I'm going to step in again after a long hiatus from the thread.
Nice to see you guys again.
NC guy who grew up with Ray Farmer.
Panthers fan.
Wanted to get your take on a few things.
I can take it; how do you guys feel about Farmer?
Admittedly, he whiffed on two first round picks but did pretty well on the rest of the draft no? He also accumulated another first for this year which will come in handy and a chance to "redeem himself."
Then there's "text gate." talk about that. He came out and took responsibility. Of course, he may have run off Shanahan in the process.
What do you guys think about Cleveland building through the draft, resigning top players, etc.?
I'll hang up the phone and listen.
Last year he killed it in free agency with WR Andrew Hawkins, LB Karlos Dansby, and SS Donte Whitner, before factoring in the post-draft flurry of free agency signing when he got RB Isaiah Crowell and their were other pretty good signings like WR Miles Austin amongst others like WR Gabriel.
In the draft, first pick #4 I think everyone loved the trade-down with Buffalo getting extra 1st and 4th round picks this year before we heard about WR Josh Gordon's suspension and that Ray didn't bother to draft a WR in a very-deep WR draft class. I think most still love the trade but don't agree with the decision to not pick a single WR in last year's draft.
Then after the trade we held the 9th pick in the draft but I think Ray panicked and basically blew a 5th round pick to move-up one spot. Hated that trade because it made Ray look like an amateur IMHO. I was terrified that we'd pick QB Johnny Manziel with the 8th pick and was relieved we took CB Justin Gilbert but honestly hated that pick at the time. I had no idea about WR Josh Gordon's suspension or I probably would have thought about ODB Jr but I wanted LB C.J. Mosley. Gilbert caught me off-guard so I stayed up late that night pouring over everything on what the Browns were saying and came away convinced it was Head Coach Mike Pettine needing a shut down press cover cornerback to start opposite Pro Bowl CB Joe Haden. So I wasn't happy but felt better about the pick after hearing the reasoning. Gilbert was picked mostly due to Pettine IMHO.
Obviously QB Johnny Manziel is a failure but most people think that was owner Jimmy Haslam behind that pick. The QB coach who took that damn text message was hired BEFORE Pettine so he seemed like a plant from the owner IMHO. He got fired after the season and may have been tied up in the text gate. So not only was Johnny a failure we also traded-up so we blew the 22nd pick in the first round and our 3rd round pick on that fiasco.
Second round OG Joel Bitonio is a stud and was a first round talent. Should be a staple of the offensive line for a long time.
Third round we took LB Christian Kirksey and he has been solid, good pick. We signed RB Ben Tate but still drafted RB Terrence West in the third rond but had no extra third round pick due to Johnny trade-up so we had to blow extra picks to trade-up to take West. West has had his share of issues but reports are he dropped some weight and hopefully has matured because he is shiftier than Crowell and could have a big role in new OC Flip's offense.
Fourth round CB Pierre Desir started out looking like a long term project but got PT late in the year and looked really good in limited action. Could be a legit sleeper even though he lacks the speed and overall athleticism of Justin Gilbert.
Ray then traded away a late 7th round pick for an additional 6th round pick this year to add to the extra 1st and 4th round picks from the Buffalo trade.
Ray is a mixed bag but overall his draft was good even if both 1st round picks bust because of the extra 1st and 4th round picks and how big Joel Bitinio pick turned out and the solid play of Kirksey and promise of West and Desir before factoring in Crowell and the rest of the free agents.
Some in the media don't like his demeanor because he doesn't answer questions directly and they think he is trying to be the smartest guy in the room. I hate that saying because goddamit NFL GMs are PAID to be the smartest guys in the room on draft day so I think that is petty bickering by frustrated old men who cover the team and are truly sad-sac characters who basically whine.
But per Ray.
Its all about the QB.
He has to learn that if he hasn't already.
He blew it on Johnny and should have stood up to Haslam and told him NO that he was sitting tight and not trading up for that Texas QB and would take QB Teddy Bridgewater at 22. If he did that then he would be seen as a savior because not only would we have the QB we also would have been able to keep that 3rd round pick and save the picks we blew to move-up into the 3rd round to take RB Terrence West.
I don't think Ray can get his QB this year. I hope he doesn't blow both 1st round picks to move-up because I am not sold on Mariota and would prefer to trade-down one of those picks to get an additional 1st round pick in 2016 to load up to get a QB then.