What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Star Wars Universe (2 Viewers)

I'm not sure if I'm missing something or not, but, why did they even have to split up? I will go train with him so you can go free. You won't remember anything and won't know what you're supposed to be doing and the jedi will just use you to find us, but, at least we won't be together!

Dumb.
 
Not horrible but certainly not great. Given that this apparently pulled in a fraction of Obi Wan’s viewership, I’m guessing there isn’t going to be a season 2.
 
Just got around to watching the last two episodes. Underwhelmed overall. Couple of "oh wow"/"neat" scenes, but not something I'd pick up to watch again. After the first two episodes I stopped watching it and picked it up when bored. Completely different vibe from other SW content. I felt like they drug their feet for about 6 episodes and then tried to rush things along in the final two. Nothing seemed to fit together. Definitely set up a season 2, but I don't see it happening - or most likely I don't see me watching it. Just wasn't a good story all around, IMO.
 
I felt like they drug their feet for about 6 episodes and then tried to rush things along in the final two.
I agree with this. Ridiculously slow setup. If this were a movie you’d have to provide that context within an hour. Get it moving.
With the exception of Andor, I think that's one of the biggest problems with all of Disney's Star Wars streaming series. All of these ideas seem like they started out as 2 hour movies, and then they stretch them out to 6 or 8 episodes, with about 5-6 hours of runtime. They need showrunners who know how to make TV series work story-wise.
 
I felt like they drug their feet for about 6 episodes and then tried to rush things along in the final two.
I agree with this. Ridiculously slow setup. If this were a movie you’d have to provide that context within an hour. Get it moving.
With the exception of Andor, I think that's one of the biggest problems with all of Disney's Star Wars streaming series. All of these ideas seem like they started out as 2 hour movies, and then they stretch them out to 6 or 8 episodes, with about 5-6 hours of runtime. They need showrunners who know how to make TV series work story-wise.
Marvel too - maybe it's a Disney problem.
 
I agree with the majority: very underwhelming. Just hard to invest in these characters. I understand the desire to draw more complex characters instead of just regurgitating stark good guy/bad guy dynamics, but I didn't much like any of these characters and found myself only marginally rooting for one of them (Sol). I thought the actors themselves were all pretty good, but they didn't have much to work with imo.
 
Put on ESB and then straight into Jedi for a mini marathon of just good movie watching this afternoon, hadn't watched them front to back no commercials in a while.
Still think Lucas screwed them up with too much updating in 1997
It looks out of place on top of the original prints IMHO

-Why does Chewie make the Tarzan yell in Jedi? that is pretty cheesy, the Ewoks are the beginning of the end for this movie franchise

Rogue One is still in my Top 3 for this franchise, wish someone would come up with another one of those.
The better ones don't all have perfectly happy endings

ESB - New Hope - Rogue One....1, 2 and 3 in my book

Next up, I want to go back and watch Phantom Menace again, take a nap thru Clones and then watch Sith one more time, only watched it maybe once at the theater, once at home.
 
Bad Batch was awesome. Like, truly great.

The live action Star Wars shows have been up and down but the animated ones I've seen - Clone Wars/Rebels/Bad Batch - are must see. They're so good they made me actually like the prequel and OT trilogies more.
 
Bad Batch was awesome. Like, truly great.

The live action Star Wars shows have been up and down but the animated ones I've seen - Clone Wars/Rebels/Bad Batch - are must see. They're so good they made me actually like the prequel and OT trilogies more.
Totally agree. I’ve liked most live action but the animation hasn’t had any clunkers like Boba Fett or semi clunkers like Acolyte.
 
Yea pretty easy to see they were never going to spend another 200M to continue that story. Shame. Had potential especially with the sith actor - he was good.

The first 5 weeks just felt like Star Wars on the CW and they lost all their momentum then. Few good episodes to end it but by then it was too late.
 
good riddance...series like that damage the brand and its long term viability

Now, back to more Mandalorian and Andor please.
I see a lot of people dancing on the grave here but this isn’t good unless you just want 500 more Luke Skywalker stories.
It's good if you want them to stop raping the corpse of Star Wars. At some point they will stop, but first it has to become unprofitable.
 
good riddance...series like that damage the brand and its long term viability

Now, back to more Mandalorian and Andor please.
I see a lot of people dancing on the grave here but this isn’t good unless you just want 500 more Luke Skywalker stories.

Well, I do want 500 more Luke Skywalker stories. I want them to make every damn EU Book!

But I thought this deserved a second season. It was way better than Book of Boba Fett, and in some ways better than Season 3 of Mando.

