I just watched it and I didn't think it was really all that bad. Yeah, there are some nitpicks and creative choices that I wouldn't have made and I think the last episode was kinda irrelevant.
Agreed, I think any time there is a child actor with us Boomers it's a tough sell. We aren't the target audience for some facets of these shows.
Overall I liked this show much more than the Acolyte for example.
This has come up a few times before and I think for most people it's not that the show was BAD, just that it was pretty middling despite having insanely incredible source material to work with.
If you'd told me in the past we were getting a show about Obi-Wan where we see prime Vader kicking butt, and a battle between Vader/Obi-Wan we didn't know about, I'd have been jacked to the moon and thought "this is going to be incredible". Instead it was like a network quality TV show. Forgettable and unlikable characters (the ones they added), all the characters making dumb and out of character decisions and changing motivations for no reason other than to advance the plot. Really only one really really cool scene towards the end to redeem the rest of the mediocrity.
Even though it was okay I think it was actually more disappointing than the Acolyte just beacuse the Acolyte was a throwaway storyline and it can just be forgotten. But the source material behind Obi-Wan is now wasted forever, when it should have been done so much better.
I think it's the same thing Rings of Power S1 suffered from. It wasn't BAD per say. It was just pretty a pretty average use of great source material that we'll never get to see done better.