4. Lay It on the Line
Album: Just a Game (1979)
Writer: Rik Emmett
Lead vocals: Rik Emmett
Chart History: US Hot 100 #86
Video?: Yes
Lyrical category: Love/lust/breakup
Alert: This is Track 2 on Just a Game.
Among Boomers and Gen Xers -- the people who remember Triumph when they were active -- there are a handful of tunes in the discussion about what is the band's signature song. For Millenials and Zoomers, there is no debate: It is "Lay It on the Line," the second single from Just a Game and one of the band's first songs to make an impact on radio in the U.S. "It created kind of a formula for us," Mike Levine said on Behind the Vinyl many years later.
The reason has nothing to do with anything that happened when the band was active. Instead, it is due to the song's inclusion on Guitar Hero 5 in 2010. This sparked renewed interest in the band, leading to the release of a new compilation, Greatest Hits Remixed, which remains the band's most popular release on streaming services and on which, you guessed it, "Lay It on the Line" is Track 2. "Lay It on the Line" is by far the band's most popular track on Spotify, as the Greatest Hits Remixed version has more than 25 million listens and nothing else is over 20 million. Throw in the Just a Game version and the version from Classics, a 1989 compilation, and "Lay It on the Line" has more than 30 million listens, not counting live versions.
The song begins with some mellow guitar chords with synths in the background, over which Rik Emmett lays some ascending notes that take us into the song. As Emmett begins to sing the first verse, Levine adds some bass fills, but there is no action from the drums yet. That comes as the first verse transitions to the second one. As the second verse progresses, Emmett plays a ringing guitar line that is the song's calling card. The chorus features a crunchy riff, a memorable melody and soaring harmonies at its end, and leads into Emmett's first guitar solo, which sports some flexible fingerwork in a radio-friendly structure.
The third verse and second chorus follow the established patterns but get more insistent and aggressive, matching the increasing anguish of the song's narrator. Emmett's second, longer guitar solo starts out slow and lyrical but builds in intensity, and its ending trills probably have a lot to do with why it was selected for Guitar Hero. That leads into a bridge in which Emmett's narrator pleads with his (soon to be ex?) lover and then into the final chorus, during which Emmett interjects some of his trademark high notes in between the repeated singing of the title phrase, after which the song fades out.
The song is about a man who can no longer trust his lover and confronts her. It may not technically be a breakup song, but it sure sounds like an about-to-break-up song.
It's the same old story all over again
You turn a lover into just another friend
I wanna love you, I wanna make you mine
Won't you lay it on the line
I'm tired of playin' your foolish games
I'm tired of all your lies makin' me insane
I don't ask for much, truth will do just fine
Won't you lay it on the line
Lay it on the line
Lay it on the line
Lay it on the line
Don't waste my time
You got no right to make me wait
Better talk, girl, before it gets too late
I never ever thought you could be so unkind
Won't you lay it on the line?
Lay it on the line
Lay it on the line
Lay it on the line
Don't waste my time
You know I love you (you know I love you), you know it's true (you know it's true)
It's up to you, girl, now what have I got to do?
Don't hold me up, girl, don't waste my precious time
Won't you lay it on the line?
Lay it on the line
Don't hold me up, girl
Lay it on the line
Yeah, yeah
Lay it on the line
Lay it on the line, girl
Lay it on the line
Oh, don't hold me up
Lay it on the line
etc.
Wikipedia says this is Triumph's most popular song on "classic rock radio" today, which is believable though I haven't seen anything to verify that. It was embraced by FM radio from its release and even made the lower reaches of the Billboard Hot 100 -- "until the payola stopped," Mike Levine says in a clip below.
"Lay It on the Line" has the second-most documented live performances of any Triumph song, which makes sense as it is their second-oldest song to never leave the setlist once it was introduced, usually appearing early in the show. It can be found on every live release. It was even played on the Emmett-less Edge of Excess Tour, with Rick Santers singing. After the band's initial run, it was performed in Emmett's solo sets as well as both 2008 reunion shows and as one of three songs at the surprise 2019 fan club event gig (though it is the only one of the three performances that does not appear in the documentary.)
In the Worldwide Countdown, Raging Weasel ranked "Lay It on the Line" #15.
Video (leotard alert):
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nn_yRlYVnUw
Live version from Chicago in 1979, aired on the Studio Jam program on FM radio (the guitar solo on this version is very different):
https://youtu.be/q5kzeyQJNUU?t=834
Live version from Cleveland in 1981, aired on the King Biscuit Flower Hour:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-gRf59Dz2Fs
Live version from Baltimore in 1982, a show which aired on MTV:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O2o84BqDDXk
Live version from Ottawa in 1982:
https://youtu.be/O2TLUhfbrm4?t=312
Live version from the US Festival in 1983:
https://open.spotify.com/track/6yzuQAjhvc8OJABRPOcBpr?si=2b7811e65e2342cb
Live version from Stages:
https://open.spotify.com/track/3pZ1at2Pl9Ov2Z7NVLV9uc?si=24c2da19225c4ef5
Live version from Montreal in 1985:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-v00DGm5jCg
Live version from LA in 1985:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vj3ZkWQs5h0
Live version from Detroit in 1986, aired on FM radio:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iWX5f47-dDI
Live version from Halifax in 1987, included on the A Night of Triumph DVD:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jkx47Zsyicc
Live version from South Padre Island, Texas in 1988:
https://youtu.be/kb-40NOXmU8?t=918
Live version from Milwaukee in 1993, with Rick Santers singing:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eUNO__fTGMU
Live version from Sweden Rock Festival in 2008:
https://open.spotify.com/track/2OiIUe0fk51p7aY4mlOibF?si=8b253daf2136461a
Live version from Rocklahoma in 2008:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nrW4jdbXvV4
Rik Emmett clip on CBC showing how to play the song on guitar:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9E8q3ssYTts
Mike Levine discusses "Lay It on the Line" for Behind the Vinyl:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mOeXnQBIKT0
"Lay It on the Line" is my highest-ranking song that does not fit in to the "inspirational/hockey coach" lyrical category. At #3, the song that created that category.