But Andor should be amazing. Not sure about Skelton Crew -- AKA Space Goonies.
 
good riddance...series like that damage the brand and its long term viability

Now, back to more Mandalorian and Andor please.
I see a lot of people dancing on the grave here but this isn’t good unless you just want 500 more Luke Skywalker stories.
It's good if you want them to stop raping the corpse of Star Wars. At some point they will stop, but first it has to become unprofitable.
Most of us don’t want less Star Wars, that is nonsense. And Disney paid a fortune for the franchise so that’s not happening.
 
But I thought this deserved a second season. It was way better than Book of Boba Fett

Well to be fair it doesn't look like they're making a season 2 of Book of Boba Fett either. And that one was actually so bad that it looks like they've mothballed the character entirely, removing him from Mando S4 which he was originally planned to be in, and future movies.

Acolyte was a cheesy CW quality show. But Book of Boba Fett was a show that could compete for razzies.
 
But I thought this deserved a second season. It was way better than Book of Boba Fett

Well to be fair it doesn't look like they're making a season 2 of Book of Boba Fett either. And that one was actually so bad that it looks like they've mothballed the character entirely, removing him from Mando S4 which he was originally planned to be in, and future movies.
That seems like an overreaction. Parts of Book of Boba Fett were hilariously bad but for my money the actor and his character were fine.
 
good riddance...series like that damage the brand and its long term viability

Now, back to more Mandalorian and Andor please.
I see a lot of people dancing on the grave here but this isn’t good unless you just want 500 more Luke Skywalker stories.
This is more of a cost issue than a content issue, IMO. You can't have niche Star Wars stories that don't thrill the core fanbase when you are spending $20 million an episode. I didn't like Acolyte, but I would have watched a second season. However, a CW quality show needs to have a CW budget. Even Andor is only hanging on because Disney is willing to take a loss in exchange for the critical acclaim Gilroy has received.
 
I thought it was better than CW quality.
For the first 4-5 episodes my wife, a person absolutely not online, kept saying “it’s time for CW Star Wars”. The fact that that took off is hilarious to me and pretty telling. The acting from all the young cast members was pretty bad. It got better.
 
good riddance...series like that damage the brand and its long term viability

Now, back to more Mandalorian and Andor please.
I see a lot of people dancing on the grave here but this isn’t good unless you just want 500 more Luke Skywalker stories.
Here's a thought: how about one more Like Skywalker story? It's been 41 years, after all.
 
good riddance...series like that damage the brand and its long term viability

Now, back to more Mandalorian and Andor please.
I see a lot of people dancing on the grave here but this isn’t good unless you just want 500 more Luke Skywalker stories.
Here's a thought: how about one more Like Skywalker story? It's been 41 years, after all.
Fine with me. Give me 50 more. It’s a common complaint though from some people that they want out of the skywalker era. But then those same exact people probably complained about the acolyte too so what does it matter.
 
Acolyte by far was the worst tv series they have produced. Hedland was terrible and had no understanding of the universe she was writing in. It could have been an awesome story but glad she can’t jack up a bunch more canon doing whatever she wants without a thought around the broader universe.

Hopefully Disney learns you trot out this terrible garbage fans won’t just gobble it up.
 
Acolyte by far was the worst tv series they have produced. Hedland was terrible and had no understanding of the universe she was writing in. It could have been an awesome story but glad she can’t jack up a bunch more canon doing whatever she wants without a thought around the broader universe.

Hopefully Disney learns you trot out this terrible garbage fans won’t just gobble it up.
I think Boba Fett was many times worse, if you take out the Mando parts. Which I guess is like saying that running back only had 32 yards if you take out the 85 yard run but still, for such a popular character with such a long waited story they dropped the ball there way worse than they did here.
 
Acolyte by far was the worst tv series they have produced. Hedland was terrible and had no understanding of the universe she was writing in. It could have been an awesome story but glad she can’t jack up a bunch more canon doing whatever she wants without a thought around the broader universe.

Hopefully Disney learns you trot out this terrible garbage fans won’t just gobble it up.
I think Boba Fett was many times worse, if you take out the Mando parts. Which I guess is like saying that running back only had 32 yards if you take out the 85 yard run but still, for such a popular character with such a long waited story they dropped the ball there way worse than they did here.
For me I liked Boba Fett way more. Although the Vespa biker gang was extremely cringe.

Maybe I overlooked more things than I should have there but thought acolyte top to bottom was absolutely brutal.

Manny’s character was the one saving grace, thought he was great. The rest? Brutal.

But as I said earlier, the Acolyte is still more watchable than Episode I or II of the prequels. I can’t watch those for more than 20 minutes without turning them off.

Thankfully Favreau is the one saving grace and hopefully he can drive the storytelling going forward.
 
Acolyte by far was the worst tv series they have produced. Hedland was terrible and had no understanding of the universe she was writing in. It could have been an awesome story but glad she can’t jack up a bunch more canon doing whatever she wants without a thought around the broader universe.

