Wheaton or Dobson? Better PPR WR in redraft (1 Viewer)

[JustinHawkins]

Both of these guys are currently running as the #3 WR on their teams (well, I'm giving Wheaton the benefit over Cotchery after an impressive preseason)

Who makes more noise this year in a PPR redraft? Both appear to be guys you can get in rounds 13-15, and I would think have sleeper value. Which one has the bigger year sharks?

 

[steveski]

I would go Wheaton. Dobson hasn't really shown that he can do anything and when Gronk and Amendola are back, I don't see much left for Dobson.

 

[Man of Zen]

Dobson is one twisted ankle to a starter away from being a minor cog in a massive machine.

Wheaton is one twisted ankle to a starter away from being one of only two decent targets on the entire offense, with a QB who likes to take shots deep to speedy receivers.

 

[JustinHawkins]

Man of Zen I know you weren't trying to be funny, but that was funny (and pretty sound logic)

 

[Man of Zen]

FWIW, a minor cog in NE might be worth about the same as a major one in PIT anyway.

 

[BobbyLayne]

I don't think either one is anything more than a bye week filler this year. Questionable Dobson will be among the top 6 in the NE pecking order - Amendola, Gronk (eventually), Vereen, Thompkins, Edelman, and Sudfield (maybe early, maybe not) will all be ahead of him in targets in my view. Wheaton has a very good chance of being #3 in a less potent offense.

I'd be surprised if either topped 25-350-2.