Desert Island Song Draft - Alphabet thievery afoot - Thievery abounds, XTC and Queen popular. Starting Round 25. Chaos coming (1 Viewer)

[landrys hat]

24.C - Calexico and Iron & Wine - A History of Lovers

Calexico and Iron & Wine - History Of Lovers

Track 3 from the 2005 EP 'In the Reins' released on Overcoat Recordings by Calexico and Iron & Wine. **ALL copyright held by artists, publishers, labels and ...

www.youtube.com

 

[Yo Mama]

Wondering if we waited too long to steal - most people are already locked into the hard to find letters.

 

[Yo Mama]

Oh, and thanks @krista4 for those awesome, incredible picks!!!

 

[Eephus]

Round 23:

Nektar -- Good Day

Wikkid was into these guys because they could both prog out and rock.

Time check?

 

[Eephus]

24.H - Hawkwind - D Rider​

Nik Turner (26 August 1940 – 10 November 2022)
I caught Turner's late-career live act in 2015. It was more odd than good but I'm glad I got to see the old weirdo.

Hawkwind - D Rider

Hawkwind's D Rider and slices of space colors.

www.youtube.com

 

[rockaction]

Time check?

More like Good Morning, Good Day, and Good Evening, amirite?

 

[Eephus]

Wondering if we waited too long to steal - most people are already locked into the hard to find letters.

I think we'd need more scarcity in the draft pool or more drafters for the stealing gimmick to work more effectively

 

[Eephus]

I know I haven't been online much but It's been nice to have a music draft again. The pace for listening to new songs has been good.

 

[Pip's Invitation]

Time check?

More like Good Morning, Good Day, and Good Evening, amirite?

You might want to stop engaging with the pollster -- don't want you on hiatus again.

 

[rockaction]

You might want to stop engaging with the pollster -- don't want you on hiatus again.

So tired of the self-assuredness. It's not earned, and it's not only when there's a subjective thing to discuss. It's his assertions about things that are reasonably objective that he's also often wrong about.

Just tiresome.

 

[krista4]

I know I haven't been online much but It's been nice to have a music draft again. The pace for listening to new songs has been good.

Thanks to JML and all the drafters for being awesome.

I hope people will put together playlists for their picks. I'm very interested in hearing these mixes! Really was looking forward to where @Steve Tasker 's came out, so hoping that he'll be back for that, too.

 

[krista4]

You might want to stop engaging with the pollster -- don't want you on hiatus again.

So tired of the self-assuredness. It's not earned, and it's not only when there's a subjective thing to discuss. It's his assertions about things that are reasonably objective that he's also often wrong about.

Just tiresome.

Link to what you guys are talking about? Be careful, rock!

 

[Yo Mama]

I know I haven't been online much but It's been nice to have a music draft again. The pace for listening to new songs has been good.

Thanks to JML and all the drafters for being awesome.

I hope people will put together playlists for their picks. I'm very interested in hearing these mixes! Really was looking forward to where @Steve Tasker 's came out, so hoping that he'll be back for that, too.

I’ll be doing a playlist and like the flow of my choices so far, but I haven’t wanted to put anything together yet with the threat of steals looming.

 

[krista4]

I know I haven't been online much but It's been nice to have a music draft again. The pace for listening to new songs has been good.

Thanks to JML and all the drafters for being awesome.

I hope people will put together playlists for their picks. I'm very interested in hearing these mixes! Really was looking forward to where @Steve Tasker 's came out, so hoping that he'll be back for that, too.

I’ll be doing a playlist and like the flow of my choices so far, but I haven’t wanted to put anything together yet with the threat of steals looming.

Yeah, that makes perfect sense. When it's over I want to listen to these, though.

 

[rockaction]

You might want to stop engaging with the pollster -- don't want you on hiatus again.

So tired of the self-assuredness. It's not earned, and it's not only when there's a subjective thing to discuss. It's his assertions about things that are reasonably objective that he's also often wrong about.

Just tiresome.

Link to what you guys are talking about? Be careful, rock!

It’s nothing really. It’s in Tim’s thread. I never finish the insult. One has to supply their own meaning.

 

[John Maddens Lunchbox]

Round 26 will be one person up at a time, starting with Pip’s Invitation. No more 3ITC.
Sound fair?

Round 27, if you can do 26 picks, is just pick a favourite artist from someone else, but a different song

Would it seem more fair to have both Rounds 25 and 26 in order? I'm not sure (and it doesn't affect me a bit since I can't steal nor be stolen from), so just throwing it out there.

I would do 25 and 26 in order, since some people were holding steals just for that.

