Role players need to be role players. When your 28 year old #7 guy with a negative career BPM is trying to be the vocal leader that's not a good sign.
Yep, but role players feel like they need to go over their skis when the core is pillow soft.
Is Donovan Mitchell just not liked or is he scared to lead? He's clearly "the guy" on that team, but maybe he's not a leader?
Not everyone has it in them to lead others. I feel like Atkinson has been overblown as a coach prior to this as well. Maybe its on him? NBA culture is difficult to navigate, IMO. If you don't have a rep that precedes you (like Pop or Kerr) you have to either be a player's coach or some kind of X's & O's genius to get the players to buy in. But the players make the team. Maybe it doesn't matter who the coach is. The Bucks won because of Giannis & Jrue, not Bud. Vogel won because of LeBron & AD, not him. Players can overcome a coach, but I don't think the opposite is true.
Tl;Dr - Donovan ain't the problem
I'll unpack all my thoughts sooner vs later, but workload says that's probably not this week.
Alright, found some time this morning - so what made this team different than the Bickerstaff Cavs was this truly was a team. Atkinson used data to demonstrate to Donovan that their hitting a wall late in the season was very predictable. He took on too much of the workload, which resulted in diminishing returns as both individual games and the season went on. In order for this team to unlock the next level, he needed to cede some of this work to others. Give others opportunities to run the show, whoever the hot hand was that night, let them run with it, then he picks and chooses his spots to be alpha, but he does so fresh. No one could've predicted it'd result in such a hot start, but that's what happens when you roll it back. This is a group that genuinely gets along well together, they didn't need time to gel, and Donovan bought into what Kenny was selling. They all played less minutes than prior seasons, resulting in better health, and with Mitchell delegating more work to others he didn't burn out. 'Cavalance' became a fun schtick this season, but the above is why it was so frequent. The opposition never knew where it'd come from on any one given night.
I don't recall exactly when the team started managing minutes, but it was sometime in early March, probably on the heels of the 3rd extended winning streak. The objective was to ensure these guys were fresh mid-April unlike previous iterations when Donovan routinely played 40+ minutes in the lead-up to the postseason. I didn't put much stock into the 8-8 finish and thought that was confirmed when they steam rolled a checked out Miami team +122. So what changed? And while health played a role, the Pacers season going down like it did was way bigger than that.
They weren't mentally prepared to deal with this team. How that played out in each game varied, but all the bad habits this team used to have returned. When things tightened up, Jarrett Allen played small - 6 rebounds in the final 2 games is inexcusable and he was a non-factor on offense. When things tightened up, and despite him playing well, Mobley didn't demand the ball. When things tightened up, so did Darius. I salute what the Pacers did to Hunter, they got in his head, and it impacted his performance. As a result, Donovan was asked to do too much. Then the others (Max, Jerome, Merrill, etc) were put in position in which they had to do more than just their role, instead of what they were accustomed to - if you're on, run with it, if you're not, defer. Combine that with the Pacers style of play and this team's head was in a blender from the outset and when the going got hard, they folded.
And that last part is why this is on the players. It's not a perfect copy-and-paste, but this series went remarkably similar to the one against the Kicks in 2023. They got bullied early, waxed when they got to the pivot point of the series, and went down in 5 on their home court with Donovan feeling like he had to play hero ball because everyone else around him got small. This is a soft team. Soft teams can win in the regular season with enough talent, but they're dead men walking now. The problem is...nothing can be done about it. While I think I am very well adept at the NFL salary cap, to say I'm under-informed with the NBA's is a vast under statement. That said, I now have cliff notes on what it means to be in the second apron, which is apparently where the Cavs are. And due to that, nothing can be done about this roster. We're stuck with this pillow soft talented team and all we can do is hope they learn how to develop toughness (mental much more than physical) over the next 11 months. I'm writing this thinking that unlike the last few regular seasons, the 25-26 may not be enjoyable, which sucks...hard, because nothing they do until round 2 next year matters. And I've lost faith they can overcome whoever they face when that time comes.
Fin