What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Dynasty Value Discussion Thread (3 Viewers)

What kind of offers we accepting for Rice ?

I’m loath to sell but have to consider it as a contender. Put him on the trade block and so far

Rice for Diggs

Rice for Lagette and an early ‘25 2

Rice for W Robinson and an early ‘25 2

Not going to accept any of these but the Lagette/Robinson person is in a proper rebuild and also has BTJ and 4 x 1sts.
 
Would anybody consider selling Achane for Downs and Flowers/Higgins?

Notable players currently on my team are Barkley and Walker at RB and Diontae, McLaurin, Reed at WR
 
Got offered a 2025 and 2026 1st and Luke McCaffrey for AJ Brown and Chase Brown.

The picks are likely to be mid to late 1sts, the guy wanting AJB is currently 1-3 but also won the championship last year. For context, it’s a 10 team league, starting QRRWWTFFF. I am in a position to compete this year, am loaded at WR(also have RRice, Olave, London, Flowers, Odunze, Pittman) but also have a very young team (Daniels is my QB, Bowers my TE, Walker my RB1), only thing I really need is a RB2(currently Zack Moss/Chase Brown) which I hope to be able to pick up in the draft this year.

Is this trade worth it? If not would him adding a 2nd even it up?
 
Value check on Kareem Hunt FFPC SF. Got offered a 2025 4th, but feel that is a bit light. He should have RB2 value until Pacheco gets back which could be though the fantasy playoffs. Is a 3rd reasonable?
 
Born to Run said:
Value check on Kareem Hunt FFPC SF. Got offered a 2025 4th, but feel that is a bit light. He should have RB2 value until Pacheco gets back which could be though the fantasy playoffs. Is a 3rd reasonable?
Click to expand...
These type of questions are roster dependent. If a contender and can use the RB on the roster, he worth holding unless someone wants to pay a 2nd imo. If not a contender I would prefer to package him in a player trade versus getting a 3rd.
 
JamboTaylor said:
Barkley or Aiyuk

Fields or Lawrence
Click to expand...
Depends on win now, or build for future.

If the former, Fields/Barkley

If the latter, I’ll take Aiyuk / TLaw (and I have both Fields/TLaw in one league with Aiyuk so I like all of them)

I prefer building around WR, and Barkley’s age is a concern.

TLaw has job security. Fields is an upside gamble, but then, so is TLaw. There’s unrealized upside with both.
 
Born to Run said:
Value check on Kareem Hunt FFPC SF. Got offered a 2025 4th, but feel that is a bit light. He should have RB2 value until Pacheco gets back which could be though the fantasy playoffs. Is a 3rd reasonable?
Click to expand...
That’s light. But I do like the idea of selling before Pacheco returns. I’d try for a 2nd, or a player worth that. If not maybe a 3rd & a 4th?
 
Hot Sauce Guy said:
JamboTaylor said:
Looking to trade Achane. What’s his worth atm?
Click to expand...
Probably the worst time to sell. Concussed, and hasn't put up big numbers when healthy.

I'd wait until he has a boom game then put him on the block. FF managers have short memories.
Click to expand...
Agreed. Bad timing to sell. Good “Buy Low” market right now.
With the whole MIA offense in the :toilet:
If Tua comes back soon, then move him.

If now is an urgent need, no less than mid 1st value or young WR +
 
How about Derrick Henry in a dynasty league where he could make you the lead dog this year? How much draft capital would you trade for him?
 
ex-ghost said:
How about Derrick Henry in a dynasty league where he could make you the lead dog this year? How much draft capital would you trade for him?
Click to expand...
It's a classic "1st rounder for aging stud to try to win it all" kind of trade. imo.
The 1st will be a late one if your team is that good.
Maybe if you're lucky and have the right trade partner, you can get him for a 2nd or 2 2nds.
 
Wigglytuff's Gruff said:
Bijan

for

J Brooks, Jaylen Wright, Kendre Miller, Early 2026 1st (team is abysmal)

This seems obvious right?
Click to expand...
That has merit... While I see the offensive play calling / touch share in Atl a crime, it might be a management style to prolong his season / protect from injury. This is more common in NFL today (RBBC roles).
I could do that .. but my only concern is the 2026 pick could be anywhere being 2 years away . While it might be a 2025 1.01 pick, 2026 is a whole new beast.
 
I was the Bijan buyer in that scenario. We actually settled on the following.

Bijan

for

Garrett Wilson, Jaylen Wright, Kendre Miller, Early 2026 1st.

It would be fairly shocking if that 26 1st wasn't top 3. He's scored about half as many points as everyone this season so far and hasn't got much in the way of draft capital.
I was happy to get out of G Wilson to be honest, he was probably my WR4. The two runners obviously have potential and an early 1 is always nice but it seemed like a sensible trade to me. Keeps Bijan out the hands of other challengers as well.
 