That makes all the sense in the world.
Rounds 25 and 26 in order, one at a time. No autoskips, but one can ask to be skipped at the time

 

[John Maddens Lunchbox]

Wondering if we waited too long to steal - most people are already locked into the hard to find letters.

I think we'd need more scarcity in the draft pool or more drafters for the stealing gimmick to work more effectively

Yeah I agree. Hasnt worked out as I hoped. Theres something in the idea though. Scarcity is the most important thing.
Was hoping for 20+ drafters.
Still got rounds 25 and 26 to see if things change

 

[John Maddens Lunchbox]

You might want to stop engaging with the pollster -- don't want you on hiatus again.

So tired of the self-assuredness. It's not earned, and it's not only when there's a subjective thing to discuss. It's his assertions about things that are reasonably objective that he's also often wrong about.

Just tiresome.

Link to what you guys are talking about? Be careful, rock!

Just mr anti elvis costello not understanding why people dont have the same taste as him
Eg How can there by 27 songs better than Thriller in 82? He then ranks it 5th best on the album lol.

Not really an 82 album btw, but thats another story.

 

[krista4]

You might want to stop engaging with the pollster -- don't want you on hiatus again.

So tired of the self-assuredness. It's not earned, and it's not only when there's a subjective thing to discuss. It's his assertions about things that are reasonably objective that he's also often wrong about.

Just tiresome.

Link to what you guys are talking about? Be careful, rock!

Just mr anti elvis costello not understanding why people dont have the same taste as him
Eg How can there by 27 songs better than Thriller in 82? He then ranks it 5th best on the album lol.

Not really an 82 album btw, but thats another story.

I figured I knew who “the pollster” was but then was looking for a recent poll. Didn’t think to scour the other threads. I’m usually on board with the tim threads but missed out on the first 1/3 or more of that one and didn’t want to catch up.

 

[krista4]

Wondering if we waited too long to steal - most people are already locked into the hard to find letters.

I think we'd need more scarcity in the draft pool or more drafters for the stealing gimmick to work more effectively

Yeah I agree. Hasnt worked out as I hoped. Theres something in the idea though. Scarcity is the most important thing.
Was hoping for 20+ drafters.
Still got rounds 25 and 26 to see if things change

When we first talked about it, there was only one steal, and we worried that might mean no steals until the last round so added another. There was still some strategy here, but it might need more tinkering. With the steal concept, maybe something like putting a time limit on them, such as one expires after Round 10, another after Round 15…something like that.

 

[northern exposure]

You might want to stop engaging with the pollster -- don't want you on hiatus again.

So tired of the self-assuredness. It's not earned, and it's not only when there's a subjective thing to discuss. It's his assertions about things that are reasonably objective that he's also often wrong about.

Just tiresome.

Just an observer in here (and mostly in tim's thread too), but you've hit the nail on the head, rock.
Insufferable is how I would sum him up. I have to stop myself from engaging with him and tell myself it's pointless.

 

[rockaction]

I have to stop myself from engaging with him and tell myself it's pointless.

I wish I’d taken the same tactic. It’s pointless for sure. Argh. I need to not get so annoyed by it and let it roll off of my back.

 

[Mrs. Rannous]

I seem to be up for

Round 24.Y - "Weird Al" Yankovic - Everything You Know Is Wrong

Music and lyrics by Mr Yankovic.

 

[Mrs. Rannous]

I'll be checking in around noon, so I shouldn't hold things up too much.

 

[John Maddens Lunchbox]

@Steve Tasker owes 20-24th round picks. 5 in total.
@zamboni owes 23rd and 24th picks

24.06 New Binky the Doormat
24.08 Hov34
24.09 Tuffnutt
24.11 Steve Tasker
24.12 Rockaction
24.13 Pik95
24.16 Otb_lifer
24.17 ilov80s
Can all make their picks

After this
STOP
HAMMER TIME

Once all these picks are made, we commence round 25 with ilov80s only
One by one from then on until we reach the magical 27th round for those left

 

[Mrs. Rannous]

I believe music is called for here.

 

[PIK95]

@New Binky the Doormat @Hov34 @tuffnutt ITC

 

[New Binky the Doormat]

RD 24: "F" - The Faces - Stay With Me

whew ...tough one, I had one typed in and linked ...and went back to this.

it's too bad we didn't get more of this Rod rather than "the pure pop Rod" and then the "Vegas Rod"

 

[tuffnutt]

RD 24- Looking Glass- Brandy

I know at least one FBGer will like this pick and you can take that to the bank.

