'TobiasFunke said:
Yeah, this is pretty much nonsense in my opinion. He's had overachieving teams on a number of occasions, including two of the last three times UNC wasn't very highly regarded in preseason, 2005-2006 and 2010-2011. Even if this year's team underwhelms he'll still be batting .500 in low expectation seasons at UNC. And the "dominant point guard" thing is sort of a chicken and egg question. Nobody thought Kendall Marshall or Kirk Hinrich were all-world PGs until Roy got a hold of them. And I'm still not sure who the "dominant PG" was on some of those late 90s Kansas teams.
Kendall Marshall was #25 in the RSCI his senior year. That's fairly highly regarded. He had offers from other nationally-competitive schools. Hinrich wasn't quite on the national radar, but that's largely because the national radar wasn't calibrated to find white combo guards from Iowa back in 1999. KU fell backwards into Hinrich (and Nick Collison) because Tim Floyd left Iowa State to take the Bulls job, and landing both players was considered a big deal at the time.
I'm surprised you haven't heard of Jacque Vaughn. He was a McD's AA in high school and was four-year starter and two-time NCAA All-American at Kansas in the mid-late 90s. He played on some great teams with great teammates who went on to better pro careers, but he was a stud college player and is an NBA head coach now.
The year after Vaughn left, KU got knocked out in the second round of the NCAAs by Rhode Island. Even though the Jayhawks had Raef Lafrentz at C and Paul Pierce at SF, they had Ryan Robertson at PG. The next two seasons were Roy's least-successful ones with his own recruits at KU. By the time Hinrich was ready to run the team, KU was a national factor again.