Wigglytuff's Gruff said:
I was the Bijan buyer in that scenario. We actually settled on the following.

Bijan

for

Garrett Wilson, Jaylen Wright, Kendre Miller, Early 2026 1st.

It would be fairly shocking if that 26 1st wasn't top 3. He's scored about half as many points as everyone this season so far and hasn't got much in the way of draft capital.
I was happy to get out of G Wilson to be honest, he was probably my WR4. The two runners obviously have potential and an early 1 is always nice but it seemed like a sensible trade to me. Keeps Bijan out the hands of other challengers as well.
Click to expand...
Definitely more palatable. Bijan, while not hitting the numbers we expect is still more valuable than a criminally underutilized WR, two dart throws and a 1st two years from now.
 
Value check on Olave. If you’re looking for immediate WR help, any thoughts on who has similar value? I tried selling for Tee Higgins and was told Olave is not in the same ballpark as Tee.
 
CMC owner.. would you trade Dell or JSN to get Mason?

I have lost CMC, JTaylor, Collins, and now Aiyuk and yet only 2 games out of playoffs. Mason owner playing for future. Anyone seen a Mason deal?
 
The Captain said:
Value check on Olave. If you’re looking for immediate WR help, any thoughts on who has similar value? I tried selling for Tee Higgins and was told Olave is not in the same ballpark as Tee.
Click to expand...
1st off, the Tee owner is a moron. Olave is younger and more skilled. Tee just happens to have a much better QB. That can change instantly.
1-1 for an immediate need, I'm probably targeting someone like Waddle/Pickens. Maybe Olave + a small add to get Tyreek from a frustrated owner?
 
I think I may try to move MHJ before he continues to lose value. Whether its him or Kyler, I don't see it getting much better in the near future as the situation is not going to change.

There was a trade in one of my leagues a couple weeks ago of MHJ for Achane/DeVonta Smith. I think may try to do something like this and tiering down at WR while picking up a strong asset or pick.

Am I crazy, impatient, or both?
 
Blick said:
I think I may try to move MHJ before he continues to lose value. Whether its him or Kyler, I don't see it getting much better in the near future as the situation is not going to change.

There was a trade in one of my leagues a couple weeks ago of MHJ for Achane/DeVonta Smith. I think may try to do something like this and tiering down at WR while picking up a strong asset or pick.

Am I crazy, impatient, or both?
Click to expand...
If it's dynasty you're being impatient. It's not all on him you know. I think if it's a dynasty league you stick with the reasons you liked him in the first place, but if the deal is really good then go for it. Otherwise, take a valium.
 
InDitkaWeTrust said:
1st off, the Tee owner is a moron. Olave is younger and more skilled. Tee just happens to have a much better QB. That can change instantly.
Click to expand...

I think you have to look at New Orleans, their situation, how Olave has looked, and how Olave has scored.

Tee looks pretty good comparatively. Now, where will Tee wind up after the year, are his soft tissue issues career-long—He’s not in a different ballpark than Olave for these reasons.

But yeah, give me a choice between the two and I might take Tee.
 
JohnnyU said:
Blick said:
I think I may try to move MHJ before he continues to lose value. Whether its him or Kyler, I don't see it getting much better in the near future as the situation is not going to change.

There was a trade in one of my leagues a couple weeks ago of MHJ for Achane/DeVonta Smith. I think may try to do something like this and tiering down at WR while picking up a strong asset or pick.

Am I crazy, impatient, or both?
Click to expand...
If it's dynasty you're being impatient. It's not all on him you know. I think if it's a dynasty league you stick with the reasons you liked him in the first place, but if the deal is really good then go for it. Otherwise, take a valium.
Click to expand...
This. MHJ, for all his talent, is a ROOKIE. He still has a lot to learn about the NFL game and needs some time to gel with his QB.
 
I got a league the startup was in 2015 and Amari Cooper is my last original player, drafted him at pick 1.11 as an incoming rookie.

But I'm not sentimental, my team is very deep and a major contender with or without him and I'd rather turn him into a future asset/younger player.

Have not seem him traded lately. What's is value in standard FFPC, one start QB leagues? An early second? How much do you think would be reasonable to add to him to a contending team that has Rashee Rice to make a reasonable opening offer? That's the kind of deal I'd like to do.
 
menobrown said:
I got a league the startup was in 2015 and Amari Cooper is my last original player, drafted him at pick 1.11 as an incoming rookie.

But I'm not sentimental, my team is very deep and a major contender with or without him and I'd rather turn him into a future asset/younger player.

Have not seem him traded lately. What's is value in standard FFPC, one start QB leagues? An early second? How much do you think would be reasonable to add to him to a contending team that has Rashee Rice to make a reasonable opening offer? That's the kind of deal I'd like to do.
Click to expand...

Standard FFPC would throw me off right away, brother.