 

[PIK95]

@rockaction pik95 @otb_lifer @Ilov80s

 

[PIK95]

24.pik Steal from @Yo Mama Fugees-Fu-Gee-La

I am done with my draft now @John Maddens Lunchbox punting Y and Z. No stealing from me now.


A, B, C, D, E, F, G, H, I, J, k, L, M, N O, P, Q, R, S, T, U, V, W, and X

 

[Yo Mama]

Wondering if we waited too long to steal - most people are already locked into the hard to find letters.

I think we'd need more scarcity in the draft pool or more drafters for the stealing gimmick to work more effectively

Yeah I agree. Hasnt worked out as I hoped. Theres something in the idea though. Scarcity is the most important thing.
Was hoping for 20+ drafters.
Still got rounds 25 and 26 to see if things change

When we first talked about it, there was only one steal, and we worried that might mean no steals until the last round so added another. There was still some strategy here, but it might need more tinkering. With the steal concept, maybe something like putting a time limit on them, such as one expires after Round 10, another after Round 15…something like that.

My plan was to use my steals defensively (steal back any of my harder to replace groups that might get stolen from me). Since the stealing slowed down, I probably could have switched to offense earlier - some of the groups I was targeting to steal I’ve already chosen another option.

 

[Yo Mama]

24.pik Steal from @Yo Mama Fugees-Fu-Gee-La

I am done with my draft now @John Maddens Lunchbox punting Y and Z. No stealing from me now.


A, B, C, D, E, F, G, H, I, J, k, L, M, N O, P, Q, R, S, T, U, V, W, and X

I was going to ask this earlier, but as we get to the end of the draft, when someone “finishes”their draft (either early or after their 26th round pick) is that drafter immediately done and frozen, or are they still alive until the end of the round?

For example, when I make my 26th round pick (which is like 5th or 6th pick in the round), am I frozen or do the people behind me in the draft order still get a chance to steal from me?

Likewise, since I now owe a 24th rounder, can I steal back the Fugees or is Pik now frozen?

@John Maddens Lunchbox @krista4

 

[PIK95]

@Yo Mama I was hoping you stole Pearl Jam. I had a fire backup.

 

[PIK95]

Wondering if we waited too long to steal - most people are already locked into the hard to find letters.

I think we'd need more scarcity in the draft pool or more drafters for the stealing gimmick to work more effectively

Yeah I agree. Hasnt worked out as I hoped. Theres something in the idea though. Scarcity is the most important thing.
Was hoping for 20+ drafters.
Still got rounds 25 and 26 to see if things change

When we first talked about it, there was only one steal, and we worried that might mean no steals until the last round so added another. There was still some strategy here, but it might need more tinkering. With the steal concept, maybe something like putting a time limit on them, such as one expires after Round 10, another after Round 15…something like that.

My plan was to use my steals defensively (steal back any of my harder to replace groups that might get stolen from me). Since the stealing slowed down, I probably could have switched to offense earlier - some of the groups I was targeting to steal I’ve already chosen another option.

My plan was defend against an Arcade Fire Steal, then if that didn't happen do what I just did and bail immediately. I love it when a plan comes together. :HannibalSmithCigar:

 

[Mrs. Rannous]

I guess I'm not holding thigs up at all. And I would also like to echo Yo Mama's question about steals.

 

[New Binky the Doormat]

I guess I'm not holding thigs up at all. And I would also like to echo Yo Mama's question about steals.

same - fine with whatever @John Maddens Lunchbox vision of how this was to work out

and we get a 27th move if we fill out all 26 letters ...is that right?

 

[Yo Mama]

@Yo Mama I was hoping you stole Pearl Jam. I had a fire backup.

I actually probably would have but I forgot about it since I was traveling yesterday and just sent Krista a list to pick for me.

 

[Hov34]

@New Binky the Doormat @Hov34 @tuffnutt ITC

Skip me all day every day

 

[krista4]

24.pik Steal from @Yo Mama Fugees-Fu-Gee-La

I am done with my draft now @John Maddens Lunchbox punting Y and Z. No stealing from me now.


A, B, C, D, E, F, G, H, I, J, k, L, M, N O, P, Q, R, S, T, U, V, W, and X

I was going to ask this earlier, but as we get to the end of the draft, when someone “finishes”their draft (either early or after their 26th round pick) is that drafter immediately done and frozen, or are they still alive until the end of the round?

For example, when I make my 26th round pick (which is like 5th or 6th pick in the round), am I frozen or do the people behind me in the draft order still get a chance to steal from me?

Likewise, since I now owe a 24th rounder, can I steal back the Fugees or is Pik now frozen?

