WR than a lot of teams get.

so its not as big a strength as I thought but its not bad. I agree they likely need to address this in the next year or so. I do think Pearsall is ready for more action this year, so it might be a good time to unload Deebo..... maybe for someone that can plug and play on the O line? or just a draft pick

I think the larger issue this year in San fran was the holdout of Aiyuk and the large number of injuries they had this year. My opinion only. but I do think this is a far better team on paper than they performed at and for me this is the main reason why.

If the OL ranks as high as 14 by some metrics it's because of scheme, IMO. Trent Williams and Puni are the only above-average linemen they had and Williams didn't play much.

 

[Ray_T]

FTR, once the
Raiders
get their HC, I'd luv it if they traded #6 this year and their 2026 1st for
Purdy
, and then paid him $55 MM per for 4-5 years.

Not happening, but a
Purdy
fan can dream. I think he is still disrespected for being Mr. I.

I’ve said this multiple times but if he were a 1st round pick as opposed to a 7th he wouldn’t get nearly the criticism he does. People just can’t separate the draft capital from what he’s actually done on the field in his short NFL career.

100% agree. There aren't 10 better QBs in the NFL.

While I do think people have jumped off his bandwagon a little because of that 7th round stigma...I do think he benefits greatly from the Shanahan effect.

I think the "Shanahan effect" is overstated. That asside, I thought Purdy did OK after all his weapons went down and should look more like 2023 once everyone is healthy.

maybe, but maybe not.

there are system QB's who really can only excel in a certain type of system. I think he may be one of those. Hes good where he is at. but I'm not sure he does better if he leaves to chase dollars.

its a good offense with playmakers and a good line. This limits what a defense can do. Take away the line or some of the playmakers and hes likely no longer the player he is now.

I'd suggest its good for both sides to sign this deal. Purdy's greatest value is where he is at, and San Fran needs him to stay. if Purdy ends up elsewhere it would be bad for both him and for the 49ers

Well he had no line and no playmakers last year.

NFL Offensive Line Rankings 2025: Insights Into All 32 OLs

Our NFL Offensive Line rankings break down all 32 units using our OL+ metric. Where do the Chiefs and Eagles rank ahead of Super Bowl 59?

www.profootballnetwork.com

ok based on this link the 9ers are ranked #14 out of a 30 team league. kinda meh. but not bad. and San fran also has better blocking from the WR than a lot of teams get.

so its not as big a strength as I thought but its not bad. I agree they likely need to address this in the next year or so. I do think Pearsall is ready for more action this year, so it might be a good time to unload Deebo..... maybe for someone that can plug and play on the O line? or just a draft pick

I think the larger issue this year in San fran was the holdout of Aiyuk and the large number of injuries they had this year. My opinion only. but I do think this is a far better team on paper than they performed at and for me this is the main reason why.

If the OL ranks as high as 14 by some metrics it's because of scheme, IMO. Trent Williams and Puni are the only above-average linemen they had and Williams didn't play much.

yeah that never helps if the players are not on the field.

 

[Faust]

GM: 49ers talking with Purdy, will try to trade Samuel