KTC has something like Javonte Williams or Jordan Mason. Najee or Conner. Basically another early to mid second added on.

If I have Rice, though, and I’m a contender, I’m thinking awfully long and hard about Cooper if you throw one of those guys in. He’s got so many damn felony charges that I’m not sure he walks. (I roster Rice in another league. Zero offers for him. Ever. Bupkis. Crickets.)

But the other guy might have ice in his veins. Who knows what moves men?
 
menobrown said:
I got a league the startup was in 2015 and Amari Cooper is my last original player, drafted him at pick 1.11 as an incoming rookie.

But I'm not sentimental, my team is very deep and a major contender with or without him and I'd rather turn him into a future asset/younger player.

Have not seem him traded lately. What's is value in standard FFPC, one start QB leagues? An early second? How much do you think would be reasonable to add to him to a contending team that has Rashee Rice to make a reasonable opening offer? That's the kind of deal I'd like to do.
Click to expand...
I recently dealt him for Mooney + Okereke, which I saw as a free Mooney.

Probably worth a 2nd, yeah. The QB situation being dire there might mean you only get a late 2nd/early 3rd.

Disregard
 
Last edited:
Blick said:
I think I may try to move MHJ before he continues to lose value. Whether its him or Kyler, I don't see it getting much better in the near future as the situation is not going to change.

There was a trade in one of my leagues a couple weeks ago of MHJ for Achane/DeVonta Smith. I think may try to do something like this and tiering down at WR while picking up a strong asset or pick.

Am I crazy, impatient, or both?
Click to expand...
Late to the party but this is crazy talk.

Talk about giving your 1.1 pick no time at all, AND selling him massively low on top of that.

Hold!
 
I have been offered Achane and Flowers for St. Brown. I need serious RB help. This is a salary cap dynasty league. Hard to go into specifics but I gain some cap moving St Brown but I still have him at a killer value. I guess in a vacuum I'm getting 2 keepers for 1. My league I can keep 3 and RFA 2 that I can retain $5 more than he goes in the auction. I have a strong WR core and as much as I would hate to give up St Brown I have to give a little. FWIW the owner turned down Nabers for Achane.

My keepers would be 3 of these then I could RFA 2
Chase
Jefferson
Nabers
Odunze
Montgomery
Achane
Flowers

Pull the trigger or no?
 
joey said:
Blick said:
I think I may try to move MHJ before he continues to lose value. Whether its him or Kyler, I don't see it getting much better in the near future as the situation is not going to change.

There was a trade in one of my leagues a couple weeks ago of MHJ for Achane/DeVonta Smith. I think may try to do something like this and tiering down at WR while picking up a strong asset or pick.

Am I crazy, impatient, or both?
Click to expand...
Late to the party but this is crazy talk.

Talk about giving your 1.1 pick no time at all, AND selling him massively low on top of that.

Hold!
Click to expand...
Agreed - hold. He’s not losing value at all.

The Cards OC is holding back that entire offense, but we’ve seen what MH2 is capable of.

Bijan started his career super slow, in a RBBC on a team with no QB. I held and held and eventually (this preseason) moved him for J.Chase.

MH2 isn’t losing value, you’re just losing faith in him. Check the trade calcs & value charts - his value is intact. Be patient. Not every WR breaks out year 1, and MH2 has already shown flashes. The talent is there.
 
Markus P Dub said:
I have been offered Achane and Flowers for St. Brown. I need serious RB help. This is a salary cap dynasty league. Hard to go into specifics but I gain some cap moving St Brown but I still have him at a killer value. I guess in a vacuum I'm getting 2 keepers for 1. My league I can keep 3 and RFA 2 that I can retain $5 more than he goes in the auction. I have a strong WR core and as much as I would hate to give up St Brown I have to give a little. FWIW the owner turned down Nabers for Achane.

My keepers would be 3 of these then I could RFA 2
Chase
Jefferson
Nabers
Odunze
Montgomery
Achane
Flowers

Pull the trigger or no?
Click to expand...
Nope. Keep ARSB.

Achane is dicey, and Flowers size & the style of offense BAL plays has always concerned me.

I don’t see either of those dudes reaching ARSB’s value, & in a 2 for 1, you want to be getting the 1. There’s a reason your trade partner wants to do it.

If you want to turn ARSB into a RB, I don’t mind that move - but do a 1:1

You clearly have the depth to move him - be patient & wait for a better deal.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Hot Sauce Guy
  • Locked
Value Swings if Tush Push is Banned
2
Replies
57
Views
1K
Joe Bryant
Joe Bryant
zamboni
Should There Be A League Trade Deadline (Keeper/Dynasty)?
Replies
33
Views
3K
Mitchie
M
Joe Bryant
Why Chris Boswell Is Ranked So Low...
2
Replies
59
Views
3K
Adam Harstad
Adam Harstad

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 2 (members: 0, guests: 2)
Back
Top