Genuinely curious, what would your suggestions be?
Well, making offside feet-only would be a great place to start. I think the whole body is just too much of an advantage though -- that's like five feet.
Also, make any tactical foul an automatic yellow. Over and over we see guys get beat and they just rugby tackle the offensive player. Open the game up like the NBA and Hockey have done to great effect. They've done a lot here already, but definitely could do more.
Maybe some sort of group-stage half-point bonus for 2 or 3 goals scored in a game. Make a 2-2 draw worth more than 0-0. Stuff like that.
I spent all of 30 seconds thinking about it, so these may be terrible ideas.
This.
The whole idea is that it's a "tactical foul" means it's intentionally a foul to stop a goal scoring opportunity. That shouldn't be allowed. Giving a free kick for that usually is the same as no punishment. Same goes for ANY obvious delay. Standing in front of a free kick, tossing a ball away on a throw in, keeper holding it longer than 10 seconds (yes, make it a little longer but then actually enforce it), running with the keeper to prevent a kick or throw, etc -- yellow card for all of them.
Get rid of the garbage and it'll clean the game up and make it so much more enjoyable to watch AND increase scoring.
I so thoroughly agree on this, and it's mind bottling to me that this hasn't already been done.
Imagine in the NFL if a team was running the hurry-up and after the play a guy on the other team just punted the ball into the stands and the clock kept running, and this was totally accepted and normal.
It would be so easy to get rid of the **** housery by just penalizing the **** housery, but they have no interest.
And yes, anything where you're clearly not making a "soccer play" (IE you just wrap up a guy who's spinning away past you) should be an auto-yellow.
Am I missing something in this discussion? Most "tactical fouls" that stop a counter or possible goal scoring are carded. And most of the time people like JP and Landon incorrectly use the term "tactical fouls" to make themselves seems smarter and portray the offender as "knowing what he is doing". A blatant foul deep in the other team's half really isn't a tactical one. I don't care if this is booked or not. In most cases.
And a "tactical foul" IMO is different than time wasting imo. And I agree they need to card these more, which will help with the in game action that are discussed ad-nauseum.
"Standing in front of a free kick, tossing a ball away on a throw in, keeper holding it longer than 10 seconds (yes, make it a little longer but then actually enforce it), running with the keeper to prevent a kick or throw, etc -- yellow card for all of them."