Hopefully Disney learns you trot out this terrible garbage fans won’t just gobble it up.

Boba was way worse. And she is actually a Star Wars nerd. I don't think this was terrible at all and people are just latching on to dumb internet chatter. Disney = Woke has gotten out of hand.
 
I believe Disney has 'woke' people who are influential at the highest ranks, but I'll also agree that The Acolyte wasn't overly woke for the most part unless you consider painstaking avoidance of white male actors 'woke'.

I didn't think the show was too great, but it had its moments. I appreciated that it was a bit more realistic with the violence than much of the Star Wars Universe has been. Main characters getting offed was actually nice to see...gives a bit of suspense and realism to the action. Jedi who are impervious to getting hurt and killed gets quite boring.

I'll say Acolyte and Andor are probably the two most 'adult' series they've produced, while Rogue One is the most 'adult' movie. Ando & Rogue are the best of the SW universe in my opinion. I hope the failure of Acolyte doesn't convince the Disney decision makers that they need to only focus on kid-centric content, but I fear it will.
 
Boba Fett was one of the most iconic - and mysterious - characters that Lucas created. He was a legend precisely because of the mystery. Making him a child of the progenitor of the clones was a genius move imo. Giving him a New Zealand accent just because the actor he picked to play his dad had an accent was just dumb, and was the beginning of the end of the mystique. The nail in that coffin came with Book of Boba Fett, which was utter dreck. Favreau should have made the Mandalorian about Boba Fett, gotten rid of the accent, and never taken the helmet off. Just my :2cents:

Also, how awesome is it that windows autocorrects the spelling of "Mandalorian"? Nerds, we have truly arrived.
 
Acolyte by far was the worst tv series they have produced. Hedland was terrible and had no understanding of the universe she was writing in. It could have been an awesome story but glad she can’t jack up a bunch more canon doing whatever she wants without a thought around the broader universe.

Hopefully Disney learns you trot out this terrible garbage fans won’t just gobble it up.

Boba was way worse. And she is actually a Star Wars nerd. I don't think this was terrible at all and people are just latching on to dumb internet chatter. Disney = Woke has gotten out of hand.
She’s doing a terrible job at being a Star Wars nerd as she doesn’t understand what she’s nerding about.

With that said the writing was horrific. She is just a bad show runner. Regardless of genre.
 
I believe Disney has 'woke' people who are influential at the highest ranks, but I'll also agree that The Acolyte wasn't overly woke for the most part unless you consider painstaking avoidance of white male actors 'woke'.

I didn't think the show was too great, but it had its moments. I appreciated that it was a bit more realistic with the violence than much of the Star Wars Universe has been. Main characters getting offed was actually nice to see...gives a bit of suspense and realism to the action. Jedi who are impervious to getting hurt and killed gets quite boring.

I'll say Acolyte and Andor are probably the two most 'adult' series they've produced, while Rogue One is the most 'adult' movie. Ando & Rogue are the best of the SW universe in my opinion. I hope the failure of Acolyte doesn't convince the Disney decision makers that they need to only focus on kid-centric content, but I fear it will.
I think this is pretty dead on. I'm fairly annoyed at all the woke BS and didn't pick up on it in this show at all.

I thought it was an ok story, but overall enjoyable. I really liked the Sith guy, even though it was telegraphed super easy the very first scene we met him in, and super clear by the second/third ones.

I can't believe how much they spent on it. But the bad guys were way better and more believable than, for instance, the woman Vader follower in Kenobi. And the political BS side of the Jedi being explored is a cool angle.

I was excited to see what she actually ended up doing next season and thought it had a lot of potential to explore the sith stuff of how like there are only two, but not technically, and they tend to kill each other a lot, and all that jazz.
 
Jesus have any of you seen the new trailer for Skeleton Crew?

My god……this franchise is being abused.

Actually…..let me rephrase that…..us pioneer Star Wars fans have gotten plenty of love with Rouge One, The Mandolorian, Ando etc.

But it’s clearly a Disneyfied new show coming with this garbage lol. Cringe worthy trailer.
 
But it’s clearly a Disneyfied new show coming with this garbage lol. Cringe worthy trailer.
It’s ok to have a show for a younger set. Based off the trailer I think it’s going to be a massive hit, even if idk if I’ll love it.
 
But it’s clearly a Disneyfied new show coming with this garbage lol. Cringe worthy trailer.
It’s ok to have a show for a younger set. Based off the trailer I think it’s going to be a massive hit, even if idk if I’ll love it.
Yeah it’s no doubt for the littles.

Funny the Original trilogy was for us (at 7,10,13 years of age for me) and look at that quality.

This looks like crap that’s all I am saying.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top