@John Maddens Lunchbox @krista4

I think only people who drop out at 20, 22 or 24 get their picks "locked." It wouldn't make sense or be fair the other way IMO, and the first post specifically only mentions the locking/freezing with respect to 20/22/24. But JML will be the final say on this.

 

[krista4]

I guess I'm not holding thigs up at all. And I would also like to echo Yo Mama's question about steals.

same - fine with whatever @John Maddens Lunchbox vision of how this was to work out

and we get a 27th move if we fill out all 26 letters ...is that right?

Yes, you get a 27th, and with that you can choose any artist without stealing the artist from the other drafter.

 

[Yo Mama]

24.pik Steal from @Yo Mama Fugees-Fu-Gee-La

I am done with my draft now @John Maddens Lunchbox punting Y and Z. No stealing from me now.


A, B, C, D, E, F, G, H, I, J, k, L, M, N O, P, Q, R, S, T, U, V, W, and X

I was going to ask this earlier, but as we get to the end of the draft, when someone “finishes”their draft (either early or after their 26th round pick) is that drafter immediately done and frozen, or are they still alive until the end of the round?

For example, when I make my 26th round pick (which is like 5th or 6th pick in the round), am I frozen or do the people behind me in the draft order still get a chance to steal from me?

Likewise, since I now owe a 24th rounder, can I steal back the Fugees or is Pik now frozen?

@John Maddens Lunchbox @krista4

I think only people who drop out at 20, 22 or 24 get their picks "locked." It wouldn't make sense or be fair the other way IMO, and the first post specifically only mentions the locking/freezing with respect to 20/22/24. But JML will be the final say on this.

Yeah, I agree - but is Pik locked when he made his 24th pick, or when the 24th round is over?

 

[Ilov80s]

Rd 24 Under Your Spell Again by Ray Price

I have one Merle country song and it would seem out of place without some county companions.

I have B and R left

 

[otb_lifer]

24.xx

Morning Has Broken - Yusuf

i will need some serenity, and clarity - reminding me of all that is goodt and wonderful in this world.

remembering my daughter's choir solo to this tune will always suffice.

 

[Mrs. Rannous]

24.xx

Morning Has Broken - Yusuf

i will need some serenity, and clarity - reminding me of all that is goodt and wonderful in this world.

remembering my daughter's choir solo to this tune will always suffice.

Clever choice of Y.

 

[krista4]

24.pik Steal from @Yo Mama Fugees-Fu-Gee-La

I am done with my draft now @John Maddens Lunchbox punting Y and Z. No stealing from me now.


A, B, C, D, E, F, G, H, I, J, k, L, M, N O, P, Q, R, S, T, U, V, W, and X

I was going to ask this earlier, but as we get to the end of the draft, when someone “finishes”their draft (either early or after their 26th round pick) is that drafter immediately done and frozen, or are they still alive until the end of the round?

For example, when I make my 26th round pick (which is like 5th or 6th pick in the round), am I frozen or do the people behind me in the draft order still get a chance to steal from me?

Likewise, since I now owe a 24th rounder, can I steal back the Fugees or is Pik now frozen?

@John Maddens Lunchbox @krista4

I think only people who drop out at 20, 22 or 24 get their picks "locked." It wouldn't make sense or be fair the other way IMO, and the first post specifically only mentions the locking/freezing with respect to 20/22/24. But JML will be the final say on this.

Yeah, I agree - but is Pik locked when he made his 24th pick, or when the 24th round is over?

I'd think the former, as otherwise you don't necessarily get the "benefit of the bargain" that you've made by dropping out. Also the first post mentions dropping out after 24 "selections" not 24 "rounds." But I've been wrong before, so don't necessarily rely on me!

 

[krista4]

24.xx

Morning Has Broken - Yusuf

i will need some serenity, and clarity - reminding me of all that is goodt and wonderful in this world.

remembering my daughter's choir solo to this tune will always suffice.

This song is perfection.

 

[zamboni]

Round 23: REO Speedwagon - "Golden Country"

Round 24: Soul Asylum - "Somebody To Shove"


Used: A, B, C, D, E, F, G, H, I, J, K, L, M, N, O, P, Q, R, S, U, V, X, Y, Z

 

[Leroy Hoard]

24.xx

Morning Has Broken - Yusuf

i will need some serenity, and clarity - reminding me of all that is goodt and wonderful in this world.

remembering my daughter's choir solo to this tune will always suffice.

A friend named her cat Stevens because of this song.

 

[otb_lifer]

24.xx

Morning Has Broken - Yusuf

i will need some serenity, and clarity - reminding me of all that is goodt and wonderful in this world.

remembering my daughter's choir solo to this tune will always suffice.

A friend named her cat Stevens because of this song.

a real father to sun moment