Breaking down my roster in terms of marginal points per dollar-- how many extra points a player got me vs. if I'd just left his box unchecked and didn't spend that money elsewhere. (I know marginal points isn't the best measure, but I was curious about opportunity costs.)
0.5 points per dollar-- Anthony Richardson (7.45 points, $15). Counted once in a week I cleared by 45.
5.9 ppd-- Brock Purdy (70.3 points, $12). Counted six times, though none were season-savers.
6.2 ppd-- Jordan Love (55.75 points, $9). Counted six times, though none were season-savers.
(Glitch in the Matrix: in Weeks 2 and 3 Love scored 27.85 and the rest of my roster combined scored 172.70, leading to back-to-back scores of 200.55.)
1.6 ppd-- James Conner (32 points, $20). Counted six times, none were season-savers.
5.9 ppd-- Alvin Kamara (88.5 points, $15). Counted nine times (every week he's played), including one season-saver (added 15.7, cleared by 6.6).
10.9 ppd-- Raheem Mostert (109 points, $10). Counted eight times, but none were season-savers.
0.4 ppd-- Matt Breida (1.6 points, $4). Counted once. Wanted to bet on a Barkley injury, but forgot Breida and the Giants suck.
20.5 ppd-- Kyren Williams (81.9 points, $4). Counted six times, none were season-savers.
12.3 ppd-- Zach Moss (49.1 points, $4). Counted five times, none were season-savers. Super cheap bet on the Taylor holdout running long with handcuff potential beyond that.
(My top pick underwhelmed, but the other five-- sans Breida-- have been monsters.)
2.5 ppd-- Chris Olave (67.5 points, $27). Counted nine times, none were season-savers.
2.0 ppd-- Tyler Lockett (38.6 points, $19). Counted six times, none were season-savers.
2.2 ppd-- Jahan Dotson (30.3 points, $14). Counted five times, none were season-savers.
0.0 ppd-- Rashod Bateman (0 points, $11). Urgh.
0.6 ppd-- Elijah Moore (7 points, $11). Counted SIX TIMES, added <1 marginal point in five of them and a whopping +3.2 in the sixth. (Ralph Wiggum "I'm Helping" gif.)
0.5 ppd-- Marvin Mims (3.7 points, $8). Reverse Elijah Moore. Posted 20.3 points in Week 2. That's... pretty much it.
3.6 ppd-- Jayden Reed (24.9 points, $7). Counted five times, none were season-savers.
0.0 ppd-- Justyn Ross (0 points, $5). Still a better pick than Rashod Bateman.
(By far my worst unit, really no good picks in the group, which is disgusting with $102 spent. I've only flexed six receivers all year. Woooooof.)
4.4 ppd-- Dalton Kincaid (43.9 points, $10). Counted zero times in the first six weeks, then six times in the next six, including one season-saver in Week 7.
9.9 ppd-- Sam LaPorta (88.7 points, $9). Counted ten times (most of anyone), but none were season-savers.
7.3 ppd-- Jake Ferguson (43.6 points, $6). Counted four times, no season-savers.
2.8 ppd-- Luke Musgrave (16.8 points, $6). Counted four times, no season-savers.
(Incredible value: I've used at least one flex at TE in 9 of 13 weeks, including two weeks were both of my flexes were TEs and three weeks where a TE was my top-scoring non-flex. All for $31.)
6.1 ppd-- Jake Elliott (30.3 points, $5). Counted seven times, but none were season-savers.
6.9 ppd-- Greg Zuerlein (27.6 points, $4). Thought the Rodgers injury would sink him, but he's been okay. Counted four times, no season-savers.
6.0 ppd-- Wil Lutz (24.0 points, $4). Has only counted twice all year. Saved my season both times (+8.9 when I cleared by 6.6, +15.1 when I cleared by 12.25). My official mascot.
Overall, the unit gave me 14.5ppg for $13.
7.1 ppd-- Dallas Defense (50 points, $7). Counted six times, no season-savers.
4.5 ppd-- Denver Defense (18 points, $4). Counted seven times, only added 5, 4, 3, 2, 2, 1, and 1 points, no season-savers.
Overall, the unit gave me 10.3ppg for $11.
Positional comparison:
RB -- $57 spent on 6 players, 18.6 points per start, nine flexes all year.
WR -- $102 spent on 8 players, 15.8 points per start, six flexes all year.
TE -- $31 spent on 4 players, 17.7 points per start, eleven flexes all year.
QB -- $36 spent, 29.5 ppg
PK -- $13 spent, 14.5 ppg
Def -- $11 spent, 10.3 ppg
Value picks (3+ points per dollar):
20.5 -- Kyren Williams
12.3 -- Zach Moss
10.9 -- Raheem Mostert
9.9 -- Sam LaPorta
7.3 -- Jake Ferguson
6.2 -- Jordan Love
5.9 -- Alvin Kamara
5.9 -- Brock Purdy
4.4 -- Dalton Kincaid
3.6 -- Jayden Reed
Workhorses (40+ points added):
109.0 -- Raheem Mostert
88.7 -- Sam LaPorta
88.5 -- Alvin Kamara
81.9 -- Kyren Williams
70.3 -- Brock Purdy
67.5 -- Chris Olave
55.8 -- Jordan Love
43.9 -- Dalton Kincaid
43.6 -- Jake Ferguson
Guardian Angels (times they saved me from the Cut Lion):
2 -- Wil Lutz (for $4)
1 -- Dalton Kincaid (for $10)
1 -- Alvin Kamara (for $15)
Taking up Space (<1 point per dollar):
$15 -- Anthony Richardson
$11 -- Rashod Bateman
$11 -- Elijah Moore
$8 -- Marvin Mims
$5 -- Justyn Ross
$4 -- Matt Breida
If I simply unchecked all of those boxes, I would have scored 19.75 fewer points over the season, not had to sweat any cut lions more than I already did, and had $54 extra dollars to spend. (He hasn't been total dead weight, but I could also cut Conner; this would cost me another 36.3 points, leave me counting a 0.3 and a 0 at RB in two weeks, and drop me to just 2.05 points above the Week 11 cut lion, but would free up another $20. I think if I really wanted to cut to the bone I'd still be alive if I cut Jordan Love, Luke Musgrave, Greg Zuerlein, and Denver's Defense, too, which would shave another $23, leaving me at $153 spent and 15 players